Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2007/04/25 - Agenda Packet • THE CITY OF RANCHO CUCAMONGA HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION AGENDA APRIL 25, 2007 - 7:00 PM Rancho Cucamonga Civic Center Council Chambers 10500 Civic Center Drive Rancho Cucamonga, California • • I. CALL TO ORDER Pledge of Allegiance Roll Call Chairman Stewart Vice Chairman Fletcher Macias _ Vacant Munoz _ II. ANNOUNCEMENTS III. APPROVAL OF MINUTES Regular meeting minutes of April 11, 2007 ~~ IV. PUBLIC HEARINGS ~~ The following items are public hearings in which concerned individuals may voice their opinion of the related project Please wait to be recognized by the Chairman and address the Commission by stating your name and address All such opinions shall be limited to 5 minutes per indrvidual for each project Please sign in after speak-ng A LANDMARK DESIGNATION DRC2005-00776 -ROBERT BATHISH - A request to designate the Roberds House as a Designated Local Landmark located at 7201 Amethyst Street - APN~ 0202-161-04 Related File Mills Act Agreement DRC2007-00173 and Non Construction CUP DRC2007-00159 This action is categorically exempt per Section 15331 as a Class 31 exemption of the California Environmental Quality Act Guidelines (Historical resource restoration/rehabilitation) HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION AGENDA APRIL 25, 2007 Page 2 B MILLS ACT APPLICATION DRC2007-00173-ROBERT BATHISH- A request to implement the use of the Mills Act to reduce property tax for the Roberds House, currently applying for Historic Landmark Status, located at 7201 Amethyst Street - APN 0202-161-04 Related file Landmark Designation DRC 2005-00776 and Non Construction CUP DRC2007-00159 ~~ V. NEW BUSINESS ~~ C REQUEST TO INITIATE THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION ORDINANCE AND AMENDING THE MUNICIPAL CODE THEREOF FOR THE PURPOSE OF UPDATING THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION ORDINANCE TO INCLUDE LANGUAGE TO CREATE HISTORIC DISTRICTS AND TO BE CONSISTENT WITH CURRENT CASE LAW AND CONFORMANCE WITH STATE LAW AND FEDERAL LAW ~~ VI. DIRECTOR'S REPORTS ~~ D UPDATE TO THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION REGARDING THE PLAQUE AND MAILBOX PROGRAM. ~~ VII. PUBLIC COMMENTS ~~ This is the time and place for fhe general public to address the commission Items to be discussed here are those that do not already appear on this agenda ~~ VIII. COMMISSION BUSINESS/COMMENTS ~~ ~~ IX. ADJOURNMENT ~~ 1, Lois J Schrader, Planning Commission Secretary of the City of Rancho Cucamonga, or my designee, hereby certify that a true, accurate copy of the foregoing agenda was posted on Apnl 19, 2007, at least 72 hours pnor to the meeting per Government Code Section 54964 2 at 10500 Civic Center Dnve, Rancho Cucamonga, • //~ • HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION AGENDA APRIL 25, 2007 Page 3 Please turn off all cellular phones and pagers while the meeting is in session Copies of the Planning Commission agendas and minutes can be found at http://www ci.rancho-cucamonga.ca.us • Vicinity Map ~ Historic Preservation Commission April 25, 2007 ~ Meeting Location: N City Hall 10500 Civic Center Drive . '~ , °~ ~, • ~~ ~ ~~ ~..~.~~ - ~ ~ -~ 4_ T H E C I T Y O F RANCfiO CUCAMONGA Stiff Report DATE: April 25, 2007 TO: Chairman and Members of the Historic Preservation Commission FROM: James R. Troyer, AICP, Planning Director BY Pei-Ming Chou, Associate Planner SUBJECT: LANDMARK DESIGNATION DRC2005-00776 -ROBERT BATHISH - A request to designate the Roberds House as a Designated Local Landmark, located at 7201 Amethyst Street - APN: 202-161-04. Related File Mills Act Agreement DRC2007-00173 and Non Construction Conditional Use Permit DRC2007-00159. This action is categorically exempt per Section 15331 as a Class 31 exemption of the California Environmental Quality Act Guidelines (Historical Resource Restoration/Rehabilitation). • MILLS ACT APPLICATION DRC2007-00173-ROBERT BATHISH- A request to implement the use of the Mills Act to reduce property tax for the Roberds House, currently applying for Historic Landmark Status, located at 7201 Amethyst Street - APN~ 020216104. Related file: Landmark Designation DRC2005-00776 and Non Construction Conditional Use Permit DRC2007-00159 BACKGROUND In 1998, the Planning Department presented a proposal to designate the Roberds House as a landmark to the Historic Preservation Commission. The Roberds House was selected from a list of potential landmarks as a part of the City's program to designate landmarks and Points of Historic Interest. At the July 7, 1988 Historic Preservation Commission hearing, the Roberds family opposed the designation for a number of reasons and the designation was reduced to a Point of Historic Interest. The City Council approved the Point of Historic Interest designation on August 17, 1988. In 2005, following a request by Chris Nichols, a resident of 9532 Roberts Court, the Planning Department presented a second request to initiate an application to designate the Roberds House as a local landmark at the September 21, 2005, City Counal meeting The designation was initially postponed by Robert Bathish, the current owner of the Roberds House, while he pursued land use options for the property However, after various discussions with the Planning Department regarding possible uses allowed, Mr. Bathish is now requesting a landmark designation and a Mills Act contract on the property. ANALYSIS A. Historical Significance: The Roberds House was constructed circa 1910 as the Nazarene • Church on a site approximately one mile southeast of its present site on the west side of Archibald Avenue. In the early 1920s, Harry and Rilla Roberds purchased the structure ITEM A & B HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION STAFF REPORT DRC2005-00776 - ROBERDS HOUSE April 25, 2007 • Page 2 and moved it to the current location on Amethyst Avenue. At that time, extensive renovations were done to convert the structure from a church into a residence The Roberds House is an early example of adaptive reuse. The Roberds family once owned most of the land south of the Pacific Electric Railroad tracks down to Base Line Road on both sides of Amethyst Avenue. Harry Roberds came to California with his family for his father's health and worked in the first packing house in Cucamonga In 1913, he married Rilla Stephens, daughter of Douglas W Stephens, a pioneer vinyardist of Cucamonga The Roberds built the first house in the town of Alta Loma on the east side of Amethyst Avenue After the birth of their son, the Roberds moved the original house farther south, bought the Nazarene Church, moved it to the location of the original house on Amethyst Avenue, and remodeled the church into a residence The large shed-roofed dormers, roof deck, and pergola were added at the time of conversion. In 1920, the Fire Department was created and the Roberds' telephone was used whenever there was a fire. B. Site Characteristics• The Roberds House site is an L-shaped parcel approximately 0 93 acre in size and is located on the east side of Amethyst Avenue, immediately south of the Pacific Electric Railroad tracks and the Water District storage tanks. The site is zoned Medium-High Density Residential (14-24 dwelling units per acre) and is designated General Commercial (GC) under the General Plan. C Architectural Description The Roberds House is a one and one-half story Craftsman • bungalow with clapboard exterior walls The large, medium-pitched composite shingled roof features one large, centrally located shed roof dormer on each side. The porch is supported by large concrete columns and features decorative king post trussing The interior of the house retains its original 1920s paneled doors, molded pine door and window trim, chair and plate rails, oak and pine floorings, and pressed-tin ceiling The house also features original built-in cabinets typical of Craftsman bungalows. A two-bay garage with vertical wood sidings and a gable roof sits to the northeast of the house Immediately adjacent to the rear of the house is a small wood shed. The lower portions of the walls are wood sided while the upper portion is screened in. The shed appears to have been used as a wash house but the original function of the house is unknown. Amore in-depth description is attached (Exhibit D). D Landmark Designation: The subject site qualifies for landmark designation based upon much of the criteria from the City's Historic Preservation Ordinance, including such significant areas as historical, cultural, neighborhood, and geographic setting. Details concerning these areas of significance are contained m the Facts for Findings section The requested designation is for a structure that is greater than 50 years in age. The purpose of the designation is to preserve, protect, enhance, and perpetuate a significant feature that contributes to the cultural and aesthetic benefit of Rancho Cucamonga. E. Mills Act Agreement: In accordance with City policy, the owner has requested a Mills Act Agreement. The Agreement Schedule List of Improvements has been drafted and reviewed and is attached for reference (Exhibit C). A & B 2 HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION STAFF REPORT DRC2005-00776 - ROBERDS HOUSE • April 25, 2007 Page 3 The concept of the Mills Act program is to provide an incentive for the property owner to protect and preserve the property by retaining its characteristics of historical significance. This intent is encouraged through the reduction of property taxes, thus enabling the property owner to reinvest the money saved from the reduced property tax on the improvements. The properties that enter into the agreement are to be inspected by City staff on an annual basis to determine whether notable progress has been made in rehabilitating the property. Staff estimates the property tax savings to the owner could be as much as $3,130 per year. The exact amounts are dependent upon the County's Assessor's property valuation, which is based on income potential and capitalization rate at the time of the assessment. F. Environmental Assessment: The project is categorically exempt under Section 15331 as a Class 31 exemption of the guidelines for the California Environmental Quality Act. FACTS FOR FINDING: A. Historical and Cultural Significance• Finding 1. The proposed Landmark is particularly representative of an historic period, type, style, region, or way of life • Facts The Roberds House is representative of the Craftsman Bungalow It is also an early example of adaptive reuse Finding 2 The proposed Landmark is of greater age than most of its kind. Facts: The Roberds House was originally constructed circa 1910 as the Nazarene Church. Circa 1920, the house was converted into a residence. Finding 3' The proposed Landmark was connected with someone renowned or important or a local personality Facts: The Roberds House is connected with the Roberds family. Harry Roberds built the first house in the Alta Loma townsite. Rilla Roberds is the daughter of Douglas W. Stephens, a Cucamonga pioneer. B. Neighborhood and Geographic Setting: Finding 1: The proposed Landmark materially benefits the historic character of the neighborhood. Facts• The Roberds House is one of the few remaining historic buildings representing Old Alta Loma. As the first house built it the Alta Loma townsite, it was along with the construction of the rail, the catalyst for the development of Alta Loma. Finding 2: The proposed Landmark in its location represents an established and familiar A & B 3 visual feature of the neighborhood, community, or city HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION STAFF REPORT DRC2005-00776 - ROBERDS HOUSE April 25, 2007 • Page 4 Fact/s• The Roberds House is located on the site of the first house m the Alta Loma townsite. It was in close proximity to the railroad tracks, the packing house, and the first fire station in Alta Loma. The Roberds' telephone was used for fire .. calls. CORRESPONDENCE. The Historic Landmark designation was advertised as a public hearing m the Inland Valley Daily Bulletin newspaper, the property was posted, and notices were mailed to all property owners within 300 feet of the project site RECOMMENDATION• Staff recommends that the Historic Preservation Commission recommend approval of Landmark Designation DRC2005-00776 and Mills Act Agreement DRC2007-00173 to be forwarded to the City Council for final action. Respectfully submitted, James R Troyer, AICP Planning Director JRT•PMC\ma Attachments Exhibit A -Location Map Exhibit B -Photographs of Roberds House Exhibit C -Agreement Schedule Exhibit D -Historic Resources Inventory (Completed April 4, 2007) Draft Resolution of Approval for Landmark Designation DRC2005-00776 • A & B 4 • ,~ 0 z n LA VINE ST D -~ N -1 LA GRANDE ST LOMTA DR • Location Map Subject Parcel 500 ~ 0 500 1000 Feet • Ex~re~r,4 A & B 5 PICTORIAL EXHIBIT 7201 AMETHYST AVENUE RANCHO CUCAMONGA, CA 91701 • BY HALL AND FOREMAN, INC 9130 ANAHEIM PLACE, SUITE 120 RANCHO CUCAMONGA, CA 91730 TEL: (909) 919-7800 FOR • Fxriie~rB ROBERT BATHISH 1910 S. ARCHIBALD SUITE S ONTARIO, CA 91761 (909) 947-3600 A & B 6 LJ Figure 1 Figure 2 Looking Northerly up Amethyst Avenue from existing driveway. • • A & B 7 Looking Easterly at front on 7201 Amethyst Avenue • • Figure 4 Looking Easterly along Northern property line adjacent to existing water reservoirs. • A & B 8 Figure 3 Looking Southerly at Amethyst Avenue from existing driveway. • Figure 7 Looking Easterly from rear backyard. • A & B 9 Figure 5 • Figure 6 Looking at Northerly property line adjacent to existing water reservoirs from rear backyard. A & B 10 City of Rancho Cucamonga Historic Preservation Commission MILLS ACT AGREEMENT SUPPLEMENTAL: (To be completed by the Applicant) ~~ ~~ ~~ . w~~ r: Please list the improvements which are intended to take place over the next 10 years. List them in order of owner's priority. YEAR IMPROVEMENT '~ots'7 ila kI~N+Dt~u+S iZC S'cL~G rt ~~s~ {,r~•WOovs ~ ~cy2S "L'7 ~Dcyo.Zg Zc.o"9 ~Zc Sroe~ C~ Q ~+~...vac~ ~ 2 t_,c ~ 5T ~ -•- ZCJa~ '~'r1~2r~vC Po ~N 4~T~ orb Zoo Q.~sB'Ct~fL~ ~V-~4T~~A~ 1/~o~t7 FL~O~S ZvG~ F'A ~~.lT 'C. L~~...IL E`~T~¢_„pIZ. ZacS$ hZ ~ P:as GL, Erc rE¢..~0 ~ ~=~Lo..~: -~vZLk~ a..94sap g p tla••a.5 0 L ZdC1a: IZC~°w•~(~ ~ -2~c5Tp.Zc E-~~Si~-l~'1 L'D~+ULCr~ CG~~.a.+...aS-~-~or+ T PL~ ZO to 4, iZs.STp~ C^'L ~ 5T 1 l~ZN TC~¢.~0~ YQ~v "L ~a Oil S " LING ~~ S N CS P!N C~a..J H ~ ~ M T6/ E'~/C.G ~4 ~+ i ~,~.~„~2 !~ +a "4~n 1 L ,j'~l t .. ; . s ~L'' i~ `W ~ n "1""'4 7 h ~'^`t' ` kRtN', ~ir'< ~". ~ y,"`~ I' P~y~r~~ ~~t#~`i, 'I~Tt~ ~i`I~ ~° ~ ~~~~~~„~ `~~k ~,~:„ ~~~~~~-„ _ ,~~N'"~}~~~wr~u~" ,, 1,~,~ 7~t~,~;~,y ..~~,~,~r~~;~~, ~~~,.~~ E.-~.c.,.~ ~...i ~ ~ } ._.. .L~.uuz~~,..~'... ~~.~~~'i~a ~y1'f~n_~a,~.~_b,m~~.'fd` ~. _..z..16~i.~,~.L'~'r.' II ~"' e L2C .'~ r ~u~~~'~:t"~a I certify that I am presently the legal owner of the subject properly. Further, I acknowledge the supplemental information on this form will be used as an exhibit attached to the Mills Act Agreement. ._,~-== Date: y - ~ - Z~-~ Signatur ExNie~rC State of California -The Resources Agency DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION PRIMARY •REGORD ;Ns.. - , • ` :~Ottie~"Listlrigs " . ~ { Review Code`,'"" Primary # _ HRI # _ -"Trinomial V - ° ,~ ~NRHP Status Code Reviewer ~ Date Page ] of 6 *Resource Name or # (Assigned by recorder) Roberds House P1 Other Ident~er Nazarene Church *P2 Location: ^ Not for Publication ®Unrestricted * a County San Bernardino and (P2c, Pte, and P2b or P2d Attach a Location Map as necessary ) * b USGS 7.5' Quad Guasti~ Date 1978 T R of of Sec. B M c Addres '7201 Amethy" ~st ~4 a ue Cdy ~ Rancho Cucamonga Zip 91701 d UTM (Give more than one for large and/or linear resources) Zone 11 444825 mE/ 3776000 mN e Other Locational Data (e g ,parcel #, directions to resource, elevation, etc , as appropriate) APN 202-161-04 *P3a Description: (Describe resource and its mayor elements Include design, materials, condition, alterations, size, setting, and boundaries) The Roberds House is awest-facing, one-and-a half-story Craftsman bungalow with clapboard exterior walls and a rectangular floorplan with a central hall The large, medium-pitched, side gable roof with pro)ecting eaves is clad with composite shingles and features one large, centrally located shed roof dormer on each side of the roof Each dormer has a clerestory (ribbon of four 6-light windows) spanning the length of the dormer The main entrance consists of a pair of centrally-located multi-light casement doors framed by a large, gable-roofed porch with exposed rafter tails The porch is supported by large concrete columns and features decorative king post trussing Flanking the main entrance and porch are two pairs of French doors with simple wood surrounds A wooden pergola supported by a simple concrete collonade spans the entire front and north facade of the house A porte -couchere supported by identical concrete columns once extended over the driveway along the north facade of the house but has since been removed The fenestration is predominately one-over-one double- hung sash with the exception of a ribbon of three one-over-one double-hung sash windows on the rear (east) elevation and the six-Igiht casement windows and louvred windows on the gable ends The rear (east) facade features a small enclosed porch with wooden deck, stairs, and a shed roof Ad)acent to the small porch is the ribbon windown previously mentioned A pair of French doors flanked by two pairs of casement windows sets above the pergola on the north facade These French doors originally led out to a roof deck that has since been removed Above the French doors is a louvred window The interior of the house retains its original 1920s paneled doors, molded pine door and window trim, chair and plate rails, oak and pine floorings, and pressed-tin ceiling The house also features original built-in cabinets typical of Craftsman bungalows *P3b. Resource Attributes• (List attributes and codes) HP2 Single family property and HP16 Religious building *P4. Resources Present ®Building ^ Structure ^ Oblect ®Site ^ District ^ Element of Dtstrict ^ Other (Isolates, etc ) P5b Description of Photo (wew, date, accession #) Front (west) elevation of 7201 Amethyst taken 2/7/07 *P6 Date Constructed/Age and Source• ® Historic ^ Prehistoric ^ Both ca 1910 *P7. Owner and Address: Robert Bathish 10435 LavenderCt Rancho Cucamonga, CA 91737 *P8 Recorded by: (name, affiliation, and address) Pei-Ming Chou City of Rancho Cucamonga 10500 Civic Center Drive Rancho Cucamonga, CA 91730 *P9. Date Recorded. April 4, 2007 *P10. Survey Type: (Describe) RC Historic Landmark Designation Mills Act *P11. Report Citation. (Cite survey report and other sources, or enter "none') Stoebe, Martha Games, 'The History of Alta Loma California 1880- 1980", 1981, Dana Slawson, "Preliminary Historical Resources Assessment for 7201 Amethyst Avenue, 9532 Roberds Court, 9540 Roberds Court, and 9548 Roberds Court" Novermber 2005 DPR Historic Resources Inventory prepared by Lynn Merrill, August 6, 1987 *Attachments: ^ NONE ^ Location Map ®Continuation Sheet ®Building, Structure, and Ob)ect Record ^ Archaeological Record ^ District Record ^ Linear