HomeMy WebLinkAboutPLANNING COMMISSION AGENDAS 10/22/2014__RESCANS HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
AND PLANNING COMMISSION
RANCHO MINUTES
CUCAMONGA
SEPTEMBER 24, 2014
Page 13
It is important to list your name, address and the agenda item letter your comments refer to. Comments are
generally limited to 5 minutes per individual.
If you wish to speak concerning an item not on the agenda, you may do so under"Public Comments." There is
opportunity to speak under this section prior to the end of the agenda.
Any handouts for the Planning Commission should be given to the Planning Commission Secretary for
distribution to the Commissioners. A copy of any such materials should also be provided to the Secretary to be
used for the official public record.
All requests for items to be placed on a Planning Commission agenda must be in writing. Requests for
scheduling agenda items will be at the discretion of the Commission and the Planning Director.
AVAILABILITY OF STAFF REPORTS
Copies of the staff reports or other documentation to each agenda item are on file in the offices of the Planning
. Department, City Hall, located at 10500 Civic Center Drive, Rancho Cucamonga, California 91730. These
documents are available for public inspections during regular business hours, Monday through Thursday, 7:00
a.m. to 6:00 p.m., except for legal City holidays.
APPEALS
Any interested party who disagrees with the City Planning Commission decision may appeal the Commission's
decision to the City Council within 10 calendar days. Any appeal filed must be directed to the City Clerk's Office
and must be accompanied by a fee of$2,486 for all decisions of the Commission. (Fees are established and
governed by the City Council).
Please turn off all cellular phones and pagers while the meeting is in session.
Copies of the Planning Commission agendas, staff reports and minutes can be found at
www.CityofRC.us
Item A-13
sjir
• .�
y�j,
40
,' .•� AK1 7,'
1 � iI.WM'� 4w t�'! S 4•r � � � � r
ug
lit
Zi•
_• t �v^ t. .j.
MINIM40
:
\`S y
v '
+
T:
' �b
4?- ter}��+IC,�1
t�'r:
w �
r
' 1
w. 4`
• �i
Aw
e
�i+Mill 4511; NTANA \i«:h_
• w
t
l i `
kv I
IT
190 Ale,
I' �
� e ,� i t � L o��Y ° ✓". .r � -•;gym •x .
; .<'Ywa�l ' .,'7• 'Y,IR •'\. '� � ,r� Jr"�'t•!Ifa �t sv � � �.'+NT � � !�•
AA
N _•' Al
zlor 4.
+'• v'►ft.�. �� s �'t � .r"...�Y/ MlMtta �,. + � '+x�� .x4fsWJI' [�• �•,,. ...
At
yk
• .��, , '` ► �,,,a..� ... 1 s. .tarty� _-a,�R�'^^— __ -._�r(.
t _
is' l ♦ l ' r
7140. 4aa .r
_ � r
40
`�� ��..• �- i .� �V,L� ��5.�nl � fir y 'n
�•,�'• ,'� •�t{'�y f•i �F c } � II',if
r t t LI int '��^44 I.f
�I ,: tI •f i, •v f
I r.4-
� • II i\i I.{{aa�� F�f•'�1 •
dF
'•rv.'h_ a/ �� �i 07
� k
3
.Y: y', 4 1+ �'�. ' `�• ,.fir. ... - ��
vp
+ y 'T ,fy\'a� ♦. ..t �7 . y r 5 t.t�s�t r. y h
�� •. � f` .yam -
;r
r #,. • '. k.' �� ` :� .;..
ems: rsnti ¢ `~' y ; ' � �� • :s- �1 � �' r i• y y ;R ° "
tf-
Mn•n .r ., r - Sjc {�. ... �+'r h ��i�, . +�, ✓��� � '•�.�.rt • ' � •,Wr+t�"`�a � w �A
$ 4
T
•b, s
w
'� +; •• .. '{'�'f,,h t `_ •',f•.! 1 `. )•t►�. ` , ,•gyp ,{�,� ; •l,�'+ �i r"r'; �} '� R
.<. , y/• ...•T• ...'nrr..`!!►, -ti.fir�,�:.. � „• K'���4 ', a.,�•, a'R�` '� .�,•� ��
y-•i� y , r Ili:R������• ,►a. •. ` �.♦ `.,wl�yF�,/+rr �� T. �`� \� ��..y� • �` ,� � ' �
♦tj/',~,.. .fir• , �R'• .�.�?}r yam.• "' ^, Y•. �. y '�� �. •I►� h*y, S�\� �'S•�..•r' •�. �. - - � •••t
''��'.�'� t '• "Il♦ l'-�- `�' } �'•!, .�•�, ;.. 'n 1 :�j••�.a tl� ''t. •,;, y„_ `s�,,. •M ^ '� 1
�t"' .e7 �, •�.�,�t•. ,�•*�., �►.Q �• � �11`!�; � � k y+'♦ ;�'Y ti�'.,1'.. I' �z r .. � �`:h a - y' -
�T -' ; ' " � gid' ,• y♦ tit •�� i. � '��i'1 �I ��' / f `*.�� � ^• ���t _✓� .�.
