Press Alt + R to read the document text or Alt + P to download or print.
This document contains no pages.
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2011/06/08 - Agenda Packet r
1
• THE CITY OF RANCHO CUCAMONGA
PLANNING COMMISSION
L 'M J AGENDA
RANCHO
CUCAMONGA JUNE 8, 2011 - 7:00 PM
Rancho Cucamonga Civic Center
•
Council Chambers
10500 Civic Center Drive
Rancho Cucamonga, California
I. CALL TO ORDER
Roll Call
Chairman Munoz Vice Chairman Howdyshell _
Fletcher_ Wimberly _ Oaxaca _
• I II. ANNOUNCEMENTS
IIII. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
May 25, 2011 Regular Meeting Minutes
IV. CONSENT CALENDAR
The following Consent Calendar items are expected to be routine and non-controversial.
They will be acted on by the Commission at one time without discussion. If anyone has
concern over any item, it should be removed for discussion.
A. REQUEST TO QUITCLAIM ALL RIGHTS OF VEHICULAR ACCESS TO
AND EGRESS FROM THE SOUTHERLY LINE OF LOT 1 OF TRACT
18710 ABUTTING CHURCH STREET, LOCATED EAST OF MILLIKEN
AVENUE, SUBMITTED BY HOMECOMING I AT TERRA VISTA, LLC
(APN 227-532-16)
•
1 of 5
W441PLANNING COMMISSION AGENDA S
M JUNE8, 2011
RANCHO
CUCAMONGA
V. PUBLIC HEARINGS
The following items are public hearings in which concerned individuals may voice their
opinion of the related project. Please wait to be recognized by the Chairman and
address the Commission by stating your name and address. All such opinions shall be
limited to 5 minutes per individual for each project. Please sign in after speaking.
B. DEVELOPMENT AND DESIGN REVIEW DRC2011-00028 - K.
HOVNANIAN COMMUNITIES INC. - Architectural and site review for 63
single-family residences on 45.23 acres within the Very Low Residential
District (1-2 dwelling units per acre) of the Etiwanda Specific Plan (ESP),
located on south side of Banyan Street, approximately 1,220 feet east of
East Avenue - APNs: 225-191-12 and 0226-102-02. Related File -
Tentative Tract Map SUBTT17651 AND SUBTT18708. On August 9,
2006, a Mitigated Negative Declaration of environmental impacts was
adopted by the Planning Commission for Tentative Tract Map
SUBTT17651 and on April 15, 2010 for Tentative Tract Map
SUBTT18708. The California Environmental Quality Act provides that no •
further environmental review or Negative Declaration is required for
subsequent projects or minor revisions to projects within the scope of the
previous Mitigated Negative Declaration.
C. TIME EXTENSION FOR TENTATIVE TRACT MAP SUBTT14749 -
TRAIGH PACIFIC — A request for a time extension for a previously
approved tentative tract map to subdivide 168.77 acres into 269 residential
lots and a remainder parcel in the Low(L) Residential District(2-4 dwelling
units per acre) and Flood Control (FC) within the Etiwanda North Specific
Plan, located north of the SCE Corridor between Etiwanda Avenue and
East Avenue. APN: 0225-083-05, 06, 07, 10, 22, 23, 25, and 26, and
0225-084-02. Related Files: Annexation DRC2003-01051, DRC2003-
00409, DRC2003-00410, and DRC2003-00411. Staff has found the
project to be within the scope of the project covered by a prior
Environmental Impact Report certified by the City Council on July 21, 2004
(State Clearing House#2003081085) by Resolution 04-240 and does not
raise or create new environmental impacts not already considered in the
Environmental Impact Report.
D. DESIGN REVIEW DRC2010-01006- NEAL T. BAKERS ENTERPRISES-
A request to construct a 2,361 square foot drive-thru restaurant on a .46
acre pad within the Victoria Commons Retail Center within the General
Commercial District at 12009 Foothill Boulevard APN: 0229-023-04. On
•
2 of 5
r
V , PLANNING COMMISSION AGENDA
LSt JUNE 8, 2011
RANCHO
CUCAMONGA
January 24, 2007 a Mitigated Negative Declaration was adopted by the
Planning Commission for Tentative Parcel Map SUBTPM17818. The
California Environmental Quality Act provides that no further environmental
review or Negative Declaration is required for subsequent projects or
minor revisions to projects within the scope of a previous Mitigated
Negative Declaration
E. ENTERTAINMENT PERMIT DRC2011-00158 - CHARLES JOSEPH
ASSOCIATES - RA POUR - A request for entertainment in conjunction
with a restaurant/bar to be located in an existing building at 7900 Kew
Avenue within the Victoria Gardens Lifestyle Center-APN; 0227-464-15.
Related File: Non-Construction Conditional Use Permit DRC2011-00157
and Minor Development Review DRC2011-00182.
VI. PUBLIC COMMENTS
• This is the time and place for the general public to address the commission. Items to be
discussed here are those that do not already appear on this agenda.
VII. COMMISSION BUSINESS/COMMENTS
VIII. ADJOURNMENT
The Planning Commission has adopted Administrative Regulations that set an 11:00 p.m.
adjournment time. If items go beyond that time, they shall be heard only with the consent
of the Commission.
I, Lois J. Schrader, Planning Commission Secretary of the City of Rancho Cucamonga,
or my designee, hereby certify that a true, accurate copy of the foregoing agenda was
posted on June 2, 2011, at least 72 hours prior to the meeting per Government Code
Section 54964.2 at 10500 Civic Center Drive, Rancho Cucamonga.
•
3 of 5
4
•
Avoi.
ar.1/4fort
PLANNING COMMISSION AGENDA
�+M JUNE 8, 2011
RANCHO
CUCAMONGA
® If you need special assistance or accommodations to participate in this meeting,
please contact the Planning Department at (909) 477-2750. Notification of 48
hours prior to the meeting will enable the City to make reasonable arrangements to
ensure accessibility. Listening devices are available for the hearing impaired.
INFORMATION FOR THE PUBLIC
TO ADDRESS THE PLANNING COMMISSION
The Planning Commission encourages free expression of all points of view. To allow all
persons to speak, given the length of the agenda, please keep your remarks brief. If
others have already expressed your position,you may simply indicate that you agree with
a previous speaker. If appropriate, a spokesperson may present the views of your entire
group. To encourage all views and promote courtesy to others, the audience should
refrain from clapping, booing or shouts of approval or disagreement from the audience.
The public may address the Planning Commission on any agenda item. To address the
Planning Commission, please come forward to the podium located at the center of the •
staff table. State your name for the record and speak into the microphone. After
speaking, please sign in on the clipboard located next to the speaker's podium. It is
important to list your name, address and the agenda item letter your comments refer to.
Comments are generally limited to 5 minutes per individual.
If you wish to speak concerning an item not on the agenda,you may do so under"Public
Comments." There is opportunity to speak under this section prior to the end of the
agenda.
Any handouts for the Planning Commission should be given to the Planning Commission
Secretary for distribution to the Commissioners.
All requests for items to be placed on a Planning Commission agenda must be in writing.
The deadline for submitting these items is 6:00 p.m. Tuesday, one week prior to the
meeting. The Planning Commission Secretary receives all such items.
AVAILABILITY OF STAFF REPORTS
Copies of the staff reports or other documentation to each agenda item are on file in the
offices of the Planning Department, City Hall, located at 10500 Civic Center Drive,
Rancho Cucamonga, California 91730. These documents are available for public
inspections during regular business hours, Monday through Thursday, 7:00 a.m. to
6:00 p.m., except for legal City holidays.
APPEALS
Any interested party who disagrees with the City Planning Commission decision may
appeal the Commission's decision to the City Council within 10 calendar days. Any
•
4 of 5
• ,s PLANNING COMMISSION AGENDA
Ler JUNE 8, 2011
RANCHO
CUCAMONGA
appeal filed must be directed to the City Clerk's Office and must be accompanied by a
fee of$2,164 for maps and $2,273 for all other decisions of the Commission. (Fees are
established and governed by the City Council).
Please turn off all cellular phones and pagers while the meeting is in session.
Copies of the Planning Commission agendas and minutes can be found at
http://www.ci.rancho-cucamonga.ca.us
•
•
•
• .
5 of 5
k.
Vicinity Map
•
Planning Commission Meeting
June 8 , 2011
A C
i j j B
1
1"-:
.1 L Oc
a v = a i z
L1A ' ' H..�. i
c 1 ea
co I ,®
l w, r
•\`� AL
•
19th »\ e,I
I.i
Base Line ' ai !ase Line
i r Church gothigints i ., Church+ * E
:oothill i '`.t - Foothill
'' I J Arrow D
Arrow i c W Jersey 8th B w!
> �r�t r
a \ n n c 6th N
t7 6th : z € > Y
4th Q = , 4th
0
* Meeting Location: •
City Hall
10500 Civic Center Drive
STAFF REPORT tat
• PLANNING DEPARTMENT LJ
RANCHO
CUCAMONGA
DATE: June 8, 2011
TO: Chairman and Members of the Planning Commission
FROM: Dan James, Senior Civil Engineer
BY: Willie Valbuena, Assistant Engineer
SUBJECT: REQUEST TO QUITCLAIM ALL RIGHTS OF VEHICULAR ACCESS TO AND
EGRESS FROM THE SOUTHERLY LINE OF LOT 1 OF TRACT 18710
ABUTTING CHURCH STREET, LOCATED EAST OF MILLIKEN AVENUE,
SUBMITTED BY HOMECOMING I AT TERRA VISTA, LLC (APN 227-532-16)
BACKGROUND/ANALYSIS:
Tentative Tract Map 18710, located on the north side of Church Street, east of Milliken Avenue,
within the Medium-High Residential District (14-24 dwelling units per acre), was approved by the
Planning Commission on January 14, 2009. This project is for a subdivision of 20.69 acres of
land into two numbered lots (Lots 1 and 2) with 241 units for condominium purposes on Lot 1.
All rights of vehicular access to and egress from the southerly line of Lot 1 of Tract 18710
abutting Church Street was inadvertently dedicated to the City. The dedication of vehicular
• access rights means anyone requesting a new drive approach would have to apply for a
quitclaim of those rights to the City Council.
The developer, Homecoming I at Terra Vista, LLC, is requesting to process the quitclaim of said
vehicular access rights so they can build a commercial drive approach opening for their main
entrance on Church Street.
Staff recommends the Planning Commission make the finding through minute action, which the
proposed quitclaim of all rights of vehicular access to and egress from the southerly line of Lot 1
of Tract 18710 abutting Church Street is in conformance with the General Plan. This finding will
be forwarded to the City Council for further processing and final approval.
Respectfully submitted,
!an Ja -:
•tSenior Civil Engineer
DJ:wv/rlf
Attachments: Exhibit 'A - Vicinity Map
•
Item A
City of Rancho Cucamonga 0
Engineering Division
Vicinity Map
J
i
BASELINE l
STE
/ ittliiiippiAsp- 1 = PHASE'e, 1 •
P{ 15E ihrejp( ...-rI
I
CN ' ACM' A'/&//JJ
ib
t
FODTHILL eeU6EVmD
P^
N
4
W -jt E
it
s
Item: TRACT /87/O •
EXHIBIT A A-2 Title: V/C/N/Tr MAP
_
• STAFF REPORT ih
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
RANCHO
CUCAMONGA
DATE: June 8, 2011
TO: Chairman and Members of the Planning Commission
FROM: James R. Troyer, AICP, Planning Director
BY: Tabe van der Zwaag, Associate Planner
SUBJECT: DEVELOPMENT AND DESIGN REVIEW DRC2011-00028 - K. HOVNANIAN
COMMUNITIES INC. - Architectural and site review for 63 single-family residences on
45.23 acres within the Very Low Residential District (1-2 dwelling units per acre) of the
Etiwanda Specific Plan (ESP), located on south side of Banyan Street, approximately
1,220 feet east of East Avenue - APNs: 225-191-12 and 0226-102-02. Related File -
Tentative Tract Map SUBTT17651 AND SUBTT18708. On August 9, 2006, a Mitigated
Negative Declaration of environmental impacts was adopted by the Planning
Commission for Tentative Tract Map SUBTT17651 and on April 15, 2010 for Tentative
Tract Map SUBTT18708. The California Environmental Quality Act provides that no
further environmental review or Negative Declaration is required for subsequent projects
or minor revisions to projects within the scope of the previous Mitigated Negative
• Declaration.
PROJECT AND SITE DESCRIPTION:
A. Project Density: 1.39 dwelling units per acre.
B. Surrounding Land Use and Zoning:
North - Vacant Land; Etiwanda Specific Plan, Very Low Residential (.1-2 dwelling units per
acre)
South - Vacant Land — Proposed 76 Lot Subdivision (SUBTT18122); Etiwanda Specific Plan,
Very Low Residential (.1-2 dwelling units per acre)
.East - Flood Control Channel; Open Space
West - Single-Family Residences, Vacant Land, Christmas Tree Farm — Etiwanda Specific
Plan, Very Low Residential (.1-2 dwelling units per acre)
C. General Plan Designations:
Project Site - Very Low Residential (.1-2 dwelling units per acre)
North - Very Low Residential (.1-2 dwelling units per acre)
South - Very Low Residential (.1-2 dwelling units per acre)
East - Open Space
West - Very Low Residential (.1-2 dwelling units per acre)
A. Site Characteristics: The 45.23 acre site has been rough graded and drains roughly from
north to south. North of the site, across Banyan Street, is vacant land zoned Very Low
•
Residential (VL) (.1-2 dwelling units per acre). South of the site is a proposed 76 lot
subdivision south that is zoned Very Low Residential (VL) (.1-2 dwelling units per acre). East
of the site is a flood,control facility that is zoned Open Space. West of the site are multiple lots
Item B
•
PLANNING DIRCECTOR STAFF REPORT •
DRC2011-00028 — K. HOVNANIAN COMMUNITIES, INC.
JUNE 8, 2011 •
Page 2
that include single-family residences, a Christmas Tree Farm and vacant land which are zoned
Very Low Residential (VL) (.1-2 dwelling units per acre).
ANALYSIS:
A. Project Proposal: The project site is located on the south side of Banyan Street and 1,220 feet
east of East Avenue and is made up of two approved tract maps for a total of 63 lots
(SUBTT17651 — 56 lots on 40 acres and SUBTT18708 — 7 lots on 5 acres). The site is located
within the Very Low Development District of the Etiwanda Specific Plan and within the
Equestrian Overlay District. The lots range in size from 20,109 to 47,218 square feet and will be
developed entirely with single-story residences ranging in size from 3,084 to 4,049 square feet.
A community trail runs along the perimeter of the site, with each residence either having direct
equestrian access to a local trail or a community trail. The project conforms to all of the related
development criteria of the Etiwanda Specific Plan including 360 degree architecture, house
plotting, side entry garages and the inclusion of front porches and courtyards.
B. Design Review Committee: The project was reviewed by the Design Review Committee on
March 15, 2011. At that meeting the Committee agreed with staff that, as presented, the project
was deficient in meeting the required number of unique floor plans and the minimum 10 foot
staggering required between neighboring houses. There were also issues regarding the design
of the houses. The Committee recommended that the applicant add an additional floor plan, •
increase the staggering between houses and make the requested design changes.
The applicant made the requested changes which the Committee reviewed on May 3, 2011. The
changes included providing a new floor plan with a side entry garage, staggering neighboring
houses a minimum 10 feet and making a number of design changes. The Committee found all
the changes acceptable and recommended that the project be forwarded to the Planning
Commission.
C. Grading Committee and Technical Review Committee: The project was reviewed by each
Committee on March 15, 2011. The Committees denied the project due to a number of grading
issues. The changes were reviewed on May 3, 2011 and the Committees recommended
approval.
D. Trails Committee: The project was reviewed by the Trails Advisory Committee on April 13, 2011.
The Committee approved the project with a few minor changes related to trail drainage facilities
and the access fences and gates to the private feeder trails.
E. Environmental Assessment: Pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act ("CEQA") and
the City's local CEQA Guidelines, the City adopted a Mitigated Negative Declaration On
August 9, 2006 and April 14, 2010 in connection with the City's approval of Tentative Tract Map
SUBTT17651 and SUBTT18708. Pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15162, no subsequent
or supplemental EIR or Negative Declaration is required in connection with subsequent
discretionary approvals of the same project unless: (i) substantial changes are proposed to the
project that indicate new or more severe impacts on the environment; (ii) substantial changes •
have occurred in the circumstances under which the project was previously reviewed that
indicates new or more severe environmental impacts; or (iii) new important information shows
the project will have new or more severe impacts than previously considered; or (iv) additional
B-2
PLANNING DIRCECTOR STAFF REPORT
DRC2011-00028 — K. HOVNANIAN COMMUNITIES, INC.
JUNE)81 2011
Page 3
mitigation measures are now feasible to reduce impacts or different mitigation measures can be
imposed to substantially reduce impacts. Staff has evaluated the Development Review
DRC2011-00028 and concludes that substantial changes to the projector the circumstances
surrounding the project have not occurred, which would create new or more severe impacts than
those evaluated in the previous Mitigated Negative Declaration for each subdivision. In that the
applicant proposes building 63 single-family residences on the previously approved 56 lot
(SUBTT17651) and 7 lot (SUBTT18708) Tentative Tract Maps. Staff further finds that the project
will not have one or more significant effects not discussed in the previous Mitigated Negative
Declaration, not have more severe effects than previously analyzed, and that additional or
different mitigation measures are not required to reduce the impacts of the project to a level of
less than significant. The previously approved lots are surrounded by existing single-family
residential development and the proposed residences meet all development criteria outlined in
the Etiwanda Specific plan and the City's Development Code. Therefore, pursuant to CEQA,
staff recommends that the Planning Commission concur with the staff determination that no
additional environmental review is required in connection with the City's consideration of
Development Review DRC2011-00028.
CORRESPONDENCE: This item was advertised as a public hearing in the Inland Valley Daily
Bulletin newspaper, the property was posted, and notices were mailed to all property owners within a
660-foot radius of the project site. Staff has not received any letters or phone calls expressing
concern over the Conditional Use Permit.
• RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends approval of Development Review DRC2011-00028 through
adoption of the attached Resolution with conditions. •
Resp ulllly�subbmitted,
Jam . Troyer, AICP
Plann g Director
LH:TV
•
Attachments: Exhibit A - Floor Plans and Elevations
Exhibit B - Colored Elevations
Exhibit C - Landscape Plans
Exhibit D - Grading Plans
. . Exhibit F - Design Review Comments dated March 15, 2011 and May 3, 2011
Draft Resolution of Approval for Development Review DRC2011-00028
•
B-3
0
0
0
0
a o
N
U
0 o
I g
i g.
I'F
~ m
I ~ I J' d2
I ., ,11 1[ I
,B-b6
'0 -I 5-
I T ,.' , tl r3_ -
r ^c IT
------ . _
I � NO-14 I o-s
CO
p j I� -_ -I I h 0 i
DI liA
• Q 1 /� ___ a ' W u a
C V �� i hl ,=,,..___t ym 06 Z Y
L.
v t! 1 7S \l E d _o-t c ,g 1E' N r,�q I I a-
p I n -� � ;0, I I
1I
0
EXHIBIT A a_
B-4
a
0
0
N a
a N
iii
N
° 0
>i II fr^u a a
M2 2 O
Ql o
A l 3
.1. ll ;, ° ID nr 1°D
12E2
1� ®l0 r/i.. • n it
'fix. �! it� �•
r [ z �H-rii I
Jr'is..
lx¢ni�! v® En.
Magm�,u
i �I j I Wit...:, .._.
__Lialtararim 7
wan / ut i 1! I
3"R La IT p Z
varnat ,I=Mn ` 'T3.e� �j..i Al
laol a O s T,. F 1
^ &
Y i li cr n Warn I J
g J
ld �41 y L L'�L" -LCL Iu L I LL fry F
., u
Lid1 it° °° i° °mil. 11
m
f'ir�ccr^%' __- Fes- ` w •
- OIL. Z
r _s_ ra w
+�2�� �x
-- 1
crrIncrrni .2 MC '
cc
'^:uT ®® ° •'stn mm
I
kr`rri;,..aa mui.m -N 1
, s
•J° . 1 x26ao.
!,+„�
i.le' Os 4t. L
u
�I� �
AgicT
!1
DODO
D®o® S _
o o
r"- —+0D0® ;e—t\
- opal ® � _ w
g ❑a®m 1
�V• ell I ^ •
CD
N
0
' 0
f, ?
�$ $ < o
N
• U
EC
"I
11 l l ,i 6 rr�B 1:1 9
4I eel® _ 1i ij[iJ ll+'llxt;ir31
ri4, nib® bi I.1' ��,
■I `ilmi� I t k , re it l
lc ''1 Main X41' II 1 *ma= F
P 1
1 1I1I1 x II ��� 11
h it rII I &erig=41'I g 1 1 Ave i A,
i 3 "- I l� I � "�'I41It 'bil) a
R r9p Is J l�a��'xl�ll'11 ilrlu
itIII - ,� 01114 I {l ell rlQy. 1 I Ii.I'I
111 , k it • r r - lly I., I I I - _ lily
Lam' I t 1 1 a1' r Ali
1 I Rll f: I I 1 P r 1• I It 4 ' hx __ IIij1 o m
� 1t r � I r ,� ' 111 � a
-,ti �— ' � ' i411t1 ee® II1k,i , &1 _ Itl4 <
eo z 1 I� it 4 I M >
.LyF 11;. `G _ Irl I• &
4 1 5 „II b II 101.1 t w
iii.ip 1 irall
Al felll d I I � Di i II O
r 4 •� 13 tilil 'Li` w'p tD I t
fl to a''1- „E �a t` t fTl ll�Cfi §i �; U 7..
11 L— 5 �_ I1'�IL; l YI{ 3$ 1rr" cc I
� �C r 39/" I\ _ Illy.. O
L I, fjx - ICtIf r
y p W
Y I� fffLf 11110 ii: I i� I o
I ■Oi 5y ' mi a w
1.
I$II� OEM _ i 18 ,f� III :NE
••mf, 86
IW "11; 410 II i t ch'
l .1011.€. I up��f 1 '2 ii If + 1p
�'. ego,. y6 hFa I Ila I. ,x= III,
f it r a
�,W I
1711 I'm:II`I�I III
II . w1 III
(4' kk` i't 1 1 l 1
INV
0
i > i4 a1, ;nom.
I p 1 i = i 1 F LU
q h , 4
5�3 6�I it i E iilJ ,r4
11 t x{I--111 Ii:
B-6
m
0
0
a °
E
fri 2 Q
t gx 0 •
Uj ❑nu,i•,nnuq @ S� �jr�Nlf fc -Ilae O
r • v Yll B \�j
ik1}�,k flee di 1/ e
: 1-13: I {Q tcI
r f eooe �Irlt� II�IL �e�
p 1I�
t in. 3
irfY nee" ] ii" F'��}`
111IIIIIIIIIIIIIII, ,r >. r; ,11 I lag
g �
'1 u`�'I; �
imam B 1 }�mr X7`1 g ) 3
\4! 1-$ mar. PI I I a H,kl 6
■..■ „ Tr t� I Imo= 1111 i
1 r ... 6 ir ! / IIIIIIIIII01
I \� a
�1 elf e■Naos
°�1 �rt. 1 , , dd "�; yulA sa��/®I I1111111111 1.
{,1I� dj ae a 1, �a i IIIIIIIIIIIII! m
Ii t1{I l it Ii,i ��pillo' sin. ,„1„;,fI t'ta ® '.. ac7leli�
f { 7 1i'rs z :It�I� f I
9 n
8s 4lti+- yo N °..' �t �� �"G,I '.c: , r.b�,��t- �Liim'®®� 1 rc m
��II i 1+Y• p1 .OP
1n'u��i ❑ ae �' I•I lOI l Ey 10 E
11 08 1 d 1 It I g 0:- ,p e
�IId IIII ''� CI IE I ' '4!i 'IIIIIIIIIIIII 1: •
��\ �! 6 4 ,�i ee�e.e' ii Il w` U £a
8 tin: '- U� Z i
rr'iIf1 � 11 V� not m C i
prr . CI. lj 1,-IIIIIIIIIIIII m r
' � r1';?yy' j i�!u z
tt iir { t ,, /19' t w
jJI!4�rr ��� r
!! J,. {•I' 'yYii OHM y ,.�i'4j��9'Gx.1I e�eon W
aI I�,^j C®®IE _ _, � 1. �",��dtlj'."F eeee 'E.
CC
�� WISE I ndv , e9..
L� pC Etin _ }xf< r F:.e.r
Il�i'�� ate '" Ipesle �L ,,I V. 1❑❑I "
1'{Y ,E ,I„ii, :rue Y, } 4,
vi,,,,,,' �n� k �y J�{'{j it
I � I kr p i t
gi I p ` ❑ J 7o,t Gii ehl ennia. ' e�ofu[1 €_ va e1 I I f :tip 74,
TIN; v. mill E!E ,,i of _--- "i 'i ' ,i if 1-rn
� 5
I '- U ku k : ii o u
. � y5
4 I
JI
�� ,:__� _
INA. ow
0
•
0
In o
_
ill ` c
• ¢ i
i i-1 71P,1i�FIT ' a $'',,r,„i,fLS,, Ieelll.!ie
t IF} 17}4r`�iIi0 e
i1' 1 emcir u
Alt 1(47. CI I��
qI,? k eeco I � rX " -
�!r v r reel® 17 k i' 1! 1 a
•
Nf i.IY„„ e'o,olo g. 1.4 '
'I1�' t Si”,�4 1 II ..,l.L•. !1 Z1'�1 i 1 gjl c71 6. 1 r �I LV n y
A' ' .` :
�;: r 4-il mile® *� t
bill ■odic e s'�. ¢
hYi- •$
€ 4E1.1111° 1,10.,1!:,1' -a I '1pr,,`1 1110111111M 11
gg
s 1W!IL• yi�I III wy i \
�,I�Ii�', I °' is, hour , 'f IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII \ISI I�I.. : m
1 I e:....e a > I Y f
�LI9,1�gyr I h {�ry„I Dore ! ,, Nk yM.. �I Z
6 q� I� 11! 7011440, enie uE.< 14"1- f o
rl I H :nil ¢ rit
&E ;;01' ,I. ! F! i I`k ; `i4 11-' $€ �;I'�I�IIIIIIL��I�I�- E�
IL.L� 9 € • to =
!%.35-1-40 t!„"k a ; �� IIIIIIIIIIIII x =▪ <
I 1 ' 141
'FA g( or.. g L.,: u
; '�{I� \ `ak'y° f_ a I R�, Lim: a - Z
bIlglIF 1j ' 1'C� L_. d aoi: mtl ¢ x
.- H11'At' \°.. 414. �\\�' Illlllll i m II w d I li N Y 11 ' 'MUM I�}]4,.!1,Iif 1 a�r ra I m
a� ' ■ ll tlr ■i.ei e$ I} I I' 1 , eee•® R
1 � u all iie is -- g9 11V•41, ::ellm
14
�I`I1 Illy, I I=
.✓ 1 eije. t ac 11 �1i 11 V °=°�;
!NX 11' .. ryBoni
4[f 4—: r.ra &G 11 , { I
egne €
1 V c 11x1 y'.l,' ' �;' jj
* �'4I �J A ill
d�,i,m o i�1 I i iu1 r _o
4 1' IPI. 4t 11 L 1 a
ryV
eat r�If nq 1� 1 !w ow
it, EUEU yy�� r tip t„-,
IXti 4s I� I�d .
B-8
0
N .
0
0
N O .
a O
N
O •
•
2
Y
o 4
M, Z
J
.
a
7 LL
III p
J ..._, r-a__ 1 K9
• S
o I n.,�. O W U i Ii
1 .
•�I 1 I .
m
N
0
0
,. o
N
o
n
• u
0
.9 98 j
H
I 11
t? d F
-
:,FIII� d d -1-11P1 \t-^.
a 1 = d � r
li _
to h.
p . O
f7 1
J) x
b!L d ! n 4 K S Tr 0
e,
II X
it
l
- Ai lit '
°' ' [�{1 NNN1 IVEMER rant -I111HIN
_' ll
1 1
® .h
I®
Ig
r
y
C
tee)
e r
V
N:I, 1 i!li : 1
�na N]
• .
B•10
C
N •
0
0
N ?
rl -
I < ;
9
CIC
I I 0
e
1 i
1 lijiIit I
rie•1-4-mint.---al- o
L" iic-r;
r gi/s2 e
. , t
4 i 1. 04
I • 1;
II i■■Ni
0 0 1/7 g mg
° - ria—, i ' :g .1
,r 1. fri:■1
— c
4I-t, A I AZ-11-t
/Far re%
i*-414?-2 :::::2'ofel rii
,,_______.„ „.._.. Jr24111c4 I i
'qVAIIITIIM mo" ,I.a r,2r1,1 0 74,771F1 all
hragW-.Tr.,.--c-22 sig gil.•, -471
A-,,,,,mann M Ea ;F:Iiir,--LTit'ittIrE VOWL.4==---!
r
Itenzig..-7, .v.h7.7---re
F r-ICW"Ft11/1.-. I g "
ir•217-100--;4" •fti T 1
c i.LtIeftcratz:i i
i r QS:-=an. ...L, §
1 VC0 2 I I I 1-.r-itr&i ki:;.:10;.■;4i2-.91;1,81
I irk;•-n-V•ilic--z( 11 I nrarit.L.10i-t %MI I 0
■`T'it.--rnfl* • r 9 — -n,OCC
;
i '7774711., ..,..:-..- , .
; I
VC=r121-Es ail
I - UTZU,
..- I
I 2 '..1then ,rf sem
‘7.71-ra sof
. ,. ...,
I --,
1 'I WI I
I 7, 1 „ ni-
.0. --
,... it. ZTMIZ a M
0,47'719
rZEM2102
1 !kr,i I 1.111 ■4
kg:0-4. ,/ MI 1
-:•--/ ;7
\ to
12.-• I.
I. " . rr::? i
;
\gm Silt' I I ,-,2 lia x
.- -, 1
<
I 1 z >
• ': '4 la
III j I .,10 owe tun
i rEr so ma 1 . •41,-,
qv-rift 3 10 1r =NM il 740•'-'74 11X1 ,
ir '01 IMO NM
i' •• e rirr2r- I c• I ba
Cr •
0 w
A.I.- frearra Ilk4L I
arotarn
warners
Err.7"- -Ir.
2:90-r=Ta41
i it'll, `•9 SO-
;
r-gil r I,..Ag Cini.,•:_!
irdw:
IX ID °
frica-7.0-= ? 1
4 t' - Ir21 li t
I Co kett, z" i 11 w: 0 z ;•It''2r< 0
NM
r.-1 D
la:inrEICC E
10_224f/ .51-7-- < 1 2 ID 0 x
0
irt:mai .i CIL 1 I a E 3
armstut ,. ..) . .
Crurr. 17: 101 21
/ II I 21
\cairitir, -s—t: t. CI 1 2 I u
?nor: 2 w SE Z
r1210-1.‘ 0 I 41-' 91
0-'47m0,,,:afl A is ow■4
t
Jar a•ZA
'ar k
•V•.z. ad_
rar-- 0
_
T)
2/
:Miry
r".
:RFTF/A.
=ET! r /IRS IRisb r
%rut/ 5 2/Igif21C-.2L- 1__I
rrrtrr-,IL.5-17-t"W I I ';,[Jir'PLV; -
I-
I '
1 atizia I 1 1;■ITZ:" BE I
WRY arrit'fl•"):
-97901.1 3i ol44.11T
Wm um En. IMWar
-Crfa'g-el tr7AY1
h ititta5 g c 0 D
at"!
gE9 1.---
il FLEIE1
L1.4),I.Sq ECD D I 2 i
M M
1
--
c r- ttp"V,-4“12
END OD R M al E D
J2 , gg
L. rr.-L. •.__..A.2,
Intl DODD
I CIL-7-["; a kt".-LUSVJ:9
9132112=111
'r 17---giti t IW:Fir
; -IaIt dl 0 0 0 2 : .
..!, Ilitti MOOD ,
littan wOOD if
Turca` .1
ETAFT. NEED I I
pffr... - 1,;15,-L'itEri
itpi j=i= .: rgad:11
X;7; le/ 1 I
■ -."-:
iti21,2 bir,
I
e
....v,„.„„
B-11 "
m
n
0
0
N �
N -1.yiy < o
• 5 1g3 U¢
E9a �P�6 0
Q 3
5
i 'ue mu a•� 1 I= i9iV'A.`51
M S ��I't1 ail @ 1l 9
A ill' ,1141-W kris g
�.. , ,, I+® mil 9�7{��[
m , _ •
Sp' ` r\ tl'`I o�I fiE�
r'\ IF \ N� 1` ir.
9P1,111 gin
M{p 1'4C1j11 m�v�® i -� pp�i'N!
�1.�.�n.�1�J,.1* i' .L.1.�.�....Li`"' ,`'''S.ohl�
3 d P� „~..1 ®■® �' �mp�V{ e e Ilrt�fI i/'I , i II i
101 ilk 0 'lyy 1 i� ILJ'f /114 �p N
'' L r� 11) viip }II,IGf OY®��1a' EE eB- 1111,111 9E r O
R / 1111,':1 y i'`c�yi4l e.,ae�f1��+�I ''� iii E ',4 WMI 1�1 3 111'1 1 1 z I r 1+1 ifs a..1{�° &ny . ,Cp r�/ay,t ru�
• t.trial-r a 'u�11 G_ a.Qll 'b- ry �.11 ;3 E1�E�/Ilrvrkf[1 . '.r"I: GUI PI / ® b < O
II'I IA/ n I II On
L 1 1 l re i Ir l' �I Z
i 0r on
IY[
•1 \\.; �� .o ff L-' 3
;,..:\:: - �1�1 '1 r—'
I II 001_,'Ni4,f1 L__
111 F \• Sr I I
[ r`�•
L, \ sa /-TS: r
I X11 y4 R 1 r 1 p,,,,ro I 1x .al ;`, 1 rt I 'I''�� Y E M',11"41 DB� i ' 'G; II{ ji I 'i , ®� '1u \ 1r a:
l'LL'' ®_ ,f IIt�"A . °I !I 4
ii I,� tti gkNg_ 1 � -�;r' �C �
.e iN 9a; OIx " m
'
J ah - {
w 114111 n
14:1';`,1-1 Q ,�{
• I�fii 1rik'^'®n1
y �∎E rte„ p
B12
o
0
0
C 0
N -
s < o
$ 0 •
- 0
5 I5 Ili}f l m11111,01111 fl 5 -A �fiAZiSCS :.
II JInW Ii! Iklilul,ri
ii
l- : e 1 (grr - � 1
_ 1 -== H? .ai I'°i°�Il�l,
__ Fr BiM.
.■
41=r),41,,`,...1\�� e� ,,ax I !I MI II11 e
+�411!,11! 1 Ia` i.M■ j° 'm.-:1 imp._—re; gal
I1 I•�,�' ,,h '. , ii�.M - i! ,Iidn7a n
tf 1. a tY"14„; f Mall:!
As,:,-,611041: r„aT"rS.a'� a e
I''rI ■fi',i } r ."'' I3 us,^.•
44M __' 161 Ir i,IILI,� 9! 4I�Ia II Ida vhy a Ly Hrr r IP --'=+ a
ran a r1Fl1...1 II 1
ct� ��I, I �ti�� 1 r�;,Y h'a�;� IIIIIIIIIIII����
`I ill. I`II�II. wean II b .II �I'�I a s ,III
IIII,,, p�,l � MM�M, _ a.J`Fl�i iiee
' H I ® 3
411 �. H �a� '�'i' �}' mil �' I Ii rnol. z
,, „W 1I64 ,t.. _ 11 gip° IIIIIIIIIII Il�� o
u I. II:�,I ar. l 1 I Mehl. _. ,;A I N < W
'ya"`r �1r a I� Ch J
• IIIAllllllll6( I E' ;i ' r, + : e..1 w r '�1p w{,r �y I oniv . F�j l \ i, f ir
�I 'gill b x if _ LF iii :} i z i O •
1N '41 l=i�i1 I K y� 1 44 ? S Ic
-0 9a 1 I,iuu_ U� U
91 �I S J '��
$ ••'• cr
ri, r ,1..;4 SI i 5 Ir �M.1- mills-- g5
J °O m
cfm..tipptri, Ilk 1111 I i w
td
ro
Ftr l` lul 4f
Y 1111
e _tttkLLL{ x
{I 11j �'f�
1p ,\,i e ? r{'tt�Ihv �I
}f I I{ La� I
1r 11 1444` � �I 4"u '� 111111111-. - .mil 1401�� P. ,1 4a�J 4 I O0
Pi' �, I I J�rj7,,
51 ua ..1:h; I ` %at" I
I
®�I it , .�mmmimn4tIflUuillhI —
u���I ,� . :��I •
1111 1 11111!111 ��a , a IIIII�I-
B-13 —.,,,,.„.
•
m
0
0
N o
N -
Q ry
• F a E m I
.�'� E LI c1C a
$ S as I I 66
r ti 1 �� Lr� , - _ MIDI I Ti,/r,
't I u'J//x3 >II
EI —tic,:. ....' S
11I 7L 1-I `f».. J�yr lF Iti /r„x 1 ®. II
�„t q U4 �r r 1RIIIfkI R•(.]1](('ry : I,/ I•ANI il I "Ft { I�->a fj 47� ■®®■ rl `l II PI; } ly�� — t
P I Ili^ 111.16 ' ■®®.n} � u"{ l a t a{e
I �I} Yrr ' .1111
II MERE l,„ ilr1i�i'fl Ili], ©©fi
Till tit I I Ens 1 11�t 11 t l 13E11:-":1
l i {I ry',fi,' ' irl l l r 11111:i l l 1.11111ll { el""lr
III I;ail �x�};{�y �Ill�, �:.I I� ,r14,„11,„!i I4:1i.I: x ii4.1�
�I� 1`� jill a a}0 ti11 Wx" :....� �w,J rl I 1 1{i I up jl l_ .141/10110111441 I'
{,) guI'i dl i x1i.1 i I 1 N v ,,I,I,d � 9 �1 a.t: r .
�' 11 1 Y � x p :u t' f
'f f tl i�Y lei�1 ammo € 11 II .,.,1.: k11t. } I, . i
I
If r� II• IYyb ®o�®e E9 -il11410l`I,c Ill as
rE41"�(. If a ilt, seat p3 I I.17 !. 4 1i ki -- "
n ,J I 11 r r 7 -
L,'j M Ifilr �rE'4P.• F T w. N'c' 2- 'Him" rI yp.4 C.w.- I mmmm ZW
1I ■0'' ;Ifr lip- x kb- :meal 'lY� i �, Iir� V<u�a`' y- -'- i z
.va 4 , a�11 hr �P-.��- �5, moss 'I ,nn*M� }Y IIL 3 x�,� 1111;11II. I 9 >MOMS
�IIIIIIPl1111; i, I ammmo $116- . it w :III
ipng�= Ti 1 �t� mass a. i'r - I i z. m 1,
• LL IL x 1
F c a 67.,:t /llllll111111 . , Z5t
L yy ➢ :oa: E O" Q o r III.q,, t rcK.il 3 gEe ; :�i'Ir9 I opo�e V Q x
fr .r �L I I E s e a l 11111:1111 E m
v°<" I E, Y E a W
t�rL fie 111111111111 u
7 flF\—- Z
' ' F Ilii .I,h111f o W
. r J�L t I�j rt.
O
n . i"al• EBB Ig } ,4 w
J1 �till' ' 1 Ill 'Ty- Roil ' p
ICI{ � ILI g E 3 -0;:.M 0 1
P ''4 l ;i i 31 r.yr ,i,l l� 4•
ir a' 4a _ 1'1 I III II'll
L� 7% : O x tti II 1
h, I'+tld j fI/ INI
C` 'i yn _ _,,�J17y 111111ullr VIII
i 1 h`I 4-1 :'L
h{ 11! I ?I dui ICI
1�,i -1'u�Lry",I I 0 '��4..-t �k4 n
�I`6'311 Mi,�l _ !Ill iuldl J�F{.
4: !'®I 2'A k 4I�f if
illl m Il
,-iEL IIIIIIIIIIII�� I � 1"'It%,1111111111
B-14
•
co
N• '
• o
N o
< 3
N• •. o
•
. .
•
\ r
V 0 y I`- j IC = _ .
g _A ir o
a. K-
1 T , e II I
m 2
Q --; N z
p S II� L '¢ . °a w u
m' Z'
Q o tl U n C 1
Z y
W
A o. ❑
I111 •
rt
.i...
F ,,, •
1 L
•
•
• B-15 w,,..
0
• N
0
0
o
m -
ao
N
re
• u
re
F O
_ 7
L 1N I, !!
k-f cii L-4, (+ ' §
1: m
P0-96
____rosimilk t•ilmitioNK•� l
OI _ 1 '
i , r ....l.i e 1.
�!� gal ,' ' I,r . .lI ` a ,,r_I
Few i `
§i, 1-11, ,I - 8 s, IF ..ii
1 € __
_... ___ _.__- _-
II 1 m f
0 n°On I Vie: t) (� o �� 2 = -4,
Ill
• e �t0 mgt 9��1� 11 •■ I�I W: Z � XR '
A
` m. i ° I __ r 1 r _ Q o WIN w
���r�ry G Y
o-s
Si 2 — II OIL
g. { i�� ifPJhlWf SEA =�
to
1§© E4 3I�m.. _LC
O, r PhIGYfl1 S
I
i • gi
i 1 al 8-
I • 1 1
I>.
MI� I
I
I
L.J. .�_.
•
B-16
m
N
0
0
N o
I 'IU
1. x� i a N
p§ u
;siir I
ssta
•
rt _
7r it F` io®o e
' 3
n mi Di
ii I( � °I Daga
k .. � `� , n L; ad 1
I � I� �n�/ate
iivarcrf-lam of®1 .
,a: / Ali
O I / I=10 6 f.
d
rut=
1 et sat _i® 1 i i i\ I s
I ?, J
E zrz ,/tom d l I
z.rn' mom l 'd '
555 _S LyW. a yy i� 4
,�'yti lwuf C uS (i
, i,,sg 2^J, . F[ i
mm yr 1d1C 9 lin 4 @9
Prit :7ptgx _1 ¢[n. f �� Q K
/JJJ �'I l„m. II"iiUU
w ®g F Ip\ - ¢u
Ta]QL l$I• r ln_ ry4t,am Q < _
I`ti`I" m
1,
# / F .. L m
t ill rra: II/ s 5?p
\(C�-d "Ci - 2 : E 5 i U la
4 c s -- - a w
,gg W
LOU 1 / C �- z
{
y it . pi
mI
tY 1. o
dr\d ff, 1_
"IA EM 1 - tinar
a
—
_, '
-9S
ts;
hR-'rzcc = ws
p �. "sit.e.U_T
IL Rl$52
fig'i S
, C
ySr,
•�_L 2
.�
=11
I.j ma- Z
p !(•
..