Feature Record ^ Milling Station Record ^ Rock Are Record ^ Artifact Record ^ Photograph Record ther (List) D ~~~~T A & B 12 * Required information • • J State of California -The Resources Agency Primary # DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION HRI # BUILDING, STRUCTURE, AND OBJECT RECORD ~ge 2 "NRHP Status Code of 6 "Resource Name or # (Assigned by recorder) Roberds House 61 Historic Name Nazarene Church 62 Common Name Roberds House B3 Oregenal Use Church 64 Present Use Residential *BS Architectural Style• Craftsman Bungalow *66. Construction History' (Construction date, alterations, and date of alterations) -_ The Roberds House was constructed circa 1920 as the Nazarene Church Circa 1920 the church was moved tathe present site and converted into a residence The large shed-roofed dormers, roof deck, and pergola were added at the time of conversion *B7. Moved? ^ No ®Yes ^ Unknown Date ca 1920 Original Location approx 1 me SE of present site *B6 Related Features A two-bay garage with vertical wood sidings and a gable roof sits to the northeast of the house Immediately adjacent to the rear of the house is a small wood shed The lower portions of the walls are wood sided while the upper portion is screened in The shed appears to have been used as a wash house but the original function of the house es unknown 69 ArchRect Unknown b Builder Unknown *B10. Significance: Theme Residential Architecture Area Alta Loma Townsite Period of Significance Developmment of Alta Loma Property Type Residential Applicable Criteria (Discuss importance in terms of historical or architectural context as defined by theme, penod, and geographic scope Also address integrity ) The Roberds house was constructed circa 1910 as the Nazarene Church on a site approximately one mile southeast of its present site on the west side of Archibald Avenue Circa 1920, Harry and Rllla Roberds purchased the site and moved et to the current location on Amethyst At that time, extensive rennovations were done to convert the house from a church into a residence The Roberds house is an early example of adaptive reuse The Roberds family once owned most of the land south of the Pacific Electric Railroad tracks down to Base Line Road on both sides of Amethyst Avenue Harry Roberds had come to California with his family for his father's health and had a )ob workeng en the first packeng house en Cucamonga In 1913, He married Rdla Stephens, daughter of Douglas W Stephens, a pioneer vinyardist of Cucamonga The Roberds built the first house in the town of Alta Loma on the east side of Amethyst Avenue After the birth of their son, the Roberds moved the original house father south, bought the Nazarene Church, moved et to the location of the original house on Amethyst Avenue, and • remodeled the church into a residence In 1920, the Fire Department was created and the Roberds' telephone was used whenever there was a fire B11 Additional Resource Attributes (List attributes and codes) HP2 -Single family property *612 References 1 Dana Slawson, "Preliminary Historical Resources Assessment for 7201 Amethyst Avenue, 9532 Roberds Court, 9540 Roberds Court, and 9548 Roberds Court", November 2005 2 Martha Gaines Stoebe, "The History of Alta Loma California 1880-1980", published 1981 3 DPR Historic Resources Inventory, prepared by Lynn Merrell, August 6 1987 B13 Remarks Origenal DPR completed en 1987 Site es approximately 0 93 arcs *B14 Evaluator Pee-Meng Chou, Associate Planner *Date of Evaluation: Aprel 4, 2007 (Thos space reserved for official comments) (Sketch Map with north arrow requered) _~., ~ i ;` r.._ r ti l~ f~ _ 'r t Z ( r- ~ -_ ~ i ~ dr J ' .It i v ~ ~ h; ~~ ~~ -_ 4 l •" ! r ~~ ~~~• I ~ .~ ~,~~ ~.~ r~ / ~~` 1 }r ~'J (;1 r 3'•''~, ~ '° ~ , ,~ [~ G~ DPR 5238 (1/95) A & B 13 * Required information /7 + ~4 ~ a ~ A'~a ~~~ , State of California =The-Resources Agency: ,P~~mary # }~~ ~ ' DEPARTMEiJT OF,PARKS~AND~R,ECREATION `~iRl-# ~ °~ ' ` COSNTINUATIOIV;MS°H"E'ET„ - - >E;Trinomial - '~ ~'~° '' ~:,, ~ - '"' ~~ ~ °, ~ °, e M~„ .,,~. Page 3 of 6 "Resource Name or # (Assigned by recorder) Roberds House . "Recorded by: Pei-Ming Chou "Date: Apnl 4, 2007 ® Continuation ^ Update ADDITIONAL PHOTOS. • South elevation • DPR 523E (1195) A & B 14 "Required information Rear (east) elevation State,of California - The_Re`sources Agencyw;~; `` ~ , ~~ . , Primary # ~ - - ~ - ~DEPARTMENT"OF~PARKSAI~Df~REGREATION~~'`;~=~- HRI'#;~;•~--- '"~'" ~•~ ~'~'~ >~ -~ ~ = '~' ~ ~~ -- Oh.ev,_.» 1<z ~ _ -srr`xSh~ ~ .pv ~~!< - i- M> ~ ~~ i^4c'_rc Y ,i<4'u„~' ~' -%x a~~t, ~~~'~4a; ., „,.! ~~~,r;. ".,rr.,L,'"n~=z--`~,~~ _",~ ,~,v~~,F ~'~' ~'S~~r,xa. ,CONTI NUATIOIV ~5 E~T.'~~<'~ ' ' »a~~ ~;~ _ ~.,,. ~., ,, k,; ~ .., _ __ _ - ~, , , r.~, - ~.~ ,a~~ ~,- ~~_ Trinomial=. - ,max.. ~ge 4 of 6 *Resource Name or #: (Assigned by recorder) Roberds House ecorded by: Pei-Ming Chou * Date: Apnl 4, 2007 ® Continuation ^ Update ADDITIONAL PHOTOS • c North elevation Garage DPR 523E (1195) A & B 15 * Required information State of California -The Resources Agency Primary # ~ _ DEPARTMENT OF'PARKS AND RECREATION HRI # CONTINUATION SHEET ~ ` r` "Trinomial - ~ ~ ~ - Page 5 of 6 *Resource Name or #: (Assigned by recorder) Roberds House • "Recorded by. Pei-Ming Chou • Date: Apnl 4, 2007 ® Continuation ^ Update ADDITIONAL PHOTOS Shed at the rear of the house Built in sideboard in the kitchen • DPR 523E (1/95) A & B 16 "Required information State of California -The Resources Agency;. ~ ,Primary # ~ <~~' DEPARTMENT OF PARKS >i4ND`RECREATION~e _' "` ;~ NRI~#° ~~ ~'°~'~' '~'~" _" ' - _ ~` CONTI,NUATIOIV ~S~H,~ET° '~Tnnorn"ia~`~ -=<'~~`~ ~~:' ~ ~ ~~ ~ge 6 of 6 "Resource Name or #: (Assigned by recorder) Roberds House ecorded by: Pei-Ming Chou * Date: Apnl 4, 2007 ® Continuation ^ Update ADDITIONAL PHOTOS • J '~' . _~ -__ _. _ .. qra __~t ~ ~.+ r ~_ Tin ceiling detail DPR 523E (1195) A & B 17 * Required information RESOLUTION NO. 07-03 A RESOLUTION OF THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF RANCHO CUCAMONGA, CALIFORNIA, RECOMMENDING APPROVAL OF HISTORIC LANDMARK DESIGNATION DRC2005-00776 DESIGNATING THE ROBERDS HOUSE A HISTORIC LANDMARK, LOCATED AT 7201 AMETHYST AVENUE AND MAKING ~FINDfNGS IN SUPPORT THEREOF - APN: 0202-161-04 ~,~ _ . A. Recitals ~ - ~ ~_ ~ -a ~ ~~ - ~, 1. Robert Bathish filed an application for Landmark Designation DRC2005-00776 as described in the title of this Resolution. Hereinafter in this Resolution, the subject Landmark Designation is referred to as "the application." 2. On April 25, 2007, the Historic Preservation Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga conducted a duly noticed public hearing on the application and concluded said hearing on that date 3. All legal prerequisites prior to the adoption of this Resolution have occurred. B. Resolution. NOW, THEREFORE, it is hereby found, determined, and resolved by the Historic Preservation Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga as follows• 1 This Commission hereby specifically finds that all of the facts set forth in the Recitals, Part A, of this Resolution are true and correct. 2. The application applies to approximately 0.93 acre of land, basically an L-shaped configuration, located at 7201 Amethyst Avenue. 3. Based upon substantial evidence presented to this Commission during the above-referenced public hearing on April 25, 2007, including written and oral staff reports, together with public testimony, and pursuant to Section 2.24 090 of the Rancho Cucamonga Municipal Code, this Commission hereby makes the following findings and facts a. Historical and Cultural Significance: Finding 1. The proposed Landmark is particularly representative of an historic period, type, style, region, or way of life. Fact/s• The Roberds House is representative of the Craftsman Bungalow. It is also an early example of adaptive reuse. Finding 2. The proposed Landmark is of greater age than most of its kind. Facts The Roberds House was originally constructed area 1910 as the Nazarene Church. Circa 1920, the house was converted into a residence. Finding 3 The proposed Landmark was connected with someone renowned or important or a local personality. Facts The Roberds House is connected with the Roberds family Harry Roberds built the first house in the Alta Loma townsite. Rilla Roberds is the daughter of Douglas W. Stephens, a Cucamonga pioneer. A & B 18 HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION RESOLUTION NO 07-03 DRC2005-00776 -ROBERT BATHISH April 25, 2005 Page 2 b Neighborhood and Geographic Setting. Finding 1 • The proposed Landmark materially benefits the historic character of the neighborhood ~ . - Fact/s. The Roberds House is one of the few remaining historic buildings -_ _ • s. representing Old Alta Loma As the first house built in the Alta Loma townsite, it was, along with the construction of the rail, the catalyst for the development of Alta Loma Finding 2 The proposed Landmark in its location represents an established and familiar visual feature of the neighborhood, community, or city. Fact/s• The Roberds House is located on the site of the first house in the Alta Loma townsite It was in close proximity to the railroad tracks, the packing house, and the first fire station in Alta Loma The Roberds' telephone was used for fire calls. 4. This Commission hereby finds that the protect has been reviewed and considered in compliance with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) of 1970, as amended, and the Guidelines promulgated thereunder. The Council finds that this Landmark Designation is exempt under CEQA, pursuant to State CEQA Guidelines Section 15331, as a Class 31 exemption (historical resource restoration/rehabilitation) 5. Based upon the findings and conclusions set forth in Paragraphs 1, 2, 3, and 4 above, this . Commission hereby resolves that pursuant to Chapter 2.24 of the Rancho Cucamonga Municipal Code, the Historic Preservation Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga hereby recommends approval of Landmark Designation DRC2005-00776. 6. The Secretary to this Commission shall certify to the adoption of this Resolution. APPROVED AND ADOPTED THIS 25TH DAY OF APRIL 2007. HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF RANCHO CUCAMONGA BY: ATTEST: Pam Stewart, Chairman James R. Troyer, AICP, Secretary I, James R. Troyer, AICP, Secretary of the Historic Preservation Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga, do hereby certify that the foregoing Resolution was duly and regularly introduced, passed, and adopted by the Historic Preservation Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga, at a regular meeting of the Historic Preservation Commission held on the 25th day of April 2007, by the following vote-to-wit AYES: COMMISSIONERS: NOES. COMMISSIONERS' ABSENT: COMMISSIONERS: • A & B 19 ~, ,, ,~ ,:{ ~,. T H E C I T Y O F -- '- - -._~ ~__._. _... _ _ _..--~..t~ F.,aanss:~: ~.k amt. :., _ _ _ ... _ ,~-.....es. RANCHO CUCAMONGA Stiff Report DATE: April 25, 2007 TO' Chairman and Members of the Historic Preservation Commission FROM: James R. Troyer, AICP, Planning Director BY: Pei-Ming Chou, Associate Planner SUBJECT• CONSIDERATION TO INITIATE THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION ORDINANCE DRC2007-00254 -CITY OF RANCHO CUCAMONGA - A request to initiate the Historic Preservation Ordinance and amending the Municipal Code thereof for the purpose of updating the Historic Preservation Ordinance to include language to create historic districts and to be consistent with current case law and conformance with State law and Federal law. • BACKGROUND The Historic Preservation Ordinance was ado ted b the Cit Counal on A ril 4 1979. p Y Y P The Ordinance was amended on May 16, 1979, to change the number of voting members from five (5) to seven (7), and again on September 19, 1979, to include "Points of Historic Interest" as a designation In 1980, the Ordinance was amended to include a provision for the protection of proposed landmarks by prohibiting alterations or demolition of a proposed landmark until a final determination on the landmark status could be made by the Historic Preservation Commission or the City Council (April 2, 1980). On May 21, 1980, an amendment added language that further clarified the roles of the City Council and the Historic Preservation Commission in the process of landmark designation On March 2, 1988, the Ordinance was amended to include a penalty for the violation of the Ordinance and the types of civil penalties available m the event of a violation The Ordinance was last amended on May 26, 1993, to allow the City Counal to designate the Planning Commission as the Historic Preservation Commission. ANALYSIS: The Planning Department has determined that the drafting of a new Historic Preservation Ordinance may be necessary in order to meet the preservation goals and objectives of the City of Rancho Cucamonga The current Ordinance is out-of-date and does not reflect the current standards and practices set by the State and Federal government. In addition, the Historic Preservation Ordinance, as currently written, affords minimal protection of the City's increasingly scarce historic resources The new Ordinance will include an update of all necessary sections and the addition of standard sections recommended by the State of California's Office of Historic Preservation not previously included. Below is a preliminary outline of the mayor sections that are or should be included and the items within each section that the Planning Department has identified for revision and/or addition 1. PURPOSE: An update of the purpose to reflect the current preservation goals of the City ITEM C HISTORIC PRESERVATION STAFF REPORT DRC2007-00254 April 25, 2007 Page 2 2. ESTABLISHMENT OF THE COMMISSION: The Ordinance currently requires seven (7) members to serve on the Historic Preservation Commission. However, the Commission has only (5) members. The Ordinance must be updated to reflect the actual number of members. This section should also specify the roles of the Commission, the length of terms, and the qualifications required for each member. 3 ENABLING AUTHORITY. The Ordinance currently identifies the Community Services Department as the legal authority appointed to regulate the Ordinance This authority has been transferred to the Planning Department The Ordinance should be updated to reflect this 4. PROCEDURES AND CRITERIA FOR DESIGNATION OF HISTORIC RESOURCES: The Planning Department would like to add the designation of Historic Districts in the Ordinance The original draft of the 1979 Ordinance included a section on historic districts which was removed because of concern over conflicts with zoning. 5. PROCEDURES AND CRITERIA FOR ALTERATION OF HISTORIC RESOURCES: This section should be updated to specify the types of activities (e g. alteration, demolition, subdivision, etc ) allowed pertaining to historic resources and the procedures necessary to carry out such activities The section should also specify the scope of authority and the types of regulatory measures granted to the Commission should any prohibited activities occur or be proposed 6 ECONOMIC HARDSHIP' The current Ordinance does not include a section to address economic • hardship in the event of a situation where enforcement of the Ordinance could result in an unconstitutional taking of the property. The addition of this section would afford the property owner some flexibility and encourage rehabilitation and preservation efforts 7. DEFINITIONS. A definitions section is missing from the current Ordinance The inclusion of this section would help to clarify the scope of the Ordinance and the types of resources subject to the review and designation as detailed in the Ordinance RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Historic Preservation Commission recommend approval of the initiation of the drafting of a new Historic Preservation Ordinance for review and then forwarded to the City Council for final action. Respectfully submitted, ~~ James R Troyer, AICP Planning Director JRT.PMC\ma Attachments. Exhibit A -Existing Historic Preservation Ordinance dated May 1993 • C-2 • • C-3 • Chapter 2.24 HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION Sections: 2.24.010 2.24.020 2.24.030 2.24.040 2.24.050 2.24.060 2.24.070 2.24.080 2.24.090 2.24.100 2.24.110 2.24.120 2.24.130 2.24.140 2.24.150 2.24.160 2.24.170 2.24.180 Purpose. Material change defined. Historic preservation commission created. ,~„ Membership--Appointment and terms. Chairperson--Appointment and terms. Secretary. Commission power and duties. Designation of landmarks. Landmark designation review criteria. Landmark designation review procedure. Landmark change of use procedure--Special use permit requirements. Landmark alteration procedure--Permit requirements. Landmark alteration permit--Commission advisory function. Additional conformance requirements. Unsafe or dangerous conditions. Property owner by public agencies. Permit application filing fees. Public hearings--Notice and conduct. • 2.24.190 Appeals. 2.24.200 Enforcement authority. 2.24.210 Penalty for violation of chapter. 2.24.220 Civil remedies available. 2.24.230 Assignment of duties by city council. 2.24.010 Purpose. It is found that the protection, enhancement, perpetuation and use of structures and ?sites of historic, architectural, and engineering significance, located within the city are of cultural and aesthetic benefit to the community. It is further found that the economic, cultural and aesthetic standing of this city will be enhanced by respecting the heritage of the city. The purpose of this chapter is to: A. Designate, preserve, protect, enhance, and perpetuate those historic structures and sites which contribute to the cultural and aesthetic benefit of Rancho Cucamonga; B. Foster civic pride in the beauty and accomplishments of the past; C. Stabilize and improve the economic value of certain historic structures and sites; D Protect and enhance the city's cultural and aesthetic heritage; E. Promote and encourage continued private ownership and utilization of such buildings, other structures and sites now so owned and used, to the extent that the objectives listed above can be attained under such policy. (Ordinance 70 Section 1, 1979). 2.24.020 Material change defined. A "material change" means any change in the exterior appearance of a structure or feature, through alteration, construction, relocation, grading, demolition or otherwise. (Ordinance 70 Section 2, 1979). C-4 2.24.030 Historic Preservation Commission created. There is created the city historic • preservation commission. (Ordinance 70 Section 3, 1979). 2.24.040 Membership--Appointment and terms. The historic preservation commission shall consist of seven voting members who shall be residents of the city and appointed by the city council, subject to the following conditions: A. The term of office for each member shall be four years, except that three of the members first appointed shall be designated to serve for a term of two years, and four members for a term of four years, so as to provide a continuity of membership on the commission. Thereafter, the term for each voting member shall be four years. An appointment to fill an unexpired term shall be for the remainder of such unexpired term. B. The term of office of eadh present member of the historic commission is reduced from July 1st of the year in which each swch term is scheduled to expire to December 31st of the immediately preceding calendar year. Hereafter, historic commission members shall be appointed to terms commencing on the first day of January next succeeding each regular municipal election scheduled to occur in November of even-nurriber years. (Ordinance 292 Section 2, 1986; Ordinance 70A Section 1, 1979; Ordinance 70 Section 4, 1979). 