. .�`�'9k• ��• fa� It r •v �'rer^►11�ti� �s• � � '� ' .,�`1�'t�,�J�+ p .9 la
*' � v . � ��•�ti+;�� .�.Y •'r• :� w'1�,7 t fit���li 7 j�o 'r , r `�d��� ,� ' 7�
T
of
ar
'*M"
it
.. :. •R�i� 'L�: , l �J;�� �. l :It'. '"+,d
91 'A,
ii-41
'a ,,� � !R'► t'.R%�.,+,.2�+�7••�„�-.�7 ' �`/ •• I �' .� r, Y 11� .• �'• ,�'' 'T� �,� k ' �,s , _�• tl
41
�� . ` Ikr•'�1,i a r , \,•f{ '� !fir' ,����t . ar ..t •� A t +r „• i
,
�!. -
+Far y' r',t�17: r�' 1•;VM� ,.�r ��L�y 1 �► t':f'ir.. ,,.,9� 4 rl
•r xt /`' Y/ ;`�r �^ �( � '•� r ''• � r! �•,r r �j, r',+' I�r S T rr. r.,fR1 1-1-41
^.
' wt' ,� y
Ot'- 1. . +;t 1 f1`` y }f , ' .IiTJ' ► .. � ,,•t�',�
• gip% ', '* ',, .����' Y''9 v.' . � r,,`. �•'' �� 1 d� •`�'i;'' ;� .t '= +
-y"'r qtr^' • 4� JY'f '�� J ♦,/„7, ��rj� ' � L / 1,� �1� p�,•� `r��r..�.; .•1� 7 r � � r d
� : .� s.� •! .. .•f ,�SR�1 t ;; ,.� 7� / :'C�,�' '.• ���,. �A4 iI e � ^` .�, moi' �t}eF/R,r' s A� ., .• +. � '9�
�� r �� a' ,• f rytrJ rJ ��{r '�
4 ,y`yj �A+ its
��??
? ._ •� �' t. '• ' r(• •tee: �{ � , •�, y. y��✓ r�
•♦ r 9 ' I;t �9 __ w , a�•• t '. �T Ir..F�/ ��,�\�p•"�' •t..��' �•�!ir 7r,� ,• re R,_ r” .t r
�Y I. 'I {' « �•:,. r• �' �i1i��'►� �wtti�A1 IL +
ao s
,. +' ,f:� � t r• ,,�• '+ �' �; 1 � ��,�' -I ^ r. elf '�1•�.,� � ,, •+ . •l �•�, , � �"r
'� � r ` fl+./ �+{�'! ,r ' Fi�. '1 � 7r. . �•1A.A�" •Y a�",'�/ l ', f. - ��r +�A 1 e
• � ` � r � '�' �•`)'' � J r v�r���!/{t�l • t '�'•'• 6,' .�'� bet
,• �./ • � �",I( ' '�, RJt.' "1 �'�'' �r��.� �',1 �'�}71f�•'• ../It.. ,� t (��W,(!,� , r" •a.jfi,.",
*. '/►17.r• •"'�. � ,t _r .r
AV� a .L "7d1.h \1�V... �" t' *71Rwe� l�iSr.•�a`!!�' rt-
�•�R.� ���3�����►►^�MAMA�"11!!*. 2 l fir ►y�T' l ��� r+P_'/�`, �♦ fir+
« � �' � , t,�y `77.""' •����•,�-. • +�� "'w l.*•.4•/iT S.�s. 1_ftJlL i1 y 'j��,t �'1�`(J y'
i :i�R # 1.rr;✓`, �► 'S'u x1 SY. •'+++ " • a ar 1 j�..^ni. �•' r F
ON,
' •-,�" 't. ��•,� de,r• ,{ �..t% � � � i tc \ •r..'� wl- 1'h~,r r"• ,Mid
Ar
iV- e- �.. f , - «' �: 1`rF✓•`'',��'�r►' �.r. ♦:.�- �r'�-'L !'" :ii' err « '6
' ^,A *. .1. +++�., t .w i 'Y�' dear. � �y� ��y � r•� "T`�� �y,�
'.^r.., + �' i P��! . � a'e�y S ��,la f y a 1R• fy"jt�r , �+�"' i
v \ 4
� i►*w. s i. s 4 9 4 � d - Ji t�'t '�s •jYJd s�.m 9 Q
All-
lop
R .
r;
Y
r,W�LM.