Yl n 'y T. ,r
Pf La i
ill U_ r .� _
R
„L..::::
LL U i"7 r. �— n •
. a
11ll .,
a
a
m o
ii“ : , m -
Pdd 9
a uCr !II
§ u
ply E
• „ I M Y
{ , m ,
LL1 ilL I
on 47 .1
1::11ff Ul `�—
...1
111
tleo, \M" 'y 1 It ile WIN
-, I .- 1 I DIP STM
I O■®I Al .b 1,17
c■ a ilia 'I MI
ILq If III l$lw 11
i,$.04 III ill 4 4
11`?IF 1 ' ' oo� or' 41•'€ 1 1-I 0:1,1
3 ��4 4} 11' Ind ,..fig I I ' 11ff1
(P{I (f:lh II III ®r'®_.. q 11 1
IL nil 14[II1Ba
�i , 5 �� 1I /1 9O�L1v1Y.77 it
I LL2 4 JJ , 1 ',,, rlvllll j 1 i $5
p.f:i l Y 9 1 p 5 1 �{ ' F+..Ri W
1���.�,ur 1'3jai- 4'E '}e®l 0 HI�If 1 I� ��.`-� °sro
} E • e B@ 1' ,1 1,018 IiFFil y ,°�1�1 0
,i.i i E •Y a w. R" ,yw M. I I�•y - { f E.- I`Ilya I � E Iir' s 0t "P0' w
71 i \ 1 u 1- r: t1 '.,lll t Its vv Iiidi� �rli - f cl z
yf 1. EC r GII 11,1 § 'I�,S W
'fL ��� ' Illl ��sl II,I'P '� �yl I � � < u,
�H JJ� k�Il,p nr� 'k,,'� ., al f�4�— 'IC) m i
ibp1.11:_®III Rj I2'bag � I ,I- < - a & w. O z
�1GkYtr-�, 'IF
�i p�lIG1� � { � PH ��v�� i �3 6 0
E k:� 1 g E. L ',ar E 0 wrn
i 1 r f I 1.2
IU�I IIi 1[H, r- a $1y ' z
\EIrII I I ' <' .� f r I L 1 Bd i WO
\\ •i tv 1 E! 'IeL3r'. i I e x :gr.) 1 r 1 11 1
7I�r^1, J-• h"g.del t 1{.4I rr L s, e W
It:tx iIIl 2 1 ' `� -p-di
/. Riff` g a j}yr� 'et-2i ji°r
1 4 II I.i, S ter;; I 111220 m �'lii
'�3 Y lilti �uJ14.aV 1 I�FI[
h it 11 Lii,rJ
IOC 1 clef® If fS s1nrIE IE
h P.51 --xg, u
=O 9
�,,11 ,J
d i'�I ((``�, ' II'�
Y
,I,�EI hl' �.-
114
Ipd,..
� 1
lfr Li •C idly 'aril'
'i. Yt . E " 1µl""_ 1 R
r FI Y'
# ra ��'�tl _
' ' Er i. i lye h r-
I ' Yt ' _c, litittir-
,v...,.
B-18
0
N
0
a °
e in S a o
•
;v la j c o
•
Iftri n. if.IPI g T '"p a #ItI
'ii'( i! RE iF 11'I1i�
t1:1, r''1 Y i 1
i C .-Irk i It A
r4� € i U ! i' i
MItiIIIlhI,IY —�� .. € 'e IN J I�l'I j } 0 A�5.f .
i Lufikl g kilo p �I r*f _ I _@
Rf hi ®m.i �p , 4r IIIIIIIIIIII�
.+�:I ! 1 An ''fJl x 'h r� a
I I 1 11� aigt• II I '� �d
/.ii II •, ,li` ��- i4 •11•I
•.••I
IYt1,i��` II I N ,. Iry I4'T11r a •••°'
` y M4 IWm; &2 {5 4111,1 IIIIIIIIIIII II IIIIISII I r
'r r
li dd I jj
II If .I I /mae nll 1.'I, "nmi
8i
1 t
Ill „ Ir ,� — RII : m ` IIIi11 { I�mr�® ,
IIIII 111. e n7ll lllllli IIII 1, rt a •I�CI Ij I,�s H pl i m
v e •• 'L al C L7n z
-r 'ii C _ �1�� u r 1 2 ti, r[##J r _5 law.. O
i lm � ,.�. � I1 1= i Y{°" 1ri iI II '
}
5J
1 • re. c. IL44�I ��ui►iii iiiii>li iI r IIII
1-#1841,n K; I:.�.1lY I4 lI i_.. �I14. 6 4 1 ®ml O F O x i W,I v•oio 11 }T6a' ' J1i19 ' I III I I III , V„ U •
}} vi. 4 '4'• •••• ��I ���I tl ! Ilia z x
�d �rllit� y !u �1 ��y, "•} tl 9 `fih'1 'r / na1�+'�Ik�. / I�q�tny'2sfI — m" ¢ ?t.
_
mitt"' rip E q r: . r
A 6
W'` I 'N.;�dI�.�'� Y - s IA 141r Ian IIt E 1 W
�I7 dr': Sit, I A 1 sg'g F^'j 1p4'jf I II:ft; L_ _ ",9 j ec W ec
r 1. �.I in� T 12 ! I i �:.4{.11 y 1 a '" s
"'p 5� 1�7'.i �� .-I e_'I' ' m'- L_ ¢
8 �rry
li �■ 1I1�11 i lli 'i ]1 :=
1611, 1 IC II 1 '
II N ' It ; w 1000
I�'�V E, ;; .V "El n.g
8 92 —\�' f, -,-
',ti tf 11.16 lr,{) —. �, r
`\ ',Hale I
cp �i 1 - y'ry i 'gEg
(�1i L 1 IOQ v �i4,�,M'i A ' I '1 g
r Ai diit Lrt d�l \i,
r - 1 rr iO' III I - i"Iri�'..,_
a �1 •
, I:,, I IIII e14 f--- 1•
i i}i I 1I I I; IIII . .: ,MY
~"
B-1 9 "�
•
0
0
N o
• gIII.I�II- 8 '1. a
t"If11 6om7 a 1 41 Olt'I r Ir° CO
eama z ryp
19.JI .1.1. 1 Ir Itt ' '+in�I r �In'�'o ! a
e cl, , e I 'If,
a.-�flpj I np II !p of .lo
fl'1 aisle
rtr. $r;l 1 41 III
II . rya!1 ; I is I I I v >. j
'Ili-Il Aril ■■■■ d �'V ill 111
IL G SI ' I ae q lir,,1 I
p ry o11ii;1 E r I
r,1:5. 1 h} g '} x�J7n I
Y ■eaa
Id�hlr ' j ■ I II V Ilrp'llr �'.IllllIIII' ICI E Eiraristi:
Will { II, 1 :r r;1 11 I �1" &IhlCi.FIC:I l
fra rrn
■ II 1; IIIIIIi S1 l `t FF1 Li� ee', f IE -fr.,t` 'i • t• I L' u�
lar I til y o• 'o I �at Ie%�sG7 p
" 4v//4 I� Vrio i.1 y _,.. • r1),T r �I j 4rt t t 1 ;*". S ':'3 F
i r/� �tIL A Li .. tt�r� 11:;5aiyau a
r ;`-.'' ■�IIII�IIIIIIIIIJ ' I{ n ,,i i r I�� 1611111) 11
F\v L ' "C �I rr l I'+ '' rl'� v g® m x
1 r 1✓ I i� w b r0 I -
I��� 5+\ a ai 1{ 'u rr II t�Y �,'W t�, ` � } 1• o r� o
3r ,, I a. 7 x a F
41i TL'frIg r' - k ER::I fi,Y0 rki'It u1N � l l fljj �i�l�� o z r ; <
r f
„Ci r ;` Ih�l ::sue®� a" a s
L' s IEq. ' �e.I r d 1, r° O r,'P_j 1 n _
af.`I d,t�Ira ri 411 , a g 1f414'.1;;;';;;11 J,-111 J ti? U'Irj a y w
fr
If i l., L__ - - a S W
Au�'N III hull ill Ili ;�kl i, w
I. N� I -. I, arr5= y t r w
rl, ' Y I ■®eo III r ,IT u!r Illllllllllp I.IF�I Mum, 17 f r7 I.
M1 Y' I ti IHWVY Ea
tl '� I'I1 lfy ■eeH , a.
r r� III IIIIl]II g IPA"' ;.l ,t� eaieu J
Iv lkin-r '�" ' liege 1 11F� '�\L+
rt. i �d 14 \III1III!IIII
[It, r II�/.'' ll�.1.fr, I' al' loo c I 2 fj�f l M{ �I
I'l I 1 l llty.. - �t '1>'�' J$
LI '',III . ' 9 4.F ' IIJIuI ,IN,{pI I1j.,
4 r 1` r 4r1 . �I '1JL ,,, '.
I F rF�p`,I \ ;1h7 'Ar'
ry �9 r�1•II 4-
YI r yyatIffrI ,,ll
le .I( Ir .. Ilary�` I�I,
A ill LI. R (+IfArll
y ��M
'7 ;r .II I "1Jq I�e��
l4:
13-20 _a,:,_,
•
0
N
0
m ?
. m _
4 0
N •O
•
•
•
II ___JI IL___JDD O ____JI_..,Jl____C_ (n
g -e E ,r h
iiii or
E
z
a
�— IL
� Y
O.
W
O
• rin _h._ w: < a
G 1 c Z Y
` p 4 . P P IIII p
ury 1 N W W o _3
t y
�_ .. llL \ . , z
‘ F N
y
o F
ip
.. I- III ____ .
•
•
n,.-<
B-21
m
N
O
O
— O
Q
a e
• N
U
VI
is
�i•0 ear "
. k
�
tk<>li
F 1 I MI
— 1 3 I. _ 'IDCI' ID m
5 •r��' leg Ley r `— 5 �O tf�� } 2 m F
r b m
MI 3 l fig, o
fa ,> . z t
a� Sq II riII r 11 LF W z -
a 4 I
II f iir
ja(.. _i it M # 1
r.z_._—J,
—1 ,,
2
� 1
11 a = E�� � j_ Ci >]iU 1 II
iiiI 0
Mi_SW
L -- — 1_...! JI
•
8-22
N
O
O
N ?
Q -
Q n
I
u •
D
J I
I t ��Ma
rtratA V l _
1. - = F DUD e
I '3mmmma EirES F u .
=r /ii- ,
n Wl Iono
-c ,y �s ., r n L7"o ig
' .'' INN NM 1 w!e 0WI]0
&warn-L.-a rum.' _�crzn ^® I 4 OD it -
I E -'--w p I ,I
t ��
r.., ra`i< ant— a �-y�-i- \
I 1 y.I [tiifzu 1 'L- 12'1■11"�IC ■ I
-MC. �r i 4i44L l
r
rail
� �. g ,1k r I
w-' r F"
h g
1141-44 1
ro.fr o swam 'f l&c a rI �)IF
YPESII
■1111111 7741E6 1 �'�k evilI uu a ICI at w
IRt-al e�Ir ri vl 2 2 6 �HI 4_ d
1'r3u1 Ie�:� es \ .. r Lrii E ..al d
€ E t $IES-E+1 �_ r w Q O to 2
z
jjJg-
a 'I- \ \ n IF' 1 c w: ;� ( I 1 x' _ •
z E'rift., & w V i:jFtL.Ji s Q' z z Ix
aiarrc _� 1 uLTn 9 . Q 'o
/c 5 @ i i i i 01
^3 N�, ICP .�'b m Y
Eit ' py 3 ru �BI w y
��-.i[ci - ..� S i2 w
�••--
Nz I�� 3 (6zr T N
e �� /
i ` oo Berl 3r w
Hirer-ma iffial rin t1
.,312 == R_. '°
' \ �'
wad-132F,Cli�\ . �1C• mCT •r
i'a-' 'F^ir... r Mil
f q
,�l� 4).k
'Mil_ tairil
\ u-e.. ' c n' g''gl
.+. Lc
; zT
Veal
144U l lm, Isr E lc-
1 ] a_8�}i- ca
-- �I i;
154:-\\ y 1jr�i 'y
Ile.
= • ��
\Q. 3 • Ic`_ -- _
I plait
n we n
�
L i • I -:T ' n •
A'
3 1'
34/ ,?
,r•'=: tl sl
i
B-23
. o
0
o
5 .2 ' an
• $ Ili
6 g
` 4"--
2 n+ i fir--1'° e
„111F✓ 1 P. iyiih f
Agtr I. ee®� p ip �� i
tl�, ii. v 3 'f { ''
1 , 17.1 ' }-lV •.o
or if �Ii,1 Ii Ilml
ltil{'cell tull PSI
LEI I! mom
a 4 :'i NA
`�' ' 1 ilL6 7 I R
I,t 1 i■. F x111 ,LJ
/��� , ■�q ,;'� III trl�7� i 1
t I.
4I y iry { 1'p 1 '='�71p�'��-yid. 'Hai Ili±'lir
'I \ u 'w �i11 no e @- \a f[11,J''71��'lip �i� lliil
.% {VII 411y1'15 E D l 4 'Y,J1H f�{ X611 Y
t51 `�1 !�hl dJl I �¢ , il'e Jl�i',Alit'."fit�j �ti.5.1i1 17"
it ,1.1'I '��i a¢ :-(7-]:kiispiiiiihili� J���' \1JJ{II ©� v 5$+'' 1 Y '` Sddu9�'h5 Ir I°eiel® _� i jL�l1 X71.�''��'i io o�.h�, ' 31i .., � m e P� 3 g r Iit •• e � m.❑ �' tvl = ID IL1 a L . ram n\ I Inim ' 1 I II' h''1' p w•ue
11 E ;ill I , — lru1 { g I i>. I!lil u cc 2
11 1 111c �y m °
� l �� f+�t 11IN' I.�®, a '.'i'-'-_'__'
/A 1 l ,01 ❑ I¢ 6 m i l i
2 ' �,I ' o i€ 3 01Pao
S m ¢ x
4, i.;'] h e I`II�{Y 'r O a I m Y
u� AI �/ 7 ' O0, a u
p} I , 1� it ('c =I z
I I , el�1i1. W }" w
p 0.1,1 T ,
l' 11rie 44 ,i, m❑ 'Lill?
r, cr
4 It��n ; mil I?9
'JN 1 " f "Pit; v" a
'S
l h i15§ pr \I-=-,1,77-,;E:7,-.1,11
t I \��
ilOIII e 111 f1' I I� ❑ °'
o � GLTr _ 11' ,
} q' la = t
Lily'. ki,'LIIF d I\' - ?,11,,i
ti
err ;s 44,1 JJ ''I
VII ..'s �;��II;, ts 1111 ' 1 00- °0,1:
, 4131 Lull I, 1
�I R r "'I +I �4�1m❑Ii?'.•
r't a 1:,,`14'1;41/211'
17 fly r t Lr-- u
It 111. I \1;� 1 s r
114'rq;
m
N
o •
0
a ?
c -
i ¢ o
N
I u •11�f11.1 '�I� ,I:�s��II I I Aft 121;ittir . O
Ili Qsff�r ° i'i"� {I � r I
FF� I I ;� iII�
b,..!i 'dry ...ir t txl^4[1 III"
�� 0
Vila 1 !{
Iv f i i '' :::: a 2 e„lr,,,,,l I � 1_____'
h 1 I{r� g 1' X11 , IIIIINK , J
r d''SI ■resit ! „ - �'= I i, mac 1 •
'AOn , mats t.-- � II
'h I '� nets t.�
,,II11'II;IP. ' ' I Qn1� , w — IIAP�
:44td V'Ih If IlH1Y�'` !�im J III IiF iljl , I
I„I� h I,. 1 1� }�F �J � 71� �p,7
J I ! IIII ' C CIO. �:`1R- .o i , ul s
.�� �I,h - -1,41rn I�Iyla,, _llJ
� ' ' ` d p' 'r Ill',a ,1198.
�1 �K ii \ III' ^1t �1 7CI° lE
s , V ! t,44 „ 41r,; � llH
II .g!a�•a.w• wIII� A 1tllffli Il ' ; I� �1� II 11 4141trr�tial A©IC3i�i� z z
I� N 1.,!II ea n�•
n , a i. tli� -�a, 'IIIIIllIIIPI 0 0
b !! 191::ww I� rhi ��G' i d N I :i 1 [ Iiai. '11t' �,, /r A r •ew11e {11 & ¢ m•
tp11 'rf osmel 6 IIJ ,�a .\ / '� M1 I4yp�� E u IaA1 Jj1, IIIIIII�IIIIIIIII i W m i'di
14 Ilar own x 1.41'11^1;1, III 11--�ii1 �� $4 AI'.1.! S 1 €mai o ` •
''”j4! I'�yl I' m ggE .z , !if'lb,,,,..r �f ... E a c g - ' ¢ i -
f��y, fl,,l ml &3 a Ii "I , IlI"d u,s,T >i., a m r -
I - I,ll i�� m
_ , II'. , ,, I� i �1 I'I, ,I,i 1 i w„„,..
it ,i1/2 ,..,9.1 11 Ii�N,, q I'� fl! z 3
I!'�yyr ' f r - wain I w 1 �'I
1, A' 1-,- ¢..a / 11 I1�_I owue
41 ate. .4 �io.�l
14H+1 r Y6 r \�aI VIII /t*,r'1,n4 W—� �n , I l: 11
r aT 11I'4� / ElEill II
` �I a, l'. , I11� �I, r � I�/p 1 111
'” N wsem r11 F I. \ ii i
7 f I :mu n ;I (I n
��r ;� IIIIIIIIIIIIIII� I h L_I
I,n
k''T 41 F, Ti Jo. Iy�' I,t yi �:7
Il ,d t��gk�°rtry III1IAlllllllli d,6 l .4
. ,`II 'I i lit� ro 141' In MO
IA III
so
rl�
I i�II I I f ij s n
ka'�r1�r ' =7.71 I • N u�l •
Xda't�ltk 1I �111111111111111111' I .. X11-I l,r sA
...,.
B-25 .,.
C
. o
a
yy N
9
Ijia a ry
• 'i 5�f'IdEVi' :ilii:iii:::iT:: x �—T' rd�j�6G9(rje�11tTlep o ti
itrel yip, n Szze 'ti a j! t LYI:.
t.IHI N . 1 ] 14 N i'I � S- e
N�die.11/ f'll vevv E A ohir� '' I
0.,!-! I� :vov 4f yYu4 I I In
'Ii 000a ,}/d �
i ,A4 I
u II I^I
-r 1��1fy1 ! ccei o 5 "r`iq
�� ca•ca® a 11�
1A.g' h . I 1 r� esa„ g-
1 9.l l,+1p I ! small �c: hr 1�+ii1,�1j i-1 ;
/ I II 1 i�1' y1�u1 I;e e e l v.„,-- ,,,i,p1, �l`n`Ilf. e
.� LIES e 4 f III�C `• 1 vie,'" PI-y<h 9 ' 1t1 'v9�3tllBY3Itl RS it i
El IIIII,1 ln� I' lit.
IEa❑❑ :' 'c IRtt�1Itir �: "U"L❑ Slv%� J
I I 7;i I �, I� I�; �,(�4,1 slvs6�� ���
a r! l�lf I�11 u; 11 Srdu______
..m}�� �AI IA 1 41. 1I 1 GI'�}°�il}•Iir In eu......eose
I I 44
El i• •v1j•1a eII1t lift r _ iy i I : ��I�111110:ll tai L❑© dy
Ilti� �, 1 III 11 OIOV.'I �(' j1� ,. '��k��tll/ If ®TKOPID{ Z
II s- I }�: 1
I � i,/ mums . Crk � �Iq c O O
1 {� la/ ng
ui [ p LLL� y -Ixr e�llii gr:E' 1:::1 U':.;::U L it;!--.; ,- m i �i k i ll ,lor�IWIIm11 -;- O :
't, g jgyjY .x r• �� W u U
}' anew !', i1�fi ® y �: Z O
�yp�� '. I 6 FRI
Icy 'P j 1:'111 '1'Ti;ll' E�` j�u�iRY�+ '�' �— g U
ill X 7 lyyl 17 ! /�@ ! O
to-
IL.!i 7 I 4ee name: 1 rl/ r$�$
M 1 11 IIll�a e'I muobl l�k tlr�, �i r. ® I
r' T i Is I '!rc, ly ll�, m� y t Et
it .h X540
Tat :I ::::1: III 3:9 112,f " {I�J J t O I
tr • 1 , , IHI'l '�£�-'Ii :III I1
IF
V 1 II� lilt liltA�• M7'k 111"}�I�{
dIrI9 fi a{I���c4 �dt'(Jr�;4isry{!µ�� 4 r r z Jr.
i Ii4'r1 l 1 �f� 4� ff'fC;
ff 'ih �} s timumunn [ {r:
IcI . 1 @ @ s o1 1 .kz� } nnmmnll1 1 �k�t rILI� II
Al l.Q 11 6 ; 11'11014m- rut
::::
.j ., 1 Cvavv e
% t'' 7 se a .;I a vv�:®
1� ; �I'�
J
• ill, ry rYlq �J N Y n
s
lag u I; T. -n c
j niC IeF.e. {
7 F 1_we I:-U
• B-26 .
m
0
0
Iyo
c -
a a
u •0
G 1PrA--�—
•
-1;{ _
f► ,
J
-Q- 1 . n W
f
p
p m
cc., w ,
+-4. :-____■ �. - A lan■ m< u2 6 •
w a
11M u ax Z
z -
w
ID
0 1 I L
. L- ° -L I w
N ; I K •
.' F> I
..____, - - ° ° 1
�_
•1 —f- El - -- �0, 0
=NE •
•
• AID
B-27
•
0
0
0
o
. N —
< o
1 n
• u
3 p II
E_
I I' `_ 3 p I F
S I , I c.. I 3
4
�_ ∎ T! _ CII ._ _ ._._[ _._._ x
•3
j am, _
,
f
o
_ = ; a ° r'
® ■_+ � _ I
b _i �. I 7 �
I'I in
rn—n: --,'. W t _. . a
off. ,
47 O m
O m 1_ __,,, p
JUL• 0,,.
1 1 0 ,c_t_T
H_
,,,,, , z_ou ,
, _. , 0
, , . . ,
i z . . fl` fa11.Jll a■ •19MD (t 3 Iif. ;'
7 t7I�IN g� 1. , 1'.
1
5 � Lr
nOriN �� g a �1 Ill S 9 � l9 WWW 1i eb 9 g 1' 1 e� S ..fJ—r9 I.�.n—�11���11��npi 8 c L I 110 I_ 1MYYM ■ m S
t -
= — Tom_ J —
b
I 1.
3 V
� 1 p
1 1 �
Fs ❑
[fio
; 1
1 1
Ir_
• I J 1214 r i---- j
B-28
0
0
0
. N 0
N -
8 aN
E •_ S ee�pn'� rV O
,77/___.,= 8�i k i 1uu`� -�
6 r- �
, 1 are :I:::i; �� If�`at3•
o _� Wia. .-
• •a Sr—T TA, s$O
o to b yl
Willi 141:=7=1. 4CIEWM
R z d 0!o®H0� n
s ,>u;n
�. Minna
r clung,
4'2rr TErr7m �I® I 1 L J; , 'SI'
1031 $ @ -5 r �
,, '..` �I� S d6 ip, / ®mom .�
E , , Hs to I I I ovm=
S\ eta. on fI L /Ls, write::: rye U1
iItIy a • .-n : _ w U <
I �I ��- Yi`r.Ln is-ii E �t'-`•�I - su r ,Y —I en C i vo
� T - i L�[ L� p Y
mTTIIIItIIS JEI m B e N R S S
-*f a r MUM p Z
Ln firel d W
`
bairn-rx .- -ldt moan p
y a—
g s ft%
`6 ti w
cc
=Y
® '• a
00 _'o
a 0 MOM I
MO
M l frY• o m grng
�rn_rzvr_a' Fri
CZlil`•-.Il cm L i u _ i r-
ye�Y¢n '�LJresr L__I 1
eft rrL [3 nun's*,marr_. 0
-�an5 _.� :E L-I <
q C:m1_ y IWSE MUM
f i d1 t i!*'I i'i
H 4T3
k 1'FFi-'a \C:{,145.:,1
g L SGT tdt F
i 3nY 4t'iM'
k t rI
44,1 n
L "
�'a`.r 1I
\l! T �IVt-i
23
B-29
CO•
N
O
O
m o
E in -
3 iii a o
• e' R
W:'1
�f17 /1�-. �.I''I1a1J'.. g �' I'. i ut 3�1 'I"1@
iII r'i @„11h, i
:[V,1 ” 4 �n II{rJ�„JI� �� � e
•• III
■e® a $n H. �„Y, r�i. 1
A .I■, } '. r�o
em I ml
r 111°'._ mmi A m
111y'J1� 1 V !
.i. $N114t4 ii
sl 1 S '' I ,7 °w°-® r irf `r �-
z I' I � di W:I1
§ 1I�;, ii ,i ar k t iii, ai nn� tarr
ai I 1iI1, 55 uJr JI,.11.111DD^�..�••I,_lr il�/ I ��{ ' pp a II 1 — !f` sJ tai H� f®©sue
41-df :KM f G nil 1 G, Mg hi!�d "', ©®m1
��4 I 1 !. I , 4 1 B 1
viAII I pp ,d0 _ ,�llr, a.,1�lxd��{ '�@ '"rtit^- 9
n li 7111 -I a� I� 111 TI P & z
p x 1AI ry,�Y U Ail
644°/ • a lye I�i� �l{,�j� 'sr I•
•l jIJ I �, • LEA �I� d ..a,M,Is,1 1 1 , p n le” I a o
��y� .1./11..• S ray'. , n , 8 w, q v ¢ z
wII 1 T11 1 S y1 r 1,, 9 C $ O Y
al� E Ili a ?l yy W lir e�41 a _ IA YY O®®IJ N 12 I p Y
Lli
ry
Ir , �� �, f w
I ,- 1 I r { kllll'11 _y I J
�UI `IIi 'IN ii Ial 1019
��-a I� m� I. , 4 � ::::16
., :na VIII . ?kg ®
vi s r'll tL a
51 4,, N\ _1 3
III 14^ 3hr 7
. II� 'd� 'r r g41114 1 I LIE
It ` cif. Il F
7II� . f11I'' 1 R1 '+ c
,1 mlr) Tr. IPiK` : mm
v1 11 .. 0
li I-. 4 e
x �t -
• 1,, • .f#2'mlm +I pi
B-30
0
0
V 0
g Q a
9
s }�dll M1w'tt�i tt.x �ti °
•
,1�111 'Ir licidlillllllflf
i g
r f l��i E aall il4'I��i`I,,1 _,_�
r
tr �� p El�y SHaifl �° g8
•ui
I'fill = Realm
1 "EN,,� �tji��, L=__ =
I �; sm. :7
7x l 11 1 �t pI r
41 ',11frilvvy,
Illl �fl, 'Irli,,al PIS
d
4tVt%':rt ry�-Y:�.�9J Mcllrf 111'y ii 1 ! Y'1 't a "17CP" R...�.� t� s;-x0. 1 lit 17 A
Y "' 1 h" „).;i4,A h Cvue YE
G 11?4 1 fffl6 rfni{'�II, S IlM 101:'i I I1 I:=s.lemia� 11
1 ',. I iL 4 I�r'I. I•'0t■ I I<I 1 ', I'.f ®^.,�dr l j e
i�.3lll l ri 1 ';�pq� I01!- 1 . .I , I- _ �I t C , 1�1 'lllTl,R ___
L rir'LT,. I ,� Lrk 11�I b N N II I �- v } 1
II t' I' Vitt 5 1 l,,, h r l®lnle� e i All cD UTL tt 1 l h' a 1:
OCti'jt14,1 >r11.1 II I��������������'���1����{{{{pppp���� .. na 47,1 r".44.,�j�'�� T FI Innrri;�V/��/ I ,in
�I:1 ,I 1 .1 " �Ir 1 W�•F,�ri i�� RPx '1 ��1 Ilrl it n s yM��&A, Q
-(il �' fllN NIO al ll �1P Ili 1 t V L� I 1 '""a°G d,
A' I,.lilt litip I ■ee• ....1 I �'' �.•� 1 ''BI[17'SJ /II r I uee 'i 1 ea �\ W O$,�1f�I Jl�h �1 �d �e qe II II�. ,�. '' /� m te� { P 4 - ! Y 1,k e�LI: IE }}I'J"Iti{li�..■ ❑❑ �,',1 1'k L1FJL_l; z¢ ID i
h�u 1 T 1".41 I ,1 ]S .h{Z �'l L7p,C1 71%��/Q� &F� c `
ii���il 1,114 tl .1 LA. "lit I E6i Ill-6 h,I it i iii 1 I•tt Fag E. w- i a
/, 1I ,r ,il.; I l I'-l^. d nt'+i' t '•
Fllfi I 1 1!I IRiI �❑ £ II0 II .II II 1' 1111 t11 ''•y l tr [�� B U 0 s
t 4r � r I ! ee NI 'I^1M1 M I $ .6 v
��YI�JI� j,'^ I}! a-ale I S '"I yq; x u
'1 � i e� g a
S w
IIY111 i� f pp� I�I I �Ill"fCI il�� Z
1 LM _ig 0❑ 8 1 'hit ^III eoa!a
{f it y I/M X10 1 d$ �`° I11`tI�I 11 ,✓- e,e�c y w
Ai +till I J'∎', E d J Nn , llq K i ..=it, It /•I I II! 1 II S9 'It'll 1 pp,1hrh ,, 11111;1111 li,ki,l } h' :,�lll
� 'y�,'1 I ' ' ill 1111 . r {
k,. Ili 's . t. 0 14 I Il' . '.
i k C If�Ir 1 [ U
�� !iO 111 I ¢ bl t ` HE — `
ii � 1 tlitpfiRyR X5"1 ir nr�I
t�tt ih de, I Al),• MN 1
tN` 4l pr- 1r no
1 E"L (�t z===" Et �.,1" Ai 11 1
l� 1 4 g1& Ee i.of. Inn
vc @d ,I fly ,
Ian a�rrdC, P 41 �ti,
t 4111uH I " Li nn. e
L,�j 5 n�y��b
• r'l 41 I. ims in 0
....<,1,....
B-31
m
a
a
N a,
In -
_ .,5g • Q o
E
g a
IhYi�i oil-HI.,I➢i y �r� ,.,
-r � �II 11 1 gi IIrl ]I A� v.
] elm e0 s S 'J ! I]I fl
] I
4 1.,,1
i n1 rWi� nom.
�1 �1 � / .
,, II Wit 1;jlP t `its hyei ' 9.M
r'{� /( hurt Illy r I]Rfiirfi 'e 1,il p lI ir}P4"] a
4 ;
�If I fly�lf p llryi 'i1 9 g :qa lti r �� R, t
& t\,I 41;1 t Ill!! I I i I 1114,11 A. li II ]I
-rs P 111 trlr 1 r a a I I�1,,y1Ct I Ir""i. diEN
l s f`TI Ir f1q 41 .4�+�II; if
fIh 00 1 I {] ' k41,....1, -yfty Ili 6... . J '
'Ipi pl :in e �f]h plll , ..s'�,t
q 71:1 h I i :in �g a�`�I�ri i., Ip` r ©©
1 r- I I i I ' 1 14� C i ' �I :uI_.,ul_.,r 1411204.1` s '°'�s"
UplGpr : liu 1 <fii I I ;, 21 li
c lll
WIC?' I I ] I I�a,rl 41�. !two! I
IrPJ ,r�ith II ' .11�i' w'j�t 1111111. �,IAY a! �rTlie.' 'l�l 11 o
:ri.
r���H114 ., J II II.41,•1 t111 4l —• " �+I', `I 1-1 T �Ilfilj,, Itri mlm II_ `. .
ff�ilru71 II� it ht, h ' 'iC a' h'+uf k Iii III'I [ rl I I I zLi
! l 41 1 YT� . r �[ f II IIII �I k ] Ow
�f I I'r:I�I yI VJ 'I ` IFi
/N11LlyTr✓IJ'94i I'��l l 1pri�4h 'I , I ov m ufi,I� lln'I v a I i ',I ft w p _
II r rn i I�, ma ee OOfgl'
f��rP 41 11 g a r tt yr1 ' !r -� dT 1 Ilfi fljiJ z r w o -
tii N� I .r�y� yo ;z l •r mm II o :
,43�.111 Y I ? 1 7 ;I� ,I rrr7yyyl,,,.y1 k •
I w Z
hu7 d/ I ' LFt �C ��Y / 1�1. r• N3 0 ] I'L iI ]I ry r p: Z i <
�-i a 4 1• r—�` atw III III II I ] '1 i_II Q 'o
C�!IV.� I��s Vitt it mm �I^,L,`. g �,k I y�1r l 1 ° 9991,. . re y,
I ,1 �' Pn ( Q i{.c�4 I e If'iI1 II CC 0
0.1 y 41i"i4i a {I ] ,. � � 1 eelse Y U
�'< ( Y IIpr : r r'i nit. €v Z
w
jlilP* Y;Ir 1 ®'MI €
Lyle, l�I 111{l l e.00 op o tl
"ry'• IF , IIII III� In, w
u, 1.1 -
1 �,Iq : roc � 1; IIIIIIIIIII���IE
vC
9 i
2 fn'tit:: eeee 5s r IL J
e 1 ��j IN eeoeJ a S ]I ° pp
�1� i Illllglllll III
TY.
II I l � , I171,
' ]J 11A'
I rlllr ''I((11I]�� M'] °o. . fi i/,,+,,,,kil,l,,, S till± µ r i s
1441�ITI�A Il ] ale I�I nr <
11 I`IL I .I�3,h \'I{,t II Yil : 1:L_ .
11 prrpyl Ml 11-t 4 •p eo�oo
:tit? iF C
4.1.4:114,14:1
Tta}L���� V;." ncao
f'1 y 61 T•Ii-i 11% • 1� pii p l't MI.i y0$114. - Uok ° itJ .111 1 n
l i•LA' ry'r.. _ ;!r:1 'rilq
y,4� III IF 11
J ill
I -r,'(I i l �t lelwleler• an=
• •
i4jeC�n:IL' I r�� P ' t
B-32 .
a •
a
b o
E
u •0
6r _, _ _._
i
L E ,S O
I d .
O W
0° ■ _ IIs .. m •
N R F m' O z
e 2 `-
C ° Q U
. W Z i
a 1 z
■ W Y
L .s,. o_ ° J w 0 °
Mid O
1 _
i L-ir ,==i.
: ; : I
•
B-33
`r,..."- ,.-:1-;
,.. '
.., •
.,., ,, .
.
•
02,0• ,„.. ! e
,..; -..-:24„
tY/4 ..!. , • ''.: II,
,,, "
8
1: ?
4 ;
-
.4-.-5
-.15,i;:s. 1.-0
c;
14...; ,44i.-:-)..:. r c 9X •
cc- '4.4e-r".' • '
•./".z : - :-mi. I • oci,z:S:c„.?";2- -'. .•.; . •--ay ,
1-F,itili. -krc.‘."
S
''`A%
••,-z ,,'
-A T. "•,`"""Pi 4 nit. .„ .. El
.4;. 11 e€• ,...,i,.- —/I
''':14, •- Ea ':;,4,,.= 'PA'-,N ,;. , •
1 .. .,.1.,,./e,,.. ,... I'' •.‘..
17 •:'171.,LS '
,..g ...,,,,,,. .- ';'11'• - ' • --Q-A'
.../ .r4;::t.itzt --.a.-,-,.-,
- "7-,".11.::T
7c.„... '1
11.
./•:V it•it,firti 1 4;71... . '•-; .1= ralt2:14-;
j::, T- i.f., '
'• . 1.1.;:i.74 :., .., , . ..."7
•• ...: " -24
E ell,: • .. , , ••••cif..."- :2 m
,,,:- ICJ; a-t,„%. • , 2*:1 °E z
. , ,,„ o
r
-.
, w
.,
0 PI I
4Il i, Li.2: 0 ,
(
:, .,,-,,tme:.,
t4tPti.W." 0 CC 1 a
0
. -
. .;.-c[iiiiiiell? '; • .. ti .
W
.5.*.i. r -Th'Th r 0 Z
W
g'••,41.- :. . 1.1 r -_:-: ••
. 0
7.'"Ls. •yr:He ',::
I 11.1:
w
• IN, s, m
..4,",•:.-1- rc•,i.pit, V di LT.= , .'" J.- 4 WI
'5. ft», ---.B•5 t L—i t;?:. . • : .1:0+:1, „
c ,":- Az,ri,:!,- P€41 4 4;;;..w ;74.1.0...,■_
• ..:.t;:‘,.. rim,
tv 7 „...., r.,,,....2.14, thli ..•1.4 t 4!!:'
"...'4‘F.';•-p-441,V441 '4-1 'I
41 ' •gilt. , 4.-4 '12-. 4.4 yaqr.1541;!.:411.414 -1 1-
Wei -1-A.2.1.1r ,SYr.1:70.& I
Ilrik'flk 61-4 — -;,-- ettir4141kf C. : ; I 1
* aamfl ;
dk,' rt.-=•.
":" ,,,..., -t..4i& 7:•.,0400 00
',W4
•
• 7 ---- -.t
it
effi'.-si",, \., :71.rh! 5.4 .,..... -• il
. ^''''"' i'mni•r: i <I=
. . t)::-.1.14 '11 '7V1A444. i I InPthl 1 .
4e,Pir -.t.• ■ I/WEEP ej. d
, - --
- .;
mi- '
. .----•.;-:- .
Ps ; ,„,,,. iire.:
al . ...,...,..:...,..;:t.:: :: -;,,,/,.....5.,,,..t
"r: . ,
.. ,
_ • . .
i-it. -• ii
,
-"-----ci
EXHIBIT B B-34.
a
. .
,4
8
4 -
Et Egli C# a 3
.,;(1.••1
•!A4 '48:._ 0.5.7..,4,1
2.1, t,.!;•
1.0-S1.
• '4 .•• :1 .74..4.1; '' , il
v.-, • 4z-ivrA' 4 ? 0-4. , 4, . nErd.4 . .4
!,,•4.,'.-.*;.'`..... ,--: .i: .-m,:: :i.,-.1.;./.r.
- , „....
2.1•<•41k,?..pcli-.,4L.:14.': tii
',......w. ,,,. lr. L. ‘-_,,-__---4...•
sEty...,v.a.h.....„:
WA r..... .•,.,"1;1;.7....'`i. —-,
, .4, .., ,,... ......
...:.r. ... ••
ni
:,,r,; •-r,. ..F. , ,- ,,__,
i',,.7,-;•:.: ''
c-. .11 ..g. .- • _ .,.
• .;:s..-.-... 5-23;i,
-1•0-1 .31 11. /2 r:inr.4.-:• 1.
•- ....--:'' r..3.:r.n:
.'•It'N'.... .!..rir....,n
— P.UIIC'•1 '1."` ti OM
-;,..,•.t- ---
-N- ;
z go.,:tie. 'N-....
4 6
p
<
.r.; 14±,. :....'. • .':;,...-e ./c13,"-...., .... ..<''I 5
.3 s••,•",',„ $:•••,.•.- • 4.4 to
'• 4 .5! gi" 4 1!
c• 1•.4."1:4 •1 11 ...r.4. —
- .. . .I
• k '2,;;ti 0
v .. tdr- Att
.1
• - w _
.%.• t'.::::::: f., ,
f •
.i wry<
....: z ;
0
0 tc r
74,
zu
il
jel 0 Lo
tic?, '. •
..,‘:1):(ilr.i.,.14.:%•:.,4• I
..;j
ce
r•Th -*;• vi.5f:',1,1•'.0,. i 74_,. . i. e . ) ,.„ .:,
... 33 4• 4,..2._:...-‘1- 4-34,.; ,
e •:.14.)A.; "ii r 11(
-‘.; :10111. ' lei LI."' " 1 - , .
.4 .::4,4..,-, ..:.1 zal 1 •._ ,-
;;,...17-.A.-'. ,11117A4114.•11 -}2A.r.:
C,4- 6...,,,i•'.k., ,, ,71•.!..,.. :,!-
,,c')S'j • II Etir17&r;•
•
V't a ; -riSie liszi. 4:101*4
ifri'• % nik-S g.r.t.tr:rict,". et -4 ti,lit\ • .:1-11Ati I
irft . ,--._,:.-__--i;;;;] ,g 11.4.1&• 14 :!. r 1...1A■ 1
I CP..K?„:1,• ..' g 4
.A ' ' -.
'f•1/4 il \ '
: Wil l 1:4 /41°H4dr..7.741..ita4,11.11444M.410%4 --. ...7.1:ytaj
1
'alai 1771#-
4., ,ise4(i. pi. glrilit!' prif4V
.-.4;.!';. ,12,i; r.114'• ,-, : gk VI IV* • AIluk.
I.l.I,Iitittr.f' • iI ,...4414 A,,,orjg. ,
....-...1.•?:•:,,,y,,•:),43,1-* s • -..,---•
'1;4.1•-• - :1/4.- sill _rt it,t4c;sow.1:4,25-,a, . i•-{
„0.,.• tik.i.,4 ,. Rips,
...„1,,,...,„., i• , .....
,,,, ,,h,•„..,„di,. t....„.•I ...,, ci
•
4,...rayid i'r • • §
z
2
•:.,,,.tarcit„...t...4.,"lc, ,i „.„_.,.i.„..i. i
1-.....r.-a .
•••4,..1.•,...7 ••.. •;!, I 1; 9
(?•;:4, ' 'CC;eii4 :,.7...t.9 .1 1
C•iy: e' r:r./4.j 41
. 'ix ' 1-4<za.-"%....
1...c.r : ' '.%.,,,',..i.,A-, . N:,,-,...,„!..:4;"?..;.,.,••••
_W , ' •-,-7I',..'. 1
. ,re.cs,j,i
n.(s..- '''; I'T-___ ,gi
.I.x...Lk ,.cat,
_..,.-s.
..........„__
_.,..v. . .....-. , ,
...:: . ,..,....
B-35
N
I.... ..„,.I.V,,./;?:".,,e---16- r•:::.z.47:,11.: .11(a n
• . ...:-...„
ter a '.2:21t'',:7';;..a_. !;-11;:. .4: 4>MI 0 A -
• < ;
' 1.,L''' • ., E; i • • 6 I z
C
-, • .