2.24.050 Chairperson--Appointment and terms. The mayor, with the approval of the city council, shall appoint the first chairperson from among the members, subject to the following conditions: The term of office of the chairperson shall be for the calendar year, or that portion remaining after the chairperson is appointed or elected. Thereafter, when there is a vacancy in the office of chairperson, the commission shall elect a chairperson from among its members. (Ordinance 70 Section 5, 1979). 2.24.060 Secretary. The community services director shall act as secretary to the historic preservation commission and shall be the custodian of its records, conduct official correspondence, and generally coordinate the clerical and technical work of the historic preservation commission in administering this chapter. The community services director may designate an alternate to serve as secretary during the absence of the community services director. (Ordinance 70 Section 6, 1979). 2.24.070 Commission power and duties. The historic preservation commission shall have the power and duty to: A. Administer the provisions of this chapter; B. Perform such other advisory functions as may be delegated from time to time to the historic preservation commission by the city council; C. Cause to be maintained a current register of landmark designations for public use and information. (Ordinance 70 Section 7, 1979). 2.24.080 Designation of landmarks. The historic preservation commission, pursuant to the procedures set forth in this chapter, may recommend to the city council the designation of a "landmark" or "point of historic interest" for an individual structure or other feature, or group of structures on a single lot or site, or a site having special aesthetic, cultural, architectural, or engineering interest or value of an historical nature; A. Each such designation shall include a description of the characteristics of the landmark or point of historic interest which justify the designation and consequent benefits to the public which will be derived from its preservation. There shall be a description of the particular C-5 . features that should be preserved, and the legal description of the landmark site or point of historic interest. B. The historic preservation commission may at any time recommend to the city council the amending or rescinding of a landmark or point of historic interest designation pursuant to the same procedures set forth in this chapter for original designation. _ - C. Review and designation of "point of historic interest" will follow the subsequently outlined procedures of this ordinance pertinent to landmarks designation: 1. The "point of historical interest" designation is merely recognition for historical purposes and is not subject to protective or restrictive provisions applicabye to landmarks designations as outlined in subsequent sections of this chapter. 2. A current register of approved "points of historic interest" will be maintained for public use and information. (Ordinance 70-B Section 1, 1979; Ordinance 70 Section 8, 1979). 2.24.090 Landmark designation review criteria. When designating a landmark, the historic preservation commission and the city council shall consider the following criteria as a guide in making its determination: A. Historical and Cultural Significance: 1. The proposed landmark is particularly representative of an historical period, type, style, region, or way of life. • 2. The proposed landmark is an example of a type of building which was once common but is now rare. 3. The proposed landmark is of greater age than most of its kind. 4. The proposed landmark was connected with someone renowned, important, or local personality. 5. The proposed landmark is connected with a business or use which was once common but is now rare. 6. The architect or builder was important. 7. The site is the location of an important historic event or building. B. Historic Architectural and Engineering Significance. 1. The construction materials or engineering methods used in the proposed landmark are unusual or significant or uniquely effective. 2. The overall effect of the design of the proposed landmark is beautiful, or its details and materials are beautiful or unusual. -~ C. Neighborhood and Geographic Setting. 1. The proposed landmark materially benefits the historic character of the neighborhood. C-6 2. The proposed landmark m its location represents an established and familiar visual feature of the neighborhood, community or city. (Ordinance 70 Section 9, 1979). 2.24.100 Landmark designation procedure. A. Designation of landmarks may be proposed by the city council, historic preservation commission, the secretary or on application of the owners, or their authorized agents, of the property for which designation is requested. B. Any such proposal shall be filed with the community services department upon the prescribed form and shall include the following data: 1. Assessor's parcel number and legal desc~`iption of site; ., Y 2. Description detailing~the landmarks, special aesthetic, cultural, architectural, or engineering interest or value of an historic nature; 3. Sketches, drawings, photographs or other descriptive material; 4. Statement of condition of structure; 5. Other information requested by,the historic preservation commission. C. The application shall be referred to the historic preservation commission. The historic preservation commission shall hold a public hearing. The historic preservation commission shall recommend approval, modified approval or disapproval of the application. D. The city council may approve, modify and approve, or deny the proposed • designation. Approval, or modification and approval, of the designation shall be upon adoption of a resolution. E. The property included in any such designation shall be subject to the regulations set forth in this chapter and any further controls specified in the designating resolution. F. The secretary shall cause a copy of the designating resolution to be forwarded to any department or agency to whom the secretary considers it appropriate to have it sent. G. A landmark may be identified by an approved city marker. H. Except as otherwise provided m Section 2.24.160, it shall be unlawful for any person to carry out or cause to be carried out a material change on a proposed landmark until final action of the city council, denying the proposed designation, is taken. (Ordinance 70-E Section 1, 1982; Ordinance 70-D Sections 1, 2, 1980; Ordinance 70-C Section 1, 1980; Ordinance 70 Section 10, 1979). 2 24 110 Landmark change of use procedure--Special use permit requirements. A. Change of use of a structure on a landmark site shall require a special use permit. B. An application for the special use permit shall be filed with the community services department upon the prescribed form and shall contain the following information: 1. A plan showing the relation of the proposed use to surrounding structures; C-7 . 2. Alterations required for the change of use; 3. Other information deemed necessary by the historic preservation commission. C. After receiving an application for a special use permit, the community services department shall refer it to the historic preservation commission which shall hold a public hearing. D. The historic preservation commission may approve, approve with modifications, or disapprove the application. E. Pnor to approval or modified approval, the historic preservation ~,ommission shall find that: , 1. The action proposed is consistent with the purposes of this chapter; 2. The use proposed will not be detrimental to a structure or feature of significant aesthetic, cultural, architectural or engineering interest or value of an historic nature; or, 3. The applicant has demonstrated that denial of the application will result in immediate and substantial hardship. , F. Upon approval of an application, the historic preservation commission shall issue a special use permit, one copy of which will be forwarded to the applicant, one copy of which will be retained in the files of the community services department, and one copy of which shall be forwarded to any other department or agency requesting it. • G. Any person residing in or owning property in the city shall have the right of appeal to the city council. Notice of appeal must be filed with the city clerk within ten days following the action of the historic preservation commission. H. No special use permit shall be issued unless the proposed use at the subject location is permitted by Title 7. (Ordinance 70 Section 11, 1979). 2 24.12b Landmark alteration procedure--Permit requirements. A. Except as otherwise provided in Section 2.24.160, it shall be unlawful for any person to carry out or cause to be carried out a material change on any designated landmark unless a landmark alteration permit has first been obtained for such material change. B. Any person desiring to carry out a material change on a designated landmark shall apply for a landmark alteration permit. C. An application for a landmark alteration permit shall be filed with the community services department upon the prescribed form and shall contain the following data: 1. A statement of the proposed work; 2. Plans describing the size, height, and appearance of the proposed work; 3. A site plan showing all existing buildings and structures and the proposed work; 4. Where the application is for demolition, the necessity for demolition shall be justified; and C-8 5. Other information deemed necessary by the historic preservation commission. D. After receiving an application for a landmark alteration permit, the community services department shall refer it to the historic preservation commission which shall hold a public hearing. E. The historic preservation commission in considering the appropriateness of the landmark alteration application shall consider, among other things, the purposes of this chapter and the historic architectural value and significance of the landmark. Among other things, the commission shall take into consideration the texture and material of the building or structure in question or its appurtenant fixtures, including signs, fences, parking, site plan, and landscaping. ~~ F. The historic preservation commission~may approve, approve with modifications, or disapprove the application. G. Prior to approval or modified approval, the historic preservation commission shall find that: 1. The action proposed is consistent with the purposes of this ordinance; and 2. The action proposed will not be detrimental to a structure or feature of significant aesthetic, cultural, architectural, or engineering interest or value of an historic nature; or 3. `The action proposed is necessary to correct an unsafe or dangerous condition on the property; or, 4. The applicant has demonstrated the denial of the application will result in immediate or substantial hardship. H. Upon approval of an application, the historic preservation commission shall issue a landmark alteration permit, one copy of which shall be forwarded to the applicant, one copy of which shall be retained in the files of the community services department and one copy of which shall be forwarded to the building official. In addition, a copy shall be forwarded to any other department or agency requesting it. I. Any person residing in or owning property in the city shall have the right of appeal to the city council. Notice of appeal must be filed with the city clerk within ten days following the action of the historic preservation commission. J. No building, grading or demolition permit shall be issued by the city, if the issuance of such permit will allow a material change to be carried out on a designated landmark, unless the applicant for such permit has first obtained a landmark alteration permit. (Ordinance 70 Section 12, 1979). 2.24.130 Landmark alteration permit--Commission advisory function. The historic preservation commission may, upon request of the property owner, render non-technical advice on proposed work on a designated landmark alteration permit. In rendering such advice and guidance, the historic preservation commission shall be guided by the purposes and criteria in this chapter. This section shall not be construed to impose any regulation or controls upon any property. (Ordinance 70 Section 13, 1979). C-9 2.24.140 Additional conformance requirements Issuance of permit in conformance with this chapter shall not alter conformance requirements with the other standards and requirements of this chapter, or any other applicable ordinance. (Ordinance 70 Section 14, 1979). 2.24 150 Unsafe or dangerous conditions. None of the provisions of this chapter shall be construed to prevent any measures of construction, alteration, removal, demolition or relocation necessary to correct the unsafe or dangerous conditions of any structure, other feature, or part thereof, which such condition has been declared unsafe or dangerous by the building official, after informing the historic preservation commission when the structure is a landmark, and where the proposed measures have been declared necessary by such official to correct the said condition, provided however, that only such work as is necessary to correct the unsafe or dangerous condition may be performed pursuant to this section. In the event any structure or other feature shall be damaged by fire or other calamity, the secretary or building official may authorize, prior to the commission's review, that amount of repair or demolition necessary to correct an unsafe correction. (Ordinance 70 Section 15, 1979). 2.24.160 Property owned by public agencies. The secretary shall take appropriate steps to notify all public agencies which own or may acquire property in the city, of the responsibilities involved m the ownership of designated landmark properties. In the case of any publicly owned landmark, the agency owning said property shall obtain the approval of the historic preservation commission prior to construction, alteration or demolition thereon; and the historic preservation commission shall render a report to the owner as expeditiously as possible, based on the purposes and standards of this chapter. If historic preservation commission review of a public project involving construction, alteration, demolition or removal on a landmark structure site is required under any other law, the historic preservation commission shall render the report referred to m this section to such public agency without specific request therefor. All officers, boards, commissions • and departments of the city shall cooperate in carrying out the spirit and intent of this chapter. (Ordinance 70 Section 16, 1979). 2.24.170 Permit application filin fq ees. Before accepting for filing any application described in this chapter, the secretary shall charge and collect such administrative fee as may be set by resolution of the city council. (Ordinance 70 Section 17, 1979}. 2.24.18b Public hearings--Notice and conduct. A. Whenever a public hearing is required by the provisions of this chapter, it shall be held in accordance with the provisions of this section. B. A public hearing before the historic preservation commission shall be at a time and place fixed by the secretary but not more than forty-five days after the submission of an application or a proposal for which the public hearing is required. C. A public hearing before the city council shall be during a regular meeting of the city council. The city clerk shall fix the date for the hearing which shall not be later than thirty days after the matter to be considered is referred to the city council. D. A public hearing may be continued by the body holding the same for a period not m excess of thirty days. "' E. Notice of the time, place and purpose of the public hearing shall be published once in the newspaper of general circulation in the city not less than ten days prior to the date of the . hearing (Ordinance 70 Section 18, 1979). C•10 2.24.190 Appeals. The city council shall hold a public hearing to consider an appeal from a decision of the historic preservation commission. The city council may affirm, reverse or modify the action of the historic preservation commission. (Ordinance 70 Section 19, 1979). 2.24.200 Enforcement authority. It shall be the duty of the community services department, and the building official to administer and enforce the provisions of this chapter with the assistance of other city departments when deemed necessary. (Ordinance 70 Section 20(a), 1979). 2.24.210 Penalty for violation of chapter. It is unlawful for any person, firm, partnership, or corporation to violate any provision or to fail to comply with any of the requirements of this chapter. Any person, firm, partnership, or corporation violating any provision of this chapter or failing to comply with any of its requirements shall be deemed guilty of a misdemeanor and upon conviction thereof shall be punished by a fine got exceeding one thousand dollars, or by imprisonment not exceeding six months, or bye, both such fine and imprisonment. Each such person, firm, partnership, or corporation shall be deemed guilty of a separate offense for each and every day or any portion thereof during which any violation of any of the provisions of this chapter is committed, continued, or permitted by such person, firm, partnership, or corporation, and shall be deemed punishable therefor as provided in this chapter. (Ordinance 70 (F) Section 1, 1988: Ordinance 70, Section 20 (b), 1979) 2.24.220 Civil remedies available. A violation of any of the provisions of this chapter shall constitute a nuisance and may be abated by the city through civil process by means of restraining order, preliminary or permanent injunction, or in any other manner provided by law for the abatement of such nuisance. (Ordinance 70 (F) Section 2, 1988) 2.24.230 Assignment of duties by city council. Notwithstanding any other provision of this chapter, as the same may be amended from time to time, the city council may, by resolution, • designate the planning commission of the city as the historic preservation commission of the city and vest all of the functions, rights, powers, and duties of the historic preservation commission in the members of the planning commission. In the event the city, council does so designate, the membership, terms of office and officers of the historic preservation commission shall be the same as that set forth for the planning commission. (Ordinance 513, Section 2, 1993) L' C•11 _. \ .r ' ~~' ~:~ T H E C I T Y O F __ _. _ _ . - ~ d ~ __, __ e ,xis, x~;`, .