The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About2019-07-02 DRC AgendaI’ JULY 2,2019 -7:00 P.M. DESIGN REVIEW CoMMITTEE AGENDA RAINS ROOM CITY HALL 10500 CIVIC CENTER DRIVE A.CALL TO ORDER I Roll Call:Ray Wimberly Tony M.Guglielmo Elisa Cox Mike Smith Alternates:Lou Munoz Francisco Oaxaca B.PUBLIC COMMUNICATIONS I This is the time and place for the general public to address the Committee on any item listed on the agenda.State law prohibits the Committee from addressing any issue not previously included on the Agenda.The Committee may receive testimony and set the matter for a subsequent meeting. Comments are to be limited to five minutes per individual or less,as deemed necessary by the Staff Coordinator,depending upon the number of individuals members of the audience. This is a professional businessmeeting and courtesy and decorum are expected.Please refrain from any debate between audience and speaker,making loud noises or engaging in any activity which might be disruptive to the decorum of the meeting. I C.PROJECT REVIEW ITEMS I The following items will be presented by the applicant andlor their representatives.Each presentation and resulting period of Committee comment is limited to 20 minutes.Following each presentation,the Committee will address major issues and make recommendations with respect to the project proposal.The Design Review Committee acts as an advisory Committee to the Planning Commission.Their recommendations will be forwarded to the Planning Commission as applicable.The following items do not legally require any public testimony, although the Committee may open the meeting for public input Cl.COURTESY REVIEW DRC2O1 9-00475 —PAUL MUKAI -A request to replace an existing composition shingle roof with a standing seam metal roof,on an existing single-family residence within the Low (L)Residential District,located at 7874 Buena Vista Drive.This item is exempt Page 1 of 2 —CrCrr~C((Cf r ,r 1r JULY22019-7:OOP.M. DESIGN REVIEW C0MMrrrEE AGENDA RAINS ROOM Crr~HALL 10500 Civic CENTER DRIVE from the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA)and the City’s CEQA guidelines under CEQA Section 15301 —Existing Facilities. I D.ADJOURNMENT I The Design Review Committee has adopted Administrative Regulations that set an 11:00 p.m. adjournment time.If items go beyond that time,they shall be heard only with the consent of the Committee. I,Valerie Victorino,Executive Assistant,of the City of Rancho Cucamonga,or my designee, hereby certify that a true,accurate copy of the foregoing agenda was posted on Thursday,June 27,2019 at least seventy two (72)hours prior to the meeting per Government Code 54954.2 at 10500 Civic Center Drive,Rancho Cucamonga,CA. ~If you need special assistance or accommodations to participate in this meeting, please contact the Planning Department at (909)477-2750.Notification of 48 hours prior to the meeting will enable the City to make reasonable arrangements to ensure accessibility Listening devices are available for the hearing impaired. Page 2 of 2 DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS 7:00 p.m.Sijifredo Fernandez July 2,2019 COURTESY REVIEW DRC2019-00475 —PAUL MUKAI -A request to replace an existing composition shingle roof with a standing seam metal roof,on an existing single-family residence within the Low (L)Residential District,located at 7874 Buena Vista Drive.This item is exempt from the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA)and the City’s CEQA guidelines under CEQA Section 15301 —Existing Facilities. Site Characteristics:The project site is residential property located at 7874 Buena Vista Drive within the Low (L)Residential District and the Hillside Overlay District.The location of the site is within an area of the City that is referred to as “Red Hill”.The property is improved with a one- story single-family residence of about 2,800 square feet.Due to the street layout at the subject location,the house is bound on the east and west by Buena Vista Drive and Calle Casino (respectively),and on the south by the intersection of these streets.To the north and east are single-family residences.To the west and southwest of the site is the Red Hill Country Club Golf Course. Proiect Overview:The applicant,on behalf of the homeowners,is requesting to replace the composition shingle roof of his clients’residence with a metal roof.At the time of this report,the shingle roof had been removed.The metal roof will be a standing seam panel system. Standing seam roofing is defined as a concealed fastener metal panel system that features panels with vertical fins and a wide,flat area between the two fins.It’s also described as having raised seams,or vertical legs,that rise above the level of the panel’s flat area.The color of the proposed standing seam metal roof will be keystone grey (as shown in the attached exhibits). The homeowners are requesting a metal roof to enhance the appearance of the house and to facilitate drainage of the