!: , , • , ..— ,
< . • - f':" t' ' "r1 4
P!.'-'.-: .... J■>s< 1
. . . - I.a It 1 's
111 ir I I ft/
•
---,,,i . • /■ 7
? 4,... 11...
„
• ..vja--1 -1 .
' -.• :sZry...:
11 1,111114,
\
• It 116 I 1111 i.
.....
• -"' EY I • ‘ raill
•-.J..m.,:r:•_ .
•
. ,..,• -• L.a.4,-.•.=€:---1
,,,,,... .
,
• .7 lip■• r 1 z
- o .
.. . -• ---Irl:-- iii 0 - g
,
':: . room= i ,-...•aa q 11 Id -:: d
f. a .
z
C. a , ea o
,.;*11: ':-11 , t 1 F .34. F
.t.s.
'
.-4,-zr---t1/40.--<■•• . 1.1 ''r '.,)•:;:71:,?..:.:. . JI il I i 1 <
>
W
G ^ LU
icel;taiiiitiz. re :
0 ri 1
.t'A
• .4 , . .
•.-...
. . . ..
. .,
. . ••, ., .,, •G?-•
v g C o
0 W I
'. .,,t7. , , ,•• I to: X:* ,, a;,. palk.:,.E. °
m .
It
:-:.,4,,,., 1•.. ...,,i t,ii ,z,IMM a
u
e z
,
-
. 1.4
- .-.,it,
z - ,, i,A,,
Fi
G, ...dAy set fa, ,
... .r , 1 ag.r4
l' -.. - I. „ ., • Vt f . ';,3.It
' ,t.j, -.,*. ! ■ E -.?4, .e " .34 r.! I ,
. ii '' k i Ira
4-....i.,--:. i Is , t'e. "ti: .11:44.ii _ --J,
'ar-,, .......-;,/,
ig, i ,1 "-) 414‘.pi,.111 I 111111 1
n-S-r-F 14.1 ,-;c7;,,IRW 17CiA44 r`
iji. iri•.1,i;..24m-...
.0014'
j .441. II % 11111011 1
:ivii.elthiarrt : :Nc 4s*-0:tc.'
1, 1 , •'1 r 0.14 Wrfr Al .?
4 r II°'°Vid): 1 r:1"1141/4
.17÷,..I 11,11,41411a—"T;j4 :C..{.•‘n
,..-..n. , /.......;
' ;',A0,1. h..H,...
'ItbC1174 H4friaii,4 .
......irailb. ?4 1.,... i4,r,. ira.
. „. •,:tylia--A1„:111y1 =__—,.....4
ti ctn..,
''',2.;14•••, , 11.414S 1----r:"k ° toll:7/i ...... 0
1Tf ). --iiiiikilr r=i'S ' wr,Ir'‘=.,;:t .111 nil F.I
_ • 4., nt. :4, tkri?.A..', ihillici
i. ,_.... .,,,, 1-4
t4'',,-1, ,..-7.4 ..0
• II z
' ,-- ..: -'''t 4' ik IrS,42t,1' g
.tr,..C ,i. iii s 4:
.,„ , 1 t. ..
.,,., ,....,
.(.5, .4 , , ,, 1 P.
--1:", .'"t-r ••t----74.-1•fS
• i: „...,.....,.
..........„.......
._. •
8-36
e- 2
.1%.-as
-V.,,1.‘7 t •-•:%, r: ? 110
. 1rq. :4...2- I _
-77 . - cr:.2-1 Ek..2:,-i:1.;11 I 1,,Pc..„ < s
-----:'1?..,/,-.1 1,41,71 1;33 a 0 7
u
.E., I'17:liN 2: :
. .o. .”e.-.4 r--
4 .' .:i.i .,,' -n "
c 2 -:.
fie '
A ite-,2'.A"."1■:-7 ri. :
--;:,,,etk-.23! g •-...j.:r.,4.,..= , r5 N71
,,.::.:ii,i
II
.7.1:.. J. 's 4 I SIX
,-4. ic.11:7F;z:. •=---7.-. .r . i
` .1.1.0..
\I'l° 7.El . ■•
, • , ..t N,
r:r1' aig.. --
,4 . .i i.
,,If 5,.. •J - • '
, , ', sr,,•' , 1! ,
-I •`4."•tti .._
1
:
.• mwr' < rtm.*:;.• : !la
i
:,. 3, _1 •
' , g
, r
;. . . g ,,Le72e. ei,i i
1.2
.` ..,, ' c i J. : % cc
:-Citti%P.AZI,
A,Yrillirqc ' ...v. 7: cierit.6•1,
'Pr . --••••:::r.7,---/ W
• :
O f• '
tc"? in 2
,•,,. , .
-,:., ao■■ < o
.47 •. r ' th ft I
. .
•VqZ.3 .i'
.:Ic ,:t. .,: wilt e
2 ft;:et.:.:;0.• •' g - 0 ,._ ., ,.,
- 0
•.
) "r;:i:1-5.t="1"-tt t;•;i:...1.i..1"...1; LiMM: 1 !. ZUW
OW
z?..1 •f•II'I N: -
.
47 i7
kil
1..1:: 1:.v,,g;144 117..._ a-ti•-
•tt,-':iCrH..s }'/l,'p: ' I'll; d r:7--:- : a% .1,:"}:C.,:51:::„: 7. .:11.1.;1 '
•■-••nrOk 1,1:;i i N.1---• ..'"-7.. ."A- it.■•41 1"
wi=2
".V.ft-,■ ''404,1, ,,, 'r ..:± ittt,P r,' - ail
.,,,,,fritio4470.f. • tri...i ri.; \,. rii,,,, --,„•:6. ... „: 1.
[
. e( twiiii 77 44strj
r t i 1 ,A.',,S111/4. ' -oaf r e 4(.. k '■FI,404 . '?I--c-- '-
,Mr:: 111,4, -,..,,:st
'ItTif.t.:!E!, . —110 ..? -st. ari..A a ii ievoi,Ps.
VP1
\
" ' --P,Etttr:o 1 yi -,-----.
—
c t. ,..iti:Y/ —-I : . •-• ie :or.Al'Apr/--t z
o I; iCt t:‘,'•At' n==-"ft,";
t.,- 5
r itie /:17 1 cl.Mi w
VS:2... = , te; ::- : ,
— use.ta I.,
, ,:.• g z.:: . Ai: i
,,L'.;+:4.4.•"1 ,,,,,-,
.•' ':'.• ,.. :
I.2••••%,•.` ■./..`• WW.,44/t. •
• 5 :di- <4."- —4
.. 1•44•41X - ..`' ,,,,,,.,,...,
...,..-:....,.
B-37
.., --4•::‘ 'X..._ -.• '''#-ar".::
••1 ...‘ir•., : 4. . . . .
1- .' •:%•.,•■'...rw -".7. I
0 - V, 4ml,7; E.El• ; '.1'..1,04 renr,We -- ky_,:i. _i ; •;(.: IRIXI
":, '
< ;
.4.;V: -4 Ill' S . -.'"a
-1-4 :411'..;:q I .t" - i of• AS...":., ..=• t...-"--°' °
•.-1," -Al ': t.
454 i‘•.:
•ct .„- .4.'.•,":,ii ,0 J-4.03.; jr' .i glA
•,;... .iccr: ..,7-3-:%;
4't-riasi:•--..:4.14 611) ,,, , a —
CF•41.
pill' vil
... , .
7...T- "”:1•11,..11',N7. ''IE.!
_..1
Cr::,..:•71,:17.•:•,•:„... - —I
r "-- •1;••lig...7:;:••1; - .- •
ci ITN'1'4 i 1
'4,I S•
:;t:t.::1t.44 4
.....k.4-.4frva i 4 lilt&
PA'''. 2
el• •Al:•••4172:1 '4
"3...'• 0.,...,-...-:-I- ',-..•',‘1.7,-.,....116,- _„ <
r ." : 'II g:::ri. 11. • g
r ,..1. :t.It I'V-1 cali■zj--7 et:"_/la -ST; "' 'n
I
. ,,:si•fe.,•:A ..,:.,
..,,•:• irz
,-4f , -••:‘,.
-• , •!,. Lat., • • 41ik. a 5
cc-y 0 io
• ...02.- =. ,
.8 <
< . .
— -- . • — ...,-
;- .. •.:>1. 1J 1 0, _},.1 t.:4414: . -?; .04.:, kiistilimi 0 ow
M Al 415,,,p:Ii'," l■g ', tC, .irri 4”.• ,+,;
5tr . ....";':•.- .c,'•,':1 rail _ ow
.
tilf..foli,-41•' ----I- FT: r (7)
• " :*-t E i ' .v '4461641 17-4,' — w.]
V•le. itt,t. 14:11' , 15 -
1
011:1•;titt: it..,W1,4, \ ii; —3-
p
2I—n uj
t‘i e ••1 cl,1/44 - -- c44-: ., .400.0, pir -a-
4 t 1014 lb, 1154 4 . _ 1 :,a4Tt"Sti ail's ASS r.I II P76-hie
'•t4,444 rPfl 1;p;.441,0 1
b -4I
141■15..4-$.4 1.A-v-F..,
A...q.s . ?),..1,q 04,
!g,..2..4.14 •0:0..,
fil
_. ctrtitt•ftli
..• - Wolier"7717. 4e .f
1'V t ..121-”.1,
'144 „_,..... 901 11..,K,..,„.
722V•itti i 2.....—.1-7,C.
1,41:42 J.?. -,..-_-....1
1' 40.4,. 11140.; r --.i-a
..:,' ...11410,4;;tit it:1j Virr!/...-r•
• .2m::,•••:.•a`,*IP • : ......5•1•=-1 z 4*• V•Vi.grei!' ;PA 4 r.t.'---=-.4
--air:::3, ito' •i ■•■■•jn• 0 ,I 41 Williii^b. 111;10 1(24 !-1(4
-,_ liTet:': igra' ----"-al
', V l'-'1't.-_-11 I :itzlzA i • - iit:! • ,.. re: . --. .,
- c- wr. 171-.11•:', .1.',1!..!i':,.',...? Lt,
•,.•1•41. 1-1 i in., , -
6 etr.Iit *N.,-
-<,.,,•,:„.-:-. .,_ - ,ctick
4;111::.Y ■ F . i..1. r
Ft
i, Yil - .1 ■4,1=73 •ary.L.3...',p,V ,•-:: 4,,, i-2
III „......,.... - •=•.,.,„,..
•. ...J.,.
....„._,....,
B-38
,
--1 $
Z 4
Q -
=
0 1 . .o g ! ,s W• i �' ; i d j° dam I113
• F c i dg S 3 2 !ly l7S g 1 1 �iy g l 33C W Z J a °' i s
1,� S "y r 11 t y §' [ g5 r Igf g 93 W 2 W E
R_ D .I e1 .S 11 E E L ii 11 it H !g! 16 .g, $i n a a Q O d re*?
� 11 ill 11 11 �° � 111.c. I � ado m
Q.1IP $ i115 $ i5 5 '5' ppis g1giglig 15515 W z
,. # - fl T fi g° 11 a e ° E 3= a' v
0 o ='W
Z
Zl 133HS 33S 0 IC=O
1,I 1 11111147 Ir
ti m
II\ J O•
1 i, _J I j
"\ •. * s Z. ., g
� � , 'f s ag :w 1- a u
\ q n 1 A
• r'�s ,s▪� a� ��� ;d � �� 4 _ bah ,
i a> I I u I� , �'▪ • . ._• ,.' ! 1� N^n , 1 r‘11. own 111pp111llllll11l■ • �n 1. �� �G ,; -_ Nan
7 G• . WF IIII� ir ,� � M4a 1 01 .i / VA ." x ��pW
4, FI -f I `I: ).k..:,- a4. >z N
gi NI
f i l ;
1 h 4, , 1 ' Eli ;�
ip ro' !,,.,o • ei
I '` •
Q:
a v
I. ,1 I �,, l M�n r 1 E 111111 u ' 414* � \ 'r,z__.,ZE;..:,.:M..1..,( I
' '.> \
n ' �� V il �t•'.7. ; � . , S
�
G .,i. rr. \�.uoi v , 0.'i'. etel a. .+.. -., .�.
'�� ". —l!—fir . ms: cl : + s �r> �aq =- tea. _.
i .- --—7-AAE•FL• -. ——3r"-0
30Y1d x301 N30100
• ---cxxxx 4 xc
i t AdVON110913VM1
tZZ NdV
B-39
EXHIBIT C 'WA J_NrY3VA
—I
, ;.•i..),, -
;Lin 1 5
I /I 1
I 1
e
. 1 i at 0
r 3 att
+ I
:.5..1 tr
'4 II I -. 1 II I LI1 ,4:al i 0
Ili 1' if f.E ig t? if Ei 1 g a 11 f? it O. 1. ti .i f.? q . .
. 2 a 1 t,. 2 ti O. 2 ft ig.:2 il ff. :,..ii g f.,,, 1.! g:. it it ft ft
'CC
ii
11, .11., ri i„[IT lir 11I. 1.1/. , p 1
— „ U) •It
I i ECEIZO ES ' I
1 I
i 1): i 1 7 i tt
Z
3 i , a f 1 1 0 1 I I r
it 2
v i 111.1
I ill
' 111
O. 2 2 173 PY,
Z x- E
. .. 111 1
0 0
11 1 1 I
.",-
1 11 I
i 1
1
.1 \
\-......_.
niald dOWONIVN -1
:
:
NO.r• ;
i Alk,gm.-g ii, mir 6 -...,--,* ---ii.ea:—-—--ii:f16" .-.-.. .-5,---.6. ,..7.6".,......-101■,.. .- "tuaL, tp— co
•- ri
- '=V. -elatikUczt I'''''''.-.-I - ''4•L ,t.•Nt---- TO
t... _ .
E
= '-
.et to
11
111 'AN 1 , ...am • I .4f1:4;i::\.,,,,......I: i 1: °- 0 .7, '5'
=1;..,161711111 ,', •- " III&I 2,,S'1119,
IF 1 , ......., I .., .
4 _11 1 - Z 'te- (r.,
_.., .- z
ME.111.111 1-glibi .1. i
l''', 't ,,,,,,.% t 2
to ,,,
IL t= ct
a
1 1 , 4 - iiiil 1 . : 41IEL
1 ,,c
1 '
rt..,.
, -
'•-• '''')
., g. -,-; ., .,
,,
?, / )3` "
• /• kt• 1 i
4 r\ *
EL' 1111"1:1110111111111
■11 11
1"111„IIIIIIIIII •
-
. 0
4`11 es P
0-* I 14 1111, .i
I V:.Z. i; 1:n L! NMI'111 't •■ittta ei •1, \\ ,t. --ik.„,
I MEN tv'D 32 111
....-tt•tm : at ml
III"
i, .,:,:z :,It 411401P'i 1,11, ommir
,... ,-
7',..? I 1
,,, ■1
/ 1 s? Pi taki
_
,..
. • i I i i‘P ,,,,, '-',1.., =. 'Arm.
III 1 ' '. mmiimmtW?
M • '
411ff !"0'.). .11MMI c,' I
1. :1=1:•-•—• ' NMI c.,..,g,
'
— st
LU
ILI
: If)
N■c Lu
Ca 0
i / 1D,10
1 \
■ \ s
I N'tt,t .11,..-if-e 0,..
114=.: mi. ,
b NI ‘,..
1 ,
„Jo.., .... .(.1 , ‘
'' V..'/ C 'M '‘.
'''' Vid
1
...
71k .....:.
1 ks,ki, 4
, fe
* N. r....[
i.i., •erif * ir 05°,1 , 2 t'"'"*. A.Iil:,,',/-,. *
II II 1 ,•••I I/
' .,:,....
..i ; A4 rz 2 f.' illerlie"`"li■
Pt
• k■I 1 \
Iti 41P
1:i ' — ile;37,* . 4*91. -I'4 It* 4.1.*..! 4L-Z,-1'i •` q.. e.-.
•
11,k' s
... I
\sk ' t 1 ing•2 if•4. st ' i ..),,t;
I ‘ 4.' B-40 ^ ,(4\ I dl
'...
Ml
1 ()
J -' B
W s • r
252
i F—'§!
• it 1 11 .1 I
a' 2 W !y- •
h ip 8 III ii k i litkpi! FjP a.
4 ti :411 '
l- Il 44 : Elt
el 7:1
ir Ili! g'1-111'
o t
:q 111101 4. gi 14111 J
33 ira' i'' i gg
J »87LP
is e•al
_(,'E,_
a
LU Q 1o:
41133HS 33S Z `
O
C4. h7, v O
d �
td v•° 6 ( o
\ f '
I
�} _.-'. 41 li ill
y r -
' ro 7 i
i�A : r . 11 al {
lliki ,,,‘, - .100 m Ca �-® M 6'1sa; (
Nil, — j`—) I co a'
U
° c
_ :s u fi 1111117111t U m I ac - ♦ :12
0 I 4?3„ ��._e �*I ,4 # .x41 '' 2 N .•—'yl)
... ,
rp, +� 1 '� - o ,,z , N T{41 co t o® E /
" .-...„ ., 1 ip pi .9 it411
i %Mil . 111,411 .,..„,, 1.,„ ,,.., 4
* 3 i _ 1,‘‘/ l':'9 N VIII 0-
N .o i,�. , ,w N ,�
‘, ; A. A ,„, ,‘1 r''',.. ', 1,k l.: 1 '1 Nt Oil Ig' •
1V, p` 8
. . 11111F11.1 1
td :1\::1;
,;, M to '91 Cd { � a:',7{ y1�. N Al
.sue sc<. sa ..a �.'•.0�. '. �/
�:`;��, ,�,:�`` v N �. ^ ,,:..!c 1>•10 1' ate/
T, .,. a- -
_ 30Yld 2901 N30100 __ —p - ""' " '/ _-,"
B-41 I
J : g
N.
w 1 . .
W
2 Z
C
LL t,= Q
,
� Jig J
igJ Cl- i I
n
ZW W i •
ti 'e
5
3
^-.:.ns.. w.ae `�,`;,: Q -i a
•_`— �,_ 4 _ ., ;\ . :• f' ' �, kT_T=Ta-� L---'' Nil V) F.°ii 41
c:4 14 N ''>'' { j J i
• .
s
Y`y: 3
g
Sa I _ Z ul E m
c :� '
S H a mgm^
NM 11E0 W a a z �m
a d U 8
j ..5 t r'GY-e iZiy/ DYi4 5 Z Q p d
11 a jr r1112.2i ru+,e nnl'_y F-
Y91 O!
Ii eV! 1 91 Z Y 2
......, i'". r:1 ' II.■ • milemillur ...1.1 o
Orta p Lrook e IT 011.4114.
co
111 Nil 1116*
M irlik Alli ill 11 III l'-,' 4
ii s, :--soma � : - 1";� tLT ; ° 4°'-- 1 j,
� _
n?n..%tth�� A
30Y1d dONONIYN ,..10 rr 30Y1d dONONIYN •' I '`
i. lIR1 yyr 7�1» a '
. 4 : ifis .. N
40 0
L
A
" MP�1' r
l *. `, # >)drillilIAI H 0
w Et 1 `�, TTi r Y
. � Fri: i r° ' I(,4'IInily
111 f a =t �o., 2
�' ; ( a I
1 %$. :ice ' �D 1.4: Na' 1 . _ F W u`� �"" Ji� d�' I 1,.
o Gt l�1.1 t.. his- i o I n i I� I, !i.
La ,AL .11 '' -7'
I lir 01_, I I mi:,.9,..!ri .... - t',-:
tg, ./---rir Ito
sf 1 411)
,111 kq ail ;01
r S
>
t.: ki ) p,
I
.• 49.410" ' . t t, „,.. filo .._.)
7.. 7, �` �. . , mss,., N
.0. N+, 4• , `. 1 ---
. %' kW. . i - T Y.. � .+. : i a : 4
.1 .1
_i H q
it � I�o t om. °? i _ �. � tt =i 11;,
s-(i B-42
J s
z : @
1 Egi 5
MEEEEN 10 0 a 1 R
�.t
• r 13 13 73 a z g! La
93 •—a_ a .�, ' ��
.._ ..
`®.arc n c < a _ - � w +
P # I j i \�#� �\\ ° Q:9 p ` - �.alz: ill,
1 � 11111
" _"_ r`�i a �w �� 't Eli slEaE1i n- e,NA;
a Q W
\\\Bk 11 ,\�\\\\� g w J !Samoa. ;yI
'" gg !lr fr � QtU�
\\\ +3 ,\-, a a 1 �ie new I; \ A��iiLGQiY LAN t— o a m,
i 13
,�\ �EEEEDEE9EEE
4?--;;11:;:t::'
I\II \\Iv u II\ . h ,7 �gl 'rail 6 E
,�\ , � tEC � 4
@ pua a
111 p a
JI
V Z r= o
illINIIII:III re E 12
till 0110 i I
• �� all I. a i c al d red 111 ; 421-
�a :d a ci a iligiEREE EF fi g€ €
NZ
•\\ ■■ \\A,, 2 W �I�� IU011 1 i A IA 1
� la Y Jig \\\ ;.,sA • mis : I, rl aa <A ra'a�.y I�rr:��3�.E�E�E��E�EuE�r1��E�E�\k∎ 9 4' " IK� l :... I'I , R 11011111.4 PIP1
eke a e PI PONS a d g
a) • '�til CO ,I Il
\\\ Inp���e,c�ar ° I•Iw Q'�" / Its w
\\\ ,. i Q Q 1 r ' t ng >.
1 iFF 1 fig\ ` �. iwr © ;� __�. " 4 . 160 I6IIrI9III9III99>st„,
111('1I111Alllllli ha .�." g 5� e....b re
:3I �\ \ rty a ©! JLa - 1' ` o rig C111 Eu li- b-lif 6
R , `. 9 I 1111111191! gill!PaPa gg•\ \ A\\\\.: :_. Y� : 0.q 1i1F�Fg] 4rr1' ryyryYgi 9pglop
9O H”/ :11 Aft i3t
1 ._ ___ i�{�tJ 1(.II�t���l]hJ.'ukd1 ^4�i$c��yIi"Pill'y9 ,3
HEM MEN: chill lib it e
B-43
/AIL J
co e
g `
Ili,, IIIuIIIllr Z 4
k ] -
:d.1 4 0
3 0 �$ W Wi 2 e U o 1
€r; kF g g i ! Z .i
Y 1
1! WCi aP 5 ; r "' W °'O r0O
IL i i g ,g!% :e W= ! ( 227,8
Q U
wF- ... _ -,�T'�p-.4:-.3' 17` -". \ > °
E
L < 7 r . ', Y=o tli
O O O e S
"—=r, rm —=r it
mm 1 _ _ �' L`; Lr
I i�! I" ' :09 a0 °r_��� I�S .._.I.: , 801 ire. 2 m m
I.
-0 E
II L � _ '7�, ° __.61 ii U e u
I s11 pb s1' aim EI; ilI Z "- °
r-j, 1 . R ......091.0:� �j I I l 1 4g( Y lkJ�• 0
Imo• �� ter' �'.�,
_� o t
oe 1 1 ; 9 . d9 P-� a l' Izmir " , 1�;
�r' ^ j, i Bo� ' LI!n, a 1—,k, 4a,— i , —. ,
i.. 1 L o'' 1 ;1i , 1......, aig.... '.. 1: , ,
,,,,,,_ ,,...„ ._,. ., ,:
Sib I �t rr ao' I e.
1 i . :I,.., - : . .
a ° 1
I 1 1� P I,
•
M. 1 .0 0. mil- 1MM L :0 , -9. z II
k it r ' � qs ao '1 �dR i k '90 F Ems` j4
- Pc �, 5 9 �i- ,f Y C y A�9 iri
:��1 " i _ 1�1 ��_' .ca 9ei
• N i��
r• Y-�-.—�tr ���-.tee 1�•s s° - 9n�
•I` ...- 3 L_ _.rte '-- ��■ 0
-- — - -— - 1 — - - - .o� - - f - _-_ -- -
r t' .4..rrdr ,
, A B-44
i - 1 ' I I , I
n
I,y2y L L ^ paa [i 3 S €YEf[ .p� o
8 �� 223Yg 95 Se _ W °,�� a
it
_,
._..r. _.._, y m ° t 9 5y•
1e '< J C @t
U
t o _ W p t
w .1 2 o a
( ' en
� ' II J f
�' YP gy - J o_m
.p ar x Q z w E m
kp ��pk ' S z▪ o 0
Q m 6t2
I r Y =O H
It s p a w Uf
n
z Eilw o 1 9 § 5 . . i t 6 g °c Z
F Y
Ok n
WP i a 3 a 3 o-, r � bps �L� n E LL
P,
a 3 pp
5i w'F ¢ o a 4 � S 2
u . °
V Nzxa s�r <
co j i �rA. r5+j� � o a
3 - o a '+�t c O A o
a; p 2 bA
u b q 2' w Z e uo
a8 —r
` r e j C k . r � 3o w
C (
F) a 2 0 � ' € gti "s -
�j a� y4....i a y2y 111.i., \ z
lti d��n� � ' 4, r 4 r w
74'Ngrnin - Br.:.} tr i b
'4 rya;, w
!I] 1�* a n
Y d n3•obfca 'w -AWL, rc J w w
mb
7 SyY f b y u - i�"t� 4,a fit ) o f 2.
b` r w ex E° 4
rgtii 3'1
. �� ° \ _- w 6911 pt ' F / '�` I 1nY.9i�3t az�e
t.*„111•1494121104g I
gi
''111$111,11121,2 111E1V
nix° }£ :sr ,js"f # f— i`E Fg
• `W2. . Ci i4 I- b c iS v mrS �� u b 3F;JIM;1
Q . x. W
& B-45
m w on em w.—BLVntn as
C
"LT 1 111 ^Li ZNS CO
Y E$ 11. 1 /¢,�i
. , !!!! 5 Oo 1111! En 2°f
i 1 i3 «4'a UI_ O O OLIL
1 01111 1 �� ' 0 I ° ; ^o=
ll
! � "���x9 O d d d
d� � Z *el
Weir �aatKeriaaQticaltMaid 0 g g dg* W i— F
Q I-
I- �NZ
_ FLO
a— - - -Z- — I —�o
g
/ III u ° � ,. 0 W�
/ III t dglk r \ �<
/ II
Iii
' WE
1 �. vice . . . _Tw
i
III I yv'v ' v$ \\1 \ \''' .\\I\ �\
yv�. \�` �v ��=yi �a_vyA \�
ski ,099 d V\a 4, �V ` •�ts� i e. :I: a
\ e > \ N e \ i.� ,099
I\ \�\
111 r\\ F \G__,\ \\\\��-+p,.
\- '� \u< \ - a A\ A Q \!� I
�. \ use c
I it '_1.v `; ,. L ,° , I v viy �,_ N p
Ag
�� \\\-\\-�`, tl\n AAA\ i� �`�NIA\ �l: 4 8
III ° i `�
°I v �\\v
1
1 /
\ .II,
4 F---i --+ /
I
\ U) I ',
li ' I
k,ode
I— J
• ! I $ �
I 1 I � � I
'V
EXHIBIT D - ----� � � �--��:_ _ ---�--- -------_ a �
B46
WM III Off Weil ILL.
� mm <¢Cr-
F � @9 I °B ��d0°diT;Y flIjjMiL P) E ¢w_ ___ _ . _ _ nB•_a_ _ .I, _9 _I,I, III II ` 999 •
B� LL I HI x31°asst€� o OUC
F !-I.I_LI_LI_IiI.LL . __I-I. .I_ , . .; 71 lb lib
� �Z°
~Q<
_ m
m
2
III , $ q � O q 8 0
U m
I § § <tu § I
55 d g
CI 6 U
U
1 N t o
I , ; t F § W $ m e g
Y I I ih Q _ N Cl Q in o n g y
d .II II z, eg N .O € F o .
iI II - .a0 , L' ,- 2 O I i
z
I - ua amz
r.
1-
0 11 2 P 2
g , I I . s ,T, a I p®$ I.s a,
II 0 o 0 & zg
yI 7 .
; I
it m
n
,IF, �
O'{ N® e
® m0 , . N
, � 0® ® gl0 cq
O
•.I 4 NO E ¢ ® N T N
1
r-
71-
I
g.6 2 ICI I : 7 g '9 A I I e
,ro y „
O.. f‘HIP 11
B47
SOS w on SW ILL-m/a PUN m W.
w } CO (p QV
p - 1111/ �Lu2O
w ied% Na� °1 F2Q=c]
�`' <z 5 q � ® P ~ 0J U�.-
�a� W. tn_ NO 'JLQN
d d O
IM LLJz
Igear I- zWa
a a=1
w
il{ , I Q°
l (ID - . s¢E ci tt V g ^ °
I � 4 % s .1 u - W6
I 8 H
a CT
)E
f 1 11 I uJU
2 l
§ I ^ m o a
d I I , l Lg >g { { �O
II 1 E., �� 1 WE
Io
-_ _ . — — \ I@ 0
.4,�.. r111 1! A 1 1 !{
1g I $
g 9i 1■
ggss II•', I r
I I a S { B h R A
{� I
, 1 A e ;W 7I A 1
a 1'' i 1 1 S: 1 a _ 1 _ { 1 1 I c t - A k0{ ` A A �
I; I F { s z ■ 1 F
u 71 {
A 1
F II
.1 1� 1 e Q1 {
1 1 n C, . ie 1 9
Z I ^ r p
R I t� F ^ H
.t f• o >y A 1 1
` 1 1
__ nmum =iv c'�
4 €
� p H
I chi S A S z ..
• `1S Y Qy
I I+ I.
it I if w 7 �� F-I I I W
110] I
1 1 1 J,1� 1 1
a
8-48
o ,I
IIl - I 1
Wad 11.101 l ILL-NvldWe T610
C.9 ate-J 11, ,n i-C- l
E c• spws
pkno 11!11 OO - CnQI�-Of m.
0 U
ogf 0= U in con... •
K. fk' :
0 92Wen
6 - - - p...._ p _ Z Z`o
H
1+ ¶ . - _ ronueouo -- e s U Urn Lt
t � P i _�n.a�ul� � .E I , � 't'I 5e gs va �3, Ili'eydi'tg
$ !II ~�° � � 111��,�� • , 1" \': \\ i 5i4 I ffii @@p[;tli .-O
il:. is / N. , mt 81 74 4 r °a9i i tl�aip� j y1 W6
Hii D�1g 'i u Ci 6 11 '1 a � mI ' pgp
d! ;, T j a ae "I +7 �. B � �FPP
h. Ij CI i 1u - I— ".= ll
ate-
i lc HI VL, .i! HIS! s q 1 ii U
It T t L s p§q s � @ & @E
II' III i' ",i " I r r� C �g313 �g§°§1.1416@ Sq gig 1p g! E E i
i. 1a '°; ',,c `u 1i�IEI! �El1@1bPI'sf ls i}�{ E ��gE
;a ' „., ',two- ® o ril t; ��1 L+ ;®` i t I:11 � I ' ®4HY 4 d •II I e
s l II�m
i Il u O9,'^';,r`,tip �� a • €__
-; i Ar I �,at
I Ili ' hi
I
1. I I� 'm a ii
j
two
i 4F1 ��=� P 5 r I� i .1 T .e.'.
6.1 8 ,_„1.19 ;
1 1 '
1® 7 ;
�7i°�° F N
i — F IIMIIIIE-- — !! 6
q rr 1£ rrr,.NI it
. I W'1 8 V . 111 m II '� ' II.F i it A
F
•
L-- 9 ‘,.
x° 6
.�, -. =wva roof' ,z'=re
I -- 1?.usm P _-
u ' .
5 is Al Vf Wt W-Neu DAG ■133
' Sa ; g IGI -Z¢�te
�
(5 z lfll O
RI EE 1 y z <EIO
CO X1.4 z O O Jor,• v i w i N J LL y
oa oep- UIn-O eO t
n 1^l,"\5 ri ^� '� n ,• F a' 0 0 z
f
,I 1 1 1(S J. HS 336)3NY`1HO1v 1 1 1 f 1
I T-= 1 \ T� iii I :. 569 €'g 4_ 61? G
i}69F G
M--- L1i _a_L/_—.s_ ra 1„ .:_.tee s§§p,y P.!! alj< <ME
„ry '•-•"1°, GC ` yr rxuiru� r- "a - v n: ': I i R q @_@ @ @ @ to eR,E m
1'F •t �� i'r 1” ?y:Jbix" k. ti fl 1 a e�1gg €5 __/c1 LL
.. : 717. -pm�'! ® j, ' G�I. ge< —.L:111 u
° R'°i s�'1� 14\!'§" 3 S Eh lit� €- I E s i. „II r
j
� �
? I I a. st � et�. ' G. ,. s1 5 � 0 ' 5 U
0 �� 0 n 1n4 esH' a �I I P gie�Y Egc ii a e 1 i- Z
I .I- ��� '. 4i- 9I,r I- _ 'S_ 5 j- i °:i 3 �r 5 e 6i �€ o
II l rny� I Sig:11117!@ pii9g1€d€a , e 5 a � i � B€�&11a91 �EdgE , �! ftl U I f' 1 °'-,.i" l ' ^ 1.i ,�=r _°_ — �le1 `i 1iipiiihibi@li 111:1`a E1 �a
e1V 'Ei-e.' I Ii I �5"5'i I� i,6 aH E i I i L I I
i @p �'> Irl 4,1 " a gp�p� gdB' ""'�' jr
W Y@'7 1 L 5 ~ III Y ei ®� ill °Ii�
�� . "�., t� ._ Y,u.a1 '� � _w! i I ,i I Gana
t - d'� ' s .e i �I it a ;;t.k
! iii!T*P.. 1 exr I� E�� St! !n . j'li I 5 —1_ 11
kJ "- a = '' a Or
' a ��""
"lay'► A 4 !
c� td e� ,11,-,, khr r nal!' H �_ 1 zx� �n , 1
i Ems= n U I 5 .
/�, •� ' ,Icy 5r ® " s aE il�� � I � ����5 41
OR k1 'tHA
1 O` i^ la '�� "C�s�aw.c.. 111/19.' ... a�� � '
. P�„A; •",
Qu \ G
77 Px �a a I
. I Se
Ale .
�i B-50
a ILL ON 12114 vi-N.,,am IYJD3
z<v_
7 o i.l1 c) ^ ¢tea
B o - ubl� O �S OE
F : 9 SS^R Oi_ (n 74�¢
5yy Mil iii lilt@:g L3 >'^z§ n- N -�L.`O� •
pp 9p 37ii ep ee 28° = UFO r-
16 1 fifi m� p ^ % I Iz
¢m E 1 8 6 e,§ O O�z
"ao I �is9of N�3 UUr�rnng
!9 i p p��y is Y �• ¢ Q"•m
I 1 ee"3 i1 1 1 t® g ~ ~ 1Q
6i41.1.l e3iii d L
3i� � �EIE11 361 '5 °�°•3 �3 E E, +i+ ; 531 1 0
E1 I.Iti th:!!! i� g iiiai !01E F iP L1ti1 QL
gEEEEEEEEIEIEEEEEIEEEc EE t E E ESE E I E EEE E r—U
ICI . �� aex..= 00
8
U
O
S
U
• F CJ
7p .
elt
it
=Iraq
IL mil . .1
,, __
• ...•
aP
llry,YINNNNOJ ff p res.a Ox
I � I v -- 1 . m ° — 'H MR 3"Lno !t =
■ e
� 1 I.I e e e 1 , e—.
I I
I 1 -® 1.
i i iii ill 1 f ... .g` a 219'i4 III I
I
1 2 . —!11110 1 II/ e nd. "Iim---z- ,
_ ____1„: _ =� --
T J 5 _L.-÷9.'--
:1- µ - r `LL I9' /1 wco' .w.^Kk�3p „,,,,4\ (1 ^ 41-,i el'f x ..ge.
pkCp ' 7. x% k at
ILI _
Z i ! S
--5 J, i r _
gi,
{
_
z I
r � k LI h lift
S ,xi � � .1 � - — — II_n �-
niaory o
§ B-51 °
mor on wnbl-army 1,Mrw1101
e^QQ_
II W T I�v,ZN-
Ot,eo II II, 8 (n con I. of
�5 mp : ? O 1 ~ 69
ogoy � ' UCD r∎ •ct
¢ tD I� ¢
Z Z
H I--Mz
HO
Z8
z
8
ZU
r 61 +4
1°d U ILL
.gE it lit$` L\
. 1
0 cc
0
;;;+1 J
g s -I++
.L.-3 it $ii=
Q 3
dig
• z,s;l3
11 E 6ntlgi s1 .1-1-.
ft n --tnl-Q §Ih t =teir!
L e ,li p -1.1-1-1-$ tOR a93
• C .z-.ii C mi-5ig
in WI 1 _ I H I. I. I . ill 1 nt_-. , 1
g5 - - 1-- - -1 - - -- - - -I - - 1- - - - - -1 - - - - -1 - - g5 ---- - R -_ tt-
5! --I..----- -1-_1.--t.-1.1.1.1---- H--1-t L1.--n---1-1t---1,---1--1.1--- g -111,1-t �.; u . .�..
NI •- -.- - N - . ; --.---. •
b e li nl -tXd-RdQRtarttR—Ra'n -- -- i ! *-1-r-- e 2
O U
IIEUfl$e[R $1.. ?$ z$.'t ?$:$ 1&'1' ? $ MI:M! $1E IM 11 k-
eeeec
R
I I I F of
g py b 1i k 6 �� I�k'� gl�,z s z
9etpAgOS sP.s FSSB6 Y - R zrn z96 E £'e pti k & , pkva P9� pqA Or p
� C QKCKKC E PdS XH T.'pC .SC k pin t Q [ £�'+-�c�L Q [a $gtl
pp = dF F FP.f�S� F F F Fd_{S- ti 5 S��g @�g�{ 1 3 p �d
=3 --1 -1-----I-1-0..R+PI RX 1,4-1-1—.t Q-h & .44. - l l' .9 6p '_'L�..� Mth d - .1rid I '
B-52
m w ad.wow-m.Lav xry WOW TMUaam
i
in' iimIL1_o
z zWo
II 'l IIM gleOrr 1- 1-a a�w
M <r
o cq
li
i m $ £ m j L al 6
d NI 6- N Lv
d ; 'I I i Qv
$ ;II o
EE 88z8 fa <5
11 - 7 4 . ' t1 ' J V
A. I 71 F
�'
w c '
i: I R A w CI-
•
$ t i t a i
a s I A I A g U 114�Q3�355 ,� a ® �f R R Z
3 LX g / RI / R R $ g
g
Try F 0 g zS•
o -1-ii I
; i� T I
I t L A
f j u c
41 Q
1iii n r- o r nI A
gill
y n n
!I
ni
v .. A
fi
Ii r
E l _- " t .-- 11. I I
I
g n
,I h 5i �5 it-
; U 0 0 EHA S R •
v
1 L $ L$
�
x
$ ?I°
ilil i I
I,II, I I
lat B 53 '
IOSILLOff OlLL-MV DCt Tf11cr
m tp f\z¢v_
wg II� to NL¢N>
o2 1101 sO Oy
•
n; -^i ® 1 co HQJm3
• _ Wr N� N J COL .0_ 0 og� Y O a[As
•Caar t E Y N O O V z
Z Z o
A 'ice _ '*r ^•�-r--ta.,.^t-rt��4T. 01�vv- U ULz
P t W' '.---- Q Q hF Q CCQm
1 �'I - i t 1a' . � h' V1I� p9 +�p Hpph'
' � EG I' 84 . 1 �t gg- Fh i1F�hH tgg
A tl H
l I. eiy is +h ., E Q
�t Ih ',_t_1 ad�p ,i �I '�', "�, � � @ _aMR caa,ce
P �� !4' H! !6 . , �� E 119 6 el US
it F fl ' ` R ��", I ;. § QU
,y E1
® { '^ R ' �YTrL/FF�� I q ti F A h g h 8 I—U
,I.I x� f', � r 01 ' sa t�� I! d s 5 3"' � ♦ �', I\L�.N Y 5 S 6 � h h � � s O
j , _, d € E NI � I Hi E �¢
• (ate ftft 5 jai ••: - 'Jr wlt ��Lia ®IF�T: ®so°
l.w '...N Ift 1
di IF ; —a Y E 9 v tt
�l �� 4 ! •
I ' � xl I p y g h gg's ,I s _., ` rr r �EMili9EEh�`5 $�hp 3L eh U
If'p `� , .\'% `,� 'I I . 41--.;';',2 t sEEEEEEEE EEE EhPE�E� E5
�
_ ♦ i11 i .y-t
•
;1,:;,.?. 1� � °�� Y `� % _ p Iil .flan li =1111111111111=1. E
•.ill 1i. -I __s Iro n - ` A`t. • v ,` i r , 3 `
Ij �.:Yac t �1Xt :,j.t
W 1 A
ii
t , .tom ,, Imo' °\ 1 rAi , - ® �-1
Lit. L It _ �� m - ,_
•
1 , II � � i- . [ _ Fot
II; k /
'I l'I S aS �® 9 1 � .�
r t f1�I 4 a
a N t 11; " 1 lilt ,;131g o
n
A 0 • '],u ♦[ • J©� r. 1 it
he x;•
_: rti: i I P S : ,® I i rm I ) N 4 x � r B ' I.iI t-a k• a °"_ a Iyii N Y'4
4 s.
I b l I /I h Im60a0tldI IDVY'i1C1011[3Q%T I 9
•
[i mw on csa w-WV o•ow TMua
•
guE I! din E , !_! lD I�zZN_
aMy5y9§9q !l °��! ! ge€gEla r; a Eg la,ri ¢ z
@° di loigae 55 F O no !1111 mo-
„ap e°e as as Minax r 9g 3 5 y <z5C ` i ~ ~�¢O6
yp �i F «s, �= o �JLL
NI pp�e�g ' i a8 � n 0 ,...,_,_1w •...