~ r. ~,.._ ~«. RANCHO CUCAMONGA Stiff Report DATE. Apr-I 25, 2007 TO. Cha-rman and Members of the H-stor-c Preservation Comm-ss-on FROM: James R. Troyer, AICP, Plann-ng D-rector BY Mayuko Naka~-ma, Plann-ng A-de SUBJECT: UPDATE OF THE HISTORIC LANDMARK AND POINT OF INTEREST PLAQUE PROGRAM AND THE ORAL HISTORY PROGRAM BACKGROUND• A H-storic Landmark and Point of Interest Plaque Program The City of Rancho Cucamonga's H-stor-c Landmark and Point of Interest Plaque Program was -n-t-ated -n 1991, and was created to -dent-fy the H-storical Landmarks and the Po-nts of Interest throughout the C-ty of Rancho Cucamonga Th-s f-rst phase of the program used large bronze plaques that were mounted onto boulders. An example of th-s type of -dent-f-cat-on -s shown -n Exh-b-t A The program was updated -n 2000 and aga-n -n 2004, to g-ve more owners the opportun-ty to part-c-pate -n the program to ident-fy the-r H-stor-c Landmarks and Pont of Interest propert-es In 2000, the program was updated to ut-I-ze a more cost eff-c-ent, larger scale method The new program d-d not mount the plaques onto boulders, but placed the bronze plaque measur-ng approx-mately 11 -nches by 7 -nches, onto a V-ctor-an Style ma-Ibox. The plaque -s headed by the City of Rancho Cucamonga's crest (a group-ng of grapes) and the text reads C-ty of Rancho Cucamonga H-stor-c Pont of Interest/H-stor-cal Landmark Year bu-It Actual H-storical Name Installed by C-ty of Rancho Cucamonga The ma-Ibox, to wh-ch the plaque -s attached, -s -n the V-ctor-an Style and -s constructed of bronze colored cast alum-num The d-mens-ons of the ma-Ibox are as follows• 44 -nches tall, from base to top, 15 1 /2 -nches w-de and 10 1 /2 -nches deep. A photograph of the plaque and the ma-Ibox used for the 2000 program update -s attached as Exh-b-t B Add-t-onally, for the propert-es where a mailbox -s unsu-table, the plaque may be mounted onto a boulder, rock, or placed elsewhere -n a f-tt-ng locat-on The program rema-ns voluntary and there -s no cost to the homeowner ITEM D HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION STAFF REPORT UPDATE OF THE HISTORIC LANDMARK AND POINT OF AND THE ORAL HISTORY PROGRAM April 25, 2007 Page 2 B Oral History Program INTEREST PLAQUE PROGRAM The Oral History Program was first initiated in 1991 with an objective to examine the citrus areas and the viticulture heritage. As funds became available, the Oral History Program was updated in 1994 and in 2001 The program consists of an Oral History Respondent List of potential people to interview. They were contacted and interviewed with different consultants taking on the project such as Knox Mellon and Associates, Enid Douglass, and McBane and Associates Respectively, through the years, 35 interviews have been conducted and transcribed into recorded documentation The oral history process includes apre-interview consultant with the research time of 19 hours per interview and an average interview of 1 hour per individual The interviews are recorded on a cassette recorder, which is then transferred to a digital format and duplicate copy on the CD for inclusion to the City Archives. The finished product includes a bound and edited transcription of each interview. Interviewees sign the interview and the photograph release forms, so that the interviews conducted are made available online, on the City's website, and m audio or transcribed format for the public to view UPDATE. The Planning Department was approved $50,000 from the Redevelopment Agency to update the current Historic Plaque Program and the Oral History Program Staff intends to budget $25,000 for each project. A Historic Landmark and Point of Interest Plaaue Proaram Currently, the City of Rancho Cucamonga boasts a total of 79 Designated Historic Landmarks and 31 Designated Points of Interest Of these, approximately 46 Landmarks and 9 Points of Interest have installed plaques on their property. There have been 3 rounds to the Plaque Program, which was initially started in 1990, updated in 2000, and again in 2004 With the current budget, Planning Staff has decided to launch the 2007 Plaque Program starting with the Designated Local Landmarks This upcoming phase of the Plaque Program will be especially distinctive in that both the historic homes and the trees/groves are identified as landmarks Staff will be receiving plaques for the Victoria Avenue and the Highland Avenue Street Tree Landmarks Additionally, the railroad corridor (in conjunction with the Pacific Electric Trails Plan) will also be given a plaque Historic Points of Interests will also be added at a later date, with the hope of future funding. B Oral History Program In earlier years, difficult economic times required the City to rely on the mitigations and the donations for the oral history programs. With the approved funds from the Redevelopment Agency, the City is able to update the Oral History Program once again to add to our present collection The oral history respondent list created in 2001 still has 25 potential interviewees Staff is also adding names of individuals that are recommended or discovered. An updated version of the Oral History Respondent List is attached as Exhibit D With the amount of the current budget and taking into consideration that some • • • D-2 HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION STAFF REPORT UPDATE OF THE HISTORIC LANDMARK AND POINT OF INTEREST PLAQUE PROGRAM AND THE ORAL HISTORY PROGRAM April 25, 2007 Page 3 respondents may not want to participate and/or are deceased, approximately 15 more interviews may be conducted as part of the update RECOMMENDATION. Staff recommends that the Historic Preservation Commission receive the staff report and file for future reference. Res ectfully submitted, ~~ James R Troyer, AICP Planning Director Attachments. Exhibit A -Photograph of plaque on boulder Exhibit B -Photograph of the plaque and mailbox used for the 2000 program update Exhibit C -Brochure for the 2007 Plaque Program Exhibit D -Oral History Respondent List • D-3 • EXHIBIT A D-4 • • • • EXHIBIT B ,, .' ~~, ,.. i i ;l ^ ~ ,r y',.~ ~ :/ ~y~ r_ .r=. ~aX~Y D-5 • V • a L ~~ 0 ~ ~ L ~_ Q. ~\ ~ O a ~ a N a. • • i ~ ~ ~ ° N ~~ ~ o v ~ L ~ a,o O O L H O ~ V +-+ ~ ~ O ~ ~ N U ~ O ~ ~ a h ~ 3 v o `a ~ . ~ r ~ °' ~ ~ o c • {Z GL.1 ~ y ~ 11 b O ~ O ~ c C ° O ~ ~_ vi O ~ ~ V by ~ N V O ~ ~ N ~ 'i O "S ~ O - . *, ~ *, + v s ~ +~-+ ~ p ~ ~ ,., o ..'O "O ~ ~ ."= O O ~ 'O ~ ~ ~ • N O v } -O C ~ s` T c y ~ Lf p 0 0 •O u O~ p 0 ~ ~~ C ~ ~, ~ O O t ~ C Q ° ~ N ~ ~-aO ~ L, rn, ~,_~ - S ~ ~ O r ~/ I ~ } ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ L to o ' ~, •~ "' a o ~, -~ o ~ 0 0 2 T O O .~ •,_ ~ O C O ~ ~ ~ V ~ 0 Q ~ ~ ~ °~-s . " oa O O ~ s s C V N • ~ } ~ •Q 7 ~ ~ - -p ~ ~ ~ } O = .U N L ~ Q E a~~ c us c H o Q EXHIBIT C D-6 '^ ~ 3 ~ ~O. •~ p.-O«- O O ~ ~ ~ ~n a Q ~ •L ~ ~ O u_~~ u~ O ~ •U ~ O ~ u _A ~ Q y ~ O •L Q. ~ ~ O C ~ ~ •~ } () O C Ov ~ ~ O ~ C Q- ~ ~ ~ d. , 3, O •N • N •~ ~ u •L O ~ N~ v p N O~~ O a s '~ O >- 0 .~ Q z i--- _ ~ p .~ a ~ s ~ p N ; O N ~ U C ~ 3 vi L Q rs- ~ O Q _ O O ~ r .O ~ ` • , ~ ~ O ~ O V ~~ O" ~ O ~ ~ N Q Q ' ~ v p . O . °° ~.-. 3 .~~s ~~ a -T c ~- ~.. N O ~ u O p Q C ~ '^ 0 p `~ O Q, O Q = gy Q Q Q- - N . ,, E R v - ~ ~ L •~ N Z +' L ~ / ~ / Q. V ~ a 0 a Z O T O T a a N s v 0 m -a ~~ :~ o ~ a -a ~ -i y 3 ~ -a ~ ~"a- ~ ' ~ '~ m . ~ 3 n. :c? ' Q ~{ cD~.. O O' x . ~~ O X , ' c C c ,c ~D ` N N ~ ~D r v i ~ .. / ~ ~ ' ~~. ~~, ~' Q n -N, o ~ o Q ~, _s ~ ~ , , Q ~, ~ ~ O 0 0' ~ ' , u0i O C fl ~. -` O ~ N ~~ w ~ Q. Q ~ (~ ~ ,~ ~ ~ ~ rt ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ 3 ~p Q ~ 1 /1 cD ~ m ~ ~ ~ s _ ~ii Z O !D Q n ~- Q 0 F ~ > >' ~ a° 0 ~ O' Q o~ S fC N ~- n c Q I~ r; (A Y\ ~~'_}®I I_ ~ ~ i p\ /-'"~ ;~ - ~~~~ .~ i ---~ 1 ~1+~'~;aa, ~', r-^ "`~ a ° 1 ~ Q ~ -« N S Q o ' ~ ' ~ - v Q C o '~ ` C ., o v r~ Q C . ~ Q. ~ ~n', O 7 n- O ~ 0 c ~o o ~ ~ ~-~• ~ Q - o ~ ; < ' . . co ~~ ~., , N n oo ~ ' c Q '~~ Q . ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~, „,~ a- -« ~; m -+ V ~. _ ~ ~ • ~ N ~ In • ~ ~ i . ~O r CD ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ N ~ ' ~ _~ /~ O ~ ' t y~ I I 1 y S O ' ~.. \~ ~n ~~~ A1r ~ `~ ..m £~ 'a ~ ~ ~ o ~ ~' "D- s D O N c N ~. < Q ~O Q- n N - O,. N `~O N n ~ - ~ ~ ~ . ~ ".~ , ~ ~ ~ S N ,_„ ~ O N O ~ , a _ , O_ S ,. . .° ?: :° m ° a ° o ~ .. 0 3 ~ o_ Q• 3- fCD N Q- ~ ~ O Q ~ . N ~p M• ~ rt' Q O ~- x ~ ~ ~ Q ~ Q vim, -a O ~ (D n n ~ .,. Q a Q ~, o Q y Q ~ 0 3 3 (D ~ O _ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ O Q ti S Q ~• N ~ ^ Y( Q + ~ (D Q fp ~ vi ~^ ~_._ _ao-=- s ~mW- - ~ - K o° F A b ~ _ + n ~ _ O O ~ ~~ f ~~ = m Y ~' CZi -i ' i _ ~_ i, ~ k v ? ~ O 0 2 ~ O N ~ = ~ -• ~ ~ w n' c O ~ -n ~ ~ 'p ~ p 0 ,Y o . n ~~ r- S Q fl .Q O ~ (D n S Q -~.. Q O = O 'O ~ C~ C ~ ~ ~ 3 - ++ ~ Q ~ f1 ~ fl ~ 3 ~ Q ~ ~ ~ _ ~ o 3 ~ ~ ~ O O ~ • • • D-7 n ~ til~y~ ii .~i i~ JvY~it~ G;td~i<'la~iFxvvi!a'v 0 N ~ ~ ~ -p O N N ~ N N c~ c~ c~ ~~ O_ O O U O U O U N O O N N OC ~ U ~ ~ ~ N T N T T T T T C7 ~ L r ~ . r O N p~ ~ O ,- O J ' c c c F- ~ Z ~ ~ ~ ~ co -~ ~ -~ W Z C~ O O ~ N O N d~ ~ N O~ T O ~ N a7 r ~ ~ N ~ T O ~ ,- O ~ C D. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ' ''-' U ~ ~ > O ~ ~ N ' ~ ' C ~ C ~ (n -~ ~ O ~ z ~ cn ~ -~ ~ W ~ ~ o >- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ m ~' Q- ~ a`> ~ ~ a ~ ~ U O ~ N c~ ` ~ to ~, C ~ ~ U ~ ~ ~ O) O ~+ ~ ~ ~ _ _ ~ ~ _ ~ (~ (~ O ~- ot$ ~ cv .J ciS c in ~ c~ ~ ~ -~ ~ O ~ +r ~+ U (~ ~ (~ C Q ~~ ~, ~ ~ ~ ~ _~_ o o Q c E ~ E o ~ ~ ~ o -~ p ~ ` ~ ° c~ c~ ~ ~ c~ W J ""' W J c~ O ~ o~ p ~ U U p LL C R3 c~ U ~ WY ~ a ~ W ?~ ~ U U L.L ~ ~ -' Q cn Q z ~ o ~ ' }, ~ ~ ~a . _ U ~ ~ .... ,~ ~ E U O ~ ~' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~i u~ O 7 N N fn ~ U (A ~ ~ ` O O (n i O In ~ O ~ O ~ U ~ 2 ~ ~ ~ d. ~ ~ fn ~ ~ G 'O a~ c ~ c 'D ~ to cn ~ . -O ~ c o ~ a Ca "a c "O c J ~ ~ - ~ c~ E -O ~ c ~ -p c ~ p o~ c Q U O J T ~ ~ ~ Q J w ~~ ~~ N O N ~ ~ U p cn N m ~ J _~ to i o !n - fn O ~ ~ ~ c ~ L a O ~ (~ ~ ( ~ _ ~ ~ c (~ ' ~ ~ C6 o (d ' (~ ~ O O ~ ~ ~ ~ ,~ (t3 3or E ~ C U LL W C3~ 2 cnU (. 3 C~ OCn 4. W ~Q U ~ ~I.L U C.3 O 2 U m ~ c Q ~ i C~ M Y. O (n ~ ~ O p° ~ ~ a~ ~ j ~ a~ a >' ~ ors ~ °~ o ~ ~ - o ~ ~ ~s ~ o °~ ~ ~ ° a ~ v ~ Q m ~ ~ a ~ ~ a m c~ ~ m ,~ O p O O ~ N O ~ ~ .•-~ c O C Y Y ~ N (CS C i N fn Y C E 1 ~ ~ O O ~ N C ~ ~ .Q i . p i Y O ~ (~ N - ~ C C (~ i (~ O O i O O (~ - - ~ ~ c O ~ L N L N .~ '- ~ ~ ~ N a a a m m m m m m m m m U U ~ ~ o EXHIBIT D D-8 ~ ~ ~ m ~ m ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ c~ m U a~ U a~ U U N N ' ~ ~ ~ ~ U ~ N ~ U a n . CL `'' T `'' ~y~ t'/ T ~y~ l~/ ~ ~ T T T T /ryy~~ t~/ ~ ' Y ~ Y ~ W • T T T T '` T • ~ C) Q O C] C C C C C C .~. T C) 1 TTT V/ 1 T ~ I T C) 1 T ~ T C) 1 V~T V/ 1 lT'J VJ 1 MV/ W 1 N ~~ TT VI 1 TTT V! 1 T C) 1 C "~ ~ U O C "") C ~ > z C ~ -Q LL ~ L Q ~ ~-~ O (~ C ~ ~ N (~ ~ _ ..t (~ j L O E O . U Q °> ~ a> '~ ~ N J ~ ~ ~ U ci3 ~ aci ~ N ~ W O ~ - cc O ~ ~ ~ v C~ O ~ ~ ~ ~f [ r~ f G ~c Y ~r~ ~ ~ ~Ct (~ C ~ ~ ~ C ~ O C ~ C O O C ~ C~ ~ W ~ ~ L ~\ ~ ~ 1 ~ ~ (~ U ~ Q ~ (~ ~ C ~ ~ ~ °`~ N Q Q N ~ .p Cd LL O - ~ ~ .p RS U ~ U W Ur W W ~ W W v O O C R N L Q~ ~ U L ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ U ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ (~ ~ 'O ~ (~ (~ "O O W O 'D ~ "a m a LL. ~ ~ (~ ~ a Y ~ ~ ~ U C C ~ ~ C O O Z C C "U L L E i - Q ~ -p C ~ ~O C • L n ~~ W n/ ~~ W C Q ~ ~` n W ~ ~ ~, W ~, n W ~ ~ C7 ^`` ^,, ~1 ^ W W O O J _ ^•' n W O c C cu C ctS fI~ 1.~ ~ ~ d O .Q (SS L (~ L - O- ~ = o. O (S1 ~ L - O N N RS > '~"~ (~ Ctl L Q (i1 ~' N O O ~ (~ ~ ~ L to (jf ~ ~ 2 L ~--~ J y (~ J C`3 C'~ _ ~ Lt.. W C,~3 ~ C'3 C3 Z C.`3 L (~ (~ ~ _ ~ ~.. Q O LL ~. ,~.~ W ...., W U Q ~- C.3 L O -/~~ nCn~~ W L (CLS ~ O m i (~ ~ ~ ~ p C U °~ m o2S ~ L o o ~ ~S m ~ ~ ~ a O ~ ~ ~ D ~ ~ cn a~ o o C ~ '~ Cm C ~ C ~ U; O L m C a~ ~ i ~ O Q ~ c ~ O LL (~ ~ _U ~ C7 (n ~ ~ Z ~ Q LL ~ ~ J L ~ ~ m J LL d (i3 ~ O ~ /O I..L ~ O O O .~ ~ rt( ~ L O i X L = J E cts }' O (~ Y ~ ~ C Y ~ 'O OU ~ L L N Q U =_ __ ~ (~ ~ U i _ ~ _ ~ L (4 C[S O N U ~ O O ~ ~ D LL LL LL C7 C.7 C3 C.7 C7 = _ _ _ _ _ _ _ • • D-9 ~~ ~J ;: Lea °' -° o ~ a 0 c co ~ `~ c ao ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ m a> m m m ~ cti ~ c~ ~ a3 ~ c~ rn c~ a> a~ m m a~ U ~ U U U U O N U N O ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ U U ac o~ O O C C ~ ~ ~ ~ c 6 t U W W Q- ~- ~ ~ T r T T T ~ ~/ 0 C) ~ O I T T N T N T T T N T ~t OJ O I ~ 1 ~ 1 ~ O O O 07 ~ 1 f~ _ I C C U t "-' 1 C 1 C 1 C 1 '"" L O O ~ ~ U ~ ~ _ ~ o m Q ~ ~ ~ U c~ - ~ ~ o ' ~ N -~ ~~ i N O J O -~ J~ ~ ~ ~ +~ aj L C O Ri i~ (Cf O W Q Q U ~ W U o - ~~ U N ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ L ~ L ~ U ~ ~ ~ ~ .~ o ~ ~ ~ O N (CS ~ "O -1--~ N O C `1 `1 ~ C ~ C C N ~ ~--I ~ L W a~ a ~ ~ 'a a~ O O ~ C ~ O _ ~ ~ ~ '~ ~ C ~ C (SS ~ O to C C -Q ~ }, ~ ~ • ozf C (~ E O C N In In O ~ (~ fn O ~ ~ O p W O~ N J (~ i ~ ~ y ~ i i ~ i i N ~ C ~ ,~ (~ ~ L C i ~ ~ (6 (~ m W `1 ~ m U _ U ~- U U C3 ~ Z U LL (n W C3 m CD Q W O C ~ O N U N L Y (~ C C ~ ct~ ciS W ~ ~ ~ (~ ~ ~ O J ~ ~ ~ oZ$ O ~S ~ ~` ~ ~ cII ~ oZS r~eeff •y ~ rt ( •V U n• ~ V J W rtf ay ~ L O ~ r~[ `u L L L L ~ C ^` ~ ~ O ~ ~ ~ }, LL ~ ~ _ _ ~ W Cn ~ -~ U J Q = ~ ~ ~ ~ W ~ ~ (~ /1~ L ~ ~ C C C L ~ in ~ ~ ~ to 'C '~ .~ C3 C3 a~ ~_ ~ Y _ 2 Y Y J J J J ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ c~ D-10 U ~ U U ~ a ~ ~ ~, T N >, C7 C'') C'7 C''~ ~, ~ ~ (~ ~ ~ f6 cC W ~ W W • A 1` T T T T • O O O ~ O I O 1 O 1 O 1 O 1 1 C I C ..Q C C C C C ' • ~ ~ ' L.L T ~ VI T T T T O Imo O ) d7 I ~ O O O O ~ ' ~ `` W ^^ `` W ~ ^ \ W ~ ~ ~ ~ ^` W / /~ VJ ~ 1 111 1..~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~/ '~ V/ ^ ` W N O N ~ ~ L - _ ~ ~ N C ~ «' .C O U o ~ 3 ~ ~ rn ~ Q I ~ ~ ~ c~ 0 ~ I ~' o ~ c~ o p U ~ ~ ~ c~ v - - ~ ~ ;` U o ~ c~ ~ 0 0 ~ c ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ J ~ -~ ~ a ° ~ ~ ~ c~ a~ ~ `m m U ~ a w ~ }' o ~ U Q U ~ c a~ c~ Q C U N W N N ' i ' ~ Q J (n - ' C ~ O C C •~ ro O C~ C C O ~, ~ _ ~ O ~ cn ~ ~ ~ d ~ ~ O ~ c~ ~ Q O ~ ~ ~ n- _ ~ U o O (~ ~ r (~ c~ N ~ N O ~ N ~ O O o~ 0~ c6 ~ p Cn (n ~ I.L.. W U r~ W W (3 U (3 U r U 2 U ~ ~ ~ C/) ~ W -~ >_ c~ CD ~ ~ O ~ '~ c>s o > > ~ -C ~ ~ +~-' ~ C O Q ~ O ~ - ~ ~ ~ °~ ~ O L N ~ ~ ~ ~ 'U ~ ~ C C J N O ~ CQ ~ O C N Cis O O N i i J ~ m Q Y ~ _ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ !Z ~ m J W ~ ~ >_ N L r-~ ~ ~ O _. ~ i E ~ ~ O i.., O ~ C (IS O O ~ . ~ O ~ N ~ O U N O O U ~ O ~ ~ O O ~ N O ~ - ~ Z O ~ = d. I1 ~ (n (n Cn Cn Cn ~- f- ~- ~ • • • D-11 0 Vil1 Vi' 1bLli'1 V11V 'NV VL11~1V1`I VL1 STAFF' RAP'®RT .. n ~~ ~ ~ ~ s c9n DATE: February 9, 1983 T0: Members of the Planning Commission FROM: Rick Gomea, City Planner BY: Curt Johnston Assir.tant Planner SUBJECT: ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT AND COWDITIONAL USE PERhiYT 62-29 - ni4uLV~ ~urrriunlir unu~<un - the Development of a church an re ate roc t es nc uding seven (7) temporary relocatable buildings, plus a request to operate a preschool on approximately 10 acres of land in the R-1-20,000 zone located on the west side of Haven Avenue, between Hillside Romd and Carrara Street - 5354 Haven Avenue. Related File: VA 83-01 u ~. A. ~'~1 PROJECT AND SITE DESCRIPTION: The applicant, Hillside Community Church, request ng rev ew an approval of a Conditional Use Permit to develop their church facility on 10 acres of land located on the west side of Haven, north of Hilislde Road (Exhibit "A"). In conjunction with the development plans is Variance 83-01 which is also on this agenda for your review and consideration. The pro,~ect site 1s currently vacant, and vegetation is limited to indigenous shrubs and weeds. The property slopes to the south at approximate) 8 percent and has a fall of 50 feet north to south (Exhibit "B"~. As shown on the Master Site Plan and elevations (Exhibits "C" & "D"), the church facility will ultimately include four permanent buildings, 375 parking spaces, and an overlapping soccer and baseball field. Four phases are proposed to complete the facility. Phase I is shown on Exhibit "E" and includes seven temporary buildings (Exhibit "F"). A preschool with a capacity of 120 students is also proposed with Phase I. Zoning on the sub,)ect property rnd all surrounding land is R-i-20,000. The General Plan designates the area as Very Law Density Residential (less than 2 dwelling units per acre). Land surrounding the site is vacant except far single family homes to the south. An approved Tentative Tract Map borders the subfect property to the west as shown on Exhibit "G". ITEM F Conditional Use Permit 82-29/Hillside Community Church Plannng Commission Agenda February 9, 1983 Pogo 2 ANALYSIS: A significant amount of grading will occur on the site to accommodate the pl fields, as seen on Exhibit "H". At the north end of , the field, a 2:1 50 percent) slope up to 20 feet in height will be graded. The southwest corner of the field will be raised 11 feet above the natural grade with a 6-foot high retaining wall and a 5~foot high 2:1 slope. The permanent sanctuary will seat 1500 persons; however, with the first phase 400 seats will be provided 1n the administration building. The parking raquiram~nt for tho permanent sanctuary fie 375 apacea. About one-third or 135 spaces will be located in :h® playground aroa. Initially, the grass field will be used for overflow parking, but as the church grows and the 1500 seat sanctuary is constructed, the parking will be needed on a regular basis. Therefore, it must be designed with a compacted subsurface adequate to accommodate parking in adverse weather conditions. A condition of approval is provided for your consideration. Haven Avenue is designated as a Special Boulevard on the General Plan. As such, the average landscaping depth (streetscape) required along the street frontage is 45 feet. The first row of parking within Phase I encroaches into this required streetscape. To maintain the 45-foot average, the amount of landscaping provided in front of the main sanctuary must be increased. Reducing the width of the circulation aisle on the oast side of the sanctuary from the 26 feet proposed to 20 feet 1s recommended to satisfy the st~eetscape roq~ilrement. The protect site is located within the equestrian/rural area the City designated in the General Ptan. Along the Haven Avenue frontage, a 20 foot community trail will be provided. Also, the Equestrian Committee is recommending that a local feeder trail be provided somewhere through the site in order to provide connection to the Haven Avenue Community Trail. The church is concerned that a trail may disrupt their facilities or cause additional costs. Staff has discussed several ways 1n which the trail can be provided without causing problems to the church. A condition has been included in the Resolution far the Commission's consideration, which would require the church to provide the trail and the final design and location to be worked out with the City Planner and Trails Committee. Regarding the use of the site as a preschool, all applicable City ordinances, including parking, have been met. In addition, the size of . the playground area meets the Stmte requirement of 75 square feet for each child. Conditions of approval typical of preschool applications , are provided for your consideration. DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE: The Design Review Committee reviewed the , pro,iect and recommended approval of the proposed architecture and site :~; plan. Conditional Use Pormit Ei2-29/Hillside Ca~r~r;unity Church Plannng Commission Agonda February 9. 