rainwater that is currently collecting on the due shallow pitch of the house. Regulatory Background:Per Section 17.36.010(F)of the Development Code “all existing development within Residential Zoning Districts shall have roofing material made of tile,or the imitation thereof,but not including composition shingles.Other roofing materials such as metal,slate,or the imitation thereof,but not including composition shingles,may be approved by the approval authority if it is determined that the roof material enhances the building design.Any replacement of existing roofing materials shall be consistent with the existing material or upgraded to a higher quality roofing material.For example,a composition shingle roof can be replaced with composition shingles or can be upgraded to higher quality roofing material such as tile or slate.” Metal roofing is sometimes used in commercial and industrial applications (in the City).Such roofing material on houses (in the City)are not common.And requests for installing metal roofing as a re-roofing solution are rare.The design of them can vary,as well.Staff forwards such requests,when they occur,to the Design Review Committee for their review and consideration.The most recent request was for a metal roof system that had panels with a granular texture that was non-reflective.As a result,the panels appear like a typical tile roof. The Committee approved this request.However,the Committee indicated to Staff that they wanted to continue to review proposals for metal roofing (unless they were similar to that which they had just approved). DRC COMMENTS COURTESY REVIEW DRC2O19-00475 -PAUL MUKAI July 2,2019 Page 2 Staff Comments The architecture and typology of the houses in the Red Hill neighborhood is eclectic.They were constructed over a broad timeframe that reflects the changes in technology,favored architectural style,or a homeowner’s personal taste.There is no established architectural theme that is required for new houses in Red Hill.The proposed residence has a California Ranch design theme which is characterized by a single story,generally rectangular floor plan and,often,a low-pitched roof. Due to the eclectic architecture and typology,and the low pitch of the roof,Staff supports use of a metal roofing material.Furthermore,the low roof renders other roofing material impractical. The design of the roofing system will be architectural compatible with the design of the house and the neighborhood nor negatively affect the neighborhood.The proposed color,keystone grey,is compatible with the colors used on houses elsewhere in the neighborhood. Staff Recommendation:Staff recommends that the Committee approve the design of the metal roofing material as a replacement for the roofing material that was previously on the subject house. Staff Planner Sijifredo Fernandez,Contract Planner Staff Coordinator:Mike Smith,Principal Planner S 0 kdifteduraUsb~iral staridln9 seam roof panel 0PanelCoverage:l2”16”orlB” 0’RlbHelghtl4/4” 0 Gauges:26 ga.and 24 ga.standard,22 ga.optional 0 Snap-together panel system with fadory-appiled side lap sealant 0 Mlnfrnum roof alopeoveropenframln9 3:12 0 Mkihnum roof slope over solid substrate 1:12 0’Concealed dip designed for unlimited thermal movement 0 Accommodates up to4”blanket insulation 0’Finishes:PVDF,MSColocfast45’andAuyilctoatedGalvalumt 0’Contact Metal Sales for load-carrying capabilities V~:i S~;irii His >Ill.263,FIt Rai~s*ioe RiSig -pa eesr~ >IA 580,Can 90 Mid Ur4fi,Cauerdmi,~54,~5,261,303,34Z 343, 436,445,446,447,445.508 ad SCM UL790,classAFi.Rss~ics Rdrg -pa nu.ty V’UL2216.Qass 4 krQedRaWaroe D’ASmEl5e2RoorLkIft >ASINE1S45WWPGMSI*m >AsuIEle60AkLiaage >kbThOa CairdyA~powd,NOA 130906.05 >Tot.D.~I,.,4dwsxwa Evahia*n Rapod.RC-412 >icc Evab~i Rscot ESR-2385 D’2Ol4FSCApprowd -26gt obaitrpWxd.11560.12 ~ir Pnq -24 go.ova It?F~od,11560.l0(lrPnq -24ga.ova Ii?P~’wood,11560,11 (i&Panic -0.03?Mr*uii ova 7115’058,146451(15’Panic -0.03?Mfloii ova If?Plywood,14645.7(15’P.4 0 kthfteduratlstudural Integral standing itb roof system 0’Snap-together panel system 016”panel coverage,major rib:8”centers,1.5/8”rib height 0’Gauges:26 ga,24 ga.standard,arid 22 ga optional 0’Mlnhnum roof slope:1:12 0’Applies over open framing or solid substrate 0’Concealed dip designed for thermal movement 0’Accommodates up to4’blanket insulation 0’Finishes:PVDF and Acrylic Coated Galvalume’ 0’Coated Metal Sales for bad-carrying capabilities >Ul,flFfreB~al...Rflq-perasa >UL5WGm90MdU*Ca~%I588ad556A >1L790,CImAFflRWIIWC.Ratq-paaSefftly >Lii.1887,UpinTa lot Root CoverIng Spars I>Ui~la,t~ass 4 In’ød Reebw~e >ASTME 1502 Root L$ft >A8Th4 E 1560 Ak Lidroge >ict Ewdra5on Rscort ESR.2385 1216”onlB”Coversge 0’Square Batten Cap option for Vertical Seam Panel 0’AvaIlable at the Fontana Branch only 1-5/5’r-i 1.7/sf 1r~1rulrCoverage 12’j6”ortO”Coverage 1-3/4fh -3/4”~ ~rw~/iA 1-51rL .. 16”Coverage fri 800.406.7387 metal sales.us.corn -- Sr’ 2”- ~4f—:5,/‘3 K RI (5~t)ØZ-t39 f13KL11 -~gi’(sisdA Qj5tPs V’~ 1 1~o