. ed NI dh t I i x^- Y_ Q co t-, IQ—
• '�,,,n1 Li 1 ( 1
ci dug
-
1 R TJI` Fu ?+sa3s) v0ivw I UUz'a
o� Ile `` �t c= ..4. -a`^ ;Y s1
�merr.. .7�-�.,.s...® y� 'k7»�ve -aa,.xw.�er+a-vim -5� < < W
' b a-- - �'
cc cc m
co
< ' +,t ':I ��; ,..,.`x.„i x° I \ j�a � stf E-I� {+lR � p �9 pp gg § �`O ill_ I : yi 6 x-� I 4. " '� at , P aI I11• n„- ilT ' 1 it b i t S 4 g 1U8
1
i : ri � 1 �l ® t EE E EEE I
Q�
_` !t i ` r I_ �al1 -I *Ilia: ^E°Ne ®aO°°
,�.'�Ig ' .m; '_.'.'� ! III a! ® y •'. H§ ° e 1:,.111 b— .g pQ �Up
f�' a rp x ex I°AI ' Nh. e2 ,•I �U
..,;r, N 4 �, s ” 1::
' r 1fa Lai III ' i i� €-"i f ! �¢
iJy � • a!""_', 1 I. ,;1∎1 l 11 I ._ s iii ig§ei. gri IhFLU te 't, a y l i Oh ' � r 1 a i � i�E L ' p I EEEEEE F •t ,11: ,,,_*.J, t, i f M J/ �I' I Z k_ il
f1� ' ti ���y�&J� •
uar..a�ty / .\�•�.e �,,: ^ `'sJ�!a1�a $a,a
,al L l eh. 'r k� -ai Iii '1.1
4 rfI 1- ! , 1; I eal- sib ' wa��'
E II , ..--1 I7.t' 3 m' w . N ®w
I
�� S ' If\. . . 1 d I , dA I. a. L ay i h 'I t l ..h V0 II
I 6M i L_
ccj . t1.11 i
■1 �° � / 1 I a— �O
�i
1 rl ' f h 1 ir ()
Y
-.1 IIe • " 1 esxwse l P -i i �x
' .S '• °a y �41 1 'F '' ~ m a iF 1t.M' F 19
ap• �y 1 w• II � 1 I N �L n . .�...III. I a rl� a _ a. 1 w r Z la ,n r I • y\ 1 it tl \°l' , � t , I
I 1 F1I
3 L . I _I p
a} , � ' e T l I� : l Li 1_.a Ii n ` ee 1 P e K4; 23I n ` ' . e1 N•i N c(n ^ ) r.: 0 1 .,az__ate II 1 1GAr I t‘i II I
1 �� •;,,2; a",i- II fa,® ICs " T. I r2 ,--✓1 I I e.ter A
it
19 a ' !rte tal:Ita M• I d>
li ° l !1
gg 0 �i { a ? ji; f1k in j i eni I1 �� a •
la �= EaF vI -, alt
'. ., a bra I ,y' �� <(. 6d 1 ••gl•
I e uq a N�..
1 c. s , n -y ‘� e .,1
e_t. B 55 - °
W[MOM W-Meld in"mart
w (O ZQ�
LW. � I C7 9 ^ ¢NS
6 i y
72 eo lil� ��2 OF
agE 29 ' Sy z a I r Q-p
55g Fy NQ �§v z3�: & i O
j pp 3 y p �gow O8 ��LLN
III eat .
B i 99ii @y5•5•ie o 8° UFO O°
x� 0 N co(rc�
{ a; '9 v
= dmpdhhIle e —:;;; � �z�
a F —
1 s�W Q = z g 1 V ��ii E g I , /t!I g pg 5i o @ 1e i 3p�rp ! S g g p y
u.
1 II i [ S ImO ig a S9J P @01 L /ii II 0 sESigF1 . €eiiii 91( € Iii 1 § @HIi
Iii1111111i15.11 1 �5511
1 h 1151 X1 iii 1
QB
DU
i__O
Ft O W O
d U
€ � Z
0
geg 0
:M�M
miiiimmill
_ ` ' �
.rte
(M i� 3
____. _
.0. O
rI w��
_ [I'
iti : --:
ag: Ji
I f _ ix'S r�i
I I I I wu. I .�e1 I - y r I
I t I; +� �s�.I. _ As
3B
I I I- .LS e_. �C^a I. 1- 1-.-I W�'�` 'a 1 .. r �[f d
I , .I I __I l rl Es, I Y ;j �. : 1. 9 . Ski® ' EI li t
LI SC >0 A s0! °M.II
I a3soa '"3rvn dwviv -. , (d 1?3H6 338 v IJiMN _ qy�' � 33
lila
Ka
P 13'41
• �t I ' a
m 'i 1 gg 8 F= 1 Ito A ,I III'
m Ifni -- � d81 — M 14 r , f 1
W I J § I I G �uaory
L : '
Y
<u rr
It
�� 11 M r
B-56
E8 LW ng N, CLi^d
Je°q 11111 — in 2os
<' ? O co I— `Q�i
^ O c:�t
« o In= N � J-oy •
t
Y F° Q �7LH
ET)z ca
I 11!11 I. d m 1— 1--
°°°y i I°; °1I I'IId • . .... .>. i c c�uD
dl Q i- m
n II y;15 Its 11 !j ,,.,,. �_' ...,�� ! t— H■z
I iii 'i \
1 - !I 1!ti„°I•. °,I`I s 1 bh �• il>o alto �o _ __ 1,_
f it I,s1,1l i$i€iI i�sni:���� ,` • � • oi�0
0
55 i
d�aeaoeaaaae ! I�• Ol=Oi •eOt I 08
�m1A It�IfI 1 a l T= 1 F I W- '" `�_. - hi ll o
101- i111I1 1 ,€ 1 I }∎
I¢i1 � i it i
41 III! j i I. NH ii;• II = ,) �� -- , L'.1
41 III Ilfi !!111 I ���` .,.... �°!
/II I !I1I IiIIII I9 MI of •
111 II"' 11 IIIII!°II i 1i _ �`+ •o� °" E,Ila
y1IE 1_ _ IIIIiiil `I� °e ..�•...—�.....� °Ia
•
a0110 11 r �1l� t! !11 !I°I�1''
I IYII(3!-- , , ! III '°I NI Ii 1!p h ii:e°Ig !I
t��"Ypi- I 1�. IIe 111 1°•1 1! I ;1 II' Willi sal
/. IiFy=yS Lµ - !ii g[ li il1 .iHlk '' i id ill a •Iiglu iS; °
'Pith I 1 °If I°I • s°II II ti e Ie :!
4, 93' i{ I Ye) kg; 1 €1 . II1 i 1e1s91
E 1°. 'P Ir ! IMO; :II.. : ' i-t
S T°I a ail'Ph: E .I III e 1 1! i ; Mill! 11 N 1 II IIII 11=11tii Iiii11II1 �I'!I II hht „ g a„1 I IB�0i1lb 1 11!; 1 021114:1I
1Z I '° Ovit 1
tt1—li 119.1191 ! I f ° „ , .
iQ II 0010, °I° i 1 ! z !i1 !168 11 Ii
I`s II, l110 I 111 E, 1I fe EI YI a°
I Ie°�fli1 is a !i! z. II ii c11F.
• 1 41104 S a I ei siri i,i ill I IYI !' I1s
pig r _•
I 1 °itl� 1 11 J¢�y4 iII •` 'nil r !a �; ;! H I(e41i
1 , ( 3
5E1" C f p y i
��°1 iv @A¢91 I1 I a i 1 5 i 1 if II.ei I I i aI3:1 �41!. lekt!it 1Mil;
B-57
L.
I
m n al,wa ILL-am lmlme
¢V-
°JE Y�} C7 ENa
zjery 11W 8O W /2�s
M i O C\1 F ¢ p• O E UYno f-cn
Q fO n7 Q
Y Q ^ �L,
O O Z
z Zoo
o o E
III — - II
e III N . \` . R II ....._ p� Q Q�W
4` , a Ili a F3 \u,
& �� III E: 1 , _..... § /o
CP
&5 j __,.... e� 0 \i� it E MO
V I _ U
&LOSSS6�t9 _. , - - x Dig
dO p B1 9 R I1= a it f E yi 3
11 Z y.
el Z¢
U¢ r C I o
a 7AGG '7 +� e U
€� -7 II 1 0
X •191 1 0 111 II I
110 _ . c 11.1
• 115 H Y ._-
.,� ,f�;_1", II Him oat*
.•5,
• M_. __ H. __
n' ni _ .n. T .
I
1 •
hi i I
4
el
e 1•u I
r7? i Yc . . . w •
°
e!1y 5
Vi `I e6IMj 1 -
N¢ - ; 5 A :a-I IF
• { - {el _ I I 1'
el
• 1111 :v _. - II I_ 3p
I _ a5
!I � :..�- gn
iI ........ wows. 6.6.........
B-58
Ka 13.Ca MOUL-an.03A0311
w m ' <�_
.
o$ li113 9...., M �'�'
,e n! ^ ` of
O O c�—fflii NJ 'J t,iO WC.0 xn F CC
Dm
el•
<^ O z
ZZ
_ � Q �-� -
(4,t....
3:7-r rIcr33011 k . . et
II� ,�
b1:.Yw 7 A a 11- I A QO
I) II I LLI
317E @ Ei95 `II i! ' P 'a �' m I'rt �C7
E u l
CO-90
II— 1 111 x 1 ! 7 s I I IJJU
� 57 E 1
d Zy, 13 . 6 II I1.{Ii — U
it 1
tolS¢ S'0y' hs P 's`1° f °
•1@ . i; r b
1' , 3
� .
\ s!
RI
•
III III . .n. S III • �`
- l,ama� � . ...... _ T --33eld 30:1314311
II — 'SC . . .°l'` a ,i `�:
___� -7I • II:I 9 1 ■ I P II x • 1
5 III III 5y
I I I Sy
T
�S. I 5z
• h l l a 7.
�in:W W
e f
417"@ • II I II I
?I g II I•
!O 3i i III II I, _ + r F�•
A Yi
Z eS @ • 1111 Is m - 'ft,: J+ A iii g
i<Yqf I
e I A i
▪ 6 .., c ........ is
A
III .. - rr .� I, III • I II I 5g
gat
8-59
. vn 1 In ^I I Icc N j mg
p_- III" 5 el,n iu• t bU
F= Q CO n
El
_ Q cozen
Z Z
i , . "s'—'1"\ iilti I F HOQ
5 I I p �� a.jijJJ 55 55 1 . 11 ° 3 01 1 1� 1— 1— 2
•
71 9 1 5: 5 5tl t.1 51 • .11;b — 1, , e T --a—— /V1O
]5 eIla i !i ! lest ss_ i :iii 1Z� z W
eO^I • B B S B B . ® f !!°3 °�
Ebel 1 I a5A E•4 le “ • �o
� > 9 1 I ,
1 a E ° !I 0
0�1 @ ! d 4! 1 !• I1 0
l o ° U
`y i i I 1 1€ .e,s_ Z
�QlE6� i I 1a
sgg I ��a� `aa I `l ,11111 W a �t
EE e 0
H I 'II q do F11" 1 ,,, �I � r°1 �ll;��
1, Ie S4E ! a .... -I. a
IS!y 9Pq. .ling:�'f1 ' •,....o d�igg,__—L_4��__— ___ Ifp;
• 'S 'PMfi ,II2E ® :y r—'-( iT �� �1r'
Ea
tag _ 1--a `Ii:
4 11 l 1! °g{ - 11 i !
II! 7i( 11 a e1 6e Ni e. ! liebi ii
; a@ ! I ��b dl; d b•eq LI !� ��I le #�{ii�p[p! 1!1 II
i1 ! 1 X11 ' lfill 1 !q� d1d •• ='gr i ; t� t •1
1 9 '�( ! ! ! 1t III i'4t! p31 • 6 fi,;l19
1 !!. i it : i IS ,,,. 1111 t I�, I: .0 1
ib p iIitIiif !� y �I hi 1@ I!ht ,ii, JIit th lilkili!] hl .iii il 4gi! I 4 e I Ii!i 1 l
b Ohl
01`5 1413 ! pe 1 I ° [/1 -
i CC
t�1 11 1 Illi ` f gs; et�l
%Cr 11PI il to °' 4
! Ws i!i Ip° l f1
• ° ,.1. ��v '�°1' go 1 111 @6i 1:1„,
!
tI: i!@I`!I 11 ° ! @ s a b e! 1lii I I 1 alt: .t1E1 r 1.
B-60
• S w ow ucuw-n..name
- En 17 ^D f0 ■ AGV_
o Ih�ii O 7_- ' ¢"a
o - 11111 O - `R Of
zNgn I ilj QIp.
¢ as N' ��pN •
E ai Ta f CC CO
° � �zrn
Z Z Z
•
>-:_cn
Q
•
m°
u)-9
U
O
• 2
U
N
. LL
O
•
•
° - was•YVe xi y •
- ¢9wA wall WI I 0
It s�i a Y 1
rl° h
re 4 - a a
e
jI
0
@ 3{ !Yfi!b t
1
Li
11-4 4M
<' �� ` •
54 S'A'Y adYAi�/
r —a•P
7 7 i 11 ba •
I I w I� 9
I I w m urvi 11
r 7 r t i g Y®E
R-R/R TV
B-61
I
.a U On nWI W-ml.Lae w .w IOO1
w • ppg$ • ` '
t 1 g C1 ;� w if�• Y ZN-
°tea 'I s dSts gS g -v. 0 " I fJ I (:) ,AR IA o- ^'" k
, BEE°Ey 1 _ € fi eZ p € —co r Q^
` k, d 1 z�°� I <-
O `f:, 1aaH 54 QQQ 5yy <igq mmm�(�(�(���I��I��I�� O 0 0—
ELL �'�� I 5y: ' FE i i� o N' NO _J ti_
II E _ _ � iil ee_QE•'j {a 5 Q s >"6 p= OD r
,e,,,1 B o 5�l O ® 48 _ C) 1.5 °
� Mc
t CC▪ CD Na CC
Ea o
1�l191i1PEPi9! 'Ee �' 6e 51 Id ie Z Z 0
o ii g le 11111Thir f. oeaaa z -E14t� 1 Oil 1,111 �@ UU�z
w
H CC
O 2�
0
O s5g
ti g Ug 7 u g Z�
I
Q
§ m z
; III
, § g Fr Ee
a
aa w i ; i ' ' 3 (D I
ri I U P7
I II g rr I I zg z. !$ O
31 II
I I I - - `� �� _ �U
:�A" S S I a
aa� S •
S2 W si E A F
E I a j: B S &
1 is .,ti l S ® I ' " LJ• 5
yg ^y I q 1 ! v D
i 5; u g 151'
0
Ili1 R s { S zg
CC
7. 1 put
iq & y q
l U 1!"1 1 ° I ° c
i
v 1 v i
Vi� ' r
I A
- 1 ■ g F
lii f
I I- —1 !
v
I 11 g & ,S .
IY4
el L
• n U
I �' I
g ° 1111
B-62
DWI w 0•11695 a-NE-Id memo wcu
to l e:1 w Z:N .
i
o;- iiifl °O - Q ofl
„a^ , fn co =FR-
eazae�znN�v i -^ o o ∎••1°
4s :.A.rvrew unu I>5,h- W in N J ��t •0 n 8 °
} ..—� l=L Si [ Ili z Q
5j 1:6 1.--.i E VV d l ik ¢ ¢Q=
a F— !— z
, B . � �vi S 3 Ie I tn/ '�� I� _ VO
I �a I
s, lra " ♦ .fir ∎�
I I ,
T 1 I v II I
0
i7 Irr U
ir,or Cr9
. '
I go
0
AI I
i f E . ho
l i i. - \� =1;i 1l
1 i$el
a ® t 83s31se¢�
y
\ • qq
e -,pn r 4. sl I .l ihilti1ePz111
I IL'I 1 o99d X99:°]^3
A I.F I . . � : r�ikt • ° € i -�
_ Iv¢ 7 4 L. Q i
'ICI , g f I l 1 / 1 @� I =
W P trt . r _ kb3 N �� 1 z - '! i+� t a iii y - IF g t & €1' z Ss I „pc x
I! ! Y R . .., ,, 1 '1.�.d�d 4s Pi ii 1 !! !°iris mad ?s1 61
Li., iii � � sfl
manta, 11A 'I 1 .. F p
, �� a � !70 2 x1 ! - I r °i II
gg
I I - ----_ Z`1 °1 I(L�--A. VIA? .ta P • 456 @ € ig;II
T cif AtllUNOM l l y_/' 4440x104 l:l W 1 E 56 G9�.w f► 0
h1!!� ' se-a. szzudv uv�vn n� Fa€a & \®
e�vn • 1111€1 � fld '
6-63 0000 ® 6
I — \min 9 \ - S� , �a kc i .'�9 '.e Amnon wan-xvay.vwweu
I - !� I - tC ' u s el gn I1zZN-
I .j 8 6eil c7 ^ ^ ¢o <
I J t{ t ow- 11H, p 2OF
1 . i, i ( 8 = as - ® 1 F ��¢°D.
I 'i i a � �a ° o oJ�_..Ln
• I IAI 7 ---41 0 n0 {. �0, e� :. . . °_ o ° ct
I 1 x p � 138 w
UUCQt' z
,1-77,1' �t �r �o<� .e a ---===.-----t,..—_, Ii F H \z FE
11,�S l s 1" `gam 4 xtmin µ,.-__ Bar g _ I Ii O
( So' - Q: 1'.e I I, IA ''I Ego / AA"@ II1;. 1;1 d ( 8B 5�5l
i t I 10 ,i ciiIai �� ! A� ' d ell,' g ,g Oil p o
pi1; , 1II g'' rI PB�E @sQZ (�f g„).0 d_ 5eo 1 .1 . ' III I yl ti € Z
\�' ICI x . ..9mm�u ,_� 0 ] tl �°-,�. Epe i .. a( 1111 eeeFe3�
V 1 na... I ��11111/ $${{ i
Og
.. l I 1 s nQ .`,. d 1 `,v (/e((Y1(e(n igi C)
•NIi� N `�? 9 1 p NO. e
tltl1iii u s a
EV
r Lie L I
`i` /6 , .$ • 1jcj4[ k I:.am.a°�__2
41
.� a 4 i i 11 0
ICI �, ��` � �.
A— 1. I
'A It i - 1' 4 i i
wI 'w 9.0ii'
-'^{'1ig r -- Ra-, ' a'a^ ..� x Ir 71
aR I 25
,Ili ` R 4T� WI 9 . .. I1 l
�a ��
.i1 o, -^i a
I � � 1� I A"y flrt,l - ilii-
�E �I l� i IV lK 1!;itl
'v � _ wQ a R _ 4 s 1ar', ' y p E
-e� �� I l,� J A _ 9 6. eeu�s 1 @6 E p
kB lA - 1 i( R I 1 'ally I '' § Q a i! @ ! PH
L.- .a. ..1 A i / - 121' .1 �
y11y
i On I 1,' I P�,P _i l 1e o
x 9 "! y r,..1 1 1 1 1 - ' gl . .I P 0 ' g 4s , „y ie s! `,
$ II i g' ~ 1 i a m;g��
all► , iE1II p
I I16 gag((r i” v �..
�: R Q= E(:' R • ,:1- A ! _1 , , I (is'� ' i7 .S(1�6 Ba�a e.. e
{ I _�- 4� 7. �>'• y.�'Ss -.at .s §s-1w p�pPSi 1' `� \� f•
w e+cb�° _ s �' - -- y: aPq'` -? � S JI 6600 e e a
ud.�.aci.umie mPL.u2Fnm a m., a. w. a .. .. �., ... «.ars.R ii.—r– —
w as n an Ma w.IrrtallanucmPOLLSIELLEICO
00 (O- QV_
ail 8 L I e 1 (7 ^_V/aC NS
f- IeieQ O
gQ z`no 11111 O O 29
p a 'eel Zimn .. ® 1 1 _ IR
5 ~ O c>-
asa ° O in
71,5
t3 Q sQ �I� I o �` �= O In of—,'i=n
Q 1 f :� it i t( i - Fe M 0 N
Y : is t. t lip
tl E: :� �m �n eV{y�; ag !t io
le pips ip�i , II!t� i; �ol: ..� Z Z z
444 II AI i v , ; 9 �! : �� sJ� f` — -cc
In
�" i Qa/ �tl� Q O 1��� will I� Q
i Q � tl� i .7, s * x nn�
O 1 cD8
WI
$ L•<
ao9 • ! '44 N/ rk s? it s 1_ 1O0
I 11 9 a �1 > . P� 1��� i �
yea �,4t ; ,+,,t- 9 1 ; i 14 LL
.x.... Is* 1 j ZO
gir NNH °
_ ' a t r-` g I9 ir.' a p � 1�h air- tl - OU
tillg$ ei p°p°�qy'e a 1�, G¢a q �� t6QOt1 Sel Y ..� 1i� 141 II emefP(9 t I- 1_` �9 �� 1 Itufl,i� I°rlu"i•P
I iii
m CC
� e
L' ° I q' �! �e la •7
! ul • Ins , ra . 91f ';t p a � f i' G.
° e l en;ii iy� �! °, ilt `'°`i 0P .t Iea ai
tB ��^p• tl p � i
tq K R,; ()
alA g Ii1 S � i, 014 p ,it g „ (94 Sl' d
ge la � a '` /i e � t � Y _ /II C T g gt Ifi
.t ! to 4 1 ill,
5 t — —
Q (e ' lQ -egg _.�°t a [11
Q lip, ' a� 9 t I
t �
ii 1
to, q. Zi .� +� :ij
1111.itQ 01111.0„ q CI •
•
g Ilia / �.' P A tg3at i El VA
ik , br St 1 eeC �_ t
i 1 h A5
11°t e
I—i .eat ii P !d a e• } 0; ! .
5 '
EOM w an wa n-ev■iao ON SELLMINCILlISLEPOZO
20 1 !!t C-.135 (^p ^rn 2NVS
`okeo Ifni o _V12oor
3^
• E° ocP.0 N cr
s p -i- c°Wvei
d d
0
g
F ��z
Zv'
QO
r^O
WI
O
Qi @
1--Ft
aP k O=
• .•. 1 Zz
PI al ' z6
feQ r H
P
is g
0
• P
Q
a D
F
P Q3 0C
fa ' <, § "z CD gi
I, Inns R= '' R;/ z
p ;SIP §5. 9
ra rP 1! ti a i} lb
g r 0
I laei 3 `fS !zi §i @ ! ( 1
A -1,—,— ( �J
P
S - .F:f1 " Qex. 1 o
a '7g n f ..r 1 p4 Lg.
'.in hi.. P E 'e 11���
P k
�t/
d '1,..1.7..c 3,...t .._._. ,re
y IL II p e� s p21
I ° y�y���yyS _ $ y e : gg
Az: ;eF @� S!aEi f� �J 8 d ;gPE @g fi
i it s es Fy py P fr' Be
RIB pi ® 6 g f f ; Q � i...
SI• 1 gill, Ea as
f g .� x I�
a tl a .. a. T'a s®>
Z f" Ili P P z e6[1 Ii
e ` y j .e
Y
$-6t
v, m ^ av_
1 �H lw7 zZN�
W y : '
i0 s P ��I i. o,e-o 11 .11 O —
HI
' u /
Z gm n : : I ig 1 16!I Q561 $1 [ ' S
z zCOo
U U "` <
Lu
il i g N m °
$$� u o G 0
III . V d U h 7 U i O aCt
U,
x V U
I
0
ill : s L
Q�
c0i ; i 1 ' U
w DO
m g :°'g x g E 9 'a e g 8 x
Q r°' 5 8�, Zg
4. < <X 0 0 O 8 0 e s LLo a.
A
4y a - _
01
• M R 1 I IT I % CO
a x dQ
i
Ii �li� A C I II 1, •
r '4:•: l{{l i R A iii;Aa
r x . q
iZ • 11 ki I-
P ',331:1:4 R a 1
9 j1 11 IN
1L a• 4 1 I c 1 A �! , `W�g
zO R A 1
t5
11 CO: O I • i 1 gU
RI W.' L
, u o to a
r i m y
``1�� s }"' Y p ilILA
° P
pp e4' n �O
V X tat I,a
y ; H r' y n I - R 11
�5 �tiB '" ° o II 1v\11 z
6±�'CC° _ c I
GO•'k n
€a : ,all
j�Qi�. '4A0©0�00 —
,2
reig
?:' ii ti
; bil U V nh g '5'`
$ '1
R?❖ .
; I e
rY
421.0; I . 7
B-67
w
u���- >m.O�BM
� w r 1 m 1h Nu_r-
8 EI [7 T �d 4
::.41/4.TE:4, o�eo tali O � Og
_ [2 �pe i O F FQ-6N.
• — M: �Lc
Z ZU
E
asC Czm
C
I— I—■ Z
m a ^
CO
I I .
16- Z O: . q i 'I l l • .._....,--.7..ete; tricr;fl 1 0
0
OL
- ad w / `
' ,, •�='- -1 rna2 `+ ".rr�" .,,, i, '.`' i'rr�- - ?j I;: , , 1
a-7,4,,y �1 Mli ST3 earl. Q—"Ea-C, , _ 3. 1 T W O
�. :ill Ub V Y r "�I
rflg
yl , I 11, o
dr 1iP zx +S�,; I� z= ( I▪ I1 !r b J r' f r^
,i I i, 3 1 r ^'�. - I U� 1;1 + s. �n lY��' V J�
) 'I ' r1 Ij^ �+' _ r �r ▪ _ I x .t. ,�
J
fi rm— Y , _ i u w 1� L Ic) CE
1, J r } 1 —I I r I ) �I r,,L+ . 1r ,3 V
IY 1, tr I•. —L r �>e
• t l , II II'Si L.i 1 IF ��3 I r I 8 �LII 8 IL v ��C r W
T 1 k,1 II f �:1 11'1.1,17j
s - it ' s• I g �� I� 6;1 nl I-
a•-:,f2<e I•l -J 5 r i j, .. .j J I i f .{ . I�II
a Lg kn j1; f. '�\ i J�41 °y'..r I� ` F?L I , I J � -1, I
• i ° 4 d Yl� 4.11 1 ✓ .f ;;g•U•
; 1 u t '' 1 ' ry II ■Y_ ,.:;7;1;:12:.21:-;I iin - it ggax -
F w �'. r ��a � 0 H I, °Ibl to i s ,iI � gl sl'. �' K�S
2 J
a I � F i
1
ji•j'� P I ,' 11 1.v I ° -~ 11 I i� 1 . II 4,,•
g ' 't�' is g..:---.: 11 r.�' 7 L �' r- I. I,.
Y <. rn - , J 1 tE y.0 iP' T:i 11 ° �I'°!' t I} { , {'� r I r.
� � 'ryI F I I rI r
k ,ah I \ R j t11 - '1
Zvi 11r. L < 'I rr1 II ': i _ F F�. 11 a7 it r�
1'- -;1'.'' r �I - 1 11 I
'1 ' �. �r '4!'•r,� °• { F I '11 4 r S' li r . l .
u .� I 1 ▪1 mil"�rs �� rp.,.�I
•
Al.
V i I. _ 4 Ac - —t r 4 ; 1 1 4
i : r•,_� �. . ., `-'' , a` tti " -
LL �M �
XtlON
s 1 w y n II:
g
X11,
8-68 -
0
ACTION AGENDA
• DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE MEETING
TUESDAY MARCH 15, 2011 7:00 P.M.
RANCHO CUCAMONGA CIVIC CENTER
RAINS ROOM
10500 CIVIC CENTER DRIVE
RANCHO CUCAMONGA
Committee Members: Lou Munoz Ray Wimberly James Troyer Donald Granger
Alternates: Frances Howdyshell Richard Fletcher Francisco Oaxaca
CONSENT CALENDAR
NO ITEMS SUBMITTED.
PROJECT REVIEW ITEMS
This is the time and place for the Committee to discuss and provide direction to an applicant regarding
their development application. The following items do not legally require any public testimony, although
. the Committee may open the meeting for public input.
7:00 p.m.
(Tabe/Betty) DEVELOPMENT AND DESIGN REVIEW DRC2011-00028 - K. HOVNANIAN
• COMMUNITIES INC. - Architectural and site review for 63 single-family residences on
45.23 acres within the Very Low Residential District (1-2 dwelling units per acre) of the
Etiwanda Specific Plan (ESP), located on south side of Banyan Street, approximately
1,220 feet east of East Avenue - APN: 0225-191-12 and 0226-102-02. Related files:
Tentative Tract Map SUBTT17651 AND SUBTT18708. On August 9, 2006, a Mitigated
Negative Declaration of environmental impacts was adopted by the Planning Commission
for Tentative Tract Map SUBTT17651 and on April 15, 2010, for Tentative Tract Map
SUBTT18708. The California Environmental Quality Act provides that no further
environmental review or Negative Declaration is required for subsequent projects or
minor revisions to projects within the scope of the previous Mitigated Negative
Declaration.
PUBLIC COMMENTS
There were no public comments.
ADJOURNMENT
The meeting adjourned at 9:07 p.m.
•
EXHIBIT E
B-69
e
DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS •
7:00 p.m. Tabe van der Zwaag March 15, 2011
DEVELOPMENT AND DESIGN REVIEW DRC2011-00028 - K. HOVNANIAN COMMUNITIES INC. -
Architectural and site review for 63 single-family residences on 45.23 acres within the Very Low
Residential District (1-2 dwelling units per acre) of the Etiwanda Specific Plan (ESP), located on south
side of Banyan Street, approximately 1,220 feet east of East Avenue - APN: 0225-191-12 and
0226-102-02. Related files: Tentative Tract Map SUBTT17651 AND SUBTT18708. On August 9, 2006,
a Mitigated Negative Declaration of environmental impacts was adopted by the Planning Commission for
Tentative Tract Map SUBTT17651 and on April 15, 2010, for Tentative Tract Map SUBTT18708. The
California Environmental Quality Act provides that no further environmental review or Negative
Declaration is required for subsequent projects or minor revisions to projects within the scope of the
previous Mitigated Negative Declaration.
Project Proposal: The project site is located on the south side of Banyan Street and 1,220 feet east of
East Avenue and is made up of two approved tract maps for a total of 63 lots (SUBTT17651 — 56 lots on
40 acres and SUBTT18708 — 7 lots on 5 acres). The site is located within the Very Low Development
District of the Etiwanda Specific Plan and within the Equestrian Overlay District. The lots range in size
from 20,109 to 47,218 square feet and will be developed entirely with single-story residences, ranging in
size from 3,401 to 4,049 square feet. A community trail runs along the perimeter of the site, with each •
residence either providing direct equestrian access to a local trail or a community trail.
Staff Comments: This proposal is designed with 100 percent single-story residences, exceeding the
25 percent design policy. Each lot meets the minimum setback and the lot coverage requirement. The
applicant has provided five floor plans with 4 elevations per floor plan. While staff feels that the applicant
has worked to address a number of inconsistencies that the project has with the Etiwanda Specific Plan,
a number of issues remain unresolved. These issues are being brought before the Committee at the
applicant's request.
1. Number of Footprints: The major issue is whether the project meets the intent of the
Etiwanda Specific Plan requirement (see attached) that residential developments with 61 to 80
homes include 7 footprints. The Development Code permits reverse footprints and alternate
garage orientations (i.e. side entry or detached garages) to count as separate footprints.
As proposed, the project includes two distinct footprints (62- and 68-foot wide houses), one with an
alternate garage orientation (side entry), and reverse footprints for each model. Staff feels that this
equates to 6 footprints, 1 footprint deficient of meeting the requirement. The applicant feels that
they are providing 4 unique footprints, one alternate garage orientation and 5 reverse footprints, for
a total of 10 footprints. The question is whether the proposed variation in footprints meets the
intent of the Etiwanda Specific Plan to avoid excessive repetition of single-family homes with nearly
identical floor plans. Staff is concerned that if one were to look at the Detailed Site Plan for the
project, it would appear that nearly identical homes are being plotted on each lot, this is especially
true of the side and rear elevations.
•
B-70
• DRC ACTION AGENDA
DRC2011-00028— K. HOVANANIAN COMMUNITIES, INC.
March 15, 2011
Page 1
2. Plotting: The Etiwanda Specific Plan requires that a minimum 50 percent of the houses not be
plotted parallel to the street frontage. As proposed, the applicant is only skewing the houses on the
large lots at the end of the cul-de-sacs. Staff feels that there is adequate room on the sides of the
houses to meet this requirement. The Committee should make a recommendation as to the
percentage of skew necessary to fulfill the requirement. Additionally, subdivisions within the Very
Low Development Districts are required to vary the house setback as measured from the property
line by up to 10 feet. The current variation averages approximately 5 feet between neighboring
residences.
3. Design Issues: While staff feels that the applicant has made a good effort in designing front
elevations that are distinct from one another, they are deficient in carrying this variation over to the
side and rear elevations. This problem is magnified because of the size of the houses (3,401 to
4,049 square feet and single-story houses 90 feet deep) and the lack of true variation in the
footprints of the house as seen from the side and rear elevations. Per staff recommendation, the
applicant has added front porches to two of the models, short walls, or railings to better define the
courtyards on the other three models, and wall pop-outs on the side elevations of each of the
models. Staff feels that additional attention needs to be directed towards the side and rear
elevations and to the front porches on the Spanish Eclectic Models 3664 and 4049, which look
dated. Staff has outlined a number of design recommendations below under secondary issues.
• Major Issues:
1. Number of Footprints — Staff feels that there is inadequate variation in the footprints between the
models to fulfill the intent of the Etiwanda Specific Plan, and that the side and rear elevations lack
adequate articulation and variation.
Secondary Issues:
1. Front porches on the Spanish Eclectic Models 3664 and 4049 look dated and should be
redesigned.
2. The garage doors on each of the Spanish Eclectic models are generic and do not enhance the
Spanish architecture.
3. Each model should have a minimum of two pop-outs on the side elevations. Additional pop-outs
should be added to the right elevation of Model 3401 and 3406 (fireplace), the left elevation of
Models 3664 and 3898 (casita window) and the right and left elevations of Model 4049 (bedroom
and kitchen windows).
4. Add wood siding to the chimney of Model 3406 — Rural Cottage.
5. Add a plaster wainscot to the chimney of Model 3664—Spanish Eclectic.
6. Carry the design elements used on the front elevations to the rear elevations of each model to add
visual interest.
• 7. Use decorative solid block walls with metal gates along the private trails. The applicant has
proposed equestrian fencing with wood-faced gates. Staff has informed the applicant that the
B-71
DRC ACTION AGENDA •
DRC2011-00028 — K. HOVANANIAN COMMUNITIES, INC.
March 15, 2011
Page 2
Committee may consider a combination 3-foot high block wall topped by tube metal fencing with
pilasters at the property corners, with a maximum of 4-foot spacing between the pilasters.
Technical Issue: The trail and wall construction details should be returned to the Trails Advisory
Committee before continuing to Planning Commission.
Staff Recommendation: Staff seeks direction from the Committee as to whether the project meets the
minimum requirements of the Etiwanda Specific Plan related to the variation in footprints (7 required),
building articulation, and 360 degree architecture.
Design Review Committee Action:
The Committee did not recommend approval of DRC2011-00028 and made the following
recommendations regarding the issues presented by staff:
1. Number of Footprints: The Committee concluded that the applicant did not fulfill the requirement
for providing the required 7 footprints. The Committee indicated that the applicant should design a
new floor plan that was substantially different than what was presented. This additional floor plan
requirement could be fulfilled with a one or two-story design. .
2. Plotting: The Committee stated that the houses were not adequately staggered and recommended •
that there be an approximate 10-foot setback difference between the neighboring houses.
Regarding staff's comments concerning skewing the house product, Commissioner Munoz agreed
with the applicant that skewing the houses could give the appearance that a mistake was made in
plotting the houses. Staff has interpreted this statement as confirmation that skewing the house
product is not required, but a variation in the setbacks by 10 feet between the neighboring houses
is required.
3. Design Issues: Overall, the Committee was pleased with the architecture and articulation of the
houses. The Committee noted that additional attention should be given to the front porches of
Models 3664 and 4049 (Spanish Eclectic) and the garage doors on each of the Spanish Eclectic
elevations. The Committee also stated that the paint scheme on the Model 3C (Classic American
West) was unappealing and too dark. The applicant agreed to modify the paint scheme for Model
3C (Classic American West).
4. Equestrian Fencing: The Committee was not supportive of the applicant's proposal for using
equestrian fencing along the private equestrian trails and recommended that they provide either
solid decorative walls or a combination wall in which the bottom 3 feet was a solid decorative wall
and the top half was open wrought iron fencing with decorative pilasters. All the gates would need
to be view-obscuring wrought iron fencing material.
The meeting concluded with the Committee recommending that the applicant work with staff and return
to a regularly scheduled Design Review Committee meeting to review the changes.
Members Present: Munoz, Wimberly, Granger, Henderson •
Staff Planner: Tabe van der Zwaag
B-72
• DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS
•
March 15, 2011
ADJOURNMENT
The meeting adjourned at 9:07 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
ye
James R. Troyer, AICP
•
Planning Director
•
•
B-73
• ACTION AGENDA
DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE MEETING
TUESDAY MAY 3, 2011 7:00 P.M.
RANCHO CUCAMONGA CIVIC CENTER
RAINS ROOM
10500 CIVIC CENTER DRIVE
RANCHO CUCAMONGA
Committee Members: Lou Munoz Ray Wimberly James Troyer Donald Granger
Alternates: Frances Howdyshell Richard Fletcher Francisco Oaxaca
CONSENT CALENDAR
NO ITEMS SUBMITTED.
•
PROJECT REVIEW ITEMS
This is the time and place for the Committee to discuss and provide direction to an applicant regarding
their development application. The following items do not legally require any public testimony, although
the Committee may open the meeting for public input.
•7:00 a.m.
(Tabe/Betty) DEVELOPMENT AND DESIGN REVIEW DRC2011-00028 - K. HOVNANIAN
COMMUNITIES INC. - Architectural and site review for 63 single-family residences on
45.23 acres within the Very Low Residential District (1-2 dwelling units per acre) of the
Etiwanda Specific Plan (ESP), located on south side of Banyan Street, approximately
1,220 feet east of East Avenue - APN: 225-191-12 and 0226-102-02. Related Files:
Tentative Tract Map SUBTT17651 and SUBTT18708. On August 9, 2006, a Mitigated
Negative Declaration of environmental impacts was adopted by the Planning.
Commission for Tentative Tract Map SUBTT17651 and on April 15, 2010, for
Tentative Tract Map SUBTT18708. The California Environmental Quality Act provides
that no further environmental review or Negative Declaration is required for
subsequent projects or minor revisions to projects within the scope of the previous
Mitigated Negative Declaration.
PUBLIC COMMENTS
This is the time and place for the general public to address the Committee. State law prohibits the •
Committee from addressing any issue not previously included on the Agenda. The Committee may
receive testimony and set the matter for a subsequent meeting. Comments are limited to five minutes
per individual.
ADJOURNMENT
The meeting adjourned at 8:01 p.m.
• B-74
DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS •
7:00 p.m. May 3, 2011 Tabe van der Zwaag
DEVELOPMENT AND DESIGN REVIEW DRC2011-00028 - K. HOVNANIAN COMMUNITIES INC. -
Architectural and site review for 63 single-family residences on 45.23 acres within the Very Low
Residential District (1-2 dwelling units per acre) of the Etiwanda Specific Plan (ESP), located on south
side of Banyan Street, approximately 1,220 feet east of East Avenue - APN: 225-191-12 and 0226-102-
02. Related Files: Tentative Tract Map SUBTT17651 and SUBTT18708. On August 9, 2006, a
Mitigated Negative Declaration of environmental impacts was adopted by the Planning Commission for
Tentative Tract Map SUBTT17651 and on April 15, 2010, for Tentative Tract Map SUBTT18708. The
California Environmental Quality Act provides that no further environmental review or Negative
Declaration is required for subsequent projects or minor revisions to projects within the scope of the
previous Mitigated Negative Declaration.
Proiect Proposal: The project site is located on the south side of Banyan Street and 1,220 feet east of
East Avenue and is made up of two approved tract maps for a total of 63 lots (SUBTT17651 — 56 lots on
40 acres and SUBTT18708 — 7 lots on 5 acres). The site is located within the Very Low Development
District of the Etiwanda Specific Plan and within the Equestrian Overlay District. The lots range in size
from 20,109 to 47,218 square feet and will be developed entirely with single-story residences ranging in
size from 3,084 to 4,049 square feet. A community trail runs along the perimeter of the site, with each
residence either providing direct equestrian access to a local trail or a community trail.
Background: The project was reviewed by the Committee on March 15, 2011, and the following changes •
were recommended:
1. Number of Footprints: Provide an additional Floor Plan that is substantially different than those
presented.
2. Plotting: Stagger the front yard setback with a minimum of 10 feet between the neighboring
houses.
3. Design Issues: Enhance the front porches of Models 3664 and 4049 (Spanish Eclectic) and the
garage doors on each of the Spanish Eclectic elevations. Modify the paint scheme on the Model
3C (Classic American West), which the Committee felt to be unappealing and too dark in tone.
4. Equestrian Fencing: Provide equestrian fencing at the rear of the lots with either solid decorative
walls or a combination wall in which the bottom 3 feet is a solid decorative wall and the top half is
open wrought iron fencing with decorative pilasters. The gates are required to be backed by a view
obscuring metal material.
Proposed Changes: The applicant has addressed many of the issues raised by the Committee by
making the following changes:
1. They provided a new one-story Floor Plan that is substantially different and includes a side entry -
garage. The new Floor Plan will replace one of the originally submitted Floor Plans (Plan 1).
2. They increased the setbacks of the neighboring houses to a minimum of 10 feet. •
B-75
•
DRC ACTION AGENDA
DRC2011-00028 — K. HOVNANIAN COMMUNITIES INC.
ay 3, 2011
age 2
3. They redesigned the front porches on the two plans with Spanish-style architecture and chose a
more acceptable garage door on each of the Spanish models.
4. They provided a rear property line wall along the equestrian trails that is a combination of 3 feet of
decorative block wall and 3 feet of tube steel fencing.
Staff Comments: Staff has reviewed the updated plans and is overall pleased with the changes.
Though, a few additional changes are recommended which are listed below under Secondary Issues
below.
Major Issues:
1. None.
•
Secondary Issues:
1. The Design Review Guidelines recommends that front porches be a minimum 6 feet deep. The
applicant proposes the porches on Plan 1 and on Plan 3 to be 4 feet deep. Staff recommends
increasing the depth of these plans to 6 feet (as measured from inside of the support column to the
front of the house)..
•2. Plan A1-3 (Bungalow) is missing the stone veneer wrap on the right garage elevation. Also, it is
recommended that the applicant add a railing to the front porch of this model.
3. There are odd side-yard return wall alignments on Lots 6, 17, and 51. The normal way of handling
these lot-wall configurations is shown on Lot 40.
4. A metal side yard gate with view obscuring backing is normally required to access the side yards of
each residence; the applicant proposes vinyl gates. Consideration should also be given to
requiring decorative pilasters on either side of the gates.
5. Consideration should be given to adding wood siding to the chimney of Model 3406 (Rural Cottage).
Staff Recommendation: Staff seeks direction from the Committee on the issues raised above and
whether the project can be scheduled for Planning Commission.
Design Review Committee Action:
The Committee approved the project with the following changes:
•
1. The front porches on Plan 1 shall have a minimum depth of 6 feet as measured from front-of-house
to back-of-railing.