14f33 Page 3 G EWVIRONMENTAL Rf:VIEId: Part I o`r the Initial Study. as completed by the app cant, s prov ded for your revle~v and eonsid2ration. Staff has completed Part II of the Environmantnl Assess~rent and found no advorse imr,acts on the environment as a result of this praJect. If the COr3ti15510n concurs wOth suc6i firdrngs, issuance of a tdegative Declaration u:ould be .n order. FACTS FOR FINDING: The project design and building placement are compati e wit t c surrounding existing and future residential area. The project site is adequate in size and shape to accommodate the development, and the proposed uses are in accordance with the objectives of the General Plan and Zoning Ordinance. The proposed building design anct site plan, in conjunction with approval of Variance D3-01 and together with the recomvm~nded conditions, are con.istent with the current development standards of the City. In addition, the project will not be detrimental tc, the health, safety, or general welfare of the public or properties in the immediate vicinity. RECOMMENDATION: It is recommended that the Planning Commission consider all input and elements of Lh1s project. Yf after such consideration the Carronission can support the facts for findings and recommended conditions of approval, adoption of i.he attached Resolution would be appropriate. Res~ctfully ~rtpmitted, Ri k GpmeP® C ty Tanner R /CJ/,jr ttachments: Exhibit '°A" - Zoning tG General Plan Exhibit "B" - Natural F'oatures Map Cxhibit "C" - t~taster Site Plan Cxhibit "D" - Clevation> (4 Sheets) Cxhibit "E" - Phase I (2 Sheets) Exhibit "F" - Temporary Buildings Cxhibit "G" - Tentative Tract 10414 Cxhibit "Fi" - Conc:eptuzl Grading Plan Cxhibit "I" - Aerial Photo Part I, Initial Study Re ,olution of Approval with fonditions ~'~ u' I~. rI ~{ ~6~ ~4 V ~ORTFI CITY OF ~~~~c~-~o cLTc.~~IO~cCt PI.~1.1~INI\G DI~'ISIO~I ITE.~1: ~.c~.P. p~ -z TITLE ~-~altt~ ~' r~~.t~zAc~'i~.~-J =,r C`:! IIIiIT• °~_ SC.1LE~ ~~, ` ~~; ,~ -j,~.~ ~• ~I/® ~~ _._... ~3r~. ,,., ~:~ ~- a ra r ~:^~1V I„ I. ,~ t ~ _ a ~. , d d ~ O ~ O ' i . a' I~RTH nCITYO~F A /'^~ ~ { g'LL'~~~Ct 1® CGTI..Ib~~l®~T~~ rt,~vr~chc otv~sl~ay <<r~ T[TLE~ -~~~!R+ S fir, EXHIBIT: ~:.~n SCALES` a ~:`• .. , 'r 1 1 a r o t t r a s u t t t r l t t t -~1 ~' ~~ ~ -':!~ ~y _. .-_.._._ __. tar- . ~f' t y11 _ 111' ~t t al' y 1 IJf .~~ al' f ~_i , -- ~ •`~-j;. Lr;,! f ~-1~11~ _~ j~ i r'- -- , ~ ~l~ ~; f f (i U I I ITS ~ ; ~ ~; t ~ -. ~ E 1 11~ ; .r .. f , .. ~' 1 1 r'rr-*.y •. ! Y 1_1`.LIBi i ..~ _ ~ 1 ~ r yT, ..`4''~ I I •' n w Y. j •I ~~ ~ P 1 '~..^ 5 `. ti., ~~+'i;~ '`t;'"~+t~~ t ~' ~ itiv..a4 ,'~,, l~u,~'tw~;._yy^~~, r•t 11' t1' J Ilnt 11..1 •rt ~ v~ y, / .y~ I ~">-- _ .. ' rr ' 1 ~ ~' +w~~s~yM+~ i/. 'i ..p t c c ~,t f r i t l'r ~;- f t 1, ! , ~ ~ ~ ~~ rl ~~~il~ ^~~_~ ~ I ' ~ v; ~ ~ n t. ~ ~ s , ~ . ~-•- - - f ~_.~I If I I yam. ~I I e~.._.~..~~..L,,;_()..~ju. 1'1 11 (~`d,.,~ ~sf , '~~ •-' h{ a a , ~ • -111' { • • _ • ~ • ~ YaswnCtA ••• ~,1 S 1 ~ `,~ -wv.aet •t r kw~ta.e x.1.1 al 11.1 1 •all 11 11. 1' t 11lI.1at Itftl ~v r a.~/ i .1.1 ..1 ai 1'111 11J 1 fN i ! i~~l.~l il~.11 1 - fl'~~ 4 I ~ V RU[tTE-[ 1 F` RA1CH0 CL'~iV~~\'GA TITI.G• .t..erD ~ 'hta~,4 ' `~; ~'~ PLANNING DIVLSIO?~i ~,YI-I6R1T "~° S~G1LE' ^- ' ,; ~;4a [;,, ~'i; ~ ~r ~~~+p}6 ~ „ 'fp a ^~ y, rd ~4Y - ~ - ~,Il S~~t,, `~~ r F4'~I y" ~ ~'~~ . ~:'i'~~: T'_-!s~ rti amt ~ t~ ~~LL u' i., ~ ~,,• v' •~,n1`~4•~«` Z,~j' lr~~ r~'{`~.~A~'~k' °). ,~~ ~'` %}h'Ty'f~'!' ah;p~`~r.. ~.. ~~ ~~+ .(7 _ t ~ f ,4.a~~~"~4 ~7~ cY Y 4 n '"'~~"1~ ~r -t ~ ~ ~,CW ~'i: 'd 1 ~ .•(IYyl ~ y~ ~ ~• . •+~, .~ Jrl~y r ..v`~.• \ ,. J, ~ >~7 q .x,,.-..,erg ~e,h. ~. J ~: ' ~.~ _ t ,r ~ r . ,~~ *, .. ,rVp1j~~ . ~,s~ vi"Sd .~ 'A'.ti . A,i , l ~'~ •t`r'RY~h 1 J l r ~--~ 1 r, o .,.g:,J.., r f ~1Y'yrl t'~Y o= "ti'+ .~ w .~-'p.f'a' ~fy, '~ n, ~~~ ~'~" ~o(a ~~ ~ °r ~ ~.~1 ~ ~~~ ~i~~..`).ie'1'`y~1~;r~, TITI_I: ~le..__.~'iTL~~' r u~~ ( cF ` _, •' ~~ ~~ ~. cl~ or A'~~ PL~VNItiG DIVLSI(~V ~;y -. ~`~*:~r,~ ,r • ~,~~ ~ L_~_~._ 'FAMILY t-'~~. '~„a~^o. ~, ;~r, ~„ r, ITC11~ G~ u.T. ~$ °~__ T1TLE~ ~l~IB~`n' ~,y -~.a:~r~., ~ GtI11131'1'~ "~" SOLE: ~ `, *rN , 2. m¢ ^~a 1 ~„ I ~ 1"' rQ.~ ~XJ 11~ 7 a C ~ ~„ r. ,~. (~ .. ~ .t.. .. vu~•~8. • 1 Yi r. . 5017'PF~ .nen~...e"ei• . ~,,~ rr ~~ Mi.. r ®~ 1TFrV9: ~ " ~ ':- CITY CLC~.IVI®i\Gt~ ~t~.c~ ~ ~"~ •~.°'~' `~ pL,~NNING IIIVLSI~N ,~ . ~ ®~ 't}~~~,. 1 , j ~ '~ i ~, I 1 l t CITY O~ ,1 ~ R.AllCI-~O CLTCAMCh'~GA ,T~~,, ~ . ~. P. ~~ -~ ~ ~~~, ,;.~ 4 TITLE ~lc~y~Y rr o.i._-s~ p-;~ Pi.AIVMNG DIVISION GKH,B,T~ SG1LEr ~~,~~;~; f ` Y, ~~ /~ ~~ :.,Y 't~r 1i , ~'2„~, , ~ ~U~~f.~; , ' ,~ _ ~ ,~ ~t u, ~,~; ~~ l~ ~.J LLL/// CJ U ~ i ' rN ... 4Q~1! ~ I • 9B 0 h /• ¢~ ~® /l•• ~ ~~ ~yy M~ TT ~ IJ a~ 6~ , N® b Wt.b ras•scnBS-~~ l rtsT e!s- p~ ss a Fa E! n T R Y C B B R 1 ' ~ q, z i Y A tt ! it h d o ~i-f' ~r- ~ I ~ ~ ~ y _© ' ` 1~eaD-, s%eDT-"Clk4! Bann/rn4~YSg0Ue.~__-.- p ~6~If-I~~ ~ n p u ~ ~uitJll... 110 4~l~ CGRp 9 BR D !CAIl~ ~~ I~GfzTr-i ~~~~~~I ~® C~`i ~~'~~):tiC'tr~ ~tTLC ~~~-~= ~I~ A-~- t~.ai•,t PL:~~IiVI\C DI~'ISIG:~ t~;tit[3tT 'E~ St;~oLC y~. I e~z -7 . o ----® e IY" ~t16 CE r Ca _~ __._ 6e ~~. Ga2D 1..J - ~:.:~r• r ~ ~ s ~~ :: _ L .. r (~w ~®/ i Y ' _ ~ f '~~' / [-~~ ~ i J ~~~~ V !'~"~~~ ) ' '`-' f ~ ~-7 r ' ~ V //, v ' /~ `~+ (o~ /, ~lY ~l .sa ~`~-_ ~I. _;~, ~~J Lam-- .. ~ « '• j _ ~ .. v((•~~~ lam. ------ ~ Y ~ .~ o '~ o-; ~ ® o L E ~ °~ 1-~-----n---~ ~: ~_ i~.''rt`:~ ~1 ~ ,~. CrrY or ,~ RA,I~'CHC~ CUCAIV~®~'~~, r„ s~. PLANNING DIVISI~'V ,.~ , .. , r. ~ ~~ ^ ® ~ ~~ ^ m ~_.~...~ ~,. :ry~~,,~ .~ -~r~-x.«~t~o ~~v~'~o i i ~-'`,.1 ~olrrl-I TITLC~'~~_~ F 1~ .,. I~XI-11131T~ °1/r 5~ALG "~~; ~. 2 of r :> :,;~ „~ ,'~ ;, ,i~,- S~',~ ,2 ,~ FORTH ci~Y ar R~~1'CHO CL'C~1~-IO\~~ PL~~INI\~ D11~LSIOV '~,~°~ , '~r~ s~ ; ~, ~"' ''? ~x~ tTCJi• ~•~o. r. ~-- a~ iIR TiTLE+S~wsPrsrc~'~2r ~b~~i~~~ , ~~ ''~i1 ~i .~` V t a ~• ~~ 1~`; ...,,..,. 7fNM! /wfrrmw. NO[ ftrf ew.rM cis or ,' RAI~'CI-IO CLTCAI~1®i!'Gt~ ,,, ,/ PLANNING BIVLSION ~, ~'~' ~ 4 W t~~ jR.e ~`O~H ,i ;;';~y, ~rrL~• o i "'; GXHI(3ITj ff~~t SCALE=----_ r.;,a .~r~.~w art ar, __ ' -. t r ~I I teed ^~I ~ f hb~ ' ~4 ___ ~41 ] ' _ .1 4~ ~. ~~ .1 ~~ ~ ~ I a 1.3 ~` ^~~~ '~n N~ ~vy4. I" 7 w e t. s~ ~~ 4~ n ~~~ . .~~/~. f ^+ " V ,~r I1 `~ 1+~ ~~~ ~~~ ~s" R.t-~l~'CI-~O C,~T~l~/IO~TCsl~ TITLE= i~nrr.~t}a- ~°,~{~L 'PI~1s~.p ~'i `~ ',', PL.ANNIN~; D[VIStON EXI Ittl[T= w ~ 4 SCALE= - ~~ _ d^ .`a`~ii ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ . '~ .. ~, ~; '~ v I _ e o~ 1 t a e 'c'd' G ._ ~ 1'a ~fu y'~ '4 A~ Y ' I e ~, ~~ CIiY OF RlitiCFtO CLtCAL?7Rt7A IT7IT I<'? L ~ TUDY PART I - PROJECT INFORf1ATI0N SPIFFY - To b^ completed by applicant Environmental Ascescmcnt Review Fee: ~D7.OU For all projects requiring environmental ravicw, this form must be completed and ;,ubmittcd to the Developc..^.nt Revieor Committee through the department where the project application i.~ made. Upon receipt of tlais application, tho Environmental Analysis 3tafs will prepare Part II of the Initial St+±dy. The I)eveloPm~nt Stcview Committee will meat asd take action no later then yen (10) Says before 4:he public meet:.ng at which time the project '_s to re heard. The Committee will make one of three determinations: 1) Tho project will have no signzf'icant enviiormental impac': and a Ncgatzve Declaration will be filed, 2) The project w311 have a sigm ficant environmental impact and an Environmental Impact Report rill be preFared, or 3) An additional information report s{i~uld be supplied by the appl7cant giving further information concerning the proposed project. ~;~;r: a PROJIrCT TITLE: llillsid~ Commun7t,V Church APPLICANT'S NAh1E, ADDP~ESS, TIvLEPHONE: (714) 960-?191 Hillside Community Church or P 0. flex In?_8 9330 (3asel~ne 4toad, 5uitcl0A Alta Loma, 91701 ape io ueamong~e, .! U Nl~btE, ADDRESS, TI;LI;PHOZ''r. EIF PF;P.SGN TO I3E COIIT7ICTLD CONCERNING TFFIS PROJECT: Ken Johnson' (?_1 ;) 331_~H;R LU707 Covina Hitls Ftoad, Covina, CA 9'.774 LCICATIOti OF PI20JECT (STIiI~rT ADDRCSS AND ASGL'S50R P"+ItCEL NO. ) 5354 Haven, Alta Loma, CA _ o~3~il-'{ g a g e o f LIST OTHER PF.RTIITS P7CCE:,SIIRY FROM LOCAL, F.EIiIONAI , STAY); AND FEDI;P~AL AGF.DICTL'S ANI~ THE AGENCY IS.r.Uliv'G SUCFI PEF141ITS: City Guild)ng Ueparr ant ~'- 6 ,; r ~' ~ ., WILL THIS PROSECT: ' YES Np XX 1. Create a substantial change in ground contours? _, XX 2. Create a substantial change in existing noi~ae or vibration? _ XX 3. Create a substantial change in demand for municipal services (golice, fire, water, sewage, etc.)? XX 4. Create changes in the existing zoning or general plan d®signations? XX 5; Remove any existing trees? FIow many? XX 6. Creato the need for use or disposal of potentially hazardous materials such as Moxic substances, flammables or explosives? Explanation of any YES answers above: N/A IMPJRTANT: If the projoct involves L•he construction of residQntial units, complato tho form on ths: next pago. N/A CERTIFICATION: Thereby certify that the statements furnished above and in the attached exhibits present the dates and information required for thin initial evaluation to the best o': my ability, and that the fact:., statements, and information presented aro true and correct to tho be.,t o£ my knowledge and bclieF. Z further understand that additional information may be required to bo submittod before an adoquate evaulation can be made by the Dcvclopmesnt Review Committee. r,`` Date _ ~2.-/0`~2 Signatur r '• Title ~ ~ ~,7 Ss~'.~.1'~~"rte „t~ ~ ~ .. .W .._ V. ~i PROTECT DP:SCRIPTYON DESCRIPTION OF PROJECT- Church campus including, one Sanrti.~lrv, onP C_hristr~n Fadur.,~tion hiailding, one fam~iv center, one off.ce building, with ,even tem orar relo- catab a bu7 dings. ACREAGE OF PROJECT AREA AND SQUARr POOTAGD OF EiiISTIEv'G AT3D PROPOSED BUILDIP7G5~ IF aDIY: 9.4 Acres "Net" Protect square footage DESCRIBE TAE rNVIROD~*SEIdTFL SETTING GF TF~ PROJECT Slat; INCLUDING INFORMATION ON TOPOGiiAPF3Y, PLANTS (TREES), ANIPIALS, APTY CULTURAL, HISTORICAL OR SCEPTIC ASPECTS, USE OF SURROVITIING PROP;;RTIES, AND THE DESCRIPTION OF APTY rXISTING STP,UCTlIP~S P.N]) TrYEIR UST; (ATTACH NTrCESSARY SHCETS) Empty rocky field scoping to the South 4~e~t. There arc ru =~ n=~" ~, rut wes. urE arc: rru = _. r'i a ,~~ i a,pects. Tho surround7ng property ~ vacant rxcept for one tingle tamely residence at the South La ;t corner oi- t~ jirupcr y. I~ the gro7cct, part of a lar~cr project, one aL• a cer~.eo of cumulat~vc act~.ons, wteich although individually sma11, may as a whola have signaia~cant environmental, ungact? HD M ~- °~ ......».... ....... n... ~~.~,~,.,,.~~wx~. RESOLUTION N0. 83-18 A RESOLUTION OF THE RANCHO CUCA MONGA PLANNING COMMISSION APPROVING CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT N0. 82-29 FOR HILLSIDE COMMUNITY CHURCH LOCATED ON THE WEST SIDE OF HAVEN AVENUE, BETWEEN HILLSIDE ROAD AND CARRARI STREET IN THE R-1-20,000 ZONE WHEREAS, on the 10th day of December, 1982, a complete application was filed by Hillside Community Church for review of the above-described project; and WHEREAS, on the 9th day of February, 1983, the Rancho Cucamonga Planning Commission held a public hearing to consider the above-described project. NOW, THEREFORE, the Rancho Cucamonga Planning Commission resolved as follows: SECTION 1: That the following findings can be met: 1. That the proposed use is in accord with the General Plan, and the purposes of the zone in which the use is proposed; and 2. That the proposed use, together with the conditions applicable thereto, will not be detrimental to the public health, safety, or welf are, or materially injurious to properties or improvements in the vicinity; and 3. That the proposed use will comply with each of the applicable provisions of the Zoning Ordinance. SECTION 2: That this project will not create adverse impacts on the environment and that a Negative Declaration is issued on February 9, 1983. SECTION 3: That Conditional Use Permit No. 82-29 is approved subject to the following conditions and attached standard conditions: PLANNING DIVISION 1. The final location and height of all retaining walls shall be subject to review and approval by the City Planner prior to issuance of any grading permit. Retaining walls higher than 4' may require special design features and shrub planting in front of the wall to reduce the visual impact. iq Resolution No. 83-18 Page 2 2. A trail connection shall be provided from the west property line to the community trail on Haven Avenue. The final design and location shall be determined by the City Planner. Said details shall be accomplished prior t o issuance of grading or building permits. 3. The circulation aisle o n the east side of the sanctuary shall be reduced in width to 20' except in those areas where additional width is necessary for proper turning radius and maneuver~bilii;y, 4. The temporary relocatable buildings are approved and shall be removed within two years from issuance of building permits, or shall be removed from the site upon occupancy of Phase II, whichever occurs first, unless extended by the Planning Commission. 5. Building permits shall be issued for Phase I within eighteen months from Planning Commission approval, or the CUP shall become null and void. 6. All laws and regulations of the State Department of Social Services relating to licensing of children's day care facilities shall be complied with prior to opening of the school. 7. Expansion of the preschool beyond 120 students will require the approval of a modified conditional use permit. 8. If the operation of this school causes adverse effects upon adjacent properties, the Conditional Use Permit shall be brought before the Planning Commission for their consideration and possible termination of such use. 9. Operation of the preschool shall not commence until such time as all Uniform Building Code and Title 19 of the State Fire Marshall's Regulations have been complied with. Plans shall be submitted to the Foothill Fire Protection District and the Building and Safety Division to show compliance. 10. The grass parking area shall be provided with a compacted subsurface adequate to accommodate automobile parking in adverse weather conditions. The final design and details shall be submitted for review and approval by the City Planner and Building Official prior to issuance of a grading or building permit for any portion of Phase II. Resolution No. 83-18 Page 3 ENGINEERING DIVISION 11. The future half-street along the north property line shall be constructed at time of development of project to the west or until construction of either the Sanctuary or Nursery and Christian Education, whichever occurs first. A Lien Agreement shall be executed prior to issuance of building permit to guarantee construction of the street. 12. The entry lane on each drive approach shall be reduced to 15' in width. APPROVED AND ADOPTED THIS 9TH DAY OF FEBRUARY, 1983. PLANNING ~,OMMISSION OF BY: J ecretary of t ITY OF RANCHO CUCAMONGA Planning Commission I, JACK LAM, Secretary of the Planning Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga, do hereby certify that the foregoing Resolution was duly and regularly introduced, passed, and adopted by the Planning Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga, at a regular meeting of the Planning Commission held on the 9th day of February, 1983, by the following vote-to-wit: AYES: COMMISSIONERS: NOES: COMMISSIONERS: ABSENT: COMMISSIONERS: REMPEL, STOUT, BARKER, MCNIEL, KING NONE NONE a- 3r ~'e'1 ~~ ~oa"r~ ~~v ~b~ = z~ ~~ ~~ ~ -=`J ` w' Zi yo $`` S ~ N ~yy ~ ^`m~ ~ `~' ; ~ ~ m " ca yy q pp~ A M ~ w N V q ' ~ iY ~ ~ D,~ g 4 N _MQb ~^g ~~ ~ ~ b L~~~ _ LW~^ b y$ ~` q~D VW ~y N=u~ ~~ q ~i7 ~{p~ L 4J ~p yrC ~^qe Q~~ 9~f~~ j~C ~~ ~~ yDYJi o~ ,~ o r a ~ ~~~ Eg ~ ~ E ~ '< ~ .S~S ®~ ~`c~ gg It °}y~, ~~~ 'e^y~« ~^~~ ~~~~ 6 Oyu C~~S n` u .c a ~ i ,. b 23 a .~7 ~: ~$ a ~ ~= 3L G'' ~ J ~ ~.- r ~w'a "I ^1 ^I "I a ~ yl li l~i,I. ~~ q~ N .bC w~ lY s a~ sx~ Wy~ Y 1- ~~ p 9 ~~j~~ o ~ U~ ~~ ~~ ~'+ u y b y }~" ~b urT v^8 W w ~`~d ~~ ~~~ ~9~ °~ ~T }td~' H ~vv MI ^I .~'; ~I''h~" io' .. " e C ^ + ~~ / tl b ~ ~ r ^ r tl ~ WWW 46 ~ ~~ ff +~+ _ ~G ~ L~~~~ ~~} ~ "~~~_ ~ ^a ra ~~ ww°~ee~~ a C yM ~~~MCu~Ln4 G Cl "}}m~~~~ Wgg 1. '~ ~~i ~~ ba~~E'o uA° a ~~N °~ ~ ~~~~ ~ r w N ~~ xa~j.~ ar qB ~3nt6 &Fo g ~a~~ o ~ (pays L {~ Y 1] fl ~ ~ W ~ y ~[ . ~ u~ a ~ V ~g u ~~M «~ U os.a .. ~21 b .. g~~ :,~~ ~y ~~ ~~~; ~~r 4~~ ~~ ~a ~~~ ^~ '~ ~~ ~"~ sp~ LAB g~~~ ~--~ {~b y u w ~~~ =~~ Z~~ ~~~ ~~h ~~ p\~ A g W q r id~ ~.U a°~ wcT,,~ .~.a ~id a~: °~ ~~ .. ~~a ~T~ ~~ ~~~ ~~a^ ~~' 8 ~~s ric _° °~~Q~ u&u~ ~] FV. 6 ^ (.` 4 ~ U .+J t y~i ~ O (j 4 O N W aY~ \yI~ I ~ ^I ~ /I N ~ o ~ 1 m 1" ,: i ~<< s~ ~3'~~~_~E ~fr.~ fiFt a~ _ ~os~ .:a~ tgy~3~ 3 ~ ~ 9 0~ ~ b~ a n ~~ a '~ e ^.~a9~'&5~~~~5 ^°s .~ Ag E ~' ~*~tl ~lr+b «MS°ySo ~~„~~~~a~~~~ sa~~ ~~ ~~ ~ ~ ~~~~ ~'r~~ ~i~~f~aN ° ~k~ Y,,,aS~~a'^5 °u= 6 tla S ~ ~b~~ n4a~ ~Y~~ZQ ~~;~sq,.e~o~» age ~= os y~ ~~, ~~,^s ~_°ssb s ~:d pp L '_ ` B g L ~~ . ~y r+ a.~ b a J.~a~ q~yJ ~NY s~~ ~" ~$ a •~ s ~i ~ ~ ~ ~ of ~i ~ - ~ ~i o W 1 N s ~` ~-g ~ ~ s ~~~~ S ~ 8w T ~~~ b3~4 -bi: ~s~` • i ~~a~n$ ~» 1, ~>.: ~~;t,. 1 y dNBNe a~49.^n~m~ p., as of ~ y ~ ~'~ 'p ~~ ~s] ~ . r. .. A V w~u~p at ii tl^^ Y E ~ ~ l~Y~ i 'a ~ ~ e yyy~~~! ~'i'~ ~ ~G' ~ _ ~ {}./ ~r ~' g Oyu~y u a u ~Y° wJ Y MC Ga~~ iA^ q~ ~~ ~ .~L~q`X{O r^MfJ r.H 616M J u ~ ~ ~~II ~~o_ Lu Wi L-~~" Ny"{{~~"' N-,"'~`a~ N`~~9N` .p~~~q~~~q,~~' e `.i .~ v ua~ ggu3~~ ~1M fJ» i` o ~~ol ~+ ~~~ ~o u$5 d'nL =o ~u~,; ~~ = ~e IS' `cN' 4 ~ as 4~..''c °aue~.:.°. '~'uc$«.~+~i~' 't i~~ K~utU ~ V~ /VI 4Va. W~~CN~ ~N OC Q!!L6 HL{>GL U{1 O.M ~„A ~C.~.r .br Y ~ ~ N 1.1 V1 ~~tr. ±'¢.~.5~ ~ _- ~nwsRnal~a~wl~I~RR~tP~ V ~ w' ~ '~ m o '~ ~ ~ d ± F~ 1 ~ jf V n u !i ~~ b V u .. t ) :± ~~ N r~ ry y Y ~ ~ ~ ~ C v ~j tL `~+V ~T uy t~^u~ ~ "yN~ ..~ ~~ ~~ gg~ •~ 5 u ~ o~~y '~ ~b ~ MN ^ ~ I n~ •- ~Pf L ' X3 o~ ~o '~ k V a~ ~ n .. °~~ ~ : - `° F ~ ~ „v .. ~` ~ d w~ „ ~ ~ ~ ~R / N ~~ n uN ° ~~ F t °1 ~ °: ea ~ n` ~"^ n~ ~,~ .~.. ~^ b i ~~{~n l Lu w :~v~ ~ ui3N F~~ S a ~ . u ~ ti N„u.LL u ^ri~ :i ~ .~. ~~t~ ~ a p ".'~..~.rn-.m r„4~ ~,a e~ ^ ~ k1:~ ~~~~ r '~~ e ~~ ~ ~ &~ ~,,; ~ r~~}fit t ~ , ~ ~ v e, , ~ 4 ~ i I '~ ~ a ~! ~; ~I ~I ~ ~I ~i ~l ~ ~i ~i ~I ~,i ,,; ~._~ = ; sup =~ mM ~° W ~ b~ `fi is 4l~ mN ~ -. n F~., °~ V ~ i'=c'~'~'~' ~,4yr ~ ~~ ~ iii rt5 ~ mii~ ~ ' ~ 1~ ~ ' ~ L' ^ 2 t .. ~ b~P m~~ w~ ~ ~ - ~ t ~ 4 , ~'~ '" c ~, ~~ t'S a~uY.~ ' ~a Mfg u s w i MY~' ° "' ~ ~-`'~ a '- ~ ~~~ ii " - ~ 4 ~ u d a3 ,~ .. ` C 1 (~ t Y 1U t! V 4 i ~~ O 4 C 8 i. v U V ~' .- U V G „ - N V j ~~ ~ ~~i U .. ~v a.' U -'...Q 1. r`a:, ~~ v c) 4 ;~ ` uvc ..1V., `n nf1 ~; x~N y p+"~y uu ,1I ~ T~ 0n ~It ~•~ ~m~ '01 V `y u _ " M V,°_~ _ -'i" '~ 3 as ' 4 ° 'nia + ~' ~r.. u < c u ~~ a ~ N ~~ ~ u. o p u e r. U 4 ur "' ^= r " : 6 ~Y., ~ P. +y N3 " W ' ~' ` va ~ ' ` ~v ~P L~r~ - ti l ' o ~ :B EL, V ~ ~ u• a •n ~y 6 G < n ~ Q v] ~/~ N w 4 4 U l~ 4 ~ N« n lJ LL F- M 1S N ~n N i~ ~ ~ 4 •- ~ V U'- \ I i \ I vi rl ~ \ I I \` I " I o'i \ 'I \\ ~ 1 \`\ ~ 1 ~i ~i ;, ~:~1' ~ ~ r ~. ~ ~) i ~~Y!~11 yC~ L"'Qp~M; _ B .°.- ° a 1~! 'aH = tlNga.~ ~.. ' g..°^ ~~ o3 Q= ~ ~04-~„ u~8 e.F~tEky ~'s'i° y~~=~~~ i~ .^~~ a..^ N" °~ ~ w' ~BS- S+3 hg~~+~ks8 ~~~ ~gg`~ ~~ b you ~O `°+~ ~~yT ~ w~bM n~~~ ~E!~ju=Y! ~~eu ~•'~Qu° $ Yl ii w< ~~~w ~~m ~i}i ~$}Iy~gw ;(~1- p.Tn`M wn AG a~~p ups ,~ ep 4~. 