Foot . o
Foothill Blvd Foothill Blvd
.r .
.r
o�thi f I BYvd
.I
JIM ti r✓
I� _mil � _�•y^��„ !ur, ,��
.W 4.
Ham shir a _
'
�!�' rte' L
> n �`
a fp
-
r
4-0
.0 'm ILI
Wp
�� IA I,. 1► °��
ALA—
v
r,.,ca .
Ad
..
i
i
� W
r s � ss
Rp
Ir
, 1• a• s •
� si. �a• ss �� �-
IL
�aistti+tsiit~
i i t f•e*ifi•i'[i a Ee[•
•t •• 1
i • it a• s■ ii f
t
rsi 4ss • ra
� a`i •i.a 3a s�1
� a s s �►s
i a S �
1i•s•s to 4 /.
a 419"*♦a tiit•T0�4•
i t
4#44,4•iia t
'as si •• ,�
i 4! t 1� iif
as r. s u
•s s -
••a�a
,�as •r s
saga it aGoss -
Mile ..
ss •*�ilyriisttssl
�sti�aa � rt if ii ti ''
is�t
! st fire•4r a• � �,
� 4 �• . � a••ltaa�i• N
•ta�t� at• ♦• t4 � � •
f t 1 gas as I o
a!!
41 s .
tai �• atap.aa �
stta• �,� •t• #•
Li
aa�a•rt�ssl .e
me !i i •�4�� I i \ �� s
•• 't !
JLA
r ;a •4 4 1
t � • •1•Nf - •• •* i• 4�� i"4 sr C M� ar
4i ••i�F " iia! • �
•• • •i I• • • a� •i SIR •i4!• .6
• • • • `• a `: i i �*•�! s • �itr � I
• • • * • - � .its � �•
�
•* a• • a� 4 goes w7
s • •�� • •il
i 1•
a• a !
04 •4"A 4 !
so"" 0 10006
s • aiih • •4aI�. ;tt *g •� �� !3 I•
�a• •�!.
a• • •/• s•`*• 0
0040 9
4!!• t a . . ati iso 90,1664161:11 a
r •tos 0 0009Ir04
oil *00 0,091 99of 10 a i
? ? •4M�0 ii ' • eggs i►4• 000.09 4 • 1
? C !1 a • • t •Nrf�rosr •
! • **IRS
♦�a �4•� I a • 4604�I• i ••! s
.060000 a•!• 0a&.&AMAb
�{• Y
1•
F"
�' �ta PY gin, - - •'3 0,..
-.S
C— F
V.
�J
r
u
ti
s
f
- i -
pp;
I
!
a
• r,::,;'
t,
_ r
,. , CHO
s
Project Location
Im" VIA L•A DERA-,.. -I �`', •. ' ,�.u. �_ 1 i:. 1.. ° ;
lriArAfR 'SA
Lu
061 _
�7q QIN
r slit yi �
40A >F — CAtCE DE P C
ji
_ _ a
s a
RutJ.w �
� �.� _� y,.. a et •r t;� �, —,r fi �yu yis „>y�`i'i.y},�mti I.l a war y
Q 5 }y S 41".i}CA
RU `i •�@I}' to .�. �'ir
C1
October2014
r
Proposal
--------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------------------- 3
r y . — — •— — —_-_-I— is -a d'�
• Tentative Tract Map: Subdivision of 1 .02-acre parcel for purposes of constructing
an 8-unit townhouse development
• Design Review: 8-unit townhouse development along south side of property
o Three bedrooms, two stories, garage for each unit
o Open private/common space proposed: open lawn area, tot lot play area, and
barbecue/picnic area
o Private landscaped front lawn area for each unit (298 square feet)
• Tree Removal: A request to remove 9 heritage trees
October 8, 2014
Typical Floor Plan
--------------------------------------------- 4
4,1V
inlr _ _ M M. • -
m
rvwew {III' ,II1nII11
� I
♦ ' I + _
Ir ♦ !111.1-
,�
eDi� �• - t -_
� .n-1 � O ann _• _
w
L
• hi
-1 �_ r•.o1®1..��_.1.BY0•,rA1T 1,... —
fN•K !rW rIC/0I rrr�.rNiI�011
II M M � � II GYOd1�f�\Ir.M�•d11� N !_r fr __rV_�j�
--
+
nmr-�.a.u�ar wrNm.r.rl
SECOND FLUOR FIRST FLOOR
(INTERIOR UNIT 2,4.6) (INTERIOR UNIT 2,4,6)
DOd1 efJ1F0111!(fCe,1p cow �W 11 NNA V W'rl 1 tl
October a 2014
Elevations
-----------
1�
r
i
SOUTH ELEVATION-LOOKING NORTH WEST ELEVATION-LOOKING EAST
Unit#1-Model'A
sdk r.r o- Unit#1-Model'A
soak 1M'•.r.o-
Lm
EAST ELEVATION-LOOKING WEST NORTH ELEVATION-LOOKING SOUTH
Unit#1 Model'A
scah gyp-.r.o•• U I"Nt#1-Model'A
Soak lx.,1.a..