2. The front porches on all other plans shall have a minimum depth of 6 feet as measured from
front-of-house to back of support column.
• 3. Add railings to the front porches on Plan 1B and 1 C.
B-76
DRC ACTION AGENDA
DRC2011-00028 — K. HOVNANIAN COMMUNITIES INC. .
May 3, 2011 •
Page 3
4. Add wood siding to the chimney on Plan 2D.
5. Use metal gates with view obscuring backing on all side yard gates.
6. All walls shall have decorative concrete cap with a minimum 1-inch overhang.
Members Present: Munoz, Wimberly, Granger
Staff Planner: Tabe van der Zwaag
•
B-77
• RESOLUTION NO. 11-25
A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
RANCHO CUCAMONGA, CALIFORNIA, APPROVING DRC2011-00028, A
REQUEST FOR ARCHITECTURAL AND SITE REVIEW FOR 63 SINGLE-
FAMILY RESIDENCES ON 45.23 ACRES WITHIN THE VERY LOW
RESIDENTIAL DISTRICT (1-2 DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE) OF THE
ETIWANDA SPECIFIC PLAN (ESP), LOCATED ON THE SOUTH SIDE OF
BANYAN STREET, APPROXIMATELY 1,220 FEET EAST OF EAST AVENUE;
AND MAKING FINDINGS IN SUPPORT THEREOF - APNS: 225-191-12 AND
0226-102-02.
A. Recitals.
1. K. Hovnanian Communities filed an application for the approval of Development Review
DRC2011-00028, as described in the title of this Resolution. Hereinafter in this Resolution, the
subject Development Review request is referred to as "the application."
2. On the 8th day of June 2011, the Planning Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga
conducted a duly noticed public hearing on the application and concluded said hearing on that date.
3. All legal prerequisites prior to the adoption of this Resolution have occurred.
B. Resolution.
NOW, THEREFORE, it is hereby found, determined, and resolved by the Planning Commission
• of the City of Rancho Cucamonga as follows:
1. This Commission hereby specifically finds that all of the facts set forth in the Recitals, Part
A, of this Resolution are true and correct.
2. Based upon the substantial evidence presented to this Commission during the
above-referenced public hearing June 8, 2011, including written and oral staff reports, together with
public testimony, this Commission hereby specifically finds as follows:
a. The application is for a site that is located on the south side of Banyan Street and .
1,220 feet east of East Avenue and is made up of two approved tract maps for a total of 63 lots,
SUBTT17651 — 56 lots on 40 acres approved August 9, 2006 and SUBTT18708 — 7 lots on 5 acres
approved April 14, 2010; and
b. The 45.23 acre site has been rough graded and drains roughly from north to south.
North of the site, across Banyan Street, is vacant land zoned Very Low Residential (VL) (.1-2 dwelling
units per acre). South of the site is a proposed 76 lot subdivision south that is zoned Very Low
Residential (VL) (.1-2 dwelling units per acre). East of the site is a flood control facility that is zoned
Open Space. West of the site are multiple lots that include single-family residences, a Christmas Tree
• Farm and vacant land which are zoned Very Low Residential (VL) (.1-2 dwelling units per acre); and
c. The site is located within the Very Low Development District of the Etiwanda Specific
Plan and within the Equestrian Overlay District. The lots range in size from 20,109 to 47,218 square
• feet and will be developed entirely with single-story residences ranging in size from 3,084.to 4,049
square feet; and
6.78
PLANNING COMMISSION RESOLUTION NO. 11-25
DEVELOPMENT REVIEW DRC2011-00028— K. HOVNANIAN COMMUNITIES
JUNE 8, 2011 • •
Page 2 •
d. The project was designed to conform to all the development requirements outlined in
the Etiwanda Specific Plan for the Very Low Residential District.
•
3. Based upon the substantial evidence presented to this Commission during the
above-referenced public hearing and upon the specific findings of facts set forth in Paragraphs 1 and
2 above, this Commission hereby finds and concludes as follows:
a. The proposed project is consistent with the General Plan, Development Code, and
any applicable specific plans; and •
b. The proposed design or improvements are consistent with the General Plan,
Development Code, and any applicable specific plans; and
c. The site is physically suitable for the type of development proposed; and
d. The design of the project is not likely to cause substantial environmental damage and
avoidable injury to humans and wildlife or their habitat; and
e. The project is not likely to cause serious public health problems; and
4. Based upon the facts and information contained in the application, together with all written
and oral reports included for the environmental assessment for the application, the Planning
Commission finds that no subsequent or supplemental environmental document is required pursuant
to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) in connection with the review and approval of this
application based upon the following findings and determinations:
a. Pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act ("CEQA") and the City's local
CEQA Guidelines, the City adopted a Mitigated Negative Declaration on August 9, 2006 and
April 14, 2010 in connection with the City's approval of Tentative. Tract Map SUBTT17651 and
SUBTT18708. Pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15162, no subsequent or supplemental EIR or
Negative Declaration is required in connection with subsequent discretionary approvals of the same
project unless: (i) substantial changes are proposed to the project that indicate new or more severe
impacts on the environment; (ii) substantial changes have occurred in the circumstances under which
the project was previously reviewed that indicates new or more severe environmental impacts; or (iii)
new important information shows the project will have new or more severe impacts than previously
considered; or (iv) additional mitigation measures are now feasible to reduce impacts or different
mitigation measures can be imposed to substantially reduce impacts.
b. The Planning Commission finds, in connection with Tentative Tract Maps
SUBTT17651 and SUBTT18708, that substantial changes to the project or the circumstances
surrounding the project have not occurred, which would create new or more severe impacts than
those evaluated in the previous Mitigated Negative Declaration. In that the applicant proposes
building 63 single-family residences on the previously approved 56 lot (SUBTT17651) and 7 lot
(SUBTT18708) Tentative Tract Maps. Staff further finds that the project will not have one or more
significant effects not discussed in the previous Mitigated Negative Declaration, not have more severe
effects than previously analyzed, and that additional or different mitigation measures are not required
to reduce the impacts of the project to a level of less-than-significant. In that the previously approved •
lots are surrounded by existing single-family residential development and the proposed residences
meet all development criteria outlined in the Etiwanda Specific Plan and the City's Development
Code.
8-79
•
PLANNING COMMISSION RESOLUTION NO. 11-25
DEVELOPMENT REVIEW DRC2011-00028— K. HOVNANIAN COMMUNITIES
• JUNE 8, 2011
Page 3
c. Based on these findings and all evidence in the record, the Planning Commission
concurs with the staff determination that no additional environmental review is required pursuant to
CEQA in connection with the City's consideration of Development Review DRC2011-00028.
5. Based upon the findings and conclusions set forth in Paragraphs 1, 2, 3, and 4 above, this
Commission hereby approves the application subject to each and every condition set forth below and
in the Standard Conditions, attached hereto and incorporated herein by this reference.
Planning Department
1) Approval is for the architectural and site plan review of a 63-lot subdivision
located on the south side of Banyan Street and 1,220 feet east of East
Avenue - APNS: 225-191-12 AND 0226-102-02.
2) All Conditions of Approval related to Tentative Tract Map SUBTT17651
and SUBTT18708 shall apply.
3) The project shall conform to all recommended mitigation measure outlined
in the acoustical studies (DKS Associates — November 29, 2005 and Vista
Environmental — April 25, 2008) related to the City's interior and exterior
noise standards.
• 4) All wood and stone siding material shall be carried to the adjacent return
wall or a change in wall plane.
5) Add a wood railing to front porch of Plan 1 (Classic American West).
• 6) All lighting fixtures used on the side and rear elevations shall match the
lighting fixtures used on the front elevations.
7) All walls exposed to public view shall be split face block.
8) Side yard gates shall have a minimum 90 percent view obscuring metal
privacy screen.
9) All access gates to public and private equestrian trails shall be
constructed to the standards outlined in the Rancho Cucamonga
Engineering Department Standard Drawings.
Engineering Department
1) Applicable conditions of Planning Commission Resolutions 06-75, for
Tract 17651, and 10-16, for Tract 18708, shall continue to apply. The
following conditions were noted on the public improvement plans:
• a) Install private landscaping and irrigation systems in the parkways of
• corner lots 1, 11, 12, 22, 23, 34, 35, 45, 46 and 56 prior to public
improvements being accepted by the City.
B-80
cc': ;Y;, COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
DEPARTMENT
STANDARD CONDITIONS
•
PROJECT #: DRC2011-00028 •
SUBJECT: DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
APPLICANT: K HOVNANIAN COMMUNITIES INC.
LOCATION: APNS: 225-191-12 AND 0226-102-02
ALL OF THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS APPLY TO YOUR PROJECT.
APPLICANT SHALL CONTACT THE PLANNING DEPARTMENT, (909) 477-2750, FOR
COMPLIANCE WITH THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS:
• Completion Date
General Requirements
1. The applicant shall agree to defend at his sole expense any action brought against the City, its _/_/_
agents, officers, or employees, because of the issuance of such approval,or in the alternative, to
relinquish such approval. The applicant shall reimburse the City, its agents, officers, or
employees, for any Court costs and attorneys fees which the City, its agents, officers, or
employees may be required by a court to pay as a result of such action. The City may, at its sole
discretion, participate at its own expense in the defense of any such action but such participation
shall not relieve applicant of his obligations under this condition.
2. Copies of the signed Planning Commission Resolution of Approval No. 11-25, Standard _/_/_
Conditions, and all environmental mitigations shall be included on the plans (full size). The
sheet(s) are for information only to all parties involved in the construction/grading activities and
are not required to be wet sealed/stamped by a licensed Engineer/Architect.
3. The applicant shall be required to pay any applicable Fish and Game fees as shown below. The /_/_
. project planner will confirm which fees apply to this project. All checks are to be made payable to
the Clerk of the Board Supervisors and submitted to the Planning Commission Secretary prior to .
the Planning Commission or Planning Director hearing:
Notice of Determination -$50 -X
B. Time Limits
1. Development/Design Review approval shall expire if building permits are not issued or approved / /
• use has not commenced within 5 years from the date of approval. No extensions are allowed.
SC-12-08 1
(:\PLANNING\FINAL\PLNGCOMM\2011 Res & Stf Rpt1DRC2011-00028Stnd Cond 6-8.doc
B-81
Project No.DRC2011-00028
Completion Date
C. Site Development
1. The site shall be developed and maintained in accordance with the'approved plans which include / /_
site plans, architectural elevations,exterior materials and colors, landscaping, sign program,and
grading on file in the Planning Department,the conditions contained herein, Development Code
regulations, and the Etiwanda Specific Plan, and the Community Plan,
2. Prior to any use of the project site or business activity being commenced thereon, all Conditions /_/_
of Approval shall be completed to the satisfaction of the Planning Director.
3. Occupancy of the facilities shall not commence until such time as all Uniform Building Code and _/_/_
State Fire Marshal regulations have been complied with. Prior to occupancy, plans shall be
submitted to the Rancho Cucamonga Fire Protection District and the Building and Safety
Department to show compliance. The buildings shall be inspected for compliance prior to
occupancy.
4. Revised site plans and building elevations incorporating all Conditions of Approval shall be /_/_
submitted for Planning Director review and approval prior to the issuance of building permits.
5. All site, grading, landscape, irrigation, and street improvement plans shall be coordinated for /_/_
consistency prior to issuance of any permits (such as grading, tree removal, encroachment, •
building, etc.) or prior to final map approval in the case of a custom lot subdivision, or approved
use has commenced, whichever comes first.
6. Approval of this request shall not waive compliance with all sections of the Development Code,all / /_
other applicable City Ordinances, and applicable Community or Specific Plans in effect at the
time of building permit issuance.
•
7. All ground-mounted utility appurtenances such as transformers, AC condensers, etc., shall be _/_/_
located out of public view and adequately screened through the use of a combination of concrete •
or masonry walls, berming, and/or landscaping to the satisfaction of the Planning Director. For
single-family residential developments, transformers shall be placed in underground vaults.
8. All building numbers and individual units shall be identified in a clear and concise manner, /_/_
including proper illumination.
9. A detailed plan indicating trail widths, maximum slopes, physical conditions, fencing, and weed /_/_
control, in accordance with City Master Trail drawings, shall be submitted for Planning Director
• review and approval prior to approval and recordation of the Final Tract Map and prior to
approval of street improvement and grading plans. Developer shall upgrade and construct all
trails, including fencing and drainage devices, in conjunction with street improvements.
10. Local Feeder Trail entrances shall also provide access for service vehicles,such as veterinarians _/_/_
or hay deliveries, including a 12-foot minimum drive approach. Entrance shall be gated provided
that equestrian access is maintained through step-throughs in accordance with Engineering
Department Standard Drawing 1006-B and 1007-B.
11. Local Feeder Trail grades shall not exceed 0.5%at the downstream end of a trail for a distance _/_/_
of 25 feet behind the public right-of-way line to prohibit trail debris from reaching the street.
Drainage devices may be required by the Building Official
• 12. Provide a 24-foot by 24-foot or 12-foot by 48-foot corral area in the rear yard adjacent to the Local _/_/_
Feeder Trail. Grade access from corral to trail with a maximum slope of 5:1 and a minimum
width of 10 feet.
•
2 •
I:\PLANNING\FINAL\PLNGCOMM\2011 Res & Stf Rpt\DRC2011-00028Stnd Cond 6-8.doc
B-82
•
•
Project No.DRC2011-00028
Completion Date
13. For single-family residential development within the Equestrian/Rural Overlay District, at least one _/ /_
• model home shall be provided with a constructed 24-foot by 24-foot corral with appropriate
fencing.
14. Where corner side, interior side or rear yard property lines are adjacent to local equestrian trails, /_/_
construct minimum 6 foot high decorative masonry walls. Fences shall be constructed per the
design shown on the submitted Development plans dated May 10, 2011.
• 15. The Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs) shall not prohibit the keeping the equine _/_/_
animals where zoning requirements for the keeping of said animals have been met. Individual lot
owners in subdivisions shall have the option of keeping said animals without the necessity of
appealing to boards of directors of homeowners' associations for amendments to the CC&Rs.
16. The Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs) and Articles of Incorporation of the / /_
Homeowners'Association are subject to the approval of the Planning and Engineering Services
Department and the City Attorney. They shall be recorded concurrently with the Final Map or
prior to the issuance of building permits, whichever occurs first. A recorded copy shall be
provided to the City Engineer. The Homeowners' Association shall submit to the Planning
Department a list of the name and address of their officers on or before January 1 of each and
every year and whenever said information changes.
17. All parkways, open areas, and landscaping shall be permanently maintained by the property /_/_
owner, homeowners'association, or other means acceptable to the City. Proof of this landscape
maintenance shall be submitted for Planning Director and Engineering Services Department
review and approved prior to the issuance of building permits.
18. The developer shall submit a construction access plan and schedule for the development of all _/_/_
lots for Planning Director and Engineering Services Department approval; including, but not
limited to, public notice requirements, special street posting, phone listing for community
• concerns, hours of construction activity, dust control measures, and security fencing. — —
19. Six-foot decorative block walls shall be constructed along the project perimeter. I f a double wall / /
•
condition would result, the developer shall make a good faith effort to work with the adjoining
property owners to provide a single wall. Developer shall notify, by mail, all contiguous property
owner at least 30 days prior to the removal of any existing walls/ fences along the project's
perimeter.
20. Construct block walls between homes(i.e., along interior side and rear property lines), rather than / /_
wood fencing for permanence, durability, and design consistency.
21. For residential development, return walls and corner side walls shall be decorative masonry. _/ /_
22. On corner side yards, provide minimum 5-foot setback between walls/fences and sidewalk. The _/_/_
5-foot wall/fence setback and the parkway shall have landscape and irrigation in addition to the
required street trees. Detailed landscape and irrigation plans shall be submitted for Planning
Director review and approval prior to issuance of building permits. The parkway landscaping
including trees, shrubs, ground covers and irrigation shall be maintained by the property owner.
The developer shall provide each prospective buyer written notice of the parkway maintenance
requirement, in a standard format as determined by the Planning Director, prior to accepting a
cash deposit on any property.
•
• 3
I:\PLANNING\FINAL\PLNGCOMM\2011 Res & Stf Rpt\DRC2011-00028Stnd Cond 6-8.doc
B-83
Project No.DRC2011-00028
Completion Date
D. Building Design
1. For all residential development, provide conduit from each unit/lot and a pull box to connect to the _/_/_ •
street. Provide interior structured wiring for each house/building with minimum Category 5
copper wire, Radio Grade 6 coaxial cable, and a central distribution panel, prior to release of
occupancy (fiber-to-the building, FTTB). Plans shall be submitted for Planning Director and
Building Official review and approval prior to issuance of building permits.
E. Landscaping
1. A detailed landscape and irrigation plan, including slope planting and model home landscaping in _/_/_
the case of residential development, shall be prepared by a licensed landscape architect and
submitted for Planning Director review and approval prior to the issuance of building permits or
prior final map approval in the case of a custom lot subdivision.
2. All private slopes of 5 feet or more in vertical height and of 5:1 or greater slope, but less than 2:1 /_/_
slope, shall be, at minimum, irrigated and landscaped with appropriate ground cover for erosion
control. Slope planting required by this section shall include a permanent irrigation system to be
installed by the developer prior to occupancy.
3. All private slopes in excess of 5 feet, but less than 8 feet in vertical height and of 2:1 or greater _/_/_
slope shall be landscaped and irrigated for erosion control and to soften their appearance as
follows: one 15-gallon or larger size tree per each 150 sq. ft. of slope area, 1-gallon or larger size
shrub per each 100 sq. ft. of slope area, and appropriate ground cover. In addition, slope banks
in excess of 8 feet in vertical height and 2:1 or greater slope shall also include one 5-gallon or
larger size tree per each 250 sq. ft. of slope area. Trees and shrubs shall be planted in
staggered clusters to soften and vary slope plane. Slope planting required by this section shall
include a permanent irrigation system to be installed by the developer prior to occupancy.
4. For single-family residential development, all slope planting and irrigation shall be continuously _/_/_ •
maintained in a healthy and thriving condition by the developer until each individual unit is sold
and occupied by the buyer. Prior to releasing occupancy for those units, an inspection shall be
conducted by the Planning Department to determine that they are in satisfactory condition.
5. The final design of the perimeter parkways,walls, landscaping,and sidewalks shall be included in _/_/_
the required landscape plans and shall be subject to Planning Director review and approval and
coordinated for consistency with any parkway landscaping plan which may be required by the
Engineering Services Department.
6: Tree maintenance criteria shall be developed and submitted for Planning Director review and /_/_
approval prior to issuance of building permits. These criteria shall encourage the natural growth
characteristics of the selected tree species.
F. Environmental
•
1. The developer shall provide each prospective buyer written notice of the 210 and 1-15 Freeways _/_/_
in a standard format as determined by the Planning Director, prior to accepting a cash deposit on
any property.
2. Noise levels shall be monitored after construction to verify the adequacy of the mitigation _/_/_
measures. Noise levels shall be monitored by actual noise level readings taken on-and off-site.
A final acoustical report shall be submitted for Planning Director review and approval prior to final
occupancy release. The final report shall also make recommendations as to additional mitigation
measures to reduce noise levels to below City standards, such as, residential exterior noise
levels to below 60 dBA and interior noise attenuation to below 45 dBA.
4 •
I:\PLANNING\FINAL\PLNGCOMM\2011 Res & Stf Rpt\DRC2011-00028Stnd Cond 6-8.doc
B-84
•
Project No.DRC2011-00028
Completion Date
40 PPLICANT SHALL CONTACT THE BUILDING AND SAFETY DEPARTMENT, (909)477-2710;
R COMPLIANCE WITH THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS: •
NOTE: ANY REVISIONS MAY VOID THESE REQUIREMENTS AND NECESSITATE ADDITIONAL REVIEW(S)
G. General Requirements
1. Submit five complete sets of plans including the following: _/_/_
a. Site/Plot Plan;
b. Foundation Plan;
' c. Floor Plan;
d. Ceiling and Roof Framing Plan;
e. Electrical Plans (2 sets, detached) including the size of the main switch, number and size
of service entrance conductors, panel schedules, and single line diagrams;
f. Plumbing and Sewer Plans, including isometrics, underground diagrams,water and waste
diagram, sewer or septic system location, fixture units, gas piping, and heating and air
conditioning; and
g. Planning Department Project Number (i.e., DRC2011-00028) clearly identified on the
outside of all plans.
2. Submit two sets of structural calculations, energy conservation calculations, and a soils report. _/_/_
Architect's/Engineer's stamp and "wet" signature are required prior to plan check submittal.
• 3. Contractors must show proof of State and City licenses and Workers'Compensation coverage to _/_/_
the City prior to permit issuance.
4. Separate permits are required for fencing and/or walls. / —
H. Site Development
1. Plans shall be submitted for plan check and approved prior to construction. All plans shall be _/_/_
marked with the project file number(i.e., DRC2011-00028). The applicant shall comply with the
latest adopted California Codes, and all other applicable codes, ordinances, and regulations in
effect at the time of permit application. Contact the Building and Safety Department for
availability of the Code Adoption Ordinance and applicable handouts.
2. Prior to issuance of building permits for a new commercial or industrial development project or _/_/_
major addition, the applicant shall pay development fees at the established rate. Such fees may
include but are not limited to: City Beautification Fee, Park Fee, Drainage Fee, Transportation
Development Fee, Permit and Plan Check Fees, Construction and Demolition Diversion Program
deposit and fees and School Fees. Applicant shall provide a copy of the school fees receipt to
the Building and Safety Department prior to permits issuance.
3. Street addresses shall be provided by the Building and Safety Official after tract/parcel map _/_/_
recordation and prior to issuance of building permits.
4. For projects using septic tank facilities, written certification of acceptability, including all /_/_
supportive information, shall be obtained from the San Bernardino County Department of
Environmental Health and submitted to the Building Official prior to the issuance of Septic Tank
Permits, and prior to issuance of building permits.
• 5
•
I:\PLANNING\FINAL\PLNGCOMM\2011 Res & Stf Rpt\DRC2011-00028Stnd Cond 6-8.doc
B-85
Project No.DRC2D11-00028
Completion Date
5. Construction activity shall not occur between the hours of 8:00 p.m. and 6:30 a.m. Monday / /_
through Saturday, with no construction on Sunday or holidays.
I. New Structures •
1. Provide compliance with the California Building Code (CBC) for property line clearances / /_
considering use, area, and fire-resistiveness.
2. Provide compliance with the California Building Code for required occupancy separations. • _/_/_
3. Roofing material shall be installed per the manufacturer's "high wind" instructions. _/_/_
J. Grading
1. Grading of the subject property shall be in accordance with California Building Code, City Grading /_/_
Standards, and accepted grading practices. The final grading plan shall be in substantial
•
conformance with the approved grading plan.
2. A soils report shall be prepared by a qualified engineer licensed by the State of California to /_/_
perform such work.
3. A geological report shall be prepared by a qualified engineer or geologist and submitted at the /_/_
time of application for grading plan check.
4. The final grading plan, appropriate certifications and compaction reports shall be completed, / /_
submitted, and approved by the Building and Safety Official prior to the issuance of building
permits.
5. As a custom-lot subdivision, the following requirements shall be met: / /_
a. Surety shall be posted and an agreement executed guaranteeing completion of all on-site /_/_ •
drainage facilities necessary for dewatering all parcels to the satisfaction of the Building
and Safety Official prior to final map approval and prior to the issuance of grading permits.
b. Appropriate easements for safe disposal of drainage water that are conducted onto or over _/_/_
adjacent parcels, are to be delineated and recorded to the satisfaction of the Building and
Safety Official prior to the issuance of grading and building permits.
c. On-site drainage improvements, necessary for dewatering and protecting the subdivided _/_/_
properties, are to be installed prior to issuance of building permits for construction upon
any parcel that may be subject to drainage flows entering, leaving, or within a parcel
relative to which a building permit is requested.
d. Final grading plans for each parcel are to be submitted to the Building and Safety /_/_
Department for approval prior to the issuance of grading and building permits(this may be
. on an incremental or composite basis).
e. All slope banks in excess of 5 feet in vertical height shall be seeded with native grasses or _/_/_
planted with ground cover for erosion control upon completion of grading or some other
alternative method of erosion control shall be completed to the satisfaction of the Building
and Safety Official. In addition, a permanent irrigation system shall be provided. This
requirement does not release the applicant/developer from compliance with the slope
planting requirements of Section 17.08.040 of the Development Code.
•
6 •
I:\PLANNING\FINAL\PLNGCOMM\2011 Res & Stf Rpt\DRC2011-00028Stnd Cond 6-8.doc
B-86
•
Project No.DRC2011-00028
Completion Date
6. A separate grading plan check submittal is required for all new construction projects and for /_/_
• existing buildings where improvements being proposed will generate 50 cubic yards or more of
combined cut and fill. The grading plan shall be prepared, stamped, and signed by a California
registered Civil Engineer.
K. Security Hardware
1. A secondary locking device shall be installed on all sliding glass doors. _/_/_
2. One-inch single cylinder dead bolts shall be installed on all entrance doors. If windows are within _/_/_
40 inches of any locking device, tempered glass or a double cylinder dead bolt shall be used.
3. All garage or rolling doors shall have slide bolts or some type of secondary locking devices. _/_/_
APPLICANT SHALL CONTACT THE FIRE SAFETY DEPARTMENT, FIRE PROTECTION
PLANNING SERVICES AT, (909) 477-2770, FOR COMPLIANCE WITH THE FOLLOWING
CONDITIONS:
SEE ATTACHED
APPLICANT SHALL CONTACT THE BUILDING AND SAFETY DEPARTMENT(GRADING)AT(909)477-2710
FOR COMPLIANCE WITH THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS:
SEE ATTACHED
•
• 7
I:\PLANNING\FINAL\PLNGCOMM\2011 Res & Stf Rpt\DRC2011-00028Stnd Cond 6-8.doc
B-87
City of Rancho Cucamonga DRC2010-00318/SUBTT17651/SUBTT18708 •
e
s t Building & Safety Department
10500 Civic Center Dr.
Rancho Cucamonga, CA 91730
• r T: (909) 477-2710 F: (909) 477-2711
GRADING COMMITTEE
• PROJECT REPORT & RECOMMENDED CONDITIONS
Project No.: DRC2010-00318/ Type: Residential Subdivision
SUBTT17651 /SUBTT18708
Location: Raindrop Place south of Banyan Street
Planning Department: TABE VAN DER ZWAAG APN: 226-102-02
Meeting Date: March 15, 2011 By: Matthew Addington
Acceptable for Planning Commission: Yes: No: xxx
If NO, see COMMENTS below:
•
PRELIMINARY:
GRC: March 15, 2011 By: Matthew Addington
FINAL: •
PC Meeting: By:
Note: Building and Safety — Grading will review and comment on future submittals for this
. project.
A) STANDARD CONDITIONS - Standard Building and Safety - Grading and Planning
Department standard conditions for Grading and Drainage Plans.
• 1) Grading of the subject property shall be in accordance with current adopted
California Building Code, City Grading Standards, and accepted grading practices.
The Grading and Drainage Plan(s) shall be in substantial conformance with the •
approved conceptual Grading and Drainage Plan.
2) A soils report shall be prepared by a qualified Engineer licensed by the State of
California to perform such work. Two copies will be• provided at grading and
. drainage plan submittal for review. Plans shall implement design recommendations
per said report.
3) A geologic report shall be prepared by a qualified Engineer or Engineering Geologist
and submitted at the time of application for Grading and Drainage Plan review.
4) The final Grading and Drainage Plan, appropriate certifications and compaction
reports shall be completed, submitted, and approved by the Building and Safety
.Official prior to the issuance of building permits.
5) A separate Grading and Drainage Plan check submittal is required for all new
construction projects and for existing buildings where improvements being proposed
will generate 50 cubic yards or more of combined cut and fill. The Grading and
Drainage Plan shall be prepared, stamped, and wet signed by a California licensed
Civil Engineer. .
•
I:\BUILDING\PERMITS\SUBTT18708\DRC2010-00318 Grading Committee Project Report, 20110315.doc
1 of
B-88
m �r City of Rancho Cucamonga DRC2010-00318/SUBTT17651/SUBTT18708
'CA, Building & Safety Department
. 10500 Civic Center Dr.
•n ' ,• Rancho Cucamonga, CA 91730 •
;t, T: (909)477-2710 F: (909)477-2711 •
6) The applicant shall comply with the City of Rancho Cucamonga Dust Control
Measures and place a dust control sign on the project site prior to the issuance of a
grading permit.
•
•
7) If a Rough Grading and Drainage Plan/Permit are submitted to the Building and
Safety Official for review, that plan shall be a separate plan/permit from Precise
Grading and Drainage Plan/Permit.
. 8) A drainage study showing a 100-year, AMC 3 design storm event for on-site
drainage shall be prepared and submitted to the Building and Safety Official for
review and approval for on-site storm water drainage prior to issuance of a grading
permit. All reports shall be wet signed and sealed by the Engineer of Record.
•
9) It shall be the responsibility of the applicant to acquire any required off-site drainage
easements prior to the issuance of a grading permit.
•
10) It shall be the responsibility of the applicant to acquire any required off-site drainage
acceptance letter(s) from adjacent downstream property owner(s) or discharge flows
in a natural condition (concentrated flows are not accepted) and shall provide the
Building and Safety Official a drainage study showing the proposed flows do not
exceed the existing flows prior to the issuance of a grading permit.
11) It shall be the responsibility of the applicant to obtain written permission from the •
adjacent property owner(s) to construct wall on property line or provide a detail(s)
showing the perimeter wall(s) to be constructed offset from the property line.
12) The Final Grading and Drainage Plan shall show the accessibility path from the
public right of way and the accessibility parking stalls to the building doors in
conformance with the current adopted California Building Code. All accessibility
ramps shall show sufficient detail including gradients, elevations, and dimensions
and comply with the current adopted California Building Code.
13) The Grading and Drainage Plan shall Implement City Standards for on-site
construction where possible, and provide details for all work not covered by City
Standard Drawings.
14) All slopes shall be a minimum 2-foot offset from the public right of way or adjacent
private property.
15) Private sewer, water, and storm drain improvements will be designed per the, latest
adopted California Plumbing Code.
16) Private streets for multifamily developments will include street plans as part of the
Grading and Drainage Plan set. Plan view to show typical street sections. Profile
view to show centerline and top of curb profiles.
•
17) The maximum parking stall gradient is 5 percent. Accessibility parking stall grades
Shall be constructed per the, current adopted California Building Code. •
I:\BUILDING\PERMITS\SUBTT1B708\DRC2010-00318 Grading Committee Project Report,20110315.doc
2of4
13 89
jizty�, City of Rancho Cucamonga DRC2010-00318/SUBTT17651/SUBTT18708
* /i"t Building & Safety Department
t''� 10500 Civic Center Dr.
Rancho Cucamonga, CA 91730
• i T: (909) 477-2710 F: (909)477-2711
18) Roof storm water is not permitted to flow over the public parkway and shall be
directed to an under parkway culvert per City of Rancho Cucamonga requirements
. prior to issuance of a grading permit. .
19) The final grading and drainage plan shall show existing topography a minimum of
100-feet beyond project boundary. .
20) The applicant shall provide a grading agreement and grading bond for all cut and fill
combined exceeding 5,000 cubic yards prior to issuance of a grading permit. The
grading agreement and bond shall be approved by the Building and Safety Official.
• 21) Provide documentation for C.V.W.D sewer offset program to the Building and Safety
Official for review prior to issuance of a grading permit.
22) This project shall comply with the accessibility requirements of the current adopted
California Building Code.
23) The precise grading and drainage plan shall follow the format provided in the City of
Rancho Cucamonga handout "Information for Grading Plans and Permit".
24) Grading Inspections:
a) Prior to the start of grading operations the owner and grading contractor
•
shall request a pre-grading meeting. The meeting shall be attended by
the project owner/representative, the grading contractor and the
Building Inspector to discuss about grading requirements and
preventive measures, etc. If a pre-grading meeting is not held within 24
hours from the start of grading operations, the grading permit may be
subject to suspension by the Building Inspector; .
b) The grading contractor shall call into the City of Rancho Cucamonga
Building and Safety Department at least 1 working day in advance to
request the following grading inspections prior to continuing grading
operations:
i) The bottom of the over-excavation
• II) Completion of Rough Grading, prior to issuance of the building
permit;
iii) At the completion of Rough Grading, the grading contractor or
owner shall submit to the Permit Technicians (Building and Safety
Front Counter) an original and a copy of the Pad Certifications to
be prepared by and properly wet signed and sealed by the Civil
•
Engineer and Soils Engineer of Record;
iv) The rough grading certificates and the compaction reports will be
• reviewed by the Associate Engineer or a designated person and
approved prior to the issuance of a building permit.
I:\BUILDING\PERMITS\SUBTT18708\DRC2010-00318 Grading Committee Project Report. 20110315.doc
3of4
B-90
,ii`4.;'�+t,, City of Rancho Cucamonga DRC2010-003181SUBTT17651ISUBTT18708 -
e,'., ti Building & Safety Department
y . 10500 Civic Center Dr. .
tr .b Rancho Cucamonga, CA 91730 •
S T: (909)477-2710 F: (909) 477-2711
25) Prior to the issuance of the Certificate of Occupancy the engineer of record shall
certify the functionality of the storm water quality management plan (WQMP) best
management practices (BMP) devices.
B) COMMENTS - The following items shall be corrected / completed, submitted to, reviewed
• and approved by staff prior to scheduling the project for a Planning Commission hearing.
. Copies of required easement/right-of-way documents, including legal descriptions, shall be
submitted for review prior to obtaining final signatures. The review period for the above
will generally be a minimum of two weeks or longer depending upon the adequacy and
complexity of the submittal:
1) All drainage swales must meet the requirements of the current adopted California
Building Code.
2) Provide cross sectional details drawn to scale of the side yard swales in relation to
the structure foundation and property lines.
C) SPECIAL CONDITIONS
1) The site shall be rough graded to eliminate all cross-lot drainage, (except in
approved facilities adjacent to private trails). All slopes and retaining walls
necessary to accomplish this shall be installed prior to final map approval.
2) Flow lines steeper than 6 percent could be erosive. The applicant shall provide hard •
lined gutters and swales where concentrated flows exceed 3fps, and anywhere that
flow lines exceed 10 percent.
3) Prior to the issuance of a grading permit the applicant shall provide to Building and
. Safety Services Director a copy of the City of Rancho Cucamonga's Memorandum of
Agreement for Storm Water Quality Management Plan for review prior to recordation
of the document. The Memorandum of Agreement for Storm Water Quality
Management Plan shall be recorded prior to issuance of a grading permit.
4) In the equestrian trails water bars shall be spaced accordingly:
Equestrian Trail Slope Water Bar
Interval
Spacing
4% to 5.99% 50-feet
6% to 8.99% 40-feet
• 9% to 11.99% 30-feet •
•
12% and greater 20-feet
•
I:\BUILDING\PERMITS\SUBTT18708\DRC2010-00318 Grading Committee Project Report, 20110315.doc
4of4
= 91
`ao�°cAMo Rancho Cucamonga Fire Protection District•
a Fire Construction Services
•
STANDARD CONDITIONS
May 23, 2011
K. Hovnanian Homes
S/s of Banyan E/of East Ave
Tract 17651 & 18708
D RC2011-00028
THE FOLLOWING STANDARD CONDITIONS APPLY TO THIS PROJECT.
FSC-1 Public and Private Water Supply
The design for Fire Hydrant spacing and location shall comply with the RCFPD Standard 5-
10 and CVWD's current standard.
• FSC-2 Fire Flow
1. The required fire flow for this project is determined in gallons per minute at a minimum
residual pressure of 20-pounds per square inch. This requirement is made in accordance
with Fire Code Appendix B, as adopted by the Fire District Ordinances.
3. Public Water plans are required for all projects that must extend the existing water supply
to or onto the site. Building permits for the construction of the homes will not be
issued until the public water plans are approved by FCS and CVWD.
4. On the site plans to be submitted for plan check, show all fire hydrants available to the
proposed site.
FSC-3 Requirement for Automatic Fire Sprinkler Systems
The 2010 California Residential Code and/or any other applicable standards require an
approved automatic fire sprinkler system to be installed in the dwelling units in accordance
with the 2010 edition of NFPA 13D.
FSC-4 Fire District Site Access
Fire District access roadways include public roads; streets and highways, as well as private
roads, streets drive aisles and/or designated fire lanes. Please reference the RCFPD Fire
Department Access — Fire Lanes Standard 5-1.
1. Residential gates installed across Fire District access roads shall be installed in
accordance with RCFPD Residential Gate Standard #9-3.
• 2. Fire lanes on public streets do not need to be identified.
3. Approved Fire Department Access: Any approved mitigation measures must be
clearly noted on the site plan. A copy of the approved Alternative Method application, if
B-92
applicable, must be reproduced on the architectural plans submitted to B&S for plan
review.
•
FSC-5 Hazardous Fire Area
This project is located within the "Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zone" (VHFHSZ), City of
Rancho Cucamonga "Hillside District , and/or within the area identified on the Rancho
Cucamonga General Plan, Exhibit V-7 as High Probability-High Consequence for Fire Risk.
These locations have been determined to be within the "Hazardous Fire Area" as defined by
the Fire District. The Hazardous Fire Area is based on maps produced by the California
Department of Forestry and Fire Protection and the City of Rancho Cucamonga.
FCS-6 Fire Protection Plans: The applicant shall prepare the architectural plans for the
construction of the buildings in accordance with the approved fire protection plan for the
community, the RCFPD Ordinance FD50, the 2010 California Building Code chapter 7A and
RCFPD Standard 49-1.
1.
FCS-7 Mobile, stationary or portable power-operated equipment in the Hazardous Fire
Area shall not be used without the Fire Safety Division's written approval. Specific fire
protection measures that may be required to mitigate the hazard include, but are not limited
to:
a. A stand-by water tender, equipped with a pump, fire hose and nozzle.
b. Pre-wetting of the site to avoid the production of sparks between blades or tracks and
rocks.
c. Conducting a fire watch for a minimum of one-hour following the cessation of •
operations each day.
d. For welding, cutting or grinding work, clear away all combustible material from the
area around such operation for a minimum distance of 10-feet. A "hot-work" permit
must be obtained from Fire Construction Services prior to cutting, welding or grinding
work.
e. Maintain one serviceable round point shovel with an overall length of not less than
forty-six (46) inches and one five (5) gallon backpack water pump-type fire
extinguisher fully equipped and ready for use at the immediate area during the
operation.
FCS-8 Prior to the issuance of any Certificate of Occupancy, Fire Protection Plan
requirements shall be installed, inspected and accepted by the Fire District staff. Schedule
the inspection with Fire Construction Services at 909-477-2713.
FSC-9 Alternate Method Application
Fire Construction Services staff and the Fire Marshal will review all requests for alternate
method, when submitted, The request must be submitted on the Fire District "Application for
Alternate Method" form along with supporting documents and payment of the $92 review fee.
FCS-10 Fire Access Roadways: Prior to the issuance of any Certificate of Occupancy, the
fire access roadways must be installed in accordance with the approved plans and
acceptable to Fire Construction Services. •
The CC&R's, the reciprocal agreement and/or other approved documents shall be recorded
and contain an approved fire access roadway map with provisions that regulate parking,
B-93 2
•
• specify the method of enforcement and identifies who is responsible for the required annual
inspections and the maintenance of all required fire access roadways.
• FCS-11 Address: Prior to the granting of occupancy, single-family dwellings shall post the
address with minimum 4-inch numbers on a contrasting background. The numbers shall be
noncombustible internally or externally illuminated during periods of darkness with non
combustible fixtures. The numbers shall be visible from the street.
FCS-12 Landscaping: The lots must landscaped with the required vegetation in accordance
with approved landscape plans.
•
•
•
•
B-94 3
•
cbt-44
• STAFF REPORT L�
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
RANCHO
CUCAMONGA
DATE: June 8, 2011
TO: Chairman and Members of the Planning Commission
• FROM: James R. Troyer, AICP, Planning Director
BY: Tabe van der Zwaag, Associate Planner
SUBJECT: TIME EXTENSION FOR TENTATIVE TRACT MAP SUBTT14749 - TRAIGH PACIFIC — A
request for a Time Extension of a previously approved tentative tract map to subdivide
168.77 acres into 269 residential lots and a remainder parcel in the Low (L) Residential
District (2-4 dwelling units per acre) and Flood Control (FC) within the Etiwanda North
Specific Plan, located north of the SCE Corridor between Etiwanda Avenue and
East Avenue. APN: 0225-083-05, 06, 07, 10, 22, 23, 25, and 26, and 0225-084-02.
Related Files: Annexation DRC2003-01051, DRC2003-00409, DRC2003-00410, and
DRC2003-00411. Staff has found the project to be within the scope of the project covered
by a prior Environmental Impact Report certified by the City Council on July 21, 2004,
(State Clearing House #2003081085) by Resolution 04-240 and does not raise or create
new environmental impacts not already considered in the Environmental Impact Report.
• SITE DESCRIPTION:
A. Surrounding Land Use and Zoning (Etiwanda North Specific Plan):
North - Southern California Edison (SCE) and Los Angeles Department of Water and Power
(LADWP) Electric Transmission Line Corridors; Utility Corridor
South - SCE Electric Transmission Line Corridor; Utility Corridor
East - Etiwanda Creek; Flood Control
West - Rancho Etiwanda Estates; Low Residential (2-4 dwelling units per acre)
B. General Plan Designatioris:
Project Site - Low Residential (2-4 dwelling units per acre)
North - SCE and LADWP Electric Transmission Line Corridors; Utility Corridor and
Conservation
South - SCE Electric Transmission Line Corridor; Utility Corridor
East - Etiwanda Creek/Conservation
West - Rancho Etiwanda Estates; Low Residential (2-4 dwelling units per acre)
C. Site Characteristics: The approved Tentative Tract Map is located within the Etiwanda North
Specific Plan and occupies 168.77 acres, of which 107.28 net acres will be developed with
single-family residential (99.26), park area (3.1 acres), equestrian park (2.7 acres), equestrian
trail (0.44 acres), and drainage channel (1.77 acres). The development will have a gross
density of 1.59 dwelling units per acre and a net density of 2.5 dwelling units per acre. The
remaining 61.49 acres will continue to be used for flood control purposes.