'lti ~^ ~.~. ^ _ ^vl °al p ~ ! VIYVVI ~~00 CJ C~~~L Y.mOY 4U~G/~~4 ~ ~ tl~ ~5 ~~.6 s~5~`o d 4 a .: a d o fi ~m m, a ~ ~t :t$u ~II~a ~~w~lj 0~, ,~1~~,w '°~ .-I~ i^1 i7 k'u ~~ {p~1 U yY, y ~ c, AYCC ne~ q~ v yr ~T~C ~ > y^~ V -^ uN i)~W Ol . u a 4 y ~ggY~~ 1] Q q~~q JM K ^ ~ ~ ~ ~ p~ a` ~J'``!{~,•~ ~} n i!~s o ~~a~ o:{ Wsi m p1 }1 wy'~ u`~ ~ J Lu NV~ u y :f p u u ~55 o Y y F' ~ '..v' +... ~ '. ,, .n ~ 4 i~ w ~ lM1 ~ •,~' ~~u?? "}"},~;;~ o `°' y w '% -~°a emu. viu ~ ~uulr i s cu'8r',~ u`, ~"~'~ .n ` .i uo' u v uua'3 'Jo tJ~Fas ~ ~ i~ v. \\\4~ \~j' v~ f ~ i' ~~ :rr _ ~" A ~~Opp ~ NI " 1 I W ~I NI ~I vl ~ .. ~ ~~t' ~ ~~ i r~, V 5~'"FY ~n =~ io uc ls'~ ~ \ / ~{ w \ ! J „~ ? u 3z „i a \ 777 ~6 U3 ~r ~ ~~ ~ ~, ~ 4^~L a°~;~m o r ~ S w =` =~~ ~Ll7;;~ a mil :. M ~ ~~ m r£.N ~o~u~ ~ ". Y ~ "NO ^~w Ym` - oti~p3 u ~L''~ ~ G~ ?LW Yl S ~ - trT M • ~., P L~ 0 4i ~ r~ ~~ Yi " y Y ~ ... Sr y U 1y~~ d e Ll 3L c i .` . ' ~"= ~ m W ~~( ,~ S ~' Mr >v, t. !. i. ur rl 'r~ rn .., 1~ V [n Q ~i~ ~ `. u ° ... ~ ~ ~] T J W ~ ~~ L n YJ w ~ S ~~ " v)i~^y u ~ ~~ O ~ Ir .. , u ~ 1~ c LaM ~ ~ ~L; a i~C -'~ `..Ll~~p~' y , ~ y ~t hN;, ~P ~; C k ~~=~ 4~ ' <+ h : "~ ~9 ~ wki~;,~ Y ~ :i I a~" ~N x ~~iu v i u rr i ~:1 , .,u o ..,w ..~~~r i i ] ~~ ~~ \ JI \I ~I ~ 1~ ~~~~ . r00 .-P ~ ~.n ; w ~~ u ` ~ ~ g, ` ~ ~ ~ u L :7 / ~ " ' n V NY^ ~!^ ~ L V " ~ u 1• v u^i ~ ~ '° L .:. .. ~ n 4~ :: W~& aOU ~~~ ~, w" w. ` y ~ iL ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ r ~ L ~~ 4 C r y 4 U ~~ ~ M N'Y Li ~~ ~ ~JN T~ ~n ~ L` v C `, _ I { °r .~'~ u ' ~ ~ c ~ d~ ~ " ' ~`~' 'u I " r w1 ;~~ ,~ d~ r y Y,m ' V r r ~NL pn ~` ~ ui5~ ~' „'. ii ~i N ~ . ~i ti_ T I a _ .+ ~ rj ~ ~ ~ u V ~ , tt w u~r ~t .~+. L rr ~ L, .. Y /I -1 91 ~I ~ M1I WI •I Vl:~r ~, N r y',~ ~ 'au L t• `y rr r k~ 4 V L4 A " IW N _~ ~~~^i' W~u u~~ a N u ~i n~ V'C t {1~ V nt q y v L ~) 2 FI ~' v~ (L r i •~ tD W i~• CI N rlu I] v~ m x u ~ P ~y N C O m ,r 1 ~ ~ 4 ~ rte. !I Q L U J~ ~I Ifl N WI mM .rL1y 4 y ~ ~ p~^ - u ~ 5 ~ SA 2 z, .. S _ ~ .n ~ ~~„ R a $ e 3~ ~ ~ ~ ~a ', W ° °' o ~ ° c , ry« L~ pp ~ L~ ~~a ~ ryry _D U ~ `~ 4 q Y ~~ O ~~ ~ ~u ~ ~ ~ 8i `~{' ew « ~ E ~ 4 N Y p~u i! ^ 14 tl~y ~ ` ~ ~ p~ t x~ Y ~~ ~~ M C ~r~ ~ '~ N ~ ~ ~ L tl~VNL Y~ tl N~~ ~ ^ Y~ ~ ~, ~~ Y Y .~ NA ~~v~1 ~~~ - Q`` W G 4`y` Q /L j~ L~~ !r~ '~ \y 1 ~ N Fj I ~ I .,; . 1 ti 4 .U ~. ma~ ~ w r ~ ~ r < 3 ~ ~~ ~ ~ m ' ~ ~' ~ l ~ wu ppp~ ~ ~ i~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ LM ~ ~ pp ~ - L! ~ { ~ y ~ ~ nJ J Y pL ~' ~ ~ ~ y N q 4 sf O ~ Y Y O = U 8 u X13& = Q : ~ u Y1 u ~ 1'! f~~' ~ Y '~'Y '- :1 M 41 u Y .'~~' '~' c ~~ 2~~ ` '2 ~~~ ~~a= ; ~ ~ '~ ~ II ~ ~ ri ^a B ~ 5~~ 'g ~~' ~b ~~Afs ~"g ~~~~ ~ ~ - ~ ~~s d a ~q 3~ ti"' - ~ \ m M ~ ~ N d o ~ m c ~ n "~ ~y no ~: ~ m ~ r , ~ u p 1-O r LO ~rS ~ 4J ~(~i~w ~ ~ 'h-~ ` v I- 01 r~.S L Q S N y~~ Y ..C ~- -- v N.-. C ^I 8 N I ~ ~I ~ VI I m~ N v \AI JI I O 4 •~ j y G~ • I' ~~ i ~' ^' CITY OF RANCHO CUCANiONGA ~tiro~ S'~.f~FF ~tEPOI~ 1 ~~ ~ ~ .~ ~ a r O O F- M~ Z ~ a - ~9i7 DATE: May IG, 1984 T0: City Council and City Manager FROM: Lloyd B. Hobbs, City Engineer BY: Barbara Kra11, Engineering Technician ' SUBJECT: Acceptance of Real Property Improvement Contract and Lien Agreement submitted by Hillside Community Church for CUP 82-29 located at 5354 Haven Avenu e CUP 82-29 was approved by Planning Commission on February 9, 1963 for the development of a church and related facilities on approximately 10 acres of land located on the west side of Haven Avenue between Hillside Road and Carrara Street. The attached Lien Agreement is to guarantee future improvements of the street along the north property line. These improvements are to be constructed at the time of development of a permanent Sanctuary or when the property to the west develops. t1ECOtg4ENDATION It 1s recommended that City Counil adopt the attached resolution approving said Lien Agreement and authorizing the Mayor and City Clerk to siyn same. Respectfully sub fitted, ~- LBH :Sao Attachments I~ ~~ ~~ ~y~] ..w~.r-+ E`'1 webs. • r~ ~ JS•~` ~~ ~ ~ ~` ~ ~,'_^` •~ :1w l ~i .r ~ . .+ '~'` ' - ti , i CITY Of' ItrlNCl•10 CUCrl~110NG~1 t't l"% .:.yelp.. „ ~ •p, LYU~ ~~ "aS 1 ~; '~-:'r '>o LNC;INE;rRING Di~'ISION ~~IJI ~pW "- ,y7>~"' ~'ICiNITY ~1~P 1 ~ ~'" 1 ~ papc ~ ~~~ _ , RESOLUTION N0. B4-126 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COIINCIL DF THE CITY OF RANCHO CUCAMONGA, CALIFORNIA, ACCEPTING A REAL PAOPERTY IMPROVEMENT CONTRACT AND LIEN AGREEMENT FROM HILLSIDE COMMUN2TY CHURCEi FOR CUP 82-29 AND AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR AND CITY CLERK TO SIGN THE SAME WHEAEAS, CUP 82-29, located on the west side of Haven Avenue between Hillside Road and Carrari Street, submitted by Hillside Community Church was approved on May 16, 1984; and WHEREAS, Installation of curb, gutter, asphalt pavement and appurtenant work established as prerequisite to issuamne of Building Permit has been met by entry into a Real Property Improvement Contract and Lien Agreement by Hillside Con unity Church. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RE50LVED that the City Council of tho City of Rancho Cucamonga, California does aoeept said Real Property Improvement Contract and Lien Agreement, authorizes the Mayor and the City Clerk to sign same, and directs the City Clerk to record same in the Office of the County Recorder of San Bernardino County, California. PASSED, APPROVED, and ADOPTED this 16th day of May, 1984. AYES; Wright, Buquet, Mikels, Dahl, King NOES: Nome ABSENT: None o D. Mikelsayo~ ATTEST: Beverl A. Authelet, City Clerk 3p ,,. , ~, , AECOADf17G REQUES'T8D DY: and tfHEN RECORDED MAII. TOt Cl1'Y CLERK CITY OP RANCHO CtJCAMONOA P, 0. Box 8117 RANCHO CUCAMONCIA, CALIFORNIA t1F7b0 REAL PROPRR'S'Y TMPAOVEMENT CONTRACT AND LIEN AGRERMENT TN1S AGREHIIBNT, made and ontered into this day of . lfl~ try and botween x'°"11 ~^~%~±~ ~,:+~..«ia OF 1C: Fa~Sfl: SLJt117IST (horelnafter refortad to os "Dovoloper"), end tha C1TX OF RANCHO CUCAMONOA, OAWFORNIA, s munlotpel corperetlon (horelnafter refortnd to es "City"), provides es (oUows[ S WH£RBAB, ns a ganoral oondltlon prooodent to tho L•suanoe of a building ~ pormlt for D, R. 82-0D. ftlllslda Community Churoh, tho Clty roqulres tho oonetruotfon of miming of[-alto tt+oot Improvoments lnoluding ourb, gutter, osphnlt pavlt[B and - appurtonant work ed)noent to tho proporty to ba dovelopedl and WHCRBAS, the Do~elopor deeiros to postpono eonstruatlon of such Improvements untU s later doto, as detarmtned Dy tho Cltyi and tYFIEREAE, the City is egroeeble to ouch postponement provfdod that the 1, Devoloper enters into this Agreement requlrtng the Dovaloper to oonstruct sold Improvement., :; r" experoc to the Clty, attar domand to do so by the Clty, which sold ' Agreement ehaU also pr,wido that the Clty may construct sold Improvements (f rho Lwelopor falls or nogla•fts to do so end that rho Clty ahaU hove a Ilan upon the real propert;' henlnofla aeearlbod oe aeourlty for the Dovoiopor's performanoa, sad any ropeymntt due City. NOW,'t'HEA£f~ORE, T[iE PARTIES AORG£, 1. Tho , vr,lonor hereby egroos that ttroy wlU InsteU of!-site streot r [m?rovemr s IncludlnQ curb, gutter, asphalt poving and appuRenant work !n eccordaneo ~ and comp,,ance with o11 eppllenblo ordlnmmo+ resolutions, rules and regulatlom o! the City In offset nt rho rhos of rho fns~nlletlon. Said lmprovemenu shall be Installed upon h and rlong future attest looa[erf on nn; ~hcrly property lino of sold pro)ect. 2. Tho mstnllatlon o! en{d Itnprovementa shall be eomplclad no Ialer then ~ anc (I) year followhtg wrrtton notice to tho Oovolopcr from rho Clty to eommeneo 1 `I -- lnstelintion of the aemo. lnslaUetlon of sold Improvements shell bo of no exponae to the Clty. 9, N the event the Developer she11 fall or refuse to cempleto the s ' lnstsilatlon cf said improvements In a Hme1y mantwr, Clty may et any time thoroetter, upon giving the Developer written notice of !b Intontlon to do w, enter upon the ' property horelnolter daseribod and complete sold improvements and recover au cosh of completion Incurred by the Clty from the Developer. {. To socuro the performance by the Doveloprr of the farms and oondltlom • ~ of fhb Agroemant and to soouro the repayment to Clty of any lunch whtoh may be expended by Clty In eompletltgf said Improvements upon dofn~•;; ;,;, the Developer hereunder, the Developer doer by these prosonta grant, bnrgnt,t~ sell and Canvey to the City, In trust, lha followlrtg tieeerlbed coal property situated In the Witty of ftanaho Cucemanga, County of San Bornnrdino, Bteta of Cnlllornle, to-wlh Lot 1 of Showalter Subdlvlatan in the Clty of Aaewho Cueamottgn, Cowttq of San Barnardlnp, Butte oP Calltornla, on ptr mop recordrd In Book !9 of Mrpe, Psgp 7S to the O[tlce of the Caurttq Reeorder of ufd County. (201.101-25) 9, Thb convoyanoo b !n trust for tiw purposes described above. ' 0, Bow, therefore, -f the Developer shalt lolthfully perform atl or the acts and things to be dons under tltls Agreement, than this cronvcyonce sYutll be void, ottwrwlae, It shall remain !n full Faroe and otfoal and In ell ^oapocts shell be conotdared and trooted ae o mortgngo on the rani praporty and the rights and obligotloru of the • pnrtloa with respect thereto shill fro govnrnod by the provfslons of the Clvll Codo of the Btelo of Cnllfomle, and nny ollror npplieable statute, portafning to mortgageta on real property. " ' 7, 7ttn Agreement shall bo Wnding upon end shalt lnuro to the honeflt of the hetnt executors, admtnlsireton, auoaeeaare rtnd noalgns of Dash of the partlaa hereto. ~ B. To the extent rcqulrod to glue etfeet of fhb Agreement es o mortgage, the term "Develap~r^ shell bo "mortgegnr" and the Clty eholl bo fife "mortgagee" as ti,oso terms era teed in the the Clvll Codo of lho fitato uI Ca!lfornla uhd nny other atntute pertnining to morlages on root property. 0. If Iognl aetlon b commenced to enforce any of the provisions of thfa Agroomenr, to reaovcr any sum which the Clty Is ontltloA to recover from the t)avoloper hereunder or to toreeloso the mortgage created hereby, then the prcva0fnq party shall be entitled to rocovor its ao+ts end such roasottohle atlornevs fora ae eholl 6c nwnrdod by the CaurL ~„ 2 CITY OF RANCHO CUCAMONGA STAFF REPQ~T DAB: September 28, 1988 T0: Chairman and Members of the Planning Commission FROM: Brad Bu11 er, City P1 anne r g1': Beverly Nissen, Assistant Planner SUBJECT: ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT AND CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT 88-10 - - e eve opmen o a as er an or a urc consisting of a sanctuary, administration building , education/nursery building, and Family Center on 8.5 acres of land in the Very Low Residential District located on the west side of Haven Avenue between Carrara Street and Hillside Road. APN: 201-101-25 RELATED FILE: CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT 88-38 I. PROJECT AND SITE DESCRIPTION: A. Action Requested: Approval of the Master Site P1 an, Conceptual i;raai-ng an , onceptual Landscape P1 an , bui 1 di ng elevations and issuance of a Negative Declaration . B. Surrounding Land Use and Zoning: North - Vacant; Very Low Residential District (less than 2 dwelling units per acre). South - Single Family Residential ; Very Low Residential District (less than 2 dwelling units per acre). East - Single Family Residential; Very Low Residential District (1 ess than 2 dwell i ng units per acre) . West - Vacant; Very Low Residential District (less than 2 dwelling units per acre). C. General Plan Designations: Project Site - Very Low Density Residential (less than 2 dwelling units per acre). North - Very Low Density Residential (less than 2 dwelling units per acre). South - Very Low Density Residential (less than 2 dwelling units per acre). East - Very Low Density Residential (less than 2 dwelling units per acre). ITEP S PLANNING C ION STAFF REPORT CONDITIONAPERMIT 86-10 - HILLSIDE COMMU~ CHURCH September 28, 1988 Page 2 West - Very Law Density Residential (less than 2 dwelling units per acre). D. Site Characteristics: Gurren tly existing on the site are three emporary mo u ar uildings which occupy approximately 11,520 square feet and Parking Lot A, consisting of 100 spaces. The remaining portion of the site slopes at approximately 8 percent from north to south. E. Parking Cal cu] ati ons Number of Number of Type Parking Spaces Spaces of Use Ratio Required Provided Church 1 per each 88 100 (Existing) 4 fixed seats Modulars (350 seats for Phase I) Church 1 per each 375 375 (Proposed 4 fixed (upon Master (1,500 seats completion Plan upon completion of Phase of Phase iV IV) II. ANALYSIS: A. Background: The Hillside Community Church was previously approve3~y the Planning Commission on February 9, 1982 by Conditional Use Permit 82-29. The project currently before the Commission is identical to that which was previously approved except for the design of the sanctuary. Currently existing on the site are three temporary modular buildings which occupy approximately 11,000 square feet and Parking Lot A consisting of 100 spaces. These buildings constitute a portion of Phase I which was granted approval by the previous Conditional Use Permit mentioned above. B. General: The project is proposed to be completed in four p ases see Exhibit "A"). Phase I has been completed as noted above except for the construction of the game fields in the southwestern portion of the site and the Family Center building. The existing temporary modular buildings are proposed to be removed upon completion of the Family Center buildings. The game field area will also be the site of 125 unpaved parking spaces when completed. 3y CONDITIONAL ~ PERMIT September 28, 1988 Page 3 88-10 - HILLSIDE COMMU~ CHURCH Phase I I wi 11 cansi st of the nursery, and one of the Christian Education buildings. Phase III will consist of the remaining Christian Education bull dings and the Administration building. Phase IY will consist of the sanctuary and Parking Lot B (125 spaces). (See Exhibit "A"}. The sanctuary building will have a seating capacity of 1,500 and upon completion 375 parking spaces will be available. C. Design Review Committee: The Design Review Committee (Kroutil, ~ lea, eric zn~ sally reviewed the project on July 21, 1988. The original proposal reviewed by the Committee was identical to that which was approved by the Planning Commission on February 9, 1982. At this time, the Committee did not approve the project due to concerns regarding: 1.} Proposed seamed metal roof material and its compatibility with existing single f amily residential neighborhoods. 2. } The architectural design of the sanctuary. 3.) The height of the sanctuary (50 feet} and its relationship to existing single family residential neighborhoods. The applicant then revised the architecture of the sanctuary building and reduced the height of the roof to 35 feet. The Design Review Committee {Chi tiea, Biakesley., Buller} reviewed the project on September 8, 1988 and approved it subject to the following conditions which have been included in the attached Resolution. 1.) A the roof material is to be provided. 2.} Staff was directed to work with the applicant regarding color selection of the roof tile, which is to be presented to the full Commission. D. Technical Review Committee: The Committee reviewed the project an a ermine a wi the recommended Conditions of Approval, the project is consistent with all applicable standards and ordinances. E. Environmental Assessment: Part I of the Initial Study has been comp e e y e app scant, Staff has completed Part II of the Environmental Checklist and found no significant impacts on the environment as a result of this project. 35 PLANNING C ION STAFF REPORT CONDITIONAL PERMIT 88-IO - HILLSIDE COMMU~ CHURCH September 28, 1988 Page 4 III. FACTS FOR FINDINGS: This project is consistent with the eve opmen o e an he General P1 an, and will not be detrimental to adjacent properties or cause significant adverse impacts. The proposed use and building design, together with recommended conditions of approval, are i n compliance with all applicable regulations of the Deve1 opment Code. IV. CORRESPONDENCE: This item has been advertised as a public hearing ~n a a~ y Report newspaper, the property pasted, and notices sent to a proper y owners with i n 300 feet of the project site. V. RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Planning Commission approve on it~onal Use Permit 88-10, subject to all conditions of apprava1, through adoption of the attached Resolution and issuance of a Negative Declaration. B6:BN:mlg Attachments: Exhibit "A" - Master Site Plan Exhibit "B" - Building Elevations Exhibit "C" - Conceptual Grading Pi an Exhibit "D" - Conceptual Landscape Plan Resolution of Approval with Conditions 36 • • RESOLUTIQN N0, 88-198 A RESOLUTION OF THE RANCHO CUCAMONGA PLANNING COMMISSION APPROVING CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT N0. 88-10, AND DE5IGN REVIEW THEREOF, FOR HILLSIDE COMMUNITY CHURCH LOCATED ON THE WEST SIDE OF HAVEN AVENUE BETWEEk HILLSIDE AND CARRARI IN THE VERY LOW RESIDENTIAL DISTRICT (LESS THAN 2 DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE) APN : 201-IO1-25 A. Recitals. (i ) Hi 11 si de Community Church has fi 1 ed an application for the issuance of the Conditional Use Perm3 t No. 88-10 as described in the title of this Resolution. Hereinafter in this Resolution, the subject Conditional Use Permit request is referred to as "the application". (ii) On the 28th of September, 1988, the Planning Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga conducted a du]y noticed public hearing on the application and concluded said hearing on that date. (iii) A11 legal prerequisites to the adoption of this Resolution have occurred. B. Resolution. NOW, THEREFORE, i t is hereby found, determined and resolved by the Planning Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga as follows: 1. This Commission hereby specifically finds that all of the facts set forth in the Recitals, Part A, of this Resolution are true and correct. 2. Based upon substantial evidence presented to this Commission during the above-referenced publ i c hearing on September 28, 1988, i nc1 udi ng written and oral staff reports, together with public testimony, this Commission hereby specifically finds as follows: Ca) The application applies to property located at 5354 Haven Avenue with a street frontage of 660 feet and 1 of depth of 675 feet and i s presently improved with 3 temporary buildings, a parking lot and Community and local equestrian trails; and (b ) The property to the north of the subject site i s vacant, the property to the south of that site consists of single family residential dwel 1 i ngs, the property to the east i s Haven Avenue, and si ngl a family residential beyond, and the property to the west i s vacant and designated for single family residential. 