Parking
----- --------------- --- --- 6
------------------- -------------------------------------------- ------------------------
-----------------------
2 spaces per unit ` • Each unit has a 2 car garage
Visitor parking — 1 per 3 units • Garages were set back 19 feet
r
�7
Oc toberi
Nei h boyhood Meeti n
g g
O
Held on December 12 ,
2public
013
No attendance from
sir
Email received from
resident on February
- .
j"
• 2014 — concern
with traffic safety and
access • project site
� J
October $, 2014
Studies Provided
------------------- ._. - ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------8
• Acoustical Analysis
F -
• Arborist Report �., u
• Cultural Resources Assessment
Rd _ -
• GHG/ Air Quality
* Included noise conditions and I �,
construction methods to project to reduce
noise issues related to project ~-
i.e. - STC glazing to all windows and doors Noise Contours
for Units 9 and 2, cement block perimeter 70 dBACNEL
wall, specific wall construction for unit-to- 65 dBA CNEL
unit noise 60 dBA CNEL
i 55 dBA CNEL
Tree Removal Permit DRC2013-00825
--------------------------------------------------- -------------------- ---------------------------------------------------------------- ------------------------
r-
TREr E
NWA
--K
# I R".0EE
US, MEE Is
PEbKm l
(t MEE If
MEE.
ROP)VE6 M e28
REYOY� F'�v I,
lQ�"�l� REYOHE I -_ IwEE�I
l y�•• �n, t�l� �Q� _ 1 'TREE 7E 11EypyE
1 .,. ` iPtk E l I1lEfi tI MEEE�J rPEE ii 04L
REYO�F RErOVE ;_l 8111011E ___ RFS-0E NCF •-'' r
`yr1 •I• TPifi t}��•SE. TRFF U �TR1E1Ep�H
W
4� �fONCRCiC I ' t tI
$�\ t REIION[ (4„L
1 MEE 17 FREE 77 COPCPEiC iPEMOY� u �f RfE�O
{ TREE 1 NEUONF ��� N 1+ REF II i
` ;•[7'� TREE I '< '--"i
[` 1. tREF 1� d� �j
T .'.{t e Z.ILL.III TREE 10 'E`� [t•(f Mff A IREE 77 MEE 77 `
t 1R[E E '1, RfER7v4.(v7 -`t"5 , y RE7 W I.EChlow �E TREE 77 VW 7�i___ -00 -' `TOME�-._ �•
�._ _ ,�� I 4 �E11 �u 2, .•-" � AP L�� - �
`— - - -- - _ REE►_bt� _ r.] �y rte. �nti TPfE 7t �O .I J {/�(��''3�� 4' =
•REEP�—�V��hwY TREE 7E l7 a •,-. .. . -7lRR!
• 41 trees existing on-site
• 11 trees are considered to be Heritage Trees
• of the 11 heritage trees, 9 are proposed for removal
• Requesting to remove 34 trees total as part of project
• Replace at 1 to 1 ratio
• Landscape plans show total of 56 trees on-site
October 8, 2014
I
Committees
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
10 --------------------------
I" .
• Grading and Technical Review Committees: June 17, 201t
• Design Review Committee: June 17, 2014
• Design Review Committee: September 2, 2014
At
U J 14
UNIT # 3 UNIT # 4 UNIT # 5
(MODEL 'B') (MODEL 'G')
October2014