ANALYSIS:
• A. Background: Tentative Tract Map 14749 was approved by the Planning Commission on
June 9, 2004. This approval was appealed to the City Council on July 21, 2004, where the
Item C
PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT
SUBTT14749 —TRAIGH PACIFIC AND PARKWEST LANDSCAPING
June 8, 2011
Page 2 •
•
Amendment] and 730 [Development Agreement] on August 4, 2004). A lawsuit was
subsequently filed on August 18, 2004, against the City over the approved project (Spirit of the
Sage Council v. City of Rancho Cucamonga, with the applicant (Traigh Pacific L.P) as the Real
Party of Interest). The case was settled on December 20, 2005, with the applicant agreeing to
pay a settlement to the petitioner and the original City approval remaining intact. The
settlement agreement became effective on February 10, 2006, with the lawsuit dismissed
7 days later on February 17, 2006.
On June 12, 2007, the City's attorney informed staff that pursuant to Government Code
Section 66452.6 (c), the subject tentative tract map is entitled to an automatic time extension
for the period between the date the lawsuit was filed (August 18, 2004) and the date the
lawsuit was settled (February 10, 2006), or 541 days. Tentative tract maps are approved for
3 years. The start date of the 3-year approval period was the date of the second reading by
the City Council for the Specific Plan Amendment and the Development Agreement (final
approval of all aspects of the project), or August 4, 2004. With the Time Extension due to the
lawsuit taken into consideration, the official start date for SUBTT14749 was January 27, 2006,
with the 3-year expiration date on January 27, 2009. The state legislature passed two.Time
Extensions (SB1185 and AB333), which lengthened the unexpired tentative tract map a total of
3 years. With these extensions, Tentative Tract Map SUBTT14749 now has an expiration date
of January 27, 2012.
B. Time Extension Request: The applicant is requesting a Time Extension to extend the
approved map from January 27, 2012, to January 27, 2013. The City's Subdivision Ordinance
(Municipal Code Section 16.16.160) states that approved Tentative Tract Maps are valid for
3 years. The applicant may request up to five 1-year extensions (Municipal Code
Section 16.16.170), which must be approved by the Planning Commission. The extension is
being requested in order to provide additional time for the applicant to work with Federal and
State agencies to resolve the Etiwanda Creek drainage permitting issue to determine the final
design for the project. The applicant is not requesting any changes to the approved map.
C. Environmental Assessment: Pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act ("CEQA")
and the City's local CEQA Guidelines, the City certified an Environmental Impact Report on
July 21, 2004 (State Clearing House #2003081085) in connection with the City's approval of
SUBTT14749. Pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15162, no subsequent or supplemental
EIR or Negative Declaration is required in connection with subsequent discretionary approvals
of the same project unless: (i) substantial changes are proposed to the project that indicate
new or more severe impacts on the environment; (ii) substantial changes have occurred in the
circumstances under which the project was previously reviewed that indicates new or more
severe environmental impacts; or (iii) new important information shows the project will have
new or more severe impacts than previously considered; or (iv) additional mitigation measures
are now feasible to reduce impacts or different mitigation measures can be imposed to
substantially reduce impacts. Staff has evaluated SUBTT14749 and concludes that substantial
changes to the project or the circumstances surrounding the project have not occurred which
would create new or more severe impacts than those evaluated in the previously certified EIR.
In that the Time Extension is being requested in order to provide additional time for the
applicant to work with Federal and State agencies to resolve the Etiwanda Creek drainage
permitting issue that will determine the final design for the project. Staff further finds that the •
project will not have one or more significant effects not discussed in the previously certified
EIR, not have more severe effects than previously analyzed, and that additional or different
mitigation measures are not required to reduce the impacts of the project to a level of less-
C-2
PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT
SUBTT14749 —TRAIGH PACIFIC AND PARKWEST LANDSCAPING
June 8, 2011
Page 3
than-significant. In that the applicant does not propose any changes to the previously
approved tentative tract map. Therefore, pursuant to CEQA, staff recommends that the
Planning Commission concur with the staff determination that no additional environmental
review is required in connection with the City's consideration of the Time Extension for
Tentative Tract Map SUBTT14749.
CORRESPONDENCE: This item was advertised as a public hearing in the Inland Valley Daily
Bulletin newspaper, the property was posted, and notices were mailed to all property owners within a
660-foot radius of the project site. Staff has not received any letters or phone calls expressing
concern over the proposed Time Extension.
RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends approval of a 1-year Time Extension for Tentative Tract
Map SUBTT14749 through adoption of the attached Resolution of Approval with conditions.
Respectfully submitted,
Ja. s R. Troyer, AICP
Planning Director
JRT:TV/ge
• Attachments: Exhibit A - Tentative Tract Map 14749
Exhibit B - Letter Requesting Map Extension
Draft Resolution of Approval of a Time Extension for SUBTT14749
•
C-3
:5 ...
dEil;
/
/
-,t-
-
, , : 4,-„-- .;1„ 1 I. 1 \ •,, E.-- . i_411f2
i .
i
t
i I Z i-c il; it
1 i '
LT4 ifir„1.:
, .
H
... ,•
y
• . . .
- -Hs iillii •-;4: f,
-: i'
s J .,...7• c , i. --, ,-, 1 -ir,4,--,-, ,,,'
l'il l.t I - 50
II
J Lii L
NAC.,i
-?'"Aill■ ' .7.--'17A€':- ,i tr, 'r r,77:0, , - IL-
.,. .:yr i, i -) :,,1:1 • s-
„ ;1/4141H11.21 -s ,.,_ , t
.,,,---.-r- -H7,- I 'i 1,--,, 'i., t
'. ",„ te” )>:*.t, ''' ii z'--i1, t.' ‘,:-. 14,,' , ,.1.1..a, ;lugs
' I ■: C , .e."CY ii, \'''.. ' +-A ' 4: 1' '' j' ' ' ' -
. 146Th Kos 1,--.1,111q:,:kc, ,dif-7-0- i it \, i. glum!,
,. ......,
• z----- . 1 .-.- , 11 -,. ,,,-,,,: 4 . 7.1,A.,,1: -,
L,i ,;<gia it trt -74440- ib . _ • ---:::: .1s,
Tit
' - -1 ...s, , -....,r,o,„,_„:„, ,,-,_• _.._:_ i
11,'Lzi 4 geNall i n r.,',..r- = 11-,‘' _ moki,lliki igirs47.7 t,, i'',_- i•IN ' i ilycli(1/4:‘, il
r-,.. .,,i
4-\--,-i\ N \
.„, 114.. -.-‘. 1;
rt... :
, 4-rs..,. iiii-,,, zrst law(',II4?,1 ; h C
-I t _ , ,w.. ,c,....gi :.tp,,, ,.......--n_ iii-, I ',, L - :
,,....„
1 A It); ... - .,,T.-i. - -___--,p12,),,h. .:, ) ,,
q ill law ■1101'75,*, . ::,.._n%1A'\, e:n—ctr\, t 4 9', t.
i
1
t te' ". 1.7—, 111_3§-' 'Inicz,:-*-4Th\.'-,.`ii,`, :
1,, .,
—\. „ ,,,:k. 1 .;: tack\work 141,,.), ...."......,g, k;mars. r \.' 1 "' %. %,■1 5 `t., '
-km,ill 1 '\'; V ast10-4,;,A,'' . •0\‘ ,- Ilak' .,:, iRr \ .- c> .. .... I] ,
• ' 4-
. , 1,
..
IC-
a \ 111\- - J7. 1-‘‘ '' '1 ‘ \\ 1
44:‘,(\,% .\‘', / 17,c,,if-1 , ‘, t1.\\\__ .\.
, .i` , ‘\.k.. ; ,-- ffy--\ \ \,.), \.. .i,- k
, i ,,,-.-7,- .■ 11\:\ 'PNEe;.,-\ , ' ' \ A'
\
J I., 11;,,;(,\I„: .th:zi.,.:3A, :s• ..„,eitir\.,t1,......,40,tek.k. _\,_\22,,,______,„!j,b---. ,
---- .,
''.-- ----154,-' ',•2:7-',- ', '?"1,-511L t
LI---“-----\„,. \--"e--yr14, t
-,,1:1C15:1 - .11-■-\\ N., ....7
-."--• ‘) /-C\I \
• % t ) -
EXHIBIT A
C-4
•
•
C. A. Company
Page Com
�' P
200 Opal Avenue
Balboa Island,CA 92662 Phone : (714)745-2326
20 March 2011
Larry Henderson
City of Rancho Cucamonga
10500 Civic Center Drive
Rancho Cucamonga, CA 91729
Subject: TT 14749, Request for Extension
Dear Mr. Henderson:
I'm writing on behalf of the applicant,Tom Tracy of Traigh Pacific and Parkwest
Landscape, to request a 12-month extension of the referenced tentative map. This would
be the first of two 12-month extensions that are available. The current map is effective
until February 10, 2012. This request is for an extension to February 10, 2013.
• Since initial approval of the tentative map and development agreement in July 2004, the
following milestones have occurred:
•
The lawsuit with Spirit of the Sage was settled. Spirit of the Sage filed a lawsuit
against the City and Traigh Pacific in August 2004. In June 2005, Spirit of the
Sage filed for a writ of mandate against LAFCO, the City, and Traigh Pacific.
After numerous settlement conferences, the parties settled in the first quarter of
2006.
In 2006, Tom Tracy acquired 167 acres of mitigation property (164 was required
by the City as mitigation). The County Open Space District 1 has agreed to
accept the property.
The Chambers Group, on behalf of Traigh Pacific, filed applications for a US
Army Corps 404 permit, 401 Regional Water Quality Board certification, and a
California Department of Fish and Game 1602 permit. The 1602 permit was
issued. The 404 permit application was received with a request for supplemental
gnatcatcher and SB K Rat surveys. The survey results were negative. These
surveys were completed and submitted to the Corps. Chambers prepared a
Biological Assessment for Section 7 consultation with US Fish& Wildlife
Service.
•
EXHIBIT B
c_5
Larry Henderson •
20 March 2011
Page 2
Regional Water Quality made an unusual request for fmal design of the water
quality and detention facilities before it would issue the 401 certification;
however, the fmal design parameters cannot yet be determined because of
Regulatory permit issues that affect both TT 14749 and Richland's TT 16072,
which abuts the southerly boundary of TT 14749.
Currently, Richland, Traigh Pacific, and Parkwest Landscpe continue to work with the
US Army Corps of Engineers, US Fish and Wildlife Service, State Department of Fish
and Game, and Regional Water Quality Control Board to resolve issues related to the
discharge of City Master Plan of Drainage facilities into Etiwanda Creek. Drainage
common to both projects will flow through these Master Plan facilities. When the San
Bernardino County Flood Control District obtained Regulatory permits for renovation of
the Etiwanda Creek and San Sevine systems, it failed to include the Master Plan facility
outlets into Etiwanda Creek. This was either intentional or oversight, but the result is that
the owners of TT 14749 and 16072 must solve the problem in order to proceed with final
design and construction of the projects.
Extension of Tentative Map 14749 is requested to provide additional time to work with •
the Federal and State agencies to resolve the Etiwanda Creek drainage permitting issues
that will determine the final design for the project.
Sincerely,
Craig Page
For Traigh Pacific and Parkwest Landscape
cc: Tom Tracy
•
C-6
•
• RESOLUTION NO. 11-26
A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
RANCHO CUCAMONGA, CALIFORNIA,APPROVING A TIME EXTENSION
FOR TENTATIVE TRACT MAP SUBTT14749 PREVIOUSLY APPROVED
TO SUBDIVIDE 168.77 ACRES INTO 269 RESIDENTIAL LOTS AND A
REMAINDER PARCEL IN THE LOW (L) RESIDENTIAL DISTRICT (2-4
DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE)AND FLOOD CONTROL(FC)WITHIN THE
ETIWANDA NORTH SPECIFIC PLAN, LOCATED NORTH OF THE SCE
CORRIDOR BETWEEN ETIWANDA AVENUE AND EAST AVENUE; AND
MAKING FINDINGS IN SUPPORT THEREOF - APN: 0229-263-05,
0229-283-04 AND 05.
A. Recitals.
1. Traigh Pacific and Parkwest Landscape have filed an application for the approval of a
Time Extension for previously approved Tentative Tract Map SUBTT14749, as described in the title
of this Resolution. Hereinafter in this Resolution, the subject Time Extension request is referred to
as "the application."
2. On June 9, 2004, the Planning Commission adopted its Resolution No. 04-79, thereby,
approving Tentative Tract Map SUBTT14749 subject to specific conditions.
3. On July 21, 2004, the City Council adopted its Resolution No. 04-243,thereby,approving
Tentative Tract Map SUBTT14749 subject to specific conditions and time limits.
4. On June 8, 2011, the Planning Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga conducted
a duly noticed public hearing on the application and concluded said hearing on that date.
5. All legal prerequisites prior to the adoption of this Resolution have occurred.
B. Resolution.
NOW, THEREFORE, it is hereby found, determined, and resolved by the Planning Commission
of the City of Rancho Cucamonga as follows: .
1. This Commission hereby specifically finds that all of the facts set forth in the Recitals, Part
A, of this Resolution are true and correct.
2. Based upon the substantial evidence presented to this Commission during the
above-referenced public hearing on June 8, 2011, including written and oral staff reports, together
with public testimony, this Commission hereby specifically finds as follows:
a. The applicant is requesting a Time Extension to extend the approved application
from January 27, 2012, to January 27, 2013. The City's Subdivision Ordinance (Municipal Code
Section 16.16.160) states that approved Tentative Tract Maps are valid for 3 years. The applicant
may request up to five 1-year extensions (Municipal Code Section 16.16.170), which must be
approved by the Planning Commission. The Time Extension is being requested in order to provide
additional time for the applicant to work with Federal and State agencies to resolve the
Etiwanda Creek drainage permitting issue that will determine the final design for the project. The
• applicant is not requesting any changes to the approved map; and
b. Because of a lawsuit filed on August 18, 2004, and subsequently settled on
February 10, 2006, on June 12, 2007, the City's attorney informed staff that pursuant to Government
C-7
PLANNING COMMISSION RESOLUTION 11-26
SUBTT14749—TRAIGH PACIFIC AND PARKWEST LANDSCAPE
June 8, 2011
Page 2
•
Code Section 66452.6 (c), the subject tentative tract map is entitled to an automatic time extension
for the period between the date the lawsuit was filed (August 18, 2004) and the date the lawsuit was
settled (February 10, 2006), or 541 days. Tentative Tract Maps are approved for 3 years. The start
date of the 3-year approval period was the date of the second reading by the City Council of the
Specific Plan Amendment and the Development Agreement (final approval of all aspects of the
project), or August 4, 2004. With the time extension due to the lawsuit taken into to consideration,
the official start date for SUBTT14749 was January 27, 2006, with the 3-year expiration date on
January 27, 2009. The state legislature passed two time extensions (SB1185 and AB333), which
lengthened the unexpired tentative tract map a total of 3 years. With these extensions, Tentative
Tract Map SUBTT14749 now has an expiration date of January 27, 2012.
c. The previously approved Tentative Tract Map SUBTT14749 is in substantial
compliance with the City's current General Plan, specific plans, ordinances, plans, codes, and
policies; and
d. The Time Extension of the Tentative Tract Map SUBTT4749 approval will not cause
significant inconsistencies with the current General Plan, specific plans, ordinances, plans, codes,
and policies; and
e. The Time Extension of the Tentative Tract Map SUBTT14749 approval is not likely
to cause public health and safety problems; and
f. The Time Extension is within the time limits established by State law and local
ordinance.
•
3. Based upon the facts and information contained in the application,together with all written
and oral reports included for the environmental assessment for the application, the Planning
Commission finds that no subsequent or supplemental environmental document is required pursuant
to the California Environmental Quality Act(CEQA) in connection with the review and approval of this
application based upon the following findings and determinations:
a. Pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act("CEQA") and the City's local
CEQA Guidelines, the City certified an Environmental Impact Report (EIR) on July 21, 2004 (State
Clearing House #2003081085) in connection with the City's approval of Tentative Tract Map
SUBTT14749. Pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15162, no subsequent or supplemental EIR or
Negative Declaration is required in connection with subsequent discretionary approvals of the same
project unless: (i) substantial changes are proposed to the project that indicate new or more severe
impacts on the environment; (ii) substantial changes have occurred in the circumstances under
which the project was previously reviewed that indicates new or more severe environmental impacts;
or (Hi) new important information shows the project will have new or more severe impacts than
previously considered; or (iv) additional mitigation measures are now feasible to reduce impacts or
different mitigation measures can be imposed to substantially reduce impacts.
b. The Planning Commission finds, in connection with the time extension request,that
substantial changes to the project or the circumstances surrounding the project have not occurred
which would create new or more severe impacts than those evaluated in the previously certified EIR.
The proposed time extension request does not raise or create new environmental impacts not
already considered in the Environmental Impact Report for the tract map. Staff further finds that the •
project will not have one or more significant effects not discussed in the previously certified EIR, not
have more severe effects than previously analyzed, and that additional or different mitigation
measures are not required to reduce the impacts of the project to a level of less-than-significant. The
C-8
PLANNING COMMISSION RESOLUTION 11-26
SUBTT14749 —TRAIGH PACIFIC AND PARKWEST LANDSCAPE
• June 8, 2011
Page 3
•
The proposed time extension request does not raise or create new environmental impacts not •
already considered in the Environmental Impact Report for the tract map.
c. Based on these findings and all evidence in the record, the Planning Commission
concurs with the staff determination that no additional environmental review is required pursuant to
CEQA in connection with the City's consideration of the time extension.
4. . Based upon the findings and conclusions set forth in Paragraphs 1, 2, and 3 above, this
Commission hereby grants a time extension for:
Tentative Map Applicant Expiration
SUBTT14749 Richland Communities, Inc. January 27, 2012
5. Based upon the findings and conclusions set forth in Paragraphs 1, 2, 3 and 4 above,
this Commission hereby modifies the Conditions of Approval contained in Resolution 04-243 and the
Standard Conditions, attached thereto and incorporated herein by this reference,to read as follows:
Planning Department •
1) The applicant shall agree to defend, at his sole expense, any action
brought against the City, its agents,officers,or employees, because of
• the issuance of such approval, or in the alternative, to relinquish such
approval. The applicant shall reimburse the City, its agents,officers,or
employees, for any Court costs and attorney's fees which the City, its
agents, officers, or employees, may be required by a court to pay as a
result of such action. The City may,at its sole discretion, participate, at
its own expense, in the defense of any such action but such
participation shall not relieve the applicant of his obligations under this •
condition.
6. The Secretary to this Commission shall certify to the adoption of this Resolution.
APPROVED AND ADOPTED THIS 8TH DAY OF JUNE 2011.
PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF RANCHO CUCAMONGA
BY:
Luis Munoz, Jr., Chairman
ATTEST:
James R. Troyer, AICP, Secretary
I, James R. Troyer, AICP of the of the City of Rancho Cucamonga, do hereby certify that the
foregoing Resolution was duly and regularly introduced, passed, and adopted by the Planning
• Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga, at a regular meeting of the Planning Commission
held on the 8th day of June 2011.
•
•
C-9
PLANNING COMMISSION RESOLUTION 11-26
SUBTT14749 —TRAIGH PACIFIC AND PARKWEST LANDSCAPE
June 8, 2011 •
Page 4
AYES: COMMISSIONERS:
NOES: COMMISSIONERS:
ABSENT: COMMISSIONERS:
ABSTAIN: COMMISSIONERS:
•
•
•
C-10
STAFF REPORT y
• PLANNING DEPARTMENT LJ
DATE: June 8, 2011 RANCHO
CUCAMONGA
TO: Chairman and Members of the Planning Commission
FROM: James R. Troyer, AICP, Planning Director
BY: Steve Fowler, Assistant Planner
SUBJECT: DEVELOPMENT REVIEW DRC2010-01006 -.NEAL T. BAKERS ENTERPRISES - A
request to construct a 2,361 square foot drive-thru restaurant on a .46-acre pad within
the Victoria Commons Retail Center within the General Commercial District at
12009 Foothill Boulevard - APN: 0229-023-04. On January 24, 2007, a Mitigated
Negative Declaration was adopted by the Planning Commission for Tentative Parcel
Map SUBTPM17818. The California Environmental Quality Act provides that no further
environmental review or Negative Declaration is required for subsequent projects or
minor revisions to projects within the scope of a previous Mitigated Negative
Declaration.
PROJECT AND SITE DESCRIPTION:
A. Surrounding Land Use and Zoning:
North - Multi-Tenant Commercial Center; Foothill Boulevard Districts (Subarea 4),
Community Commercial
• South - Vacant Lot; Industrial Park Subarea 7
• East Nursery and Southern California Edison Utility Corridor; Open Space
West - Masi Plaza; Industrial Park Subarea 7
B. General Plan Designations:
Project Site - General Commercial
North - Community Commercial
South - General Commercial
East - Flood Control and Utility Corridor
West - General Commercial
C. Site Characteristics: The project site is located on the south side of Foothill Boulevard
between Rochester Avenue and the Edison Utility Corridor in the General Commercial District.
The Baker's restaurant site is a rectangular-shaped parcel that is part of an overall master
planned project known as Victoria Commons. The rectangular shaped parcel is a .46-acre
pad located near the east end of the Victoria Commons site at 12009 Foothill Boulevard.
Presently, the Victoria Commons project has one multi-tenant retail building and a retail bank
building constructed with two additional vacant pads located along Foothill Boulevard. A
two-story office professional building that fronts Rochester Avenue was constructed
approximately 3 years ago. At the southeast corner of Foothill Boulevard and
Rochester Avenue, is the Aggazzotti home, formerly a winery and designated Historic Point of
Interest (not-a-part of the project).
D. Parking Calculations: The project is parked per the parking criteria of the Development Code
• and the tabulation of the required parking spaces is as follows:
Item D
a
4
PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT
DRC2010-01006 — NEAL T. BAKERS ENTERPRISES
June 8, 2011
Page 2 •
Number of Number of
Square Parking Spaces Spaces
Type of Use Footage Ratio Required Provided
Fast-food restaurant 2,361 1:75 31 31
with drive-thru
•
ANALYSIS:
A. General: The master planned project, Victoria Commons, was originally approved through
DRC2005-01084 with a mix of office, retail, and restaurants that creates synergy consistent
with the commercial/office corridor of Foothill Boulevard. The Victoria Commons project
proposed five retail/restaurant and bank buildings fronting along Foothill Boulevard. The
project has one main entrance off of Rochester Avenue for the professional office building
(Building F), and two ingress/egress accesses are provided off of Foothill Boulevard: the first
just east of the Aggazzotti residence, and the second at the eastern property line. The
eastern Foothill Boulevard access is aligned with the signalized median break that was
approved for the northerly commercial project (DRC2005-00365).
•
The project site has allotted ample parking for the proposed use. The fast-food restaurant
requires 31 parking spaces and 31 have been provided with 15 new stalls and 16 existing
stalls. This includes reciprocal parking that was calculated in the original master plan.
This project proposes a 2,361 square foot fast-food restaurant building with a drive-thru. The •
proposed building is a single-story structure with a winery-inspired architectural theme. Some
of the elements utilized are three heavy trellises located on both the east and west elevations,
with one slightly wrapping around to the north elevation. The exterior of the building consists
of a mixture of earth-tone colored stucco and stone veneer. The stone veneer is utilized for
wainscot, on the columns of the trellis features, and on the columns of the two tower elements
on the north and south elevations. The two towers are accented with exposed tails at the roof
lines. Tuscany blend "S" style roof is used on the roof, and wrought iron accent elements are
utilized on the east and west elevations of the tower. The tower on the south elevation utilizes
a window with shutters as an accent piece. Wood doors will be utilized on the north elevations
to reflect the winery theme. Murals have been proposed on the east and west elevations near
the north end of the building to help provide visual interest to these areas.
The roof-mounted equipment will be screened by the parapet walls, and the shed roofs are
utilizing the same Tuscany "S" tile as the towers. The building utilizes materials from the
existing buildings to incorporate it into the center but not duplicate the style.
B. Design Review Committee: The Design Review Committee (Munoz, Wimberly, and Granger)
reviewed the site, building elevations, materials, and Conceptual Landscaping Plans on
May 17, 2011. The Committee requested that the applicant consider a composite material for
the trellises instead of wood and recommended approval of the project with this change. The
applicant indicated that they would look into an alternative composite material for the trellis
and coordinate this with staff.
•
D-2
PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT
•
DRC2010-01006— NEAL T. BAKERS ENTERPRISES
• June 8, 2011
Page 3
C. Grading and Technical Review Committees: The Grading and Technical Committees
reviewed the development portion of the project on May 17, 2011, and recommended
approval.
D. Environmental Assessment: Pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act ("CEQA")
and the City's local CEQA Guidelines, the City adopted a Mitigated Negative Declaration on
January 24, 2007, in connection with the City's approval of Tentative Parcel Map
SUBTPM17818. Pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15162, no subsequent or
supplemental EIR or Negative Declaration is required in connection with subsequent
discretionary approvals of the same project unless: (i) substantial changes are proposed to
the project that indicate new or more severe impacts on the environment; (ii) substantial
changes have occurred in the circumstances under which the project was previously reviewed
that indicates new or more severe environmental impacts; or (iii) new important information
shows the project will have new or more severe impacts than previously considered; or (iv)
additional mitigation measures are now feasible to reduce impacts or different mitigation
measures can be imposed to substantially reduce impacts. Staff has evaluated Development
Review application DRC2010-01006 and concludes that substantial changes to the project or
the circumstances surrounding the project have not occurred, which would create new or
more severe impacts than those evaluated in the previous Mitigated Negative Declaration.
The original submittal considered impacts associated with a fast-food restaurant with a
drive-thru and the current proposal is for the same type of use. The current footprint for the
• proposed fast-food restaurant is smaller than the previously analyzed footprint of 2,430 square
feet. Staff further finds that the project will not have one or more significant effects not
discussed in the previous Mitigated Negative Declaration, not have more severe effects than
previously analyzed, and that additional or different mitigation measures are not required to
reduce the impacts of the project to a level of less-than-significant. The original analysis took
into consideration a larger fast-food restaurant and the new fast-food restaurant is smaller,
thus creating less of an impact on the site. Therefore, pursuant to CEQA, staff recommends
that the Planning Commission concur with the staff determination that no additional
environmental review is required in connection with the City's consideration of the
Development Review Application DRC2010-01006.
CORRESPONDENCE: This item was advertised as a public hearing in the Inland Valley Daily
Bulletin newspaper, the property was posted, and notices were mailed to all property owners within
a 600-foot radius of the project site.
RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Planning Commission approve the Development
Review DRC2010-01006 through the adoption of the attached Resolution of Approval with
conditions.
Respectfully.submitted,
R.
Jam R. Troyer, AICP
• Plan g Director
D-3
PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT
DRC2010-01006 — NEAL T. BAKERS ENTERPRISES
June 8, 2011
Page 4 •
JRT:SF/ge
Attachments: Exhibit A - Site Plan
Exhibit B - Floor Plan
Exhibit C - Elevations
Draft Resolution of Approval for Development Review DRC2010-01006
•
•
D-4
1- Mb; OCLIB VO 'tDUOWtN7 OIIOU61f
• 0 . " "DAB 1114JOO,� soon
— < fi�fl 'O° eeeljdielu3 .te'ug '1 IueW E + 6 Q a
o J %kn.,"
• - a - -s� - — . d°, Ionised rub anu®saaYeg a . i t e " s cc R
B sB y 1
co
9 d
$ 1 t r
“1 € III a ' I q
g 9 - 84 9 , I� i €G e) C T �' �' F A S
w 4 III , : ; _ g 22 _ .- : _ w ip iii i i G E
w ea 0 i 13 w . w s t i E
'm � � 0 ; g : 1 g § I I y . CO SOS 0o0000o
— — —
i / _
I La2_J 4 a a
I
cc
a.
i , w
i it
h
ifCC
I I 'I e/ 1-
ci
I n« �9`n j • i U
cc
11E11111111.07011 i • j�
• �� .• q
m1 5� '� , �vioo ° ° O�Q •is;
1
I 7q;3' p + y �IL
ein
4 —
aimo d4 a
•
.:,,
i
r..J i
•
j
j
L..J
ti r .
i
I
d a1g
- II
• 1
r s
I I
EXHIBIT A
0_5
.- 0606 YO •e0m yc
uoeo00 Oeea
0 2 °y '.o Oe6 II1WOOj 60031 .
W 1j #el '° 4 0
I is o� seepdioju3 i9Ha9 '1 teeN e I
a - o . .w
'a�,�. [ d sod aueine dlullanuasJa E 1 . ; a 1 $
a
• — - 1 -
I
z Li o �1gaa La'
111 P I: x x W § $ $3 W5'a�@6
ii gg g co g ggAggggg g 4 CO I
m F8 4E 3 - 'v§§'s.v4 -
o Y . . . . c .°4§§'s§:,
Qe 44 " 444 ' Q °,,44'4 ,
40 3 s eeoeeeeo O v 0 eocoe
q q .,.1 ? Q Q q rMtl=li
0— n cc
a-< -rin' i sd1 pi O, a
O- 4 it 1pone :a; ___ T o
t ell
1 C
p .-. .o.n ■ L' alt
� , ■ li� II
E — o
II '•I ■il i,�•_ill o-. -
III 11 ,='
w. , yo
®Il P e E R
i. 0 II!Set ;Ram°C y1 ge li ,'. • I.--�_i .^
o— ' ;!'fix! - �al ._-:__.____J:_ -a
`TT�-
e-., ..-° .m., 1 a.. l o-. 7
a o -e
• 1 a 14 Q g l .P
o-n 0
4 eIl -_ �e-. .1 �. .v .
a of n a a .. Ilse P
eI H MI 1 e
as 0— ooh `. l i ' _, a®
o O o e -0
• I MA b O I s.e. a:.
❑ .8. ❑ 4 —6
.A ° I.
.- .-'
EXHIBIT B • b 4 - b
b b b 6
•
D-6
r. z„,j(ar
..q�, a .`5�it i ¢ i'S"� C^' 9 +`f rr .' y. r+Cxf F`1 ar''LL--k*u '.
• iT2I4 x .r g? T2:4 � ` tklet x 9.f�x t 75 y r LiL V y t:`k` kf. B.y: 1cyk + P y ° 4' � is 4Pi14:c1Y1{ s» ' 1 0.-... E4 la ti U
. r YI ,y I+ :rY "{ f 1y I ry '*r iK, 4 �. ° f r ere. k. o V
I
, !1511{ r + , 1∎ e �4` , "X. F + *law-4,4_,#,rl 1 ° � 1 i�+'S I � � N
.I I + - I i II f {7495 e, x 1 1 1 c//• it
e v t 11111 a,' ly '+t'+f i?I"
t'r 3 id,.: F0.` f ` ® L U
,, tt ,;� + r, II 0II y - 1,ytiL41 +rtxa� { II+ � 'S, I I . I : o c
it
+ r�11IIii e C a n 'it, 11 t1411ifn 4y I t 1• W'/ e
;I{'^"M(` 1 ° r ,x11 r �ue�uY t It x Pik:: r � 1 t " I ..
{a ..x4 I, L „ i.,. i , .4„ I t .t,t :i �p II ILO
i I 51 1yt � 3”' Y+, + v Y1 :71 , I I ,j
r�:`? iI � 4II1'4171 , I �I� �� I, let y!� .51x ' I f iI i 1�Ea r 1 a 1. I41 . r 1, t $.. —
✓ I + rt"L +��i i11 � �� ( � � ..-L o i III I
+. �i 1 11 ' O G .5'141+ {
1 � s n c
IT. l fE1 '. 1 -s '0 0 # , 9 tlisrd . riL o, 'z$'1 1 1 1 . r VIM. IQ 0 s'+R.r irk
u 4 t "l rv+H .� .!,0,,:--,-1,/ i..LLI I n '7,4 1' i . In 1,51 4. n -
,"'S ' , 1 't x i _„ Fl f Ir}Ir e ��, � c,,,, 00
�, f I ( 1 1 411 ,y'+ fr .ri p 0 '4. 1 {_:.0.1.,z,,,.0 4, I e rz. H* I :t2
1 ' 4 ' x 111 1 : 1 a i (& 0 0 1 I`I,1+u { 0 �k l
• �'r' + II I i • I .Y I, 1J 9ce j�f..1�14 " > f' "_:8 j 1 1 It ' 1 T.
1�_ ` ,.,i, IfIi1 1 t r .1 � 1 -, 0. . 0. t�i�.I ��°,, 'sX;.h" z. N4.N' '.�lcr :•
1 I ; y5
II F + ell , _ 1 zxA t jziF 11 + °rl t1 s ., ` v'
�. a k 14 I Ifryry y K r Iii
x` Il"C%r 1 ' 4 4 u, .f I1+ d I4 !III. 1 rs xg1r n 14 { 4II Ir!:
*} i . NNN. 11!111 ` -- i.ii_i�, I anti 0 ."` .
ti + N� II ` 1 n tot-. I n t s ") + I{I 11 dm, +
_ v .A411'1,411 y , I l l ' a 1 ,if ;ly
'S' r °'. a , S 1#4,"'143::".1'4,11; r I•�1 { f rs acy, I� ; t >
n ..,-4'-i. q t, 1 �' y I j I r y Oki: ,,4, 'r 1 I��� -z 3 451._ m
. r{ r_. I 4� '$ II'l �. 4 I 110 I N
40- 'v I+I I r r+ I' x -* i ,491,49;4 er +
r M II .j.- 1 IEv I?L lr t f`'ur f I , 351 ry _ r- .I i m
�x' t a 17f 1�1:201;:-;.-=-11-1:,:.,.:,;:1 �Iixll tr. LG4 1 .1 rn5 [I I �1
of A.,J,.Ly ' l I ,c t1 (1.1trt I,4 �l '
S" L ;"!fit a 4
+ r 1 �10,. F X1 II '`j1 eL 9e h- 1 I qs r.;:1,'r �4+jLq i ; � P� 4 rltiyl
1N i1�:�411-1�� t Ir.i1y1� +�y` a � � � " ]“,tr, 1 4� 1,4,9;1j tii 4 11 tYf4C r 'C 7 (' 'y�i pitsim' +l4,?i1•Cy ,4 I'
9 4 xi a �i ail de ' r p1°p1 n� 1 1
y r IS b.' kq S41 ,+ r3'lw -.A - l i p L`$:,..7 �)
ggt �L ' . 1 of r t n , '-
Mx� 'ts aT �/, zn v " da , s > .r .� �. 1 x lr
�ykT` t r. 41:4:117,4). ,r.r y4“fr +n x'h r..g ,- i j6I :II �i14',+ j�K �2
'-` 'li, +" sj.§rt{�"T' i7'','1 .w{';. :. r�, C- aid-WI t � �,� ''141i mat W 3
k I
• "x51 '1 $ ° _', f
EXH I B IT C ° ° I �r,4�,5sit i,
art w.: a,� v:�°"
D-7
o >0._
w-.
— !hill e�a
< g s(, a, ,.�
t °sll! V7 vBUOwranp olotlrtl
'DAB 1181100.d eoozl
eetWOJel3 Je4Eig 'J. IaeN
c7
Ionised
rutll aAPO Sieleg 11 1 31 ;11 I 3 ' •
N
'
0 d
Y 5 4 41 ;, et _ _ tl M X Y S Q / ° o
e tl F
$ f 3g 99 3 38 $ l °°o° Ell
N ( >
• 5 qq II pg1pg 1 11 e F R 1 @1 @1 tl -" "\�PV���I�t�_li?�Ij',t'i'i�il 1, '!
LSI
2.. 1 1 l S ' 'le lib egeg ¢$ e A 3 --_
8J Bg 9 � d '�! 41a p �J�`. 4 ��` -ISii Pm"pia_ ,,�
z f f f f s di di d! L :f f ti i ! if ! I °S- li ;;.y',i't
IL oaaaa o a a aamo m o moo m m a- -- - � ,Illiij+
9 & 1D1
3 `�Fe{�� li, it
e Q pl 1 0 ° 1.2_
;1X46 0 7al:1 Ii _ °°
41'y oyll�,!s!�I:ubilll�lai�� W i II
Z
.11 3 4g o
II, 14 It lil'I Il 4 I
1 II 16.1`4Iuf.IL
II !dE � I IYw I ,.,1�-1-��;
°e° ,el '�I�r ( °° °e I{ co �i ;p ill.
.._ lil u !ri, ; i —�
m e . I,11= 1 •
I . II . W tllfk 4ri hii;151 a
���I it/4, 1 1 l l 11.11210".
( liii I 1111 ©gal e e a °°
�J r ,- ram, I
e c° I i' ¶III�I:IIAI�IQ 1�IV4 gill
t 4hkI;�R
°e° 'r. �pm e 1 ° tw'ill
i',"�9n Il�ii1 4il!irt:a I��� I
r ilih7i
° e °O d" ii41 14Y 1 i1 . li'•
NN °° _ °8 I �1.. 1.
�
e e e al ........ • ® Igrt i
r
•, gig!I!701,,111 117::=1 qE I °
i °CI
a _I .AI I
e "
1
° •
e son. eeao
@ Y
B $
C
•
D-8
• - n MI6 PO 'v0u0WPOnO 000u.0
U 44 PAG 11101004 BOOR
.L! 1134111 lip•°C�°
ig;11[1 of ,� Beelld�67u3 Je>fe9 1 IBM 112 0
• D < ear ! ,� acid Ionised wilt anu1 va>1e8 ! I . ; a : w a i
W e p " @ ' g Bp ® 9 1 Z
0 ?
p5 s' s' s 3 : e ? p ev 9 p
9 W 1 g a
J rg �g i Ind al it co vOO° a °
J g g 7 3 1111 g 1 4 441 B3i it 11 iA1 t Ii .I7 411I1liilIa11� t 0 W
Z 13 l i s �.i d!€ !. ._ :! 9 - - :2. : :2 a i';,lr,
ET
It 0300E E 0 0 0000 0 0 000 0 0 C1610 ^'l!"
g F 3
B p e 2
B 1 p p p 1 O El 1
-� I I I j �O _I
/di,.dl�'lI.�II 0 I I I4fi I a 1,C W�+ W �'1 I
Bae0 1I
�: °1 ¢ 111•1`
I
' 00 I tiN
0oo ;f 9 „,
tI 11.9 Q .P o I °
•
'.I,i 1+,m 1=. II m N�I,I`y'b1�411fyy;f.
I
�� ;''
all
e 'nit1
I I I(::::: au of IJf -'I'I 1p °G Iliii II
=; 13
`I, r p 1 rl o �I10;,1? l III, —
�1 4 n° l. II 1111 j 1P`-•i '7 O
li 1111 I. I1IR If i 1 14 $n
il pu '. IM 1 0
o a I' & °° 4.
i/i -nom t Ma idol)
If1: ®AhI °° (idol
e �� 1 li!!
CI? i lilil m al l
I1.. rlrel it IIIJOPTIlli121 o I
Y111 tjl,0191
°aao - IA47,lII¢i ,II,
08 00°°,
•
jJrj
i
•
D=9
RESOLUTION NO.11-28
• A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
RANCHO CUCAMONGA, CALIFORNIA, APPROVING DEVELOPMENT
REVIEW DRC2010-01006, -A REQUEST TO CONSTRUCT A
2,361 SQUARE FOOT BAKER'S DRIVE-THRU FAST-FOOD
RESTAURANT ON A .46 ACRE PAD WITHIN THE VICTORIA COMMONS
RETAIL CENTER IN THE GENERAL COMMERCIAL DISTRICT, LOCATED
AT 12009 FOOTHILL BOULEVARD; AND MAKING FINDINGS IN
SUPPORT THEREOF—APN: 0229-023-04.
A. Recitals.
1. Mr. Terry Tally with Neal T. Baker Enterprises filed an application for the approval of
Development Review DRC2010-01006, as described in the title of this Resolution. Hereinafter in
this Resolution, the subject Development Review request is referred to as "the application."
2. On the 8th day of June 2011, the Planning Commission of the City of
Rancho Cucamonga conducted a duly noticed public hearing on the application and concluded said
hearing on that date.
3. All legal prerequisites prior to the adoption of this Resolution have occurred.
B. Resolution.
NOW, THEREFORE, it is hereby found, determined, and resolved by the Planning
• Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga as follows:
1. This Commission hereby specifically finds that all of the facts set forth in the Recitals,
Part A, of this Resolution are true and correct.
2. Based upon the substantial evidence presented to this Commission during the
above-referenced public hearing on June 8, 2011, including written and oral staff reports, together
with public testimony, this Commission hereby specifically finds as follows:
a. The application applies to the property located at 12009 Foothill Boulevard,with a
street frontage of 126 feet and a lot depth of 155 feet and is presently improved with a parking lot
and lighting; and
b. The property to the north of the subject site across Foothill Boulevard is
Victoria Promenade; the property to the south consists of a vacant lot; the property to the east is a
nursery within the Edison Power Line Corridor; and the property to the west across
Rochester Avenue is the Masi Plaza; and
c. The project,together with the recommended conditions of approval,complies with
all minimum development standards for the City of Rancho Cucamonga; and
d. The project incorporates a blend of architectural design and site planning that gives
character with compatibility through the use of like building materials and an attractive plant palette.
• 3. Based upon the substantial evidence presented to this Commission during the
above-referenced public hearing and upon the specific findings of facts set forth in Paragraphs 1
and 2 above, this Commission hereby finds and concludes as follows:
D-10
PLANNING COMMISSION RESOLUTION NO.11-28
DRC2010-01006— NEAL T. BAKERS ENTERPRISES
June 8, 2011
Page 2
a. The proposed project is consistent with the objectives of the General Plan because •
it provides another use within the commercial center that creates a wide range of
community-oriented and regionally-oriented businesses; and
b. The proposed use is in accord with the objectives of the Development Code and
the purposes of the district in which the site is located because the project is compatible with the
existing center through the use of compatible building materials and design; and
c. The proposed use is in compliance with each of the applicable provisions of the
Development Code because the project complies with the established designed standards of the
Development Code such as setback, landscaping, and parking requirements; and
d. The proposed use, together with the conditions applicable thereto, will not be
detrimental to the public health, safety or welfare, or materially injurious to the properties or
improvements in the vicinity because the project has been designed with the complete center in
mind and will complement the rest of the center through the use of complementary architecture.