3. Based upon the substantial evidence presented to this Commission during the above-referenced public hearing and upon the specific findings of facts set forth in paragraph 1 and 2 above, this Commission hereby finds and concludes as follows: 3~1 PLANNING COMMI SS I'~'tESOLUTION N0. SS -198 • C4NDITIONAl. USE P IT 88-10 September 28, 1988 Page 2 (a) That the proposed use is in accord with the General Plan, the objectives of the Development Code, and the pure oses of the district in which the site i s 1 ocate d. (b) That the proposed use, together with the conditions applicable thereto, will not be detrimental to the public health, safety, or welfare, or maters ally injurious to properties or improvements in the vicinity. (c) That the proposed use complies with each of the applicable provisi ons of the Development Code. 4. This Commission hereby finds and certifies that the project has been reviewed and considered i n compliance with the Cai i fornia Environmental Quality Act of 1970 and, further, thi s Commission hereby i ssues a Negative Declaration. 5. Based upon the findings and conclusions set forth in paragraph 1, 2 and 3 above, this Commission hereby approves the application subject to each and every condition set forth below and in the attached Standard Conditions attached hereto and incorporated herein by this reference. Planning Division 1. Tile roof material shall be provided. Revised elevations of all buildings shall be reviewed and approved by the Design Review Conmittee prior to the issuance of building permits. 2. All walls within public view shall be constructed of a decorative masonry material. 3. The three existing modus ars shall be removed within two years or upon completion of Phase i, whichever occurs first. 4. The proposed modular shall be removed within two years or upon issuance of building permits for the Administration building, whichever occurs first. 5. Natural stone shall be used in all instances where stone is called for. 6. Final design and materials of the ball field parking area shall be reviewed and approved by the Design Review Committee. Engineering Division 1. The existing Community Trail on Haven Avenue shall be reconstructed to current standards, Revised parkway improvement plans shall be required for review and approval by the City Engineer. 38 PLANNING COMMISSIf~?ESOLUTION N0. 88-198 S CONDITIONAL USE P ,,. T 8B-10 ' September 28, 1988 Page 3 2. Parkway improvements a 1 ong Haven Avenue shall conform to the results of the Haven 'Beautification Study. 3. The southern most driveway on Haven Avenue shall have a 50 foot stacking depth to the first parking stall. 4. The northern most driveway on Haven Avenue shall be removed and either: a.) reconstructed to al ign with Ridge Canyon Raad, or b.) replaced with curb, gutter and parkway improvements. 6. The Deputy Secretary to this Commission shall certify to the adoption of this Resolution. APPROVED ANO ADOPTED THIS 28TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 1988. PLANNING COMMISSION 4F THE CITY OE RANCNn rttcar~nur_q BY: ATT I, Brad Buller, Secretary of the Planning Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga, do hereby certify that the foregoing Resolution was duly and regularly introduced, passed, and adopted by the Planning Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga, at a regular meeting of the Planning Commission held on the 28th day of September, 1988, by the following vote-to-wit: AYES: COMMISSIONERS: BLAKESLEY, CHITIEA, MCNIEL, TOLSTGY NOES: COMMISSIONERS: NONE ABSENT: COMMISSIONERS: EMERICK 3°I A 0 ~"" V W a a C L Cpp fti Y 1N L N V N 7 l ^aa 3`` ~}.~S^rVOwVpL S9YL q~ ''~>^V OqV RNY MY i' 7 V L N V ^ V 6 V~ M 6 C> C L pp> pVj ~ y C Z L O L ~ y S 7 ^ V~ S T V q E q y L~ N V w Y C ~q V V L V A W r N 6L1 Y ~r V S S C Ld ~. yy O ~5~~~~Y1-Y q^ VCy NyL pq~ Cd~gA qw~+ OdeVL O g V 0 ~" O qCqO ~ O C~C C L Cw^ O~+ gpL L~ q 2 O. pi L LV ~LqY L~ OC Oqe ~+~ ! _Mp Y Yu~+q ~.C. tqN C/gNUq O\f.i 6M VMA ~ ~ OIN V^~ =>~Y yL`NV _ S ~>> VMSC y 'O~ GS ~~ L~~C Vey, L C 6~d .r ~ p^ O~ > ' D V V~ V 7 T L Q O L V Y r. r„ rl S Vp7Y L OVY CN Y~ L ~r~ ' V D.~V~^« Y O L pp V C ~ O q ~16~.-YVq'OjNY C9M LOV^V Lw Cr" I°+Q ~^~^ d Me L' ~ N ~ O M p ~~ d s"~ q 5 ~~ S ' V ~. L A u N ~~ Y AA V ~ ~ N L ~+ 7 >S~ C O e~ A TO V ^_ q = C M Y C L C^ 7 V >~ M V C+~ 1v V O ~ C~` L N O7 fSV Y'om' VO O Vv q p0 VS6 e Yw a~wN=}~ eu~LC~c ~+ N` ~s°V e^e1~eS ~i y~Np ~1`e~i±°wN o«~O~i+ C~~ ~uri^o LeLi ~y ~~O'+«a M~^ q ^ M C V~ r a V ~ N M ~ N O ar3 y O g q C O M ~I C t p {^~ _eyt Sao Vq A U1gr U~ O~N> CON ^O NN ty+ ~+N01r L~~l~ .C..N {^C{^~~Y ~L^S q^• ~C ^^L 'V^VV~ {I L `O C CMC ^q glS7 i00 0 I V L ~~+O~~SV~~wA V~p N CLL St M M ~}C^A ! V OO M y~ N N i~cY~NYi'~3 .q.e°o ~e'RL'S '~s ~+~L~^ ~~~" ~ .«~e~ OCCC p C ^ C N 'r '; ~ V V _ M Myy 1 Cw~ y G V C O~~ M q> O L S '~ O N ~~ 1~ ~ S C w ~C„ ~P p' } LL w V y q^ 7 q •Ll C ~ N a M w N~ C^ N ^ L~ C O p~ N .~ V O ~w G C ~ {~ ~ ~~ ~ N Lr. ~~ q O r. M 4; ~ C a V CC i Y u V N° e 6 L~~~ u 1V s u {1 «yy p s ~^ ML C_0A VO N^ qV CNw `p O OVVL YI ,O V {~l~ UM CNM V M V M V y OC S+~ V V V ^~Q OI O yu,A ~ S C1r I~y ~Ci CYdv Y MO Nd VYq Y • V ~tV Y~ O.w} Vi.i L +^ s e1rLL~v7 Y L C M~^ ~^ N^O. N V Vtt p`A~^ _N N~Yrf~ TT}}O M L C ~ ~>1 1.1 Q {N{~~ ~ {~{.. v V ~CC i M q > ~CC CY w ~ ~ ys{e~~ V ~ ppp D.w LL pp CYY M i~~Yq 60sNLq j~ ~OG~N OVL y~ ~N~~1~~ iOA~ FCC SL O.t~ Y YY> 10 O N Af f Vt x~ ~, 0 W O a Z rW F 0 N Q.~.. S u O N ~p ~. O V {~ M D1Y L L i w V $ O OLACMOO V SSS YY LL 7 s M Mq ~CCti 0 Y ~ ~> A O C O N~ Y u {> N V y > •wC. N 7 M~ G Y 11 Y I C } ~"! N Y V ~_ 01N 1ppe M w C M ~eY i O V~ ~f~ C C L O r ^ V N M V V Y N C C C 4 4ppp ~ ~ q ~ A O. 0/ MO ~~^~q0 CC+' C ww O pL « N ~r 7 w` r C t V Y y T~ _c ors p~ ae" pe O O q Y ' N C C~y M^~ V q 0 {L Y ~ ~ ~ v C s V .~ C O q D ~ Y~ ~ LY M V q p ~ x ~ ~ ~ a i+ ~' ° u o '~' o 6S L ~ V 7,r ^ ~ ~ V ^u l~^ C V A ~ N~~ 4 ~ ~gpq~oo"w O ~J d Q N A ~ ~. ~~ C V N~ i V i_ C ~+ ^ i ' L 70 Y~r~ ~ q~ i C^ ~" C O SS ~ V l a ~ t > V ~ ~ C L ^ ~ ,mom _ ~ ~Z'~ are > ° _~° aua '~ Y {y~ ~ L ~ ^L d~Owe7~ M O A ~ ~ d C C ~ G i O g p V Y N~ ~ 0 ~ u o ~ $ ° ~„ v ~ ic~ w ~ pae~ .~+~.N+ du > c s > qc ~i~+ge~~c . ++ V 7 J pp.-. V i pp O. LLN y TO} Y~ ~~ i N N `L = O ! q 1~ q `~ ] N g N t N ~ ~ _ V w ~ ` E U ~- J w N "7 f H1 ~3- ~ 8 ~- ~ O_ u u W 1~ ~~~ ~~~ \i"' fl F•• ~..~ W d AO LY OI {G~7 >>~ OI ~I >.Y. 1~ ~ .Y L~N>.C 0l~ 61Y • O L~rW y rr~+s G10^ G>OLIO«YOyG d~~LC~L 01 GON C O~ yp ,_O1 y ~•K r s c Y w L Y r~ •~~a.°1S o4rtr 9daGi~ {~~°ao ~ .;~~«L.~a .°,~°e ;~ °a~~ a~`~p GM ~ O...N w LM 6NOY O D.N aNCZ w d'.~ NppO N C O.a ~Ns Oww wL> tN Vp N O. L Ys N d aYN~ CCVCV~ OyOywyVOVUO t7 LO C4~~^C dw'~ r .S^YN 00 Y w'R' $`wYw YrNY '~O~ ~ 6Y w 'j v~N ~ wLwe 6YY p •r Y ^w1~ =^^O ~~y.v~ YCC ~dV^wU~ Lv C.Y. q =M 6pA oC O~ L L ~I M L 3 N ~ 8w ~ O w` d w D C C7 w ~O ~ O Q 9 60 C M r U1 Y~ •i1 C M V ,C Y 7' }~ 0 0 ~~ N},, j• >^ ` w t n Y N q N~ « C O w~ CC I ~ L j L e O d ~ E C M a N C G Y N 7 L N~ L Y ~ L 6L1n~ pNVL wC~~^`+~ry O~GY~V^ ~9Y b. T Y1C w~`` V OY' V 7Y Y^NNCC~ M_K ~Y ~+G^ 01.^.~ KOt ~ A 6 N C V "" ..G. M Y w ~' r OL I W$ X 0 0 wpp ~ V= w~ y} L ~_ ~ w ~ a ? .. ^0 10 0t N ~Y yo w O N O y U G ~^ L G {1 N' d C O O. w M N y O L~ C {~ i~ ~• ^ Y C GM L d pn.~ Y yyyp~r M4L 7r OQ C•~l ~VM ww'0~ wMN Y L GLf d~ O y~ G~ ~ w~ •.J N O w M M ~ L Y C O~ C Y~ V N~ O L ^ O ~01I CC CC ~ ~,, ~~ V L~ .~ r r ~^ yy ~ r w w ~ L r 0 s 6 O~ N ~ C ~ M^ •' .w- Y 61 M N ~ pI r C t C qq~ Ors{~ ^q^ f rrrC rAw C~C CC N N^ 1N0 LAC ±C~CG a^r NV~rMwN ~S wGY~n~ wL~Y u~ «Y}Q N~ t OI _ 6N w J w x N ~^ d C O C {I id ~ 0 d L •~ V C' G p r Y r G~ N w 7 ~+L ~C^ D ~~47 N O NN^w C$ CNVY a= b w Sm LY !w~ ~Y M OM^ w~' • OIQQQ> d ~La Mw ~^ oy ~L ~~~~ ~CNNY^'O ~~Y ^~ p1~7n sq o y~ N 10 «I {1' ~ o~ LL w~ ~~11 c orO Q G~ a a w~W ~;Y^C r NY~N VT~ ~Cr.Y ;~Yp C~`e N Y ~w~wN V' ~~ 9 NTOIr O~L ~>Y ~•.^O ~~jJi ~'LM r^ ~T CMC ON O 1: C M^yl'. GN OC +.^ V~Y N CNb 01 C wL^ ICY q ~w0lI~w~ =w O Vd~L~G A~~YN G~ OMOG 7r Lw ~ Is .>. ~Lr 01 ~`~CC ~yr r~a1 r'V E ~CMOQ V`Mw p0 CY >tG O.G w r• ^ C y~ M w w V > Y {^1 >. P >~ 8O N ~ S C Y s~1 01 E 01 a~V CM ~w01I ^~ Y~I Y YN M^~ C 01~~_ ` QI`M L ^ OV t`J Y C `7C 7 Cr C C~ L Y t~ppGnO. wM^rr~~~ V Y N w I p{L1 y O {L~ O~ Y C1 L J ~_ C C~ •~ 0w VO.O CC ^Q LLw9 ~~N1L LKO M C0 ~7000~ CC~w ~p ^w~ 1010 ~ f~ a` K N V Y '~ 171 Y N N L S~ M Y V O s 1- N M Y M ~. d W ~. r] C ~ L w M S N a Y N 1O ^ C r ~ ."~ N Pf r 1!1 r I I I I I ' N u i ^^ >~ 01 ~1 f~ N ~ ; ~ p < • >~O V .Y M ~1 C 01 N W OI 7~ L ~ C C G O 8 p r C G 01 N Y C O~^ Y w~ O Y 1 LL O~^ Y^ y C ~~1000 OCT O rYw ~ JfM WVC a•Y^ b _l~ {1 ws _O ~S'~L ~+ ~~w p 10010 w1O~ {L~GGG ~paeCOH OM wM L~11MY Y e4' qqn . yy~ O. Y•• r ~ C~ ~ `w N~~M rN ~ O Y 7 M it 0~LL11 {~ y1 EE C w _ L _ O Y w~ l~CCO ` q O a~ bb Y N T L r qr. L ~ L= 'C 1J~1Y YRO1N~ ` C ~w~YyL ~ws CYY 7L K~a.G. ~ w v M~ r N 4 L>, Ow ^ YO ~ ILK C10r _r C ONL 7~AW L a w~ '~ N N ~C Ir w L V ~` C ^ G~ L Q V O ~ ^ 1~ O q 7 t1 V Y G w r (O/ _ C~ O L d o w w 0 01~Y1 ~Y C 9 ^ N N~ V r=S~ w COq LwO Z ~Y MLM VM 01M NQ~~~ y1 OtO Y it L C ~1 Y ~ O ~O~11 a E Y C r Y ^~ N~ C~ w M O~ QN L ~' My ~~ ^_ d N~' w > V .O 01D wC CCV ~~ i~ ~ ^ ~;' O N V y 01~ w Y ~ > N C w =_^ O ~ N^ +W pp•N ~O V V CG G N L ~ O CNO~~C C~Yr a.-. ^Yyy >Q O~Ir >OI 'i' ~,CYCL~ mow' ~O^~ CCY ~L^ ~ M G Y± Z 9 N O O C L Y M M^ O N M . OW O^^ L~ >1 LL L .. C ~0/1 CC PP CC ~1 r ~~ L N 1Y N C a^ 9 pp, C O^ ~ N O ry Y iJ L 7 w G w C M d YI ~ ~Z L w$ V V= O l V `IYO YN Y C NL' N C Y 7 M _M C$ •q A 1Y100 V r~ 3w1 G r~~ 7 N T4 w O{ ~ y O C~ N M V~} y~` GY COVO Ys w ~ yLVC C67Y COI ~Y'yYNO g Lf COa Y Ca G~ ww~N V V~N Mid}4 w~1}~ yG 'V OI 8^ M •Q OB~ YMW YaO 0• .>..G. ~ Y L> g 0 W b ~ N_ 7 7 W 1 G0 ~ C =C ~ L C 01 Y N iU.i ~ y ~ •+ OIL G ~y1 C a.C G p V ~ .C- V ~ G w +' O N w Q^ Y G O 7 C { O~ C d ~. 01^0 Y' L^^ w~p ~«C C• VU C9 •>„~Lw A LYrN q~w `^~ t'tY Lw Nt ~>Y YDr O Gw^VQ O~O~ Cq ~Olr N C$17L T G N t N N ^ N OI L Y. L w w C 01 O N C O G ~ Z G S 0~ G L Y w C O Y^ C O C d D. JwGN L~ wrC •+.V.'G pw0 L C a^rw. Cam. sC GI>'. ,~ rYC•.•. d Y d w D ~> .... 7 0 OI ^ d w Y~ yy M • w C w _M ' ,,,, • A C t w 1. d L V L ~~ G Y C d~ ~ C~ Y y 9 r'~ q O r co v ~ '^ ~+ 9 ~+~ N ^y11. L w w NC N^~ 9 Y w a^+ ~ do ._ IA Y o '~ i+~ w .Y+ ~ ~ e ~ Y ,~',, L L O^a ~ ~ a a N Y~ CCt w L M Mrs _ Q^ w L) Y V q 1~ V Y ~= J O 0 7^ N ~_ I N N N Y N M Y~ V t..i O^ L O • O ~ d C L Y A _ t V^ w w M W A N ~ ~ ` L 1` G L ^ Y LLL C {N~ Y Of ~ « ~vC « ~ - ~ 1~ N M N N O N r ~' ~ N >• ^~ d N C ~ u C • C 3« w ~^l Y~ C U p r Y y C 0~ ~ r01 C G` C G G^ O ^ O ''0 N'Or Va> L1N~~C 7OC L~eC ~_C 1000^~ +•C^ aGi ~O CNMY Yw OV A M ~ ! w 'O O a YY 01 •O 7 L Y w L w` ~ D {I > L~ ]y ~ ~ y 0' •! V O^ L Y C C r•9 •r7 Q~ ~ Y> ~! O O G r O~+ ^ O O w Y d -~ Yom. Y L 0 L p N p1L~ i/~_> N~• D O4.> G O L^ D G^^ N t C^ ^1 V y^ L O 10 w O w N 01 ` V O L V p7 d O u L O L L l d 00 001I O w d w~ w> ` L r~ 41 V L +00+~1 rf~ 6 ~O• `O` V C {/ 01 01 ~ V N Y V G M~ O K1e 6ZG .~•NG HL NC l~NO NA~ !y J~C p~qA 01~ l~YOVN ~^D. •+Ld Y Y N C w w< p L /4b 1. OD 01 .Ci ... r ..n ~ 1 ~ / 0 0 V "W~ a ~o:o ~o ~ o~ ^ v .- C K •~• u Y Y y ~ ~ y Ol d g 6 C K = 1 6 N y d ~= N ^O L O. N A tef ~ r Y p d V d O O 01N~ _ ' d C d L~^ O A N ` ~ t ~ d wN O D. O N N C ° L' V N O ~+ N M L A C _Y q N L C c q G N ! q V ^ .. D ~ ~+~I .r O~ O Myy^ _ w yN N C~ y d O\ O L °~ A CC ~~pp jQ YO1 ~ o C N L ~ aN ~ L q N pi OL1 ..O. y C^ y L d M q G^ L L C 4Lr MM p0 O N ~ } ~ N f( ~ M C ~~•0 Ole d O ^N O ~• °~ Lrv Z'~ A ac° ovv o~ d~ w A v N,~t L C p0 d~ N`q ~s`=~ ~~ a ~N ~ aM _ ~ « « C N d ` M I> A O I ~ 11y~0 ^ ~~ d I O /~~ N N* L wV L~ p~ 4^''r p ~ V ~V ~^M G d G.C. O ^ w ~1 N ~ .V. ` ~ N ~ N ~ C 6 ~ O •+.~Y ~Y •L GA d oyd+d 'eN e.r Z' M ~ ~ ~ w L~ i ~i ~' N~N~ M ~ N^ t N = N O ~) ~I 1 COIL O y DI 4 '~ ^ O ~ V A ~ V~ u O A y ~~ >~ ~~ W O N d w M w d v " d O N +Y L 1. p ~ p w p DM G ^ w Y A ~ uy. c N ~ M N V p d ~ .+ ~ HMt A 000 O N.C. Y'f 4d4 L N« ~~~~ C Ldd CN C di+cdcL SSL ~O^~ ~~ ~ a d O~ d ~~ C d N~ CO L ,C 01~ C y L .~~ O M L C y d~ O~p~1~6m7r C}L CC~d° M OC7L 4r.~~ q..u Arm d O p u€j C gpLd MC LQ V CMC W w6 ^ P~ q ~ELOA D _ d d ~ ~ ~T ~ O L ^ L ~ ~ w O q~ O O N C NC y aY ~ D.T O O ~ ° ~M y a d N^009 NOF yM u~C.~ ~'~ NA O^` u w C ° LL L LCq~ Od 4A d 7V~p0 d~ A w ^ O A d O f a- C N~ w > ~ N ^ _ C° d ~dt A N N~ C~ ~,r` A w ~ d ~T + ~^^ O IV[ N~ O N C O d 7 C N ~ • .. L N d A ON Md Z y~~N' N ^rT~ V 4`W.~C ~Ny~~ ~ LdCC 0~ Z d • pN 0 0^.. ~y ~^ ~M O' C y N N d q A q N N y Oy~~ L~ A r..O y 7 ~ L C Y O W q W Ol~' t C 0 O. C G y~ A A yC Ow V •+~ pNp~ dMY yq p•~ C ~ ^ • N N pad N ~~ O A ~" ~ ^ = L O y N d _O L~r °Y d. ~~~ ~~6p~gNO~ 01A 01V~wC CA ~ N O^ +...'~ ~' d Y N t G~ d d '~` ~ L ° ^ ' CC CC L w L~ y 0 M A« ~ a C~ G + N } 0 0 Y N d V V N N N w A j~ C g T Y N d A~ ~~'~' `Laow~n'" e~p~~p N~ cLa~ T^ C~~+° N~ YY C w CLL N M q a~ L M c N 6 01M N 1 V VY~ ~ q L^ r+ G T ~ w~ M me' V NLM `Z Y wN OI MOy pld °NA~ M V N ~ ~~ L O w C ~• N O. ~ ~ C ~ V C V V Y V ~ p wL. 6 O 1> > ^~ ~ yy~ M LqN wl>L MC yy ~p1~ O y °^~Od O N N YT O a g C C Y~ w OI ~~ L q e CC2a ~~ c gag3~ H O L Y d C~ O N d~ S N=~'~> C w" MwNq w ~ Aaa ~, .- Ld w.. .w C L. L~ L^++° ~{~{~~ yuy T C yy A °Cp 0 ~C/7~ KLN Vw~~~g1 O~~MGO lw~0` <Y 1~Ow 6N ~ O1 N H I M Y y Yy d°4O o 9 C Q C4Vp L ~ d ~1 C O1 pw CC O C OrA T O ~ O~^ ~ G s 010 .TL A.L...OO L Y d NJt O y~ L' C7 C N~` Qd qyY y w ~ ^~ C .J qL ^ 7yy L M C C +L CT Y^ f~ pV ~N i0 NT 9 C C O S N'~ G CCY N L,1Tt p pT wC^ N aL ~^ pp N° !^ r ! ~ a tdd pwL LCo ~ p ~ d.G~. O.T~A d dpi C^p ~ N N OJ[ M CLy V~ 01 d 6 a C.~ 7d _ _ dM d ~ d C t ~O~r ~ L ' O OI w 01 L A ~ O•^ •- 4 ^ ~O L NLd C C d ~~ ~ pO y M~ ~ O C~ MC w p ~~ ^ r. w w^ L L B C N w` N N S L O _ ~ q c ~ N NYw ° 7; O~pT dO AN s. O AO~C ~ O~ N Old L SLY > M G V~ V Lr C d G yC L j a'~ ~ ^r L O d «~ ~ v q~ C T~r~ GMar„ N C d 9 6 L C ~~ L V ! L= V y C ~~ "^ V~ w C> > L K N O n t MC N L dd d1 C ~ ~ ` ~1 Cs C Ol~ wT ~ w N~ ~ ~` Y d~ A ~ O•p G9 LW~- p y w C p~~ ~ ~ Q y r w~ V' C Y + N d O^ d p Y~YI q C C~ d u c OOt~~ N C d V L^ '/ a6 L N N d ^( Y ~I C 7 ° .-. N O « yy ~ w N O ~+ s C O:' b ~N. ip w ~. ! p L N N L4~ ~NCN ~ ~ y0 d OY 7~p0 NO ~~~«a ~C p~00d ~ L G G r. d^ L 44> N • V • CC~ N Y ^ 7 r^ A L V A F• yr° .9 w^ d M V N N ~~ O C d Q L > V d^ O ,O 44 W M N M ~ V q d 7 ~ > N N O N ^ IL ° L~+ L q C T`` f° ~ ywdd S NM • t^ _N O.. ~d~' .~ C ddy O~a~ O• ~ L C L^ 0 ° G ~'' q p V• •^ q L y H W ~° C C ~= O. C V L O +°~ q C i0 L. A V r L^ d W C+ O N G' ^ 6l W` w N Y ~+ ~ C ^ C O L~ „p, ~ d 7 Q~ oLp CO N ^G p +aa d ^_ w^ ~ d Y L O M `^ ~ M r w y r~ A N G~ C> 6 N~ •° M+ q N N y L 1V d L q C G y_ N ^~ 01 N~ w V ^ N Lf ^ C w N pQ ~ N M N y N C C> A V O C C y 0 4^ ~+ y ~O v ~~~ N N 4 4 • q i 7 T~ A' T d N° O O ~ ~ C N q A L d p ~ O n0. O. L L d N^ A.~~ ~° ~~~ d^ A m y C O • C ~ 5 Y G ~ C t1 °~ C c~C ~ wC ~+ y A: ° M = L} V C N ~' 6j p M C L Y' L Y C C it C } C N C Y w ~ ~ ~' 'e u L d~^ `y c _y LT` N7YYy ~~ + sLOi 7'C ^_ s^ VI CAd~ 6 C Mme. = A+ 7 6N L C N q N ~ 7 O V~ d SLY w~ , ~+ Mme' L p C ~ ^ ~ C ^' ~ > V p ~ ~i>lI L~ ~ L V N N + ^ V ~. L ~ y .~ + ~ p d i _ _ _ _ + ` ^ o u c a •-to~ ^LL7 r ^ .'. ~~c ^~ ` de.oc~ ''>YY °cis Ke~cooo KvND lglrm > K°N 1~O.N tL7 ~[d ~ON~y ~C6 C KND.w W~6~v1 M•.. ~O ~ C .+ N w7 r 4R ~O V ..• N 1 '~ ~~ I~ I I I ~~ I o W ~~ 0 V 0 x ~". ~..~ W a Yis«r7 q.N.a ayi=o~ ~~ cqc ~: aiac o07+vd ~c Y C ~ t y C ~~ M ~~Ljj . ~ ^ O w ^_ i 7 C w S N P C y N C q O O C ~.. O M N N N u w ' ^ ~ N e g IYI C O G y W ~ L a u 1- m Z u ~^ ~ e ~ O Y two C C M X SL~ ~uC V.: LYE ~~~ ~ wyyC y~ ~ u~y~ ~d ~~ y «^ N V ~ Y.C. S w+ a O^` O L O O ~_^ ys vu.~ war ~" LY can{~~y~{ u}Q; o.N ug _ c _ u $9 c ' L V~ L y y C ~ .... O ~j ~ C V O> ~ q 61 L +yyt iY' Y V L N 1r O ~ C; N M= ^ ?f.d apt = M ,CY 1- w {I E N O 1r O Y Y~ Y Y ~~ O Y C g V L C .J Y C N^ Y yL ~ G./ ~ O~^ ~tl^1 p ~~ ` .~ L w~ Y V y~ iu./ L p w ~ 6.p ~ L L u Y C w y Y Y 71 C y O OlY ~~~ scQv~ q~gi~ '^u~ W ~~up cr-NN,'7~„CC~ L'~~ 9 uN wN.L. VSO QLO~r 1M~1 i~N ~ y YV q Yp ~~Y ^ CL y Y N 7 Y M y+ ^ C Cy~7 O 1 K ~ Y t M N C a 7 w y ~ N m d g O O (.i O~ + ~0 M~ U Y ~ ~ ~_ y ~ ~ ~ ~ OI pL w q « w M W Y ~ ~ ad =~O N'1~^~ C~4C 7 .mow. ^N CYY.y^ ~ w ~ ~ m~ N~Y C V LD. ~C^^6N O[O W YO O.` ~_N Nr G 3N~w a~ C O 6V w Y$«~C ~Oy ~J_ S w0 X..qY ~~~J! d ~Ow Y04 YOC OyCUy4 L~~ G _~~Y~ ~Y qmS ~Y {I ~ ~r .O ~ t LEI w r. wO ~ p C q O Y O w N >~ l~ w.' yL~ ^ V C L CC M ~ 3 N ~ tU~M ~. YMIY ^~O ~Y fO OA V O N C w i LQ^' L N C~~ i.i ~ O Y s M Y V IL ~ w G _~ L d YC A g ,C K > N + > y~ ~ y0. ~ w^~ w CS M ~ L^ Od O. ~ N O `0' ~ Y~ N 7 W y L y'O~ u IV g Y~ y p O $ O> C C ~ O u^> s~Y wc~lY•Y•s ~re B u± ° y~«i ~y'~yw ... +L'a ~ ^ C O. ^0+ O.YA<~ Y 'N H Cye~y ~'7 N4 OS ~ Ly q S..C- iY~ G w LLI C Y y>S ~ C Ir Iry! G~4r. N YY y M M~ ~~ ~ 61 O w C N ^ia~ V V N G +l G`~ >^; Y C N y (L ~ ^ ^ ~ + c '~ n= NN V y '~ ~e~ ~ ^ rl{Iq V N ^S oe+ .qu-«y.- ~~ sue' QL~~ w ~~a ~ '~~N ~L a OM + M~~ ~ u O•L N ~Lyyy ~gC11 w N~S ~Mq J ~OV~ ~OY rC NiV SAC*~ w N V4YN w p ~ 0.4Yi L..O~` 6L e ~ G wpry pw N~+~ M3Y~ ~ Y ~ 7 A~ LLY `SSY NfCC~OY r~L wwC T`O LLNM `6 ! iYp Y01 S~M a+tiy Yi T}~06V w L 7 `Y~ h'~7~ ~`D.S i~4.N6 F~~ O h~4AOW~LI `'CJ G~4d. lx `~6YL r L N w•O of y dy > > N ?~ O O .~ N P1 ~! ..C. .r f f 9~~ I I (~ I 3 = ~ C N ~ N Y d7 C S M {iL « M~ w M G qwy+ N a •O. Yw y ~ L S wL V Yu LV~ s ~~ ~`\\' ~ e'w ~ Cgs G ~ N n Y a^~ a u u .+.. CCVL x V v A`N EuA ~ Yd~C Y~O '•A~ ~ Ow CMYu ^~p~ L ~ at ^~7, Y p•~~.0 ~P LNN u w+ uDA O _ y ~.1 L _ O.V 9 w CN y f..1 y 0.L ~_N N~ r.C> + Y~ Y C~ ^Ij C • w C Y I~y ~+Y > wN ! Y wO ' ~y i L f wi > O itt y^+ ,p+ CYY yy~ Y ~~w M V ^ ~ C> Y Nam Y y CqO ^ ` T CC ~ NW > O «^=~ a w~w s+a o : No Mw pVw ~ CNC ~Lc a,~sw c ~i e ~ ~ i~4Le ~ ~d E .Y+u yO~'i sLOm v ~ a ~ u~+ Csw+ co OY ~ °e LGyN Ol .+_. B~ ~.6 S wC Yd w Yy O.L , ~~ V q ~C C ~ ~ C= {I aM Yy s N~ Gv i L~ w ^ L N Y N O. {I ~ ~` • i Y U 0~. q OOO C O Y C C C M Y O L L w+ N Y 7 ~`~ ~ LL N w~ ~ v S T Y ; w r. `~ a« v N ^~ p' V~ N w _~ ' C ~ M^ N ~ L L~ y =j w O .. N ~ y ~j G r+ i~ w w Y+ p- yo0 NNw y L {IO~ v w U YY~ O 6 y O C~ L 11. ~ VI > M> = y > N^ ~ y d"'S^ N ~ L 4 ~y M L' U ~ ~ ~ a° t ~ ... ~ d N M G~ 6Q7 g0` L 0.7 ~ N = >+ w V L w d N N N L N O G N N IO L r L O. Y~ yf1 N L VY L C 6 C Y~ tj L ` w M yl + Y M 0 O d ~a'L C' L a M~+Y O~Oy ^ c Y>N W Y ~O.Q YO iA~ ^~rY •+^.. w 0 y C OI ~ N O y L Y M~ ~ C ~ YI Y C~ U~ L S~ ... W+ C >Ir Y Y ~ V N y a 7~ N NC t O. N L G ~ Yy w ~_ + r- N a y O LC> ~ G w w~ LY N O01yw~ a~ C ~C LY N O OyY N.r d pw+ Y _ u ~t ~ +~~ ~ + Y^~ + ~ ~ ~M ~ ~ Q y C 7 °'~w~a o eii' v L CC w w win O D. ~j w^ v NYL Yi C d a O S~ N ^ Y ~7 A o ~N ! Y f~Y ~ Q C N L'+ yO. V.w~ V~ v a ear ~+ '..~ ~ °^$ u _ 3~« v N~ !~Y C N D N~ a~~ w C ~ C G N~ `6q. N= qN"' =G S O N~ C C ^ Y Y C ~ C O^ ~' ~ O O~ S w O IL Y. N ~^ Y+ ~ wV+ n~cY w c~°~+i ea ~cYr ~' u°e ~Qo~-° w1 Q T C w N M w V L°1 w~ V ~ p w ~ Y^ O C ~i O E M Y ~t 4 W C` Y ~ L N N W u Y d Y^ ~ C O~~ Y .~ N L U' r C C Y~ q~ N LI y ~~ L O C O Y 9 C d Y w M ~+ + L y Y O. 6 N 7 _w + _L C 6 N rNau.+ v~ N ^ ~o ~+c.+ ~' J L ~ w ~ w~ K d~ C U N+ V 1L W d 1 ~ W v C d _JI~I _JN~~ If rf ~I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~I NI ~I ~ I_ - T ~ i `` ~ ~-a ~ 0 Z ~..~ ~..~ W a v a $00 w~~°"5 ~ L eyp Yee^e ~'~'~ '"~ c e a voac d y v « f M N L ~ y~ ~ ~ U N^ '° C 01O 61 9 L e W ~ y~ N U W~^ 7 A L ^ A q+ r~~ t g O V ~~ d M e ~ d ~ C Q M~ d y' a°S no ~.g ~ ~ ~Jw p C V Y O ° N V J ~ ) M ~ ~ + p C P Y ~ {~Y~ O ~ O a+ ° e 7qp ~ C ~, p A V q^ CC^ y O O A ~ `~ L M p V `p ~ i0 d~G ~CNO G LS ~ ~1 ~ M ~ N r e ~~ Y Y M+ C~ ~ L~ ~ = L M ^ N ~ ~ QN ~ 4 = 4 N C y0. yON~ e1 ~ ~ ~ n ~ ^6 ~ T C `~ w$~ M~ ^~ Y G W ~ O~ E L~ Ol V I M • A dAN =YA~pl~ C N01 C y L ~ O lyye i0 N_p ~~r, y ~ N~ V L F N L ~ L ~ C 1V ,~ L 0 LL~1 nu..'~' -L o ^' C ~ Nom. L~ N M « y V V L N Y O yN~ O w e~ ` C C Y! C Y- M M •\~. r O ~ _QV G C C Q p v O dfY N„~fjp~ ~ Yw O ~ V C~ = Y v~~~~ `L tl v^cddi o ~~~N,, ay o°`+ a C C C u~ ~ ^Q~ N~~«~~ Nc NY~~ N~ Y ° L C ^~ O O O O L 0 ~y 6 C M L pp ^ ~ w 4a f' cYo r. '. Y ~` V + ~ ~ N ~ N W ~ + V ~ Y Y ~ n L N ~ ~' {~ ~ M ^ ° n~ ' N ~ Ola V M V G y !