4. Based upon the facts and information contained in the application, together with all
written and oral reports included for the environmental assessment for the application,the Planning
Commission finds that no subsequent or supplemental environmental document is required
pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) in connection with the review and
approval of this application based upon the following findings and determinations:
a. Pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act("CEQA") and the City's local
CEQA Guidelines, the City adopted a Mitigated Negative Declaration on January 24, 2007, in •
connection with the City's approval of Tentative Parcel Map SUBTPM17818. Pursuant to CEQA
Guidelines Section 15162, no subsequent or supplemental ER or Negative Declaration is required
in connection with subsequent discretionary approvals of the same project unless: (i) substantial
changes are proposed to the project that indicate new or more severe impacts on the environment;
(ii)substantial changes have occurred in the circumstances under which the project was previously
reviewed that indicates new or more severe environmental impacts; or(iii)new important information
shows the project will have new or more severe impacts than previously considered; or (iv)
additional mitigation measures are now feasible to reduce impacts or different mitigation measures
can be imposed to substantially reduce impacts.
b. The Planning Commission finds, in connection with Development Review
Application DRC2010-01006, that substantial changes to the project or the circumstances
surrounding the project have not occurred, which would create new or more severe impacts than
those evaluated in the previous Mitigated Negative Declaration. The original submittal considered
impacts associated with a fast-food restaurant with a drive-thru and the current proposal is for the
same type of use. The current footprint for the proposed fast-food restaurant is smaller than the
previously analyzed footprint of 2,430 square feet. Staff further finds that the project will not have
one or more significant effects not discussed in the previous Mitigated Negative Declaration, not
have more severe effects than previously analyzed, and that additional or different mitigation
measures are not required to reduce the impacts of the project to a level of less-than-significant.
The original analysis took into consideration a larger fast-food restaurant and the new fast-food
restaurant is smaller, thus creating less of an impact on the site.
c. Based on these findings and all evidence in the record, the Planning Commission •
concurs with staffs determination that no additional environmental review is required pursuant to
CEQA in connection with the City's consideration of Development Review Application
DRC2010-01006.
D-11
PLANNING COMMISSION RESOLUTION NO.11-28
DRC2010-01006 — NEAL T. BAKERS ENTERPRISES
June 8, 2011
Page 3
•
• 5. Based upon the findings and conclusions set forth in Paragraphs 1, 2, 3, and 4 above,
this Commission hereby approves the application subject to each and every condition set forth
• below and in the Standard Conditions, attached hereto, and incorporated herein by this reference.
•
Planning Department
1) Approval is for the construction of a 2,361 square foot fast-food
• restaurant with a drive-thru within an existing retail center located at
12009 Foothill Boulevard.
2) No exterior changes to the design of the project, including exterior
materials, shall be permitted without prior City review and approval.
3) All applicable Conditions of Approval for Tentative Tract Map
SUBTPM17818 and Conditional Use Permit DRC2005-01084 shall
apply.
4) Any stone veneers used on the project(e.g., buildings, perimeter walls,
pilasters, etc.), shall be installed in a manner that does not give the
appearance of a tacked-on element. All stone veneers shall be applied
and/or extended so that the material terminates at an appropriate point
on the structure.
• 5) Per the Design Review Committee, during the plan check process, the
applicant shall coordinate with staff to consider wood composite
material for the trellis features.
Engineering Department
1) Prior to the issuance of Building Permits, a Diversion Deposit and
related administrative fees shall be paid for the Construction and
Demolition Diversion Program. The deposit is fully refundable if at
•
least 50 percent of all wastes generated during construction and
demolition are diverted from landfills, and appropriate documentation is
provided to the City. Form CD-1 shall be submitted to the Engineering
Department when the first Building Permit application is submitted to
Building and Safety. Form CD-2 shall be submitted to the Engineering
Department within 60 days following the completion of the construction
and/or demolition project.
2) The following impact fees shall be paid upon issuance of Building
Permit, in conformance with the CFD 2003-01 financing agreement.
Fees are subject to change annually.
a) Transportation Fees, excluding $6,976.00 per 1,000
square feet
Backbone and EV Preemption Less 70.7 percent
• b) General City Drainage Fees Exempt
D-12
PLANNING COMMISSION RESOLUTION NO.11-28
DRC2010-01006 — NEAL T. BAKERS ENTERPRISES
June 8, 2011
Page 4
6. The Secretary to this Commission shall certify to the adoption of this Resolution. •
APPROVED AND ADOPTED THIS 8TH DAY OF JUNE 2011.
PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF RANCHO CUCAMONGA
BY:
Luis Munoz, Jr., Chairman
ATTEST:
James R. Troyer, AICP, Secretary
I, James R. Troyer,AICP, Secretary of the Planning Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga,
do hereby certify that the foregoing Resolution was duly and regularly introduced, passed, and
adopted by the Planning Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga, at a regular meeting of the
Planning Commission held on the 8th day of June 2011, by the following vote-to-wit:
AYES: COMMISSIONERS:
NOES: COMMISSIONERS:
ABSENT: COMMISSIONERS: •
ABSTAIN: COMMISSIONERS:
•
D-13
doe
r COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
3
DEPARTMENT
STANDARD CONDITIONS
PROJECT #: DRC2010-01006
SUBJECT: DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
APPLICANT: NEAL T. BAKER
LOCATION: 12009 FOOTHILL BOULEVARD —APN: 0229-023-04
ALL OF THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS APPLY TO YOUR PROJECT.
APPLICANT SHALL CONTACT THE PLANNING DEPARTMENT, (909) 477-2750, FOR
COMPLIANCE WITH THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS:
General Requirements Completion Date
1. The applicant shall agree to defend at his sole expense any action brought against the City, its _/_/_
agents, officers, or employees, because of the issuance of such approval,or in the alternative,to
relinquish such approval. The applicant shall reimburse the City, its agents, officers, or
employees, for any Court costs and attorney's fees which the City, its agents, officers, or
employees may be required by a court to pay as a result of such action. The City may, at its sole
. discretion, participate at its own expense in the defense of any such action but such participation
shall not relieve applicant of his obligations under this condition.
2. Copies of the signed Planning Commission Resolution of Approval No. 11-28, Standard • / /_
Conditions, and all environmental mitigations shall be included on the plans (full size). The
sheet(s) are for information only to all parties involved in the construction/grading activities and
are not required to be wet sealed/stamped by a licensed Engineer/Architect.
3. The applicant shall be required to pay any applicable Fish and Game fees as shown below. The /_/_
project planner will confirm which fees apply to this project. All checks are to be made payable to
the Clerk of the Board Supervisors and submitted to the Planning Commission Secretary prior to
the Planning Commission or Planning Director hearing:
a) Notice of Exemption.- $50 X
B. Time Limits •
1. Development/Design Review approval shall expire if building permits are not issued or approved / /_
use has not commenced within 5 years from the date of approval. No extensions are allowed.
•
SC-12-08 1
I:IPLANNINGIFINALIPLNGCOMM12011 Res & Stf Rpt1DRC2010-01006StdCond 6-8.doc
D-14
Project No. DRC2010-01006
•
Completion Date
C. Site Development
1. The site shall be developed and maintained in accordance with the approved plans which include /_/_ •
site plans, architectural elevations,exterior materials and colors, landscaping,sign program,and
grading on file in the Planning Department, the conditions contained herein, and the
Development Code regulations.
2. Prior to any use of the project site or business activity being commenced thereon,all Conditions /_/_
of Approval shall be completed to the satisfaction of the Planning Director.
3. Occupancy of the facilities shall not commence until such time as all Uniform Building Code and /_/_
State Fire Marshal regulations have been complied with. Prior to occupancy, plans shall be
submitted to the Rancho Cucamonga Fire Protection District and the Building and Safety
Department to show compliance. The buildings shall be inspected for compliance prior to
occupancy.
4. Revised site plans and building elevations incorporating all Conditions of Approval shall be _/_/_
submitted for Planning Director review and approval prior to the issuance of building permits.
5. All site, grading, landscape, irrigation, and street improvement plans shall be coordinated for _/_/_
consistency prior to issuance of any permits (such as grading, tree removal, encroachment,
building, etc.)or prior to final map approval in the case of a custom lot subdivision, or approved
use has commenced, whichever comes first.
6. Approval of this request shall not waive compliance with all sections of the Development Code,all _/_/_
other applicable City Ordinances, and applicable Community or Specific Plans in effect at the
time of building permit issuance.
7. Trash receptacle(s)are required and shall meet City standards. The final design, locations, and _/_/_
the number of trash receptacles shall be subject to Planning Director review and approval prior to
the issuance of building permits. •
8. All ground-mounted utility appurtenances such as transformers, AC condensers, etc., shall be /_/_
located out of public view and adequately screened through the use of a combination of concrete
or masonry walls, berming, and/or landscaping to the satisfaction of the Planning Director. For
single-family residential developments, transformers shall be placed in underground vaults.
9. All building numbers and individual units shall be identified in a clear and concise manner, /_/_
including proper illumination.
10. The developer shall submit a construction access plan and schedule for the development of all _/_/_
lots for Planning Director and Engineering Services Department approval; including, but not
limited to, public notice requirements, special street posting, phone listing for community
concerns, hours of construction activity, dust control measures, and security fencing.
D. Shopping Centers
1. Provide for the following design features in each trash enclosure, to the satisfaction of the _/_/_
Planning Director .
a. Architecturally integrated into the design of(the shopping center/the project). _/_/_
b. Separate pedestrian access that does not require the opening of the main doors and to /_/_
include self-closing pedestrian doors.
c. Large enough to accommodate two trash bins. _/ /_
2 •
I:\PLANNING\FINAL\PLNGCOMM\2011 Res & Stf Rpt\DRC2010-01006StdCond 6-8.doc
D-15
Project No. DRC2010-01006
Completion Date
d. Roll-up doors. /- /_
• e. Trash bins with counter-weighted lids. / /_
f. Architecturally treated overhead shade trellis. / /_
g. Chain link screen on top to prevent trash from blowing out of the enclosure and designed _/_/_
to be hidden from view.
2. Graffiti shall be removed within 72 hours. / /- _
3. The entire site shall be kept free from trash and debris at all times and in no event shall trash and /_/_
debris remain for more than 24 hours.
4. All operations and businesses shall be conducted to comply with the following standards which
shall be incorporated into the lease agreements for all tenants:
a. Noise Level - All commercial activities shall not create any noise that would exceed an /_/_
exterior noise level of 60 dB during the hours of 10 p.m. until 7 a.m. and 65 dB during the
hours of 7 a.m. until 10 p.m.
b. Loading and Unloading-No person shall cause the loading, unloading,opening,closing,or _/_/_
other handling of boxes, crates, containers, building materials, garbage cans, or other
similar objects between the hours of 10 p.m. and 7 a.m. unless otherwise specified herein,
in a manner which would cause a noise disturbance to a residential area.
5. The lighting fixture design shall compliment the architectural program. It shall include the plaza / /_
area lighting fixtures, building lighting fixtures (exterior), and parking lot lighting fixtures.
E. Building Design
• 1. All roof appurtenances, including air conditioners and other roof mounted equipment and/or / /_
projections shall be screened from all sides and the sound shall be buffered from adjacent
properties and streets as required by the Planning Department. Such screening shall be
architecturally integrated with the building design and constructed to the satisfaction of the
Planning Director. Any roof-mounted mechanical equipment and/or ductwork, that projects
vertically more than 16 inches above the roof or roof parapet, shall be screened by an
architecturally designed enclosure which exhibits a permanent nature with the building design
and is detailed consistent with the building. Any roof-mounted mechanical equipment and/or
ductwork, that projects vertically less than 18 inches above the roof or roof parapet shall be
painted consistent with the color scheme of the building. Details shall be included in building
plans.
2. For commercial and industrial projects, paint roll-up doors and service doors to match main /_/_
building colors.
F. Parking and Vehicular Access (indicate details on building plans)
1. All parking spaces shall be 9 feet wide by 18 feet long. When a side of any parking space abuts _/_/_
a building, wall, support column, or other obstruction, the space shall be a minimum of 11 feet
wide.
2. All parking lot landscape islands shall have a minimum outside dimension of 6 feet and shall _/_/_
contain a 12-inch walk adjacent to the parking stall (including curb).
3. All parking spaces shall be double striped per City standards and all driveway aisles, entrances, /_/_
and exits shall be striped per City standards.
• 3
I:\PLANNING\FINAL\PLNGCOMM\2011 Res & Stf Rpt\DRC2010-01006StdCond 6-8.doc
D-16
Project No. DRC2010-01006
• Completion Date
4. Handicap accessible stalls shall be provided for commercial and office facilities with 25 or more / /_
parking stalls. Designate two percent or one stall; whichever is greater, of the total number of
stalls for use by the handicapped. •
G. Landscaping
1. A minimum of 20% of trees planted within industrial projects, and a minimum of 30% within _/_/_
commercial and office projects, shall be specimen size trees -24-inch box or larger.
2. Within parking lots, trees shall be planted at a rate of one 15-gallon tree for every three parking _/_/_
stalls.
3. Trees shall be planted in areas of public view adjacent to and along structures at a rate of one _/_/_
tree per 30 linear feet of building.
H. Signs
1. The signs indicated on the submitted plans are conceptual only and not a part of this approval. _/_/_
Any signs proposed for this development shall comply with the Sign Ordinance and shall require
separate application and approval by the Planning Department prior to installation of any signs.
APPLICANT SHALL CONTACT THE BUILDING AND SAFETY DEPARTMENT, (909)477-2710,
FOR COMPLIANCE WITH THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS:
NOTE: ANY REVISIONS MAY VOID THESE REQUIREMENTS AND NECESSITATE ADDITIONAL REVIEW(S)
•
I. General Requirements
1. Submit five complete sets of plans including the following: _/ /
a. Site/Plot Plan; •
b. Foundation Plan;
c. Floor Plan;
d. Ceiling and Roof Framing Plan;
e. Electrical Plans (2 sets, detached) including the size of the main switch, number and size
of service entrance conductors, panel schedules, and single line diagrams;
f. Plumbing and Sewer Plans, including isometrics, underground diagrams,water and waste
diagram, sewer or septic system location, fixture units, gas piping, and heating and air
conditioning; and
g. Planning Department Project Number (i.e., DRC2010-01006) clearly identified on the
outside of all plans.
2. Submit two sets of structural calculations, energy conservation calculations, and a soils report. _/_/_
Architect's/Engineer's stamp and "wet'signature are required prior to plan check submittal.
3. Contractors must show proof of State and City licenses and Workers'Compensation coverage to _/_/_
the City prior to permit issuance.
4. Separate permits are required for fencing and/or walls. _/ /_
4 •
I:\PLANNING\FINAL\PLNGCOMM\2011 Res & Stf Rpt\DRC2010-01006StdCond 6-8.doc
D-17
Project No. DRC2010-01006
•
Completion Date
5. Business shall not open for operation prior to posting the Certificate of Occupancy issued by the —/—/-
Building and Safety Department.
•
• Site Development
1. Plans shall be submitted for plan check and approved prior to construction. All plans shall be —/—/-
marked with the project file number(i.e., DRC2010-01006). The applicant shall comply with the
latest adopted California Codes, and all other applicable codes, ordinances, and regulations in
effect at the time of permit application. Contact the Building and Safety Department for
availability of the Code Adoption Ordinance and applicable handouts.
•
2. Prior to issuance of building permits for a new commercial or industrial development project or / /
major addition,the applicant shall pay development fees at the established rate. Such fees may
include but are not limited to: City Beautification Fee, Park Fee, Drainage Fee, Transportation
Development Fee, Permit and Plan Check Fees,Construction and Demolition Diversion Program
deposit and fees and School Fees. Applicant shall provide a copy of the school fees receipt to
the Building and Safety Department prior to permits issuance.
3. Street addresses shall be provided by the Building and Safety Official after tract/parcel map —/—/-
recordation and prior to issuance of building permits.
4. Construction activity shall not occur between the hours of 8:00 p.m. and 6:30 a.m. Monday —/—/-
through Saturday, with no construction on Sunday or holidays.
5. Construct trash enclosure(s) per City Standard (available at the Planning Department's public /—/-
counter).
K. New Structures
• 1. Provide compliance with the California Building Code (CBC) for property line clearances —/—/-
considering use, area, and fire-resistiveness.
2. Provide compliance with the California Building Code for required occupancy separations. —/—/-
3. Roofing material shall be installed per the manufacturer's "high wind" instructions. —/—/-
4. Plans for food preparation areas shall be approved by County of San Bernardino Environmental /—/-
Health Services prior to issuance of building permits.
5. Provide draft stops in attic areas. —/—/—
6. Openings in exterior walls shall be protected in accordance with CBC Table 5-A. —/—/—
L. Grading
1. Grading of the subject property shall be in accordance with California Building Code,City Grading —/_/-
Standards, and accepted grading practices. The final grading plan shall be in substantial
conformance with the approved grading plan.
2. A soils report shall be prepared by a qualified engineer licensed by the State of California to /—/-
perform such work.
3. A geological report shall be prepared by a qualified engineer or geologist and submitted at the —/—/-
time of application for grading plan check.
• 5
•
I:\PLANNING\FINAL\PLNGCOMM\2011 Res& Stf Rpt\DRC2010-01006StdCond 6-8.doc
D-18
•
• Project No. DRC2010-01006
Completion Date
4. The final grading plan, appropriate certifications and compaction reports shall be completed, /_/_
submitted, and approved by the Building and Safety Official prior to the issuance of building
permits. •
5. A separate grading plan check submittal is required for all new construction projects and for _/_/_
existing buildings where improvements being proposed will generate 50 cubic yards or more of
combined cut and fill. The grading plan shall be prepared, stamped, and signed by a California
registered Civil Engineer.
APPLICANT SHALL CONTACT THE POLICE DEPARTMENT, (909) 477-2800, FOR
COMPLIANCE WITH THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS:
M. Security Lighting
1. All parking, common, and storage areas shall have minimum maintained 1-foot candle power. _/_/_
These areas should be lighted from sunset to sunrise and on photo sensored cell.
2. All buildings shall have minimal security lighting to eliminate dark areas around the buildings,with / /_
direct lighting to be provided by all entryways. Lighting shall be consistent around the entire
development.
3. Lighting in exterior areas shall be in vandal-resistant fixtures. / /_
N. Security Hardware
1. All roof openings giving access to the building shall be secured with either iron bars, metal gates, _/_/_
or alarmed.
O. Windows •
1. Storefront windows shall be visible to passing pedestrians and traffic. / /_
2. Security glazing is recommended on storefront windows to resist window smashes and impede /_/_
entry to burglars.
P. Building Numbering
1. Numbers and the backgrounds shall be of contrasting color and shall be reflective for nighttime _/_/_
visibility.
Q. Alarm Systems
1. Install a burglar alarm system and a panic alarm if needed. Instructing management and _/_/_
employees on the operation of the alarm system will reduce the amount of false alarms and in
turn save dollars and lives.
2. Alarm companies shall be provided with the 24-hour Sheriffs dispatch number (909) 941-1488. / /_
APPLICANT SHALL CONTACT THE FIRE SAFETY DEPARTMENT, FIRE PROTECTION
PLANNING SERVICES AT, (909) 477-2770, FOR COMPLIANCE WITH THE FOLLOWING
CONDITIONS:
SEE ATTACHED
6 •
I:\PLANNING\FINAL\PLNGCOMM\2011 Res & Stf Rpt\DRC2010-01006StdCond 6-8.doc
D-19
•
uct Rancho Cucamonga Fire Protection District
oy
�� eia7,Fa .
•
Fire Construction Services
FIRE
STANDARD CONDITIONS
January 11, 2011
Baker's Drive Thru
New Fast-Food Restaurant
12009 Foothill Blvd
DRC2010-01006
THE FOLLOWING STANDARD CONDITIONS APPLY TO THIS PROJECT
The RCFPD Procedures & Standards which are referenced in this document can be access on the web at
http://www.ci.rancho-cucamonga.ca.us/fire/index.htm under the Fire Safety Division & Fire Construction
Services section. Search by article; the preceding number of the standard refers to the article. Chose the
appropriate article number then a drop down menu will appear, select the corresponding standard.
FSC-1 Public and Private Water Supply
1. Design guidelines for Fire Hydrants: The following provides design guidelines for the spacing and location
of fire hydrants:
• a. The maximum distance between fire hydrants in commercial/industrial projects is 300-feet. No portion
of the exterior wall shall be located more than 150-feet from an approved fire hydrant. For cul-de-
sacs, the distance shall not exceed 100-feet.
b. The preferred locations for fire hydrants are:
1. At the entrance(s) to a commercial, industrial.or residential project from the public roadways.
2. At intersections.
3. On the right side of the street, whenever practical and possible.
4. As required by the Fire Safety Division to meet operational needs of the Fire District.
5. A minimum of forty-feet (40')from any building.
c. If any portion of a facility or building is located more than 150-feet from a public fire hydrant measured
on an approved route around the exterior of the facility or building, additional private or public fire
hydrants and mains capable of supplying the required fire flow shall be provided.
d. Provide one fire hydrant for each 1000 gpm of required fire flow or fraction thereof.
FSC-2 Fire Flow
•
1. The required minimum fire flow for this project, when automatic fire sprinklers are installed is 1500 gallons
per minute at a minimum residual pressure of 20-pounds per square inch. This flow reflects a 50-percent
reduction for the installation of an approved automatic fire sprinkler system in accordance with NFPA 13
with central station monitoring. This requirement is made in accordance with the California Fire Code
Appendix, as adopted by the Fire District Ordinances.
11111. Public fire hydrants located within a 500-foot radius of the proposed project may be used to provide the
required fire flow subject to Fire District review and approval. Private fire hydrants on adjacent property
shall not be used to provide required fire flow.
D-20
4. Fire protection water plans are required for all projects that must extend the existing water supply to or
onto the site. Building permits will not be issued until fire protection water plans are approved.
5. On all site plans to be submitted for review, show all fire hydrants located within 600-feet of the proposed •
project site.
FSC-3 Prerequisite for submittal of Overhead Automatic Fire Sprinkler Systems
1. Prior to submitting plans for an overhead automatic fire sprinkler system, the applicant shall submit plans,
specifications and calculations for the fire sprinkler system underground supply piping. Approval of the
underground supply piping system must be obtained prior to submitting the overhead fire sprinkler system
plans.
FSC-4 Requirements for Automatic Fire Sprinkler Systems
Automatic fire sprinklers shall be installed in buildings as required by the2010 California Fire Code and the
Rancho Cucamonga Fire Protection District Ordinance FD5O and/or any other applicable standards require an
approved automatic fire sprinkler system to be installed.
FSC-5 Fire Alarm System & Sprinkler Monitoring
•
1. The 2010 California Building Code, the RCFPD Fire Alarm Standard, Ordinance FD50 and/or the 2010
California Fire Code require most fire sprinkler systems to be monitoring by Central Station sprinkler
monitoring system. A manual and or automatic fire alarm system fire may also be required based on the
use and occupancy of the building. Plan check approval and a building permit are required prior to the
installation of a fire alarm or a sprinkler monitoring system. Plans and specifications shall be submitted to
Fire Construction Services in accordance with RCFPD Fire Alarm Standard.
FSC-6 Fire District Site Access •
Fire District access roadways include public roads, streets and highways, as well as private roads, streets drive
aisles and/or designated fire lanes. Please reference the RCFPD Fire Department Access Roadways
Standard.
1. Location of Access: All portions of the structures 1st story exterior wall shall be located within 150-feet of
Fire District vehicle access, measure on an approved route around the exterior of the building.
Landscaped areas, unpaved changes in elevation, gates and fences are deemed obstructions.
2. Specifications for private Fire District access roadways per the RCFPD Standards are:
a. The minimum unobstructed width is 26-feet.
b. The maximum inside turn radius shall be 24-feet.
c. The minimum outside turn radius shall be 50-feet.
d. The minimum radius for cul-de-sacs is 45-feet.
e. The minimum vertical clearance is 14-feet, 6-inches.
f. At any private entry median, the minimum width of traffic lanes shall be 20-feet on each side.
g. The angle of departure and approach shall not exceed 9-degrees or 20 percent.
h. The maximum grade of the driving surface shall not exceed 12%.
1. Support a minimum load of 70,000 pounds gross vehicle weight (GVW).
j. Trees and shrubs planted adjacent to the fire lane shall be kept trimmed to a minimum of 14-feet,
6-inches from the ground up. Vegetation shall not be allowed to obstruct Fire Department apparatus.
3. Access Doorways: Approved doorways, accessible without the use of a ladder, shall be provided as •
follows:
2•
D-21
a. In buildings without high-piled storage, access shall be provided in accordance with the 2001
• California Building Code, Fire and/or any other applicable standards.
b. In buildings with high-piled storage access doors shall be provided in each 100 lineal feet or major
fraction thereof, of the exterior wall that faces the required access roadways. When railways are
installed provisions shall be made to maintain Fire District access to all required openings.
4. Access Walkways: Hardscaped access walkways shall be provided from the fire apparatus access road
to all required building exterior openings.
5. Commercial/Industrial Gates: Any gate installed across a Fire Department access road shall be in
accordance with Fire District Standard. The following design requirements apply:
a. Prior to the fabrication and installation of the gates, plans are required to be submitted to Fire
Construction Services (FCS) for approval. Upon the completion of the installation and before placing
the gates in service, inspection and final acceptance must be requested from FCS.
b. Gates must slide open horizontally or swing inward.
c. Gates may be motorized or manual.
d. When fully open, the minimum clearance dimension of drive access shall be 20 feet.
e. Manual 'gates must be equipped with a RCFPD lock. The lock must be purchased at the Fire
Administration Office.
f. Motorized gates must open at the rate of one-foot per second.
g. The motorized gate actuation mechanism must be equipped with a manual override device and a fail-
safe or battery backup feature to open the gate or release the locking Mechanism in case of power
failure or mechanical malfunction.
h. Motorized gates shall be equipped with a Knox override key switch. The switch must be installed
• outside the gate in a visible and unobstructed location.
i. For motorized gates, a traffic loop device must be installed to allow exiting from the complex.
j. If traffic pre-emption devices (TPD) are to be installed, the device, location and operation must be
approved by the Fire Chief prior to installation. Bi-directional or multiple sensors may be required due
to complexity of the various entry configurations.
7. Fire Lane Identification: Red curbing and/or signage shall identify the fire lanes. A site plan illustrating
the proposed delineation that meets the minimum Fire District standards shall be included in the
architectural plans submitted to B&S for approval.
•
8. Approved Fire Department Access: Any approved mitigation measures must be clearly noted on the
site plan. A copy of the approved Alternative Method application, if applicable, must be reproduced on the
architectural plans submitted to B&S for plan review.
6. Roof Access: There shall be a means of fire department access from the exterior walls of the buildings
on to the roofs of all commercial, industrial and multi-family residential structures with roofs less than 75'
above the level of the fire access road.
•
a. This access must be reachable by either fire department ground ladders or by an aerial ladder.
b. A minimum of one ladder point with a fixed ladder shall be provided in buildings with construction
features, or high parapets that inhibit roof access.
c. The number of ladder points may be required to be increased, depending on the building size and
configuration.
d. Regardless of the parapet height or construction features the approved ladder point shall be identified
• in accordance to the roof access standard.
e. Where the entire roof access is restricted by high parapet walls or other obstructions, a permanently
mounted access ladder is required.
3
D-22
•
f. Multiple access ladders may be required for larger buildings.
g. Ladder construction must be in accordance with the RCFPD Roof Access Standard Appendix A.
h. A site plan showing the locations of the roof ladder shall be submitted during plan check. •
i. Ladder points shall face a fire access roadway(s).
FSC-10 Occupancy and Hazard Control Permits
Listed are those Fire Code permits commonly associated with the business operations and/or building
construction. Plan check submittal is required with the permit application for approval of the permit; field
inspection is required prior to permit issuance. General Use Permit shall be required for any activity or
operation not specifically described below, which in the judgment of the Fire Chief is likely to produce
conditions that may be hazardous to life or property.
• Compressed Gases
• Public Assembly
• Commercial cooking •
•
• Tents, Canopies and/or Air Supported Structures
Chronological Summary of RCFPD Standard Conditions
PRIOR TO ISSUANCE OF BUILDING PERMITS — Please complete the following prior to the issuance of
any building permits:
1. Private Water Supply (Fire) Systems: The applicant shall submit construction plans, specifications, flow
test data and calculations for the private water main system for review and approval by the Fire District.
Plans and installation shall comply with Fire District Standards. Approval of the on-site (private) fire
underground and water plans is required prior to any building permit issuance for any structure on the site. •
Private on-site combination domestic and fire supply system must be designed in accordance with RCFPD
Standards. The Building & Safety Division and Fire Construction Services will perform plan checks and
inspections.
All private on-site fire hydrants shall be installed, flushed and operable prior to delivering any combustible
framing materials to the site. Fire construction Services will inspect the installation, witness hydrant
flushing and grant a clearance before lumber is dropped.
2. Public Water Supply (Domestic/Fire) Systems: The applicant shall submit a plan showing the locations
of all new public fire hydrants for the review and approval by the Fire District and CCWD. On the plan,
show all existing fire hydrants within a 600-foot radius of the project. Please reference the RCFPD Water
Plan Submittal Procedure Standard.
All required public fire hydrants shall be installed, flushed and operable prior to delivering any combustible
framing materials to the site. CCWD personnel shall inspect the installation and witness the hydrant
flushing. Fire Construction Services shall inspect the site after acceptance of the public water system by
CCWD. Fire Construction Services must grant a clearance before lumber is dropped.
3. Construction Access: The access roads must be paved in accordance with all the requirements of the
RCFPD Fire Lane Standard. All temporary utilities over access roads must be installed at least 14' 6"
above the finished surface of the road.
4. Fire Flow: A current fire flow letter from CCWD must be received. The applicant is responsible for
obtaining the fire flow information from CCWD and submitting the letter to Fire Construction Services.
PRIOR TO THE RELEASE OF TEMPORARY POWER •
The building construction must be substantially completed in accordance with Fire Construction Services'
"Temporary Power Release Checklist and Procedures".
4
D-23
PRIOR TO OCCUPANCY OR FINAL INSPECTION — Please complete the following:
• 1. Hydrant Markers: All fire hydrants shall have a blue reflective pavement marker indicating the fire
hydrant location on the street or driveway in accordance with the City of Rancho Cucamonga Engineering
• Standard Plan 134, "Installation of Reflective Hydrant Markers". On private property, the markers shall be
installed at the centerline of the fire access road, at each hydrant location.
2. Private Fire Hydrants: For the purpose of final acceptance, a licensed sprinkler contractor, in the
presence of Fire Construction Services, shall conduct a test of the most hydraulically remote on-site fire
hydrants. The underground fire line contractor, developer and/or owner are responsible for hiring the
company to perform the test. A final test report shall be submitted to Fire Construction Services verifying
the fire flow available. The fire flow available must meet or exceed the required fire flow in accordance
with the California Fire Code.
3. Fire Sprinkler System: Prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, the fire sprinkler system(s)
shall be tested and accepted by Fire Construction Services.
4. Fire Sprinkler Monitoring: Prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, the fire sprinkler
monitoring system must be tested and accepted by Fire Construction Services. The fire sprinkler
monitoring system shall be installed, tested and operational immediately following the completion of the
fire sprinkler system (subject to the release of power).
5. Fire Suppression Systems and/or other special hazard protection systems shall be inspected, tested and
accepted by Fire Construction Services before occupancy is granted and/or equipment is placed in
service.
6. Fire Alarm System: Prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, the fire alarm system shall be
installed, inspected, tested and accepted by Fire Construction Services.
•7. Access Control Gates: Prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, vehicular gates must be
inspected, tested and accepted in accordance with RCFPD Standards by Fire Construction Services.
8. Fire Access Roadways: Prior to the issuance of any Certificate of Occupancy, the fire access roadways
must be installed in accordance with the approved plans and acceptable to Fire Construction Services.
The CC&R's, the reciprocal agreement and/or other approved documents shall be recorded and contain
an approved fire access roadway map with provisions that prohibit parking, specify the method of
enforcement and identifies who is responsible for the required annual inspections and the maintenance of
all required fire access roadways.
9. Address: Prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, commercial/industrial and multi-family
buildings shall post the address in accordance to the appropriate RCFPD addressing Standard.
10. Hazardous Materials: The applicant must obtain inspection and acceptance by Fire Construction
Services.
11. Confidential Business Occupancy Information: The applicant shall complete the Rancho Cucamonga
Fire District "Confidential Business Occupancy Information" form. This form provides contact information
for Fire District use in the event of an emergency at the subject building or property. This form must be
presented to the Fire Construction Services Inspector.
12. Mapping Site Plan: Prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, an 8 '/z" x 11" or 11" x 17" site
plan of the site in accordance with RCFPD Standard shall be revised by the applicant to reflect the actual
location of all devices and building features as required in the standard. The site plan must be reviewed
• and accepted by the Fire Inspector.
5
D-24
•
STAFF REPORT ' - 'y
• PLANNING DEPARTMENT Lj
DATE: June 8, 2011 RANCHO
TO: Chairman and Members of the Planning Commission CUCAMONGA
FROM: James R. Troyer, AICP, Planning Director
BY: Larry Henderson, AICP, Principal Planner
SUBJECT: ENTERTAINMENT PERMIT DRC2011-00158 - CHARLES JOSEPH ASSOCIATES -
RA POUR - A request for entertainment in conjunction with a restaurant/bar to be
located in an existing building at 7900 Kew Avenue within the Victoria Gardens Lifestyle
Center - APN; 0227-464-15. Related File: Non-Construction Conditional Use Permit
DRC2011-00157 and Minor Development Review DRC2011-00182.
PROJECT AND SITE DESCRIPTION:
A. Surrounding Land Use and Zoning:
North - Developed — Mixed Use, Victoria Gardens
South - Developed — Mixed Use, Victoria Gardens
East - Developed — Mixed Use, Victoria Gardens
West - Parking Lot - Mixed Use, Victoria Gardens
• B. General Plan Designations:
Project Site - Mixed Use
North - Mixed Use
South - Mixed Use
East - Mixed Use
West - Mixed Use
C. Site Characteristics: The Ra Pour Restaurant will occupy a partially completed (previous CUP
for DRC2007-00601 Mexico Restaurant approved but never completed) lease space of
approximately 6,400 square feet located immediately north of the TGIF restaurant building on
Kew Avenue. To the north, across an existing paseo, is an allergy/asthma relief business. To
the west, across Kew Avenue, is the Ulta Cosmetics and Moon Doggies pet shop. New
projects and/or uses within Victoria Gardens involving no significant exterior changes are
subject to final approval by the Planning Director. A Conditional Use Permit is required for the
bar and service of a full range of alcoholic beverages in conjunction with a restaurant use
subject to review and approval by the Planning Director.
ANALYSIS:
A. Ra Pour Restaurant offers "modern" and upscale cuisine. Ra Pour Restaurant will be open
daily for lunch and dinner. Hours of operation will be from 11:00 a.m. to 2:00 a.m. Monday
through Sunday with an age restriction of 21 and over from 10:00 p.m. to 2:00 a.m. (for details
• see the applicant's Business Plan - Exhibit A). The restaurant offers sit-down table service
within the leased space and in a 470 square foot outdoor patio area on the north side of the
Item E
PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT
DRC2011-00158—CHARLES JOSEPH ASSOCIATES — ON BEHALF OF RA POUR
RESTAURANT
June 8, 2011 •
Page 2
building. The Restaurant use (Conditional Use Permit DRC2011-00157) will allow the service
of distilled spirits along with the meals at the restaurant. The serving of alcoholic beverages
shall be limited to the approved hours for the operation of the restaurant. This request
includes a request for nightclub style entertainment and dancing.
Staff anticipates no conflict with nearby land uses within the center. The proposed restaurant
with bar is consistent with the mix of retail and eating uses found within the Victoria Gardens
Lifestyle Center and is similar in type and scope as other sit down restaurants. According to
the Police Department at Victoria Gardens, full-service restaurants typically present no
immediate safety concerns unless the nature of the 'restaurant changes or there is a lack of
proper management. Because this Entertainment Permit request includes a DJ, bands and
dancing, staff has attached a number of specific conditions that have been developed to
address these concerns and assist the business management in establishing appropriate
boundaries.
Entertainment Type/Hours:
The Entertainment proposed is detailed in the attached copy of the Applicant's Mission
Statement and Concept Description. The description states in part; "... band entertainment
which may include Jazz, acoustical bands, cover bands, and in House DJ. ... as the music is
designed to create ambiance and provide canned music or musical operations that •
compliment the atmosphere for high class socialization, rather than a 'night club'." Dancing is
proposed and therefore staff is recommending a specific condition related to the occupancy of
the establishment which reads:
Total occupancy of the restaurant including the exterior patio dining area shall be limited to
283 persons including employees.
The general hours of operation will be from 11:00 a.m. to 2:00 a.m. Sunday through Saturday.
The proposed entertainment hours mirror the general hours of operation. With this provision,
the applicant desires to provide flexibility for morning sporting events. Additionally, an age
restriction of 21 years and over from 10:00 p.m. to 2:00 a.m. Sunday through Saturday has
been proposed by the applicant.
Security: Ra Pour has provided security plan to address potential situations during business
operations, as well as ensure proper alcohol service. Ra Pour has provided a copy of their
security plan as Exhibit E, which describes their security procedures in dealing with any issues
that may arise.
In addition to the security procedures proposed by Ra Pour, staff has included a condition in
the resolution that will require an employee who serves alcohol to obtain a Certificate of
Completion for training in the proper service of alcohol (L.E.A.D. or equivalent). Also, an
additional condition of approval has been included requiring the applicant to cease all alcohol
sales and consumption no less than thirty (30) minutes before closing. This is to ensure that
all patrons will have adequate time between consuming a drink and leaving the establishment. •
E-2
PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT
DRC2011-00158 — CHARLES JOSEPH ASSOCIATES —ON BEHALF OF RA POUR
• RESTAURANT
June 8, 2011
Page 3
Environmental Assessment: This action is within the scope of the project reviewed in an
Environmental Impact Report (EIR) (State Clearinghouse No. 20010301028) prepared for
Development Agreement 01-02, Victoria Community Plan Amendment 01-01, and Tentative
Parcel Map SUBTPM15716. Said EIR was certified by the City Council on February 20, 2002,
and no additional environmental review for the discretionary actions mentioned in this notice is
required pursuant to Public Resources Code Section 21166.
FACTS FOR FINDING:
Entertainment Permit
The evidence indicates that:
1. The conduct of the establishment will not be detrimental to the public health, safety or welfare,
or materially injurious to properties or improvements in the vicinity as conditions have been
imposed to require onsite security during the hours of entertainment and ensure proper
service of alcohol to patrons, and the building complies with all applicable Fire and Building
Codes; and
• 2. The premises or establishment is not likely to be operated in an illegal, improper or disorderly
manner as sufficient conditions have been imposed to ensure that security provisions are in
place to regulate the conduct of patrons to prevent incidents resulting in calls for service; and
3. The normal operation of the premises would not interfere with the peace and quiet of the
surrounding office buildings and commercial centers as conditions have been imposed to
ensure that the establishment will comply with the Performance Standards set forth in Section
17.10.050 of the Development Code and will not create adverse impacts upon adjacent uses;
and
4. The granting of this application will not create a public nuisance as sufficient conditions have
been imposed to ensure that the establishment will operate in an orderly manner and will
prevent incidents resulting in calls for service.
CORRESPONDENCE: This item was advertised as a public hearing in the Inland Valley Daily
Bulletin newspaper, the property was posted, and notices were mailed to all property owners within
a 660-foot radius of the project site.
RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Planning Commission approve Entertainment
Permit DRC2011-00158 through the adoption of the attached Resolution of Approval with
Conditions.
•
E-3
PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT
DRC2011-00158— CHARLES JOSEPH ASSOCIATES — ON BEHALF OF RA POUR
RESTAURANT
June 8, 2011 •
Page 4
R- •ecttully submitted,,i
James R. Troyer, AICP
Planning Director
JT/LH/vv
Attachments: Exhibit A - Statement of Purpose
Exhibit B - Location Map
Exhibit C - Floor Plan
Exhibit D - Entertainment Plan
Exhibit E - Security Procedures
Draft Resolution of Approval for Entertainment Permit DRC2011-00158
•
•
E-4
• STATEMENT OF PURPOSE
The purpose of the document is to provide a written outline of the proposed business operations located at
740 Kew Ave, Rancho Cucamonga for the new home of"Ra Pour". The principal, Reginald Webb will
be the managing owner of this location and the one responsible for the Entertainment Permit.
MISSION STATEMENT
To provide a unique and safe atmosphere for families to enjoy a unique sophisticated vibe dining for the
family enjoys quality creative food and refreshments at a high end establishment. Our goal is to provide
a place that can be utilized by all age groups based upon their natural socialization cycles during our week
to provide for family eating during the day and evening, while later in the evening turning up the music
for responsible adults to enjoy while the grandparents and children go home for the night.
THE CONCEPT
Ra Pour is an upscale sophisticated vibe dining and serving light faire,refreshments and cocktails in a
business classy casual style environment with contemporary interior design. The menu will consist of
unique multi-course tasting menu that allows guests a personalized journey of modern creations and
traditional flavors. Pristine but not pretentious service guides guests through a memorable evening of
innovative fare. We will offer a family style environment during dining hours for all generations of the
family,kids, parents and grandparents as a definitive gathering place for those in-the-know. Ra Pour will
be featuring a luxurious, sexy interior with a decidedly modernist decor, with retractable glass garage
doors, creating a seamless indoor/outdoor feel. The kitchen is open and on display for the customers to
• enjoy the dining experience. We anticipate always been able to attract the right crowd, building the
cooking and ambiance at Ra Pour creating a perfect marriage of classical excellence and modern
interpretation. The soundtrack in our establishment will solidify the high end dining experience.
Our food will be presented with rolled silverware in cloth napkins along with friendly table or bar service.
Our business "Ra Pour" provides for an opportunity for family dining, high design atmosphere with
personalized service that is accentuated by music, occasional dancing and libations with family and
friends
During all hours of operation we will provide family type food as shown in the attached menu. Our
model is during the normal eating hours to have walk in seated service as well as reserved seating
available for all hours. Guests will be able to reserve the VIP lounge for special events. We have a select
area available with a special cooking area for a `personalized chef' to provide for special events and
family members desiring this high quality and custom service. During the later evening hours we will
continue to provide the same full menu but will focus on a modified menu for decadent and design hand
foods "tapas" to provide for a comfortable lounge experience for those family members that stay behind
to socialize with family and friends that we anticipate will be the 21-50 year old demographic. We will
encourage and expect food service at all hours of operation, however we anticipate during the evening
hours will have more of a cocktail lounge environment where we will restrict access to patrons 21 and
over from 10pm til close to ensure a positive controlled responsible environment. Our ABC license will
be a 47.
We would like to propose to extend our current business hours to accommodate sporting events in the
mornings and for availability of an additional menu and services later in the evenings along with music:
•
1
EXHIBIT A
E-5
Existing Approved Hours of Operation •
Monday—Thursday: 11:00 am to 11:00 pm;
Friday-Saturday: 9:00 AM—2:00 am
Requested Hours of Operation Entertainment
Sunday—Saturday: 11:00 am to 2:00 am Sun-Saturday 11:00am-2:00 am
Age restriction 21+from 10:00 pm-2:00 am
We would like to be provided the flexibility to modify our schedules as the business permits for band
entertainment which may include Jazz, acoustical bands, cover bands, and in House IN. We will not be
employing an outside DJ, as the music is designed to create ambiance and provide canned music or
musical operations that compliment the atmosphere for high class socialization, rather than a `night club'.
We will not be charging admission and a nightclub use is restricted in our lease operations. We will be
providing a high end establishment that provides for a safe environment for business professionals and the
discerning residents of Rancho Cucamonga. Allowing us this flexibility for conditions of approval that
cease entertainment 30 minutes prior to the close of hours of operation would accomplish our business
operation goals to provide the type of specialized entertainment in conjunction with our business
operations.
We also would like to provide the ability for special events such as wedding parties, birthday parties and
Corporate events for reservation during the day or evening hours to take advantage of our vibe dinning
environment.
BACKGROUND OF THE BUSINESS •
According to our research, within the City of Rancho Cucamonga and adjoining East/West cities, there
are very few establishments in the immediate area that can provide a place for residents to have a high
end supper club. Presently, residents of these communities must travel to Pasadena or Orange County to
have a high end lounge experience. With the emerging professional and middle age market there is
growing demand to have a localized establishment reducing sprawl within our community. Our client
base is for a unique Family dinning experience during the day and early evening hours. Our vision is
taken from the "Ra Pour" of our family that provides a place for family's to enjoy allowing for the
younger adult generation to enjoy a healthy lounge environment where our adult youth can feel
comfortable socializing and providing a safe environment to dance should the feeling arise under the
supervision of a family run business.
We will attract a more responsible age group then some of the other establishments in the area. In spite of
the economy, we have seen a positive response to our market surveys to provide a high end vibe dinning
lounge motif in the Victoria Gardens. We have seen a growth in other comfortable lounge atmospheres
such as Yard House which offer playback music, lounge environment and libations for the residents of
Rancho Cucamonga. We have received a lot of positive feedback for our business model and look
forward to taken the success from our other businesses and applying those successes to our dinner lounge.
LOCATION
2 •
E-6
• Ra Pour will be located at 7900 Kew Ave,just north of TGI Fridays, and south of the new Toby Keiths "I
Love this Bar".
MINIMIZING RISK FACTORS
Ra Pour will employ a security plan (see attached) and continuous education to employees regarding
refusal of service of alcoholic beverages to underage and intoxicated patrons and abide by all ABC
guidelines as well as restricting access to patrons during later evenings to assist in this control similar to
what is done with Yardhouse, Bevmo and Total Wine. This closing plan as suggested by the San
Bernardino County Sheriffs is a prime example of how utilizing longer business hours we can control
potential risk factors. We have assisted the Sheriffs department in identification which has resulted in
detention of a City wide crime spree. There have been no code enforcement incidents that we are aware
of and to our knowledge there have been a limited amount of calls for services, which we believe is a
direct result of demonstrating our ability to attract and manage a responsible clientele.
SUMMARY
Ra Pour's hope is to provide the community with a safe locally-owned high end Lounge establishment
that provides unique food a hip environment for family events and personalized eating experiences along
with entertainment close to home that will set the bar for supper clubs in the Inland Empire.
Thank you for your time in reviewing our application and please feel free to contact my
Consultant or myself if you have any questions or need of any additional information or
• assistance concerning my business.
Ra Pour
•
3
E-7
ml w.m.r I. l.=
_ _ `' ?st ra “.,, 1K9, lam
E,
513311N]/4V - � 4 - CI
aaOuiuuas I` I
R -• . 11
�19 Q ; °f 4 f
-.
8
p
p ' a `3l ,
f � 9 i:.FR!.!.
ith .::cc'EE - F
il _ i Y in
: y
.:`° i 1 'ia Q °1 iii 1 i 1 iig ens a 1Q 0g gB a s Y a Y e ,4 h:;
G _ e
, -, CS. S i.aa 7 g Ezyi f4 Ii BIS4 ` Qs C., /a :
litiz Bf €Z
3NY1SN301f1/9tl aLDIA
re •_, ate,
a, o,p
f via eO
,�� n.iel.e -- OgA 3i:i:T411,•1;39:
nom i i h i h h MI s ,, t
1 L. .'iC
Al
• E
aNVnaoentl I --,- S:
-- I i
t
Irte uN•l ea via
I I
I
i� G
s G
s
ig
0
{6
/V\ N•IBIT B OWA31l100 M3310 AVG
EXHIBIT
E-8
a nx \a :,� .."
- -= A °::
51031IHOUV �&.\ i ' .°.`W-.'.'°.`�'n.,. r1
aa2ucuuag ,T''' .. �o ,nH>:Qw
a` CD
sm
Y 4$ � Y
L J �■ninth Elsie O■ vtm P I ► YT- ,sun.
A �:-\\4! s1T4 '° _ •
IMEMPIIIIIIMEMIMMIalnell-0 Ls]
p __ lc— . , Rh • •
§e .1:.IN 0 Hog. r_qu. X8 1.10 ,` ■Ir■■& !
a N. 1/::.: I' �7■■!� I,
1 - it. I l t ■=Eli? , ,
s . '\—@es b� \ '1111E4.1.'1111E4.1 7 \.
;,
i m I i 7■kS■
i• :sap a
I �a II i__ _ ag t % 4
- E
s s €�d ; a
° �� 9n ♦ ♦ •♦ use.47
c _ „_
g gd 4 • ;fig■
, _, i I �__ ♦ Aar .�■
L _1 -1001
-,n! m t;14$$!s• __ iu 1�� �J'
t I' gag 1 ih.- *-- ----:!...---r--------15\0\1% 1111.110. ih
Al R--_sal" -- I::: -cast-- 'iitti 1,1 I INIIIIIIN I;LI
so , .....ffri-_-:_:__t__---.2 :7-a \I \r 1 W *UM
1111110119r;1( -.ItA \\ \ 4i % itaillillis 1.71
EXHIBIT C
E-10
,.Tits .,, ° , ^,°r.,
S1J311NJtlY i,ry� �\ =Y i41 .�iw�m��vn.r tl
.xa2utuuag m V v o m., .00„663 :. ,_
9
i I •
0 N F„ „ 5 ” a 1
0 •--- t L. g 8 i s q i
o 14 g1 . d
^a Z es_ _ $5 k- . 1
9 _s � w i
0 (1111' moll : Ens
S-. I — I I I I! 1_ ■ml : ,L - -- 1 Iii — J o
\ YS0 \ n n n •I `
jPo
g
c-2� 1a J' 4,„,, ,
0 1_ ____\ t ,
i cic ♦♦♦;,F lij g m 1:,
1 L5 H6 %I per \ ' I .,
Ws �n ��< ` `o •♦ • A- . a e�ouk!. Eli
�, . , • ks !. 1
t o f' \ �ec♦eaai" °e♦ •♦, 00 1 .
`C �7, , " • • �� it
5 •sea, \ ' \ • on
_ ,.\�,A1G\M1 �, .A , ri ••`p\!._.7— ��,,ilyiYf aa�:■.i �[�] �.op
P
E-11
n 01
5103IIMO&V \r : .1!1
uu
aaguiag fret 3.`,: scL:A51 eo'3....
f��
, .1ii
• 1s ig! p; 22:
1 1 3 w a
11 a
s_i®i pi — s et
1 F "w 3P di
Fa., y
Ely, r
{ , o
z h 3]
I 3 5
wog �`
�
o •
■ 4 wL
o nr 4 4 4L Ya
P OO
ag igiir—i'ii < w rg _ .d
ra '� th is Ho ®iii1��; fl 3 5 hi
�II� , s I re
• " it ' ° ;i
I�I1 ae � I�11`:�
!t 3 Is'1":"In o �.�III!! _
`# I III1iIII L II III■
Ii h IiIIIuøi F . g
ICI 1111 ''''':°b h!
� . _ - _- _
11111�pn IP the, lall
I�a..�i�.aa aw _.. ® i ��
ilL ,gw m ® �g, li NM �!Ill.1w 16 n ' a =' It I I _ ___ II [ IViBI is e ,
MI I I• W t® o : u•
ti 7.
• E-12
_.... ...,. . f ,..,. o L. ��. a g Lri
aa2utuuasl. "e�E —r Q�
•
IF
mEc-,l
E lI
any I II;Tr
Eat. t g
C
'il* II 111
ih
IWO €R E
al
hP
t�-
._�i_���- EEC■
i i II
IM:.11 III �I'I ■
ii
_'�
'ill. 3 ' m •
ill . ical:1 1 1 li
I MI
I WI
old
gt di
64 I
I
r /I '___�I s
i1
Ifili ;7
I
III m
tr J■
II__i rIM
II
111' 11 � iihrap
_ �
—I _ = Zi. i2.:L •
_ IdAll a
� s 'm n g o ; if
t ' qa
of ° 9 i §_ ?
m. ed, E-13 s
[, oi'.Ri,ASP."mm 77,D
S Da1IHO.ev 0,. . ro,....'S, I31 .u,. .a.: m_BBf� C♦";
Saauiuues .,_,..,m ?/. 11..1' ,.. ��v..a N,.:">:a..f.
oa ei .p
ti in
ggig p``• I = 4
6r a3a3 I �� h• iii11i
■
_ J F
10%
cl b
Ills o
z
a O W
W4
o
h 14 61kr. OOO
L/I VS
• / /
S e
B 8 Pe i.V hh" ;: § g
N y s :gig i , ?
& ,'&yF PI i 5 $S des i 3 •ede z e
H
Or
411S
0
z is n€
lb Rb ltltl 4
a i
E-14
)) ohh6
a U E lli
sy $<
y ., y Q)
W`m d l eW 0
r Ir ,
II II _1^ 0 ® ~3
I, - >g >a y is
•
% Ti u A
1 o.
1 ! 7 A m _ W>°g g
0
II l ' W8 >m ;3P =i> I i t > Y
... I s _ I^ § I�
us •
a I ICI I NF l'Ifil 1
BBiti____ i_i(91 W ;:o 1 I ; !9 g >m
tb .[® Z� [ : i tw o
CAI 1 J I, I. >*Cr ,1LiMa' .-1A?;.',1 I ' � Lr li �
llI1s'— i ; 1.Taill` � 1
•W :IC � Ii1
.
®BI I®i9®BliNgii1 i I 11 !I
i I
g x is®91�I�i�iOimfii®1 i y z a , � �3 :
L .2 : - {2' [�" f- rz. fi 5' �Ft i . i _t- : 3 7,
:1 yv >�-=il1 I ei b zr. ,1i -1t:),90::;1.11' . t� i11!1 >
I c.,•M1�j i �'�ii .. �?5` n<, I �e'mN Zmo rmigi.
ti 's t T di'S k-A 4 . m
{ 411 ;. Yo ��mmi• m
Itik 1 I rig i T ,1 n; E _ 1 Lai o Ln 00
0 <J
o mrc Z� ce
=w.a1 1111111171= Yl <� wz
II IIIIw�eW W o =�
j y6Z S J Y' u apt:f p N m . <,
I
ii i 1tf'g i a°o°o aU
Yi'y''t*d t zoo pU
iUU w0Z
'f) lis �� at <00 OIK
42: l) 1 1. 1..E
- arcs- imm®m-meta-ita
Y M k
3 0
h _4
g 1 _1 -
E-15
•
EAT
JLT Art ;1-,,..2,u1, ,,0 drcr,dcry, ; flpHro (t-typeriennt..t: unii-ttue muttc.,-ct:tuH.t,
ttrit:tt-twt .t„.it.littsis a pi.:ttt.tt.tto: tetilt:.7,c.i rtt.trt-t:t:try
tot-; T.7 tr a CI it 10: -:: %RD P ;21 C .1-:tut not tit et :'nbcus
(tit tt-ctt:-Jc: thirctutyliti rstvtin-w-tt-..1 tt,if ittrc
r,7151tit DRINK
t 'ETS 1 \IR ■.,1 I 111“,1/1
(9; \":7-,2',. titt:...ttot rtiritti:citErt. tti
ctc-iarlic ,trir tty •tf : t }cc -nL ! ; :• •
:Th,•-•;; generation
- LOUNGE
•
• LISTEN
: •
" .
EXHIBIT D
E-16
Ric lk EAT
Pecan crusted Sea Scallop on bed of spinach
•
Teriyaki Tri-tip
Mini Crab cake with mango chutney
Sweet potato gnocchi with cinnamon cream sauce
•
Pan seared Ahi tuna on field greens
Macadamia nut crusted Mahi Mahi
Chicken cour don blue
Turkey wrapped in bacon and collard greens
Black eyed peas with ham and veggies
Mini quiche Loraine •
Chicken with Artichoke and sundried tomatoes
Sausage and bell peppers on couscous
5 spice pork roast
Chipotle PRO ribs
Meat lovers' pizza
I�JVJ a';En
Pi-27a
-;focc 1'.I5jc tL s`ir` r r; i`U, �I : � �. t� brid eztlfldricy:i I iw,Vc.ry;
Assorted sorbets
Fresh fruit and cream
Apple crisp
Assorted layered cookie bars •
Angel food cake with mixed berries
E-17
Ra- Pour
•
Our staff is highly qualified and trained in our specific processes and procedures.
We are managed from a corporate level allowing corporate supervisors to visit
the site at least monthly to insure conformance with our strict code of conduct
which is in accordance with all applicable state and city laws. Our safety and
success an important factor as to why our business model will create a safe and
positive environment.
Ra Pour operates as a family dining establishment from the hours of 11 AM to
9pm+where our customers can experience our unique fare with the family. As
the evening progresses and the dinner crowd subsides, the space transforms into a
comfortable vibe dinning lounge establishment with a in-house DJ, but not a
nightclub. We will adequately staff the restaurant at all times based on the
expected number of patrons. We expect that maximum number of staff at any
one time to be 26.
The restaurant is divided between our fire &water fall feature that will house a
personalize chef where we can accommodate various culinary desires. We plan
for Generations to provide for a maximum capacity of 283, which includes
employees. Generations strives to bring our customers an enjoyable safe
environment that will have an atmosphere for all ages of guests. We will
• accomplish this by proper staffing and placement of our staff We will hire an
outside security company to handle admittance to the facility during the hours of
9pm to 2am when we are having entertainment, and insure all guests are behaving
in accordance the spirit of the environment and experience we provide. Namely,
a upscale restaurant & lounge similar to best restaurants in South Orange County,
Los Angeles and Las Vegas. We will operate ih a way that respects neighboring
businesses as well as all city and state regulations. Security personnel will be
formally trained on maintaining a safe secure environment for our guests and on
the importance of alcohol safety and ABC compliance.
Security Procedures
The purpose of Generations security personnel, called "Hosts" is to provide a safe
environment in our lounge. Our top priority is to furnish our security personnel
with the appropriate knowledge to handle any situation that may arise in the
course of operating hours. The tools provided here are based on principles
expertly designed to provide a. safe environment for our staff, patrons, and
property.
Use of Force
Regardless of the number of security staff, all contact with our patrons will
• follow the basic guidelines of the Use of Force Matrix. This Matrix is broken into
5 steps:
740 Kew Ave,Rancho Cucamonga Ca 91739
EXHIBIT E E-18
Ra- Pour
I. Apparent Force •
This Force is created by the visual sense of authority our staff projects. It is our
staffs appearance, attitude, demeanor and presence. These elements should he
professional and create a sense of authority to all patrons observing us. This
enables the patrons to know who is an employee and that when the employee
approaches them, they should pay heed to any instructions or requests. This level
of force is not achieved by intimidation, but rather by courteous professionalism..
II. Constructive Force
This Force is the result of the spoken words,what our staff says to our patrons.
This level should continue the line of professionalism and helpfulness. Profanity
used toward the patron expressly forbidden, The goal here is to give the patron
the impression that our staff is here to help. We know that as long as the patron
feels our staff is trying to help them.
III. Physical Force
This Force is where our staff would place their hands on our patrons to
restrain and or remove them from our venue, This force is only authorized when a
patron presents an unquestionably unsafe element to our environment or other
patrons. Whenever, feasible, two employees should approach the unruly patron
and work as a team. Though individual holds may be necessary, it is always
better to have two employees restrain/remove a patron for law enforcement •
handling as may be appropriate. Police will be contacted in any case wher a
disturbance may or
IV. Defensive Force
This Force provided is for an employee tb defend himself against a. physical
attack, 'Mere are three options our employee has if he or she is attacked or Push
away from the patron and create distance while calling for assistance, 2)
immediately grab the attacker and restrain them with the least amount of force
necessary. 3) As a last resort, strike the patron to scare them and immediately
grab the attacker to restrain them, Continued strikes, he either fist or feet, without
regard to restraint, will constitute excessive force for which we, the venue and
our employee may be held civilly and/or criminally responsible.
• Command
Ask or tell the patron to do or stop doing something - This is to be done in a stern,
but pleasant manner, (e.g, Good Evening, sir. My name is Shane; I'm security
here at the bar, I'm going to need you. to put your shirt. back on while inside the
bar, Thank you very much,).
• Reasons
Wk you need the patron to do or stop doing something, if they do not comply
with your command—Unruly patrons may respond to our request if given a
reason why we require their compliance. (e.g. 1 know it's hot in here and you
don't want to put your shirt on sir, but: it's a house policy that guys must wear •
shirts while in the bar. So, if you could just put your shirt back on, I'd appreciate
E-19
Ra- Pour
• it. Thanks.).
• Options
Explain what options the patron has and the potential outcomes of those options
— People do not. want to be forced to do anything, but if given options, a patron
is likely to comply. (e.g. OK, sir. I understand you don't want to put your shirt
back on, but that really only leaves us two options: One, you put the shirt hack on
and stay inside the bar and continue to have a good. time, or Two, if you choose
to keep the shirt off, I'm going to have to ask: you to leave and I really don't want
you to go, Pm glad you're here. So why don't you just put the shirt on and stay in
the Restaurant? Thanks.).
Confirmation
Again, we understand that people ward to be treated with respect and want their
opinions heard, Ask patron if they have any suggestions to amicably rectify this
issue (e.g. Sir is them anything T can do to get you to put your shirt on so you can
stay in the bar?)
If the patron refuses to comply with the laws of the city of Rancho Cucamonga
and the state of California OR to follow the house policy established to maintain
a safe environment and security has used C,R.O.C„ then Security is now
authorized to use minimal physical force to remove the patron from our venue.
Hands-on is still, always, a last resort. All staff needs to provide a thorough
account of any incident. Examples of when reports should be completed are
• fights, injury, medical or law enforcement involvement, severely intoxicated
patrons, and any crimes (e.g. Larceny from a patron, refusing to pay for services,
destruction of property), These reports must include the date and time of the
in(incident, names of the employees involved, participants and any witnesses.
The reports of all staff need to be clear and chronologically organized so that the
reader can get a clear picture of not only the incident, but the response to the
incident. These reports are required to be completed by the end of the employee's
shift and faxed. to the insurance provider by close of-that business day.
At no time are employees allowed to carry and guns, knives, other weapons, or
chemical agents. This prohibition includes flashlights that arc larger than 2 AA
batteries
Uniform
The uniform consists of a colored shirt that reads "SECURITY" in a solid script
not less than 2" so that patrons can easily identify who is in charge. The uniform
must be worn at all times while our security personnel are on the clock. The
uniform must be tucked in and pressed so that their appearance is professional.
No patron will be served alcohol without providing a valid form of identification
when requested. We comply with suggested guidelines of the California Alcohol
Beverage Control Commission which states that establishments granted liquor
licenses are only to accept "bona fide" identification which is defined as ID that is
• currently valid and issued by a government agency. Valid forms of identification
E-20
Ra- Pour
include: a state driver's license with photo, a military ID, a Passport, or a state- •
issued identification card with photo, in accordance with California, we do not
accept foreign ID will be checked at the door before the patron is allowed to enter
the establishment, and should be checked again at the bar if the server feels a
patron may he underage. We follow the California guidelines which suggest card,
anyone who looks under 30.
Any employee who is responsible for checking identification is required to
adequately handle the identification. They must read the it) and feel for raised
pictures or fraying laminate on the card, The card must also be inspected to
ensure the person presenting the card looks like the person on the ID, and that the
ID is not expired. Simply looking at an ID for the birth date is not an adequate ID
check.
If there is any question as to the authenticity of the ID, we may ask the patron
questions about the card such as what is your address, what is your astrological
sign, what day were you born, etc.. Anytime we suspect an. ID is a. fake we will
deny entry to a patron. Also, a patron will be refused entry into the restaurant if
they are visibly intoxicated or otherwise impaired before they enter the restaurant,
Security Rules
Force will only be used when it is necessary to ensure the safety of the venue„
other employees, or patron:, All use of force should be aimed at restraining the •
patron, not for fighting or hurting them. No hand-strikes are to be used unless an
employee or patron is faced with serious physical injury or deadly force.
Security employees must not leave their post unless they are relieved by another
employee. Cell phones are not to be used when the security employee is at their
post, Security employees are not allowed to consume alcohol or use drug during
their shift, Security employees are responsible for keeping their area of the
Restaurant clean from spills and debris which could cause injury to another
person if two combatants from a fight are separated, they are, to be ejected
through separate doors. The combatants should also be ejected at different times
(i.e. eject the most aggressive combatant and wait 10 minutes to eject the other
combatant).
Always treat patrons with respect and courtesy. Use phrases like "please" and
"thank you- often. Be stern but patient.
•
E 21
RESOLUTION NO. 11-27
• A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
RANCHO CUCAMONGA, CALIFORNIA, APPROVING ENTERTAINMENT
PERMIT DRC2011-00158, A REQUEST BY CHARLES JOSEPH
ASSOCIATES FOR RA POUR TO ALLOW ENTERTAINMENT IN
CONJUNCTION WITH A RESTAURANT/BAR, LOCATED AT 7900 KEW
AVENUE; AND MAKING FINDINGS IN SUPPORT THEREOF-APN: 0227-
464-15.
A. Recitals.
1. On May 21, 1986,the City Council of the City of Rancho Cucamonga adopted Ordinance
No. 290 providing for the regulation of entertainment.
2. Charles Joseph Associates on behalf of Ra Pour filed an application for the issuance of
Entertainment Permit DRC2011-00158, as described in the title of this Resolution. Hereinafter in this
Resolution, the subject Entertainment Permit request is referred to as "the application."
3. On the 8th day of June 2011 the Planning Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga
conducted a duly noticed public hearing on the application and concluded said hearing on that date.
4. All legal prerequisites prior to the adoption of this Resolution have occurred.
B. Resolution.
• NOW, THEREFORE, it is hereby found,determined, and resolved by the Planning Commission
of the City of Rancho Cucamonga as follows:
1. This Commission hereby specifically finds that all of the facts set forth in the Recitals, Part
A, of this Resolution are true and correct.
2. Based upon the substantial evidence presented to this Commission during the above-
referenced public hearing on June 8, 2011, including written and oral staff reports, together with .
public testimony, this Commission hereby specifically finds as follows:
a. The application applies to property located at 7900 Kew with a street frontage of 102
feet and lot depth of 57 feet and is presently improved with a commercial building; and
b. The property to the north of the subject site is developed and zoned Mixed Use,
Victoria Gardens;the property to the south is developed and zoned Mixed Use,Victoria Gardens;the
property to the east is developed and zoned Mixed Use; Victoria Gardens, and the property to the
west is a parking lot and zoned Mixed Use, Victoria Gardens; and
c. The Entertainment as proposed is detailed in the attached copy of the Applicant's
Mission Statement and Concept Description. The description states in part; "... band entertainment
which may include Jazz, acoustical bands, cover bands, and in House DJ. ... as the music is •
designed to create ambiance and provide canned music or musical operations that compliment the
atmosphere for high class socialization, rather than a 'night club'." Dancing is proposed as indicated
on the attached Floor Plan; and
•
E-22
PLANNING COMMISSION RESOLUTION 11-27 •
ENTERTAINMENT PERMIT DRC2011-00158 - RA POUR
June 8, 2011
Page 2
3. Based upon the substantial evidence presented to this Commission during the above- •
referenced public hearing, and upon the specific findings of facts set forth in paragraphs 1 and 2
above, this Commission hereby finds and concludes as follows:
a. That the conduct of the establishment and the granting of the application would not
be contrary to the public health, safety, morals or welfare; and
b. That the premises or establishment is not likely to be operated in an illegal, improper
or disorderly manner; and
c. That the applicant, or any person associated with him as principal or partner or in a
position or capacity involving partial or total control over the conduct of the business for which such
permit is sought to be issued, has not been convicted in any court of competent jurisdiction of any
offense involving the presentation, exhibition, or performance of any obscene show of any kind or of
a felony or of any crime involving moral turpitude or has not had any approval, permit, or license
issued in conjunction with the sale of alcohol or the provisions of entertainment revoked within the
preceding five years.; and
d. That granting the application would not create a public nuisance; and
e. That the normal operation of the premises would not interfere with the peace and
quiet of the surrounding commercial center or adjacent apartment complex; and
f. That the applicant has not made any false, misleading, or fraudulent statement of •
material fact in the required application.
4. This action is within the scope of the project reviewed in an Environmental Impact
Report(EIR) (State Clearinghouse No. 20010301028) prepared for Development Agreement 01-02,
Victoria Community Plan Amendment 01-01, and Tentative Parcel Map SUBTPM15716. Said EIR
was certified by the City Council on February 20, 2002, and no additional environmental review for
the discretionary actions mentioned in this notice is required pursuant to Public Resources Code
Section 21166. The Planning Commission has reviewed the Planning Department's determination,
and based on its own independent judgment, concurs in the staffs determination.
5. Based upon the findings and conclusions set forth in paragraphs 1, 2, 3, and 4
above, this Commission hereby approves the application, subject to each and every condition set
forth below:
Planning Department
1) This approval is only for entertainment which may include"Jazz, acoustical
bands, cover bands, and in House DJ. with the music designed to create
ambiance and provide canned music or musical operations that
• compliment the atmosphere for high class socialization, rather than a'night
club'." Dancing is permitted only within the confines of the dance floor area
specified on the attached Floor Plan currently shown as 393 square feet.
Any change of intensity or type of entertainment shall require a modification
to this permit. •
E23
• PLANNING COMMISSION RESOLUTION 11-27
ENTERTAINMENT PERMIT DRC2011-00158 - RA POUR
June 8, 2011
Page 3
• 2) The days and hours of operation for the entertainment shall be limited to
11:00 a.m.to 2:00 a.m. Sunday through Saturday. Any expansion of days
and/or hours shall require modification to this permit.
3) No adult entertainment, as defined in the Rancho Cucamonga Municipal
Code, Section 17.04.090, shall be permitted.
4) Entertainment shall be conducted inside the building.
5) When entertainment is being conducted, doors and windows shall remain
closed for noise attenuation purposes.
6) Exterior noise levels shall not exceed 65 dB during the hours of 7 a.m. to
10 p.m. and 60 dB during the hours from 10 p.m. to 7 a.m.
7) Access to the lounge/entertainment area must be from the main entrance
to the primary use and not from a separate exterior entrance. Other exits
shall be for"Fire Exit Only."
8) If operation of this Entertainment Permit causes adverse effects upon
adjacent residences, businesses, or operations including, but not limited to
noise, loitering, parking, or disturbances, the Entertainment Permit shall be
• brought before the Planning Commission for consideration and possible
suspension or revocation of the permit.
9) Approval of this request shall not waive compliance with any sections of the
Development Code, State Fire Marshal's regulations, Uniform Building
Code, or any other City Ordinances.
10) This permit shall be renewed annually by the applicant per Municipal Code
Section 5.12.115.
11) A minimum of one duly licensed, certified or trained, and regularly
employed security guard from a reputable security firm shall be required to
be on the premises from 8:00 p.m. until the parking area on the west side
of the building is cleared after the conclusion of any entertainment. The
guard shall be in peace officer attire and shall remain on duty in the parking
area and outside adjacent areas of the facility to avert problems such as
loud noise, disorderly conduct from patrons or anyone in the parking lot,
loitering activities, and any other nuisances or disturbances.
12) The applicant shall agree to defend at his sole expense any action brought
against the City, its agents, officers, or employees, because of the
issuance of such approval, or in the alternative, to relinquish such
approval. The applicant shall reimburse the City, its agents, officers, or
employees, for any court costs and attorney's fees which the City, its
• agents, officers, or employees may be required by a court to pay as a result
of such action. The City may, at its sole discretion, participate at its own
E 24
PLANNING COMMISSION RESOLUTION 11-27
•
ENTERTAINMENT PERMIT DRC2011-00158 - RA POUR
June 8, 2011
Page 4
expense in the defense of any such action but such participation shall not •
relieve the applicant of his obligations under this condition.
13) The entertainment shall not be intensified without Planning Commission
review and approval. The restaurant shall operate and be maintained in
accordance with the Floor Plan as shown in the Staff Report for DRC2011-
00158 and as attached to this Resolution (Attachment A) and hereby
referenced in the Conditions of Approval.
14) Total occupancy of the restaurant including the exterior patio dining area
shall be limited to 283 persons including employees.
Security
1) Except in case of emergency, the licensee shall not permit its patrons to
enter or exit the licensed premises through any entrance/exit other than the
primary entrance/exit, excluding entrances/exits from patio areas. Steps
shall be taken by the licensee to discourage unauthorized exiting.
2) Any patron who (1) fights or challenges another person to fight, (2)
maliciously and willfully disturbs another person by loud or unreasoned
noise, or(3) uses offensive words which are inherently likely to provoke an
immediate violent reaction shall be removed from the premises. •
3) An incident log shall be maintained at the licensed premises on a continual
basis with at least one year of entries and be readily available for
inspection by a police officer. The log is for recording any physical
altercations, injuries, and objectionable conditions that constitute a
•
nuisance occurring in, on, or at the licensed premises, including the
immediately adjacent area that is owned, leased, or rented by the licensee.
The log will indicate date, time, description of incident, and action taken.
"Objectionable conditions that constitute a nuisance"means disturbance of
the peace, public drunkenness, drinking in public, harassment of
passersby, gambling, prostitution, loitering, public urination, lewd conduct,
drug trafficking, or excessive loud noise.
4) The City of Rancho Cucamonga Police Department may require State
licensed security guards to perform crowd control inside and outside of the
establishment, based upon the type of activities anticipated at the location
or based upon prior history of activity at this establishment or other similar
businesses.
5) Security personnel required by the entertainment permit issued for the
licensed premises shall be in a uniform or clothing which is readily
identifiable as a security person. They shall maintain order and enforce the
establishment's no loitering policy, and shall take "reasonable steps" (as
that term is defined in subparagraph (3) of Section 24200 of the California •
E-25
PLANNING COMMISSION RESOLUTION 11-27
ENTERTAINMENT PERMIT DRC2011-00158 - RA POUR
June 8, 2011
Page 5
• Business and Professions Code) to correct objectionable conditions that
constitute a nuisance.
6) The owner or manager of the licensed premises shall maintain on the
premises a written security policy and procedures manual addressing at a
minimum the following items: Handling obviously intoxicated persons;
establishing a reasonable ratio of employees to patrons, based upon
activity level, in order to monitor beverage sales and patron behavior;
handling patrons involved in fighting or arguing; handling loitering about the
building and in the immediate adjacent area that is owned, leased, rented
or used under agreement by the Licensee(s); verifying age/checking
identification of patrons; warning patrons of reaching their drinking
limit/potential intoxication and refusing to serve; calling the police regarding
observed or reported criminal activity.
7) Contract security services, proprietary security personnel, or personnel
assuming the functions typically associated with security shall be familiar
with establishments written security policy and procedures; by reviewing
them and signing they have read and understood the policy. The signed
acknowledgement shall be kept in file relating to the security manual.
8) Prior to utilizing a contract security guard company, the establishment shall
• verify the security company has a current City of Rancho Cucamonga
business license.
9) Install a closed circuit television system capable of readily identifying facial
features, and stature of all patrons entering the establishment during hours
of a nightclub type operation. Cameras are to be recorded and a minimum
30 day library of events shall be kept and available for inspection by the
City of Rancho Cucamonga Police Department.
10) The owner or manager of the licensed premises shall notify the City of
Rancho Cucamonga Police Department at least three(3) days in advance
of a special promotion or special event scheduled at the licensed premises.
Special promotion shall be defined as "an event expecting more than the
usual attendance which may create congestion in the parking lot(vehicles
and pedestrians) or large number of persons waiting to enter the
establishment." .
Fire District/Building & Safety Department
1) The maximum number of occupants shall not exceed building and fire
codes. The maximum occupancy for each room shall be posted as
determined by the Rancho Cucamonga Fire Protection District and/or the
City's Fire Prevention Unit Department.
• 2) Fire Standard Conditions are attached in document dated March 9, 2011.
E•26
PLANNING COMMISSION RESOLUTION 11-27
ENTERTAINMENT PERMIT DRC2011-00158 - RA POUR
June 8, 2011
Page 6
COMMERCIAL STANDARD CONDITIONS •
If construction will be proposed the following conditions will apply
A. General Requirements:
1. Submit five complete sets of plans including the following:
a. Site/Plot Plan;
b. Foundation Plan;
c. Floor Plan;
d. Ceiling and Roof Framing Plan;
• e. Electrical Plans (2 sets, detached) including the size of main
switch, number and size of service entrance conductors,
panel schedules, and single line diagrams;
f. Plumbing and Sewer Plans, including isometrics,
underground diagrams, water and waste diagram, sewer or
septic system location, fixture units, gas piping, and heating
and air conditioning; and
g. Planning Division Project Number (i.e., SUBTT, SUBTPM,
CUP, DRC, etc.) clearly identified on the outside of all plans.
2. Submit two sets of structural calculations, energy conservation •
calculations, and a soils report. Architect's/Engineer's stamp and
"wet" signature are required prior to plan check submittal.
3. Contractors must show proof of State and City licenses and Workers'
Compensation coverage to the City prior to permit issuance.
4. Separate permits are required for fencing and/or walls.
5. Business shall not open for operation prior to posting the Certificate
of Occupancy issued by the Building and Safety Division.
6. The building and site must comply with the disable access and facility
regulations of the 2010 CA Building Code (CBC)
B. Site Development:
1. Plans shall be submitted for plan check and approved prior to
construction. All plans shall be marked with the project file number
(i.e., DRC2003-00110 and SUBTPM16125). The applicant shall
•
comply with the latest adopted California Codes, and all other
applicable codes, ordinances, and regulations in effect at the time of
permit application. Contact the Building and Safety Division for
availability of the Code Adoption Ordinance and applicable handouts.
••
E-27
•
PLANNING COMMISSION RESOLUTION 11-27
ENTERTAINMENT PERMIT DRC2011-00158 - RA POUR
June 8, 2011
Page 7
•
• 2. Prior to issuance of building permits for a new commercial or
industrial development project or major addition, the applicant shall
pay development fees at the established rate. Such fees may
include, but are not limited to: City Beautification Fee, Park Fee,
Drainage Fee, Transportation Development Fee, Permit and Plan
Check Fees, and School Fees. Applicant shall provide a copy of the
school fees receipt to the Building and Safety Division prior to permit
issuance.
•
• 3. Construction activity shall not occur between the hours of 8:00 p.m.
and 6:30 a.m. Monday through Saturday, with no construction on
Sunday or holidays.
4. Construct trash enclosure(s) per City Standard (available at the
Planning Division's public counter).
C. New Structures:
1. Provide compliance with the California Building Code (CBC) for
property line clearances considering use, area, and fire-resistive
construction.
• 2. Provide compliance with the California Building Code for required
occupancy separations.
3. Openings in exterior walls shall be.protected in accordance with
CBC.
4. Upon plan review, additional requirements may be needed.
6. The Secretary to this Commission shall certify to the adoption of this Resolution.
APPROVED AND ADOPTED THIS 8th DAY OF JUNE 2011.
PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF RANCHO CUCAMONGA
BY:
Luis Munoz, Jr., Chairman
ATTEST:
James R. Troyer, AICP, Secretary
• I, James R. Troyer, AICP, Secretary of the Planning Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga,
do hereby certify that the foregoing Resolution was duly and regularly introduced, passed, and
E 28
PLANNING COMMISSION RESOLUTION 11-27
ENTERTAINMENT PERMIT DRC2011-00158 - RA POUR
June 8, 2011
Page 8
adopted by the Planning Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga, at a regular meeting of the •
Planning Commission held on the 8th day of June 2011, by the following vote-to-wit:
AYES: COMMISSIONERS:
NOES: COMMISSIONERS:
ABSENT: COMMISSIONERS:
ABSTAIN: COMMISSIONERS:
•
•
E-29
fr;,I; -a o f
siatIHid. 1 0 a e o 1 _..,: Q
aa2ucuuaS .,_,-, .:.- . -_.......,-
Sic q
s
� aG
d
\,
w„w 81*3
ln1Mje ��°c hrr--'�,y� ©- rf ran i,,.� j�`pig '�"..-ate
�'`II■r1Y�� ' ` �!T_IIID�I�1■�Y���IYY �IY��`��'1■IY��1�mn1�1'1�' g F ,I
p - OM 1 CAI1 I' �Vj. ft,
IP�jwmlltblclowIlll a IODialindinv ,
Illif rwrifir, ,, surdrim: (11,16. ! eri -- B: 6 .-
L _ , 0 .,: - . - _ 0 i alg I: K Lan L �.�\■■'! . 1•
0 �'= ✓ I f I SIEi___
_ c ii , �� ■\■il;1im■
s5 rp-g S m____�C B1•• 1 _ _ ::!57 —
0 fir' fi �IFa:.;: �:_ ;r;._.L�J
mill13 i;a0k , I� Dili 0,� E. =3
IF”: gpljAKitioa-- 1 V . . 10 „orr•fr-ii
weira-a_...... __ ___ , t2,
0 ff ,;_ tc __jog C Vii! �♦ i �� rlia
cail ktae)t so= ! ♦ ♦ ♦ '' MEN'■ Wit.
II ♦. • • !JL1j Is
il i, / :, on ` \'ail■
11 tit ' ■.1.11,"41 ,A la% HI
0 i i;;B§ II ---- - -ala--ra 9. . 1\ \ titcca 1 g
_-_- -__-.. •.r.• \ nit 0
�� _ r t - I
rep -rre.e• n — _,
Attachment A E-30
•
., Q�`a� p� ; , Rancho Cucamonga Fire Protection District
'� Fire Construction Services
• ` FIRE
REVIEW COMMENTS
Incompleteness
March 9, 2011
Ra Pour .
7900 Kew
PMT2011-00157, 158 & 182
Fire Construction Services has reviewed your plans submitted for: Conditional Use Permit (CUP),
Entertainment Permit (EP) & Minor Development Review (MDR). This project review was based on
the plans submitted which reflect an e new restaurant business in a building previously used as a restaurant.
The project has been determined to be incomplete because
1. The fire/water feature must be described in detail,
2. The outdoor dining area lack detail on the plans and
3. The scope of the entertainment was not defined on the plans.
When the above outstanding Fire District issues have been resolved, your project will be deemed complete by
the Fire District and with the approval from all of the other city departments;it may advance to the next step
in the process.
• Please revise the type of construction of the building a type "II c" is not a proper classification. The outdoor
patio area appears to have a large patio sliding door between the dining and patio; this door cannot be used as
required exit from the dining room to the patio. Please analyze the exit paths from the interior of the
restaurant to the required exit doors. Calculate the occupant load for all areas of the restaurant in accordance
with the 2010 CA Building Code. Indicate if the patio slider is new or existing. The rear exit door appears to
have an egress path requiring several directional exit signs and emergency illumination, please illustrate on the
plans the required exit signs.
If you have any questions please contact Moises Eskenazi, Senior Fire Plans Examiner at (909) 477-2710
Extension 4209 or at moises.eskenazi cr,citvofrc.us
•
E-31 •
/Re co�� e//y
•
0 .
EAT 'S R I r: K I L. ( :. I c. T E N Ei+'.5mmt. l
•
[ EAT ]
An inspired decadent dining experience: a unique multi-course
tasting menu that allows guests a personalized journey of modern
creations and traditional flavors. Pristine but not pretentious service
guides guests through a memorable evening of innovative fare.
[ DRINK ]
Small serving sizes presented as tasters with a variety of fresh herbs,
fruits and vegetables. as well as modern tools of liquid nitrogen and
organic emulsifiers to elevate the classics and re-imagine the modern
mainstays. Welcome the next generation of inspired cocktails.
[ LOUNGE j
The definitive gathering place for for those in-the-know. Featuring
a luxurious, sexy interior with a decidedly modernist decor, with
retractable glass garage doors, creating a seamless indoor/outdoor
feel. The kitchen is open and on display.
[ LISTEN
While dining/lounging guests experience live music and/or DJ's
playing pop, rock, rhythem and blues, and acid jazz. The sounds are
a seemless accompanyment to dining and lounge experience.
-/G
f
•
1':i P i' 1 Et 4alH V( i —:? l, ht; [ I t. iSTE S
. „ o-
[ EAT ]
Pecan crusted Sea Scallop on bed of spinach
Leg of lamb with cream sauce
Teriyaki Tri-tip
Shrimp and crab ceviche
Mini Crab cake with mango chutney
•
Calamari fries
Sweet potato gnocchi with cinnamon cream sauce
Oysters in the half shell
Pan seared Ahi tuna on field greens
Spicy lobster and cucumber salad
Macadamia nut crusted Mahi Mahi
Deep fried Salmon with spicy chili sauce
Chicken tour don blue
Flank steak
Turkey wrapped in bacon and collard greens
Mac n Cheese
Black eyed peas with ham and veggies
Crab and Cheese Stuffed mushrooms
Mini quiche Loraine
Mini quiche shrimp crab and spinach
Chicken with Artichoke and sundried tomatoes
Chicken sausage on sweet potato biscuit
Sausage and bell peppers on couscous
Jerk chicken wings
5 spice pork roast
Honey BBQ ribs
Chipotle BBQ ribs
Brick oven Pizza/ Flatbreads
Meat lovers' pizza
Vegetarian Pizza
Hawaiian Pizza
Artichoke and tomatoes with pesto Flatbread
Seafood flatbread with shrimp mussels crab spinach and sundried tomatoes
Create your own flatbread or pizza
Assorted sorbets
Chocolate Mouse
Fresh fruit and cream
Homemade ice cream of the day
Apple crisp
Chocolate cookie and brownie kabob
Assorted layered cookie bars
Parfait
Angel food cake with mixed berries
U' Cream cheese flan with caramel sauce
SIGN-IN SHEET
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING
June 8, 2011
NAME COMPANY " " ADDRESS
6.6.1-4> aaec/rAe-Aafre
C / 0 to
,C7€ 4O i %t71',