~ ~ G ~ M. Y. YY. W ~ ~ ~ N N ~1 ~ ~ ~ ~I V I G~a .O~ t•G~~ ~ ~ '~ s LL CA ~ e ~~ L~M+ e L r~~~ "a' o o e o ~r°. ~ ~ NwN~g Y~' L OISy Y e~ +V A N O L a~ Y ~+ M ~I 1V ~a y^ p A^ ^y~ g Y ~^C ~ 7 N°Vp~~ CC~ e° ~ y{V{~,~ C~ ~ +~^_ O NAM ~1r Crl V O CL`N OOf~ ~ Y~ ~ 7., wL L y~ L~ mi pp ~+ L Y... `, yy NNq yp V- V lOYYO OIt ~ y _pY~yYM Y~ O~ LC ~~ L^C7M ~L 9 N O ~I 1r C~ 0 }+ ~I a Y G± v~ L ~. 4 N y}1 r E ; L ~w {e~ {er ~ y Y O' ~ D O~W Or.. aL.N LiV ~M K~ GL G GA O i~ VV ~ I ~ M f Y1 10 O A~ ~P C ~ ~C O~ LNLY~ O ~ ~ . C O C~ ~$ ~ L Ow N ° ° ^ ° ~ M~ L Vy • 4 N M ~1 O M 'O O~~ C^ A .~ L~ N pCL~~0 {L~O`~ ~ ^ ~I s ~Z~wM L~.C.Y M 4~^ d Oi~Cp L+ - y N {~ C r Y C L .C~. P` L C N M C L 4 M ~C ^GO O ery mil ~y~~ CLf i _O^ %~~_~O ~~w~ r°OQ,C ~° ~~ ~ ~ V + ~ N N..r~ V ~ ~ ~ ~ `m~ ~ C V n~r C~ L YN ~ AN V ~' ~ CL{I ~ C ~ O C^~ LO ~° N eNC `~^M ~V 6 N « M~ ~'YQ~_ Nw~^ Q v 6 Y N C V r ~ A C r C~ r .-.a~~ +~ w ~ V~~r L~^~ p~ n~C ~ y M s y e{1 o CQ wN ..C OT ~C~f ~_ ~~w=l~ Q~1~ Y 1. p^~1A~ ~~1-s~ .y1,~O~ yai0 i~ a ^N^ A ~~ C N E °.. C ,`I ~~ _w O.O • U .N~« ~° N d N C Mel ~M ~ Y« ~ A V w M Y ° r O V M~ W C V 3M C D C~ a~ p G L t~ yM ~ •M '~Y °r '^ Y ACC e s y7 Lr C w +°e M e+w~~ ~~O'~ .+ C e M A •° ° ~ ,r M a •~ N 7 ~, c pp l- L V ~~ ,^~v •~ LN 6L 11er O L Y ^ r Cr ONO L ~CL Q~~ 4 •~ e i ~ 6M O ~ V ~ = V G ~ « ~ Ol ~ O ~y ` O ~ C ~ _ ~ Nye ~ ~ A O ~ °Y = L L a s ao O O ~~ L Cl P N p9 n u - ~ a-• ^ y N p ^ _~ A~ ^~ y~ L G Y ~+ C O e M~ } ~ O~ ~~ N L Y N N a O p N~ N 7~ +"1 elV ~ A N N~ C N A ' G^ ~~~ C e~~ O O fl ~ ° C ~ 4 ~~ a'~.~a ^E -o ~ ., .. 4 .a k 3 • d7e«~ ~N Cs =~ MVCY ~' Yw~~ L~ OI~~ ° p y, ~~MP AN^ t CCC O^ ^p ygpy g~ ~^_ L e L ~ yp Gy ~~ M° ~1CV~ Nw CVICO~ LN G^ ~ ^eA~ rp° q~C^t ~° ~~ ~.ye,, 5^~Q c~ ~,e$ $ g :3 ° c'colsY «Y.u~~ °L ~a ero~L ,,, °' ,,, ~ n a o _ CO ` w ,~ a 3Ri '" ~ G o ~l S a o c N o a C~G C7 OI~ OI VY ~w °L'y0 $N tr j~ V^^ay V~ ~~~~ Mrp C~CW ~ C ^ N n ~ ~ ~ O q ~ yOj N L C * ~ ~ ~^ ~ r ~ + .'~ y ~ + yy~~~ ~ O A O p G N ~ ~ _ V O N ~ ~ {~ Y1 L W N° W VV O n CD O n! !~ ~Lm •1„I < PV ~~ { + ~ V N l`1 ~ ~ N M t 1fl 1e GO ~ 1 I ~ I ~_~Z O F~ V a €ao~ U O~ Y _+~+ ~ y O ~ d L L y O. d '0~wd N s. u u ~cyrj ~ L O d O ~ y L N O C 6y d L ~ ^ ~+ w L ~+e,"a C K Y 01 a~ c ~+°J>v ~~Q~ O aQ d ~ ° ~ L N d O euy~ w d N ~qC G ~ « N wv w' ° c a d w L d N L ~$ O d o. ~ a~ o v W+o. ~~u~ c~~ ~ d G~ y Y N ~`05$~ o~ d N Y y C L C M W M ~ M N n. w~ ~ ,ed d« d a ~ + O > e a, L o. w 'O vv C C ww y N Y d i.i L L L a.°. e° w~ y ^yc y~ Y L ~w N vv L ~ yi v ~~d > M• L vd~ L r L O ~ N M M O d ~~ Y y 6 N^ L ~ L ~ '" o ~~ C w Y d O O.y C C O ~ ~ M y O 7 7 yw O N W L Y a w d a u g ew w O O N ~ei. g °~ C~ OI ~^~iv «t ~ N ~ d~ • Y .~ `o i+ U w N d M ~_+ M N L p~ L ~~ d y d Y~ 01 ~+ W ¢u d a w t A C L 'c a+ a~ N ~ W c~ M ~ w y ~ N y~ °eu w d Y Y. ~ W ~o y ~ C 01~ C ^ L 01d r a L L M ~ N v C ~_ ~~ d~ ~~a~d d~C t O O y N N O u C ~ y L w _U y N A ~~ofN u ~ M OI P M c C C w> YY N ~ U 6~ O t 7 y ~ q u Lrv e~~ N ~ L 9 7 w y 01 M W C e,~'Y OLLC" L w ~ N M V pp• L N ..^. ~ O N C d L y p M 0.. d ~ L. > 0 u " w ° u ~ u.+o«~~ w~ c u ~~~~~~ '"~'30~• rc L« da~1y W M N L L f.. d N O q u a 0 v V a Zt a c N 4 ~ t w N C N •~~• y YM ~ 6 I N 'v N _~ N N N N ° Q` u~ C ys C ~/1 •. M w ~ N Li y v W ~ p1Y c^ w v~ Y w Y N c ~ uv _~A m A .pi .~.~ ti I ( ( ~I Q N +~+ d N C ~1 L Od v v i y ~ d u o ~ { L C w W « dy {v~Y M =yam ~' ~ n ; ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ O y w V ~ N y d y N C y O 1 L y p ~ O'~ C ~j ~' ~ y {u / C M ~ M pp L L a LO. Cr 6N 'J ~ ~" •N U 0 L L ^ ~ w a + ~ 1 C 7 (~ 4 0 C d Y C= Q ~ N N O. ° ~ N ~'. ~ ~~ a ' ~ ~~ ~' c~ L N v 7> ~J[6 CwO. y c O~ w d C^ 7 ~ ~O ~ L N~ ~ Y ~~ p> ~ t L O ! p Ly+ ~N L p ^ ° ~ ~- C ~YY C s ~ ~+ d ca N L r~ yEw ~+d O1 c C s& d w C r60 Op ~ Ny Y V^ N V y ^ N w O d L O N N ^ t M w.. 0/ L ~ ~ ~ ~ N C y O w W) w L^ O A L y Y N C N y d d ~ S y K w v .- L +` C N ~ C ~ 7~ L L .+ M P N O ~ C y 7 L y y ~ L c ^'~ ~ t~ L N d W~ s L vv C U w w < L (../ m 01 y .r N tq N J td Y C _~ e w W N c ~f a W v l ao I s~ y OI e E~ c Y°. ..~ d N O O O • e " u _ ~' l ~ M ~" CN ~ O P u~ O ~ r. 7 d d ~~ N ~ ~~ N L ,.'L, d 4 .- N ~ d o :~ y y ~ c~ w ~ u~YY 8 + ~1 W V w e ~e d w C L O Z S N !~ L q ~+ w aCv =vLd O ~ ~ O L Gp W e C O Y y • d L a d a N C 7 0 w~ d C > w •- c _ w p = N w d ~ w y y 7 L C N d r. w d C ~ 01 C y~ ... OO u `' S° N ~+ C ~ d O y N O _N O ~ 01 D ~ p w W ~+ ~ a~' uLLd ^ M Y ~ [° = ~ 11M~ N Y W ~ w O 7 y L L a° L y d d O y !~ W ~~ w O = G C p.. M ~ d L y N L Ol O.~ D y O L O d _ > ~' 9 l ~ oa v C N w M u e w y Y N d a~ w w + y ° L ~ e v o L O. N N N/ f tD OC . K .~ O N X x ~ ~ s .~ X W r H W W OC O N d v.. ~~ ~~ e ~v a~ 'e'~~ ... ~ w °Y ~' S C± O C Af ~ y w M '~~ _M ~= ~$~ d a O. L s D.~ 7 iY d L r O. N u ~e O C ... ` ~ y C a w ~ L O C C L M N ~ ~Y ~ii~ °yg d C ' ~ V a O ~ ~ e d L ~v ~o p~+ t y L~ y C N ~~ OI C ~ \,S c d ~ u iv~ w ~ Y °~ ~ ~:~~g.~ N ~e~~a,=L NnD `~ +a~ L w r C d U ~ O d q vo• "'ac C t W 7 A N L ~ O ~ 1~ yr +« ~ ~ ~ O. N(.d C ~ ... d w y~ r T ~ 1 C N C ~~~ ~~ d O ' d 2 W GM M O Y O~f~.i d ~ s~ w a V ~ N N O ~Q~ ~ ~ ty N O w _C' ~ M L w~ L d~ N G ~~ ~'~ ~~ •+C {Oj O. w L ~ ~ yO ! L N A V Y~ M w c.- N~ o.~ a c .- ao w~ ~uc+~ae .. ~~~_ e ~ s w y_> L_C~ T V ~ W ~ y N ° 4 ~ C L L O~ wd~~jy' O. N S e ~+ y 01 l p'^N 4~~ d e M w .- ~'- > ~ a w •a N+OCC } ° d ~ D 4d w C V M l V 01 yw(~ M L C C O N pW w. w ++' ou O L L y e~ p L ,~ .L. w > O ~ ~ D d w n u " N Y a ~, C .w. "~ a v C N wv d ~~ w Q f L o~ ~~ C N w N s~ 'C a w C o. ~ L d N ` L ~ L '~ ~ d WL1 C N L P 14W Jr l ~O 1 ~~5 4 _~l Z f"~ w W OC d O L p1r M~ ~ C O LV a~ o~ ~~ ` a N y . 7 C~ N soy a . C M ` _ ^E C N + O C n n O 7 ay yu L O r O1 ~+ y O L V C / ~ d d J ~ L V L N1r u - ~ ~~ a~ o ~ ~ N Y O M _ ~~ L 'J L L.i ~ N ~~ ~ Y O. g~ N L ' ° ~~r. Y n C ~ 1°r Q O !sue A ~ « ~ O +~ {t. L _ 0~ yV O C ~ o ,°r~w ~' a w ~ o y y M ~ N C w~ G O V M L ~~• A Oy ° wps V L O vin ~ Y ~w~ ~o{ ~o r~ I O C A Oyu M Ca L LI~M ' M gj C r~^ v V Nlr y pe w C K O •r A L L yyy 6p 1..~ ^ .... S M {1 M C ~ ~1 V L A~ L V M L ~^1 11 L ` ~+ L C a V ~•. w N C ~r w VV n UOL O. A a N 1r. NYw Y N w p V~ y°N Cq y1 _ _C r L 7 7 V UQQ6w L O N v C~ ~ ! a CL y ~ ~~ a N ~ p N a V M ~ Q~ N O ~ y w« ~ 6 L y- C A LsL .. dab r¢~ ' q9~ ' Y~ Y v ~ N ~/ 1°L w w 1u1 p~ S w L O~ ; G M Y L G~ C : M L ~ M N O O L ~ _ ~ Y Y Y y ~ Gw ± O y~ C O `^ Y L Y ~ L M L C A N ~ L= o' O • ~ V ~ ~ N N ~ O ~ _ y+ ~_ _ C U y^ O `~ y nL^ L L w «~ G w~' C n O w d C ~++ ~~ V V O N~ nCi V O N L w~ N{~ N MY~ w y C ~ r y$ w ` y C~ ~ V ~^^ C w v L v 0`~ ~~~ C ~ y L V O L n L b. N; ~~ C C n v~ M V W ~ y~ ~• y O N C ~ y flp + C V O r ~ N ~ N ~ ~ L1 {I ~ ~ ~ D. v1 _N y ~ 6i Y O y 4 O N~ ~~ `pN a~~117 GC y~ V C O V ~ w v~ a,,. LV 7 K /.N fy C N Y V Ly ~~ Y« a Y 4 C ~ L O~ 8 L N C C N L- N U p N O ~ N C .-'_' .r't~Q ~~ +~NS " Maser ~ oe ve zou cry= - L ~ V y . Y L uy a'1 y S L Y V ^ Yi y 0~- V W '~ C Ny ywvs V60C ~) ~V~L ~~ pA SIC r^ Cln «90 C-p^ C C V dt u N y w L L L1 ~ ~ 7 ~ w .... N L ~ Ir ~~ ~ '~ {~ C~ u ~ O ~ V Y.C. pwp C N O ~I '~J~ ~1 ~ _ Q = N O ~l y .. p~ V ° ~ A '1 y T q M L L^ Ol y V~ '~ M « C {1 M~ i C Y I~ Q J C v ~+ 4 O ~~ ^ N nu L r CL N ~~ N C 7 L C O. L C~ ~~ o s L C C M 017 ° d V L r ~. ~ V 10 p n ~+ c M 10 L W pv j ^ ; C 9 d; A ~ y ~ -. 01 Ln ~' + N ' ` C A L w ~ ~ = = O r W ° ~ M y y ~^ a ` N w D N Y C S C w ~ N{1 N~ ,+ ~ 017 a ;^ L. Y y Cr « Q Y ° y p w u Q w w ~ V M .. ' C y w C C ~` 7^ C~ ~ ~ C O ~+ V .~. L V ~~ W D C ,,. LNUO uL~ Nov /- ~' C 7 y N 9 7 L •+ ~ N~ K W G~ •[ L 4 1p t L 7 n Y Y M O-~ t t ~ ~ N H M y 1~ = 6 N .~ N ~ ~ d ~~ O. J V G = D iL r N D d ~ Mf 10 1~ m = "'~ NN fI .O N Nj I f v1 ~ I I C7 ~I I 1 I I O ~ _~ r CITY OF RANCHO C~AMONGA STAFF REPORT DATE: September 28, 1988 T0: Chairman and Members of the Planning Commission FRAM: Brad Buller, City Planner BY: Beverly Nissen, Assistant Planner SUBJECT: ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT AND CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT 88-38 - e reques o ins a a mo u ar u~ ing x or a church classroom (Sunday school) facility on 8.5 acres of 7 and in the Very Low Residential District 1 ocated on the west side of Haven Avenue, north of Hillside Road - APN: 201-1 01-25. Related File: CUP 88-10 I. PROJECT ANO SITE DESCRIPTION: A. Action Requested: Approval of the addition of one 8,640 square 0o emporary modular building and issuance of a Negative Declaration . B. Surrounding Land Use and Zoning: North - Vacant; Yery Low Residential District (less than 2 dwelling units per acre). South - Single Family Residential; Very Low Residential District (less than 2 dwelling units per acre). East - Single Family Residential; Very Low Residential District (less than 2 dwelling units per acre}. West - Vacant; Very Low Residential District (less than 2 dwelling units per acre). C. General Plan Designations: Project Site - Very Low Density Residential (1 ess than 2 dwelling units per acre). North - Yery Low Residential (less than 2 dwelling units per acre). South - Very Low Residential (less than 2 dwelling units per acre). East - Very Low Residential (less than 2 dwelling units per acre). West - Yery Low Residential (less than 2 dwelling units per acre). TP PLANNING COMM ON STAFF REPORT RE: CUP 88-3~ HILLSIDE COMMUNITY CHURCH September 28, 1988 Page 2 D. Site Characteristics: Currently existing on the site are three emporary mo u ar u ldings which occupy approximately 11,520 square feet and Parking Lot A, consisting of 100 spaces. The remaining portion of the site slopes at approximately 8~ from north to south. E. Parkin Calculations: The site as currently developed with ree mo u ar u ngs and 350 fixed seats for worship services is required to be parked at 1 stall per every 4 seats (88 required). However, 100 parking spaces have actually been provided. The addition of a 8,640 square foot building far Sunday School purposes does not require additional parking. II. ANALYSIS: A. General: The addition of an extra modular building is to be part- o~Phase I construction. Three modular buildings totaling approximately 11,500 square feet currently exist on the site along with a parking lot consisting of 100 parking stalls. The existing modular structures are to be removed upon the completion of the family center bus 1 ding (end of Phase I } . 8. Desi n Review Committee: The Qesign Review Cammittee (Chitiea, ~'T~a es ey, u er reviewed the project on September 8, 1988 and approved it with the following conditions: 1. Entry stairs facing Haven Avenue should be combined and a deck provided along the southern elevation in order to tie in with existing temporary structures. 2. A trellis element, with the supporting posts extending above the roof line, should be provided in order to tie-in to the existing modular units. It was Hated at the Commit tee meeting that landscaping was being provided and that the proposed modular would be painted to match the existing temporary buildings. C. Environmental Assessment: Part I of the Initial Study has been comp e e y e app scant. Staff has completed Part II of the Environmental Checklist and found no significant impacts on the environment as a result of this project. X18 PLANNING COMMON STAFF RE: CUP 88-3 HILLSIDE September 28, 1988 Page 3 REPORT COMMUNITY CHURCH III. FACTS FOR FINDINGS; This p roject is consistent with the eve opment o e an he General Plan, and will not be detrimental to adjacent properties or cause significant adverse impacts. The proposed use, building design, together with recommended conditions of approval, are in compliance with all applicable regulations of the Development Code. IV. CORRESPONDENCE: This item has been advertised as a public hearing 'n a ai y e art newspaper, the property posted, and notices sen o a property owners within 300 feet of the project site. V. RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Planning Commission approve on i tonal Use Permit 88-38 subject to all conditions of approval, through the adoption of the attached Resolution and issuance of a Negative Declaration. Resully syb~~tted, City P~anner BB:BN:ko Attachments: Exhibit "A" - Exhibit "B" - Exhibit "C" - EXhibit "D" - Resolution of Site P1 an Building Elevations Grading Elevations Landscape Plan Approval with Conditions y9 1 .. ! ~ :I . . ; . .; • ~ RESOLUTION NO. 88-199 A RESOLUTION OF THE RANCHd C UCAMONGA PLANNING COMMISSION APPROVING CONDITTONAL USE PERMIT NO, 88-38, AND DESIGN REVIEW THEREOF, FOR HILLSIDE COMMUNITY CHURCH LOCATED ON THE WEST SIDE OF NAYEN AVENUE BETWEEN HILLSIDE AND CARRARI IN THE VERY LOW RESIDENTIAL DISTRICT (LESS THAN 2 DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE) - APN: 201-101-25 A. Recitals. (i} Hillside Community Church has filed an application for the issuance of the Conditional Use Permit No. 88-38 as described i n the title of this Resolution. Hereinafter in this Resolution, the subject Conditional Use Permit request is referred to as "the application". (i i ) On the 28th of September, 1988, the Planning Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga conducted a duly noticed public hearing on the application and concluded said hearing on that date. (iii) A11 legal prerequisites to the adoption of this Resolution ha~re occurred. 6, Resolution. NOW, THEREFORE, it is hereby found, determined and resolved by the Planning Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga as follows: I. This Commission hereby specifically finds that al] of the facts set forth in the Recitals, Part A, of this Resolution are true and correct. 2. Based upon substantial evidence presented to this Commission during the above-referenced pubic hearing on September, 28, 1988, including written and oral staff reports, together with public testimony, this Commission hereby specifically finds as follows: (a} The application applies to property located at 5354 Haven Avenue with a street frontage of 660 feet and lot depth of 675 feet and is presently improved with 3 temporary buildings, a parking lat, and Community and Local equestrian trails; and (b} The property to the north of the subject site is vacant, the property to the south of that site consists of Single Family Residential dwellings, the property to the east is Haven Avenue and Single Family Residential beyond, and the property to the west is vacant and designated for Single Family Residential. 3. Based upon the substantial evidence presented to this Commission during the above-referenced public hearing and upon the specific findings of facts set forth in paragraph 1 and 2 above, this Commission hereby finds and concludes as follows: 50 • PLANNING COMMISSI~ESOLUTION N0. 88 -199 ' RE: CUP 88-38 - h ~ SIDE COMMUNITY Ct~IURCH September 28, 1988 Page 2 (a) That the proposed use is in accord with the General P1 an, the objectives of the Development Code, and the pure oses of the district in which the site is located. (b) That the proposed use, together with the conditions applicable thereto, will not be detrimental to the public health, safety, or welfare, or materially injurious to properties or improvements i n the vicinity . (c) That the proposed use complies with each of the applicable provisi ons of the Development Code, 4. This Commission hereby finds and certifies that the project has been reviewed and considered in compliance with the California Environmental Quality Act of 1970 and, further, this Cotmzission hereby issues a Negative Declaration. 5, Based upon the findings and conclusions set forth in paragraph 1, 2 and 3 above, this Commission hereby approves the application subject to each and every condition set forth below and in the attached Standard Conditions attached hereto and incorporated herein by this reference. Planning Division (1) Entry stairs facing Haven Avenue shall be combined and a deck provided a7 ong the southern elevation in order to tie in with the existing modular structures. (2) A trellis element, with the supporting pasts extending above the roof l i ne shal 1 be provided i n order to tie in with the existing modular structures. (3) The area surrounding the modular unit shall be landscaped. (4) The structure shall be painted to match the existing structure. (5) The proposed 60' x 144' modular building shall be removed upon the issuance of permits for the Administration Building or two years from the date of approval, whichever comes first. si +' ; r PLANNING COMMISSI~ESOLUTION NO. 88 -199 RE: CUP 88-38 - HILLSIDE C OMMUNITY CHURCH ' September 28, 1988 Page 3 Engineering Division (1) The existing Community Trail on Haven Avenue shall be reconstructed to current standards. Revised parkway improvement plans shall be required for review and approval by the City Engineer. (2} Parkway improvements conform to the results Study . along Haven Avenue shall of the Haven Beautification (3} The southernmost driveway on Haven Avenue shall have a 50-foot stacking depth to the first parking stall. (4) The northernmost driveway on Haven Avenue shall be removed and either: a) reconstructed to align with Ridge Canyon Road, or b} replaced with curb, gutter and parkway improvements. (5) Surety shall be posted and an agreement executed to the satisfaction of the City Engineer and the City Attorney, guaranteeing completion of the public street improvements, including removal or reconstruction of the northerly Haven drive approach and reconstruction of the Community Trail, within 18 months of approval of the Conditional Use Permit. 6. The Secretary to this Commission shall certify to the adoption of this Resolution. APPROVED AND ADOPTED THIS 28TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 1988. PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF RANCHn ct~cut4tnurq SY: ATT 5a ',~; .. PLANNING COMMISSI~ESOLUTION N0. 68-199 • RE: CUP 88-38 - HILLSIDE COMMUNITY C H ' September 28, 1988 URCH Page 4 I, Brad Buller, Secretary of the P1 anning Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga, do hereby certify that the foregoing Resolution was duly and regularly introduced, passed, and adopted by the Planning Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga, at a regular meeting of the Planning Comnni ssi on hel d on the 28th day of September, 1988, by the following vote-to-wit: AYES: COMMISSIONERS: BLAKESL E Y, CHITIEA, MCNIEL, TOLSTOY NOES: COMMISSIONERS: NONE ABSENT: COMMISSIONERS: EMERICK 53 Q y • ^b LbrUO,Cd CNi d Nt7 L.+ ee LM ~O CLy~M Y..r ~0 A7O> A~ C~7 w. ..q CC O dOI wbb A p L N a o a+ N o^ H L V O 4 A W o is C N t ~C l-1 L~bLa~`su Lbe be"'° as •p>A a +~ .H gA~.bi++« G Abp: Lb.^-a~y~ "~«°° =° ~o.~~~ a~+y.+ oo L C4 L q ~~ b A W N N d 1„1 y V 6 A y N N Y. L aA O>Q O qJ4.~ ip w. yq*{p7I O p A M ac b,o U ^ C~ A Ait O~ •pAy x+OC >dL'~L G9M Cb~ N 'e ... r... ~'MO ~ ~~YLYb '~$va~ c°.~~oe oAe pNM~.C t9p oo.~u L M N b~> q .'U. m C~ 6 r iY` r ~0 ~~ y 4 N • N ~~ f+ r Y rLi ~0 '..• _N O~ ~+ O CJ .+ b A C q y G 01 C y^ 7 7~ ~ N b /0 y N ~ ,~+ as v bu" s °u~,AG- d.+~ ~aL+~~a "W~ ~ga~~aagiAL°""~up ~Np~" e~p ~L~•-per cvd nGUU._ri O l~L'~gCN S~p~0'rY ~~.g^V "L~ ar. oL '~dG ~ O^M CC .~ N; ~~ _° v q ~+ m t A ~°. ~ m q g" s a '^ 'O~ t o Q O 7 A d wC. N L M x q C G Y > ~ '~ L q ~ U N q Q~ N QGLa~dA 'ab+~~•~ UOAdW bdO O.C~LL fJ+O YCMy~ A .,, L QI Cab d..C. ~ry7F gd~bG bwY NL O.O rA ° ded NwC. C pp W g _O yb ~ a y d d^ d N L L~ Y C C O N~ C A G r y Y >Od'~C bgiq V~O r+ ;~ ^OA~jO 2L~: d~.0++ y N d •' q=~ a L p W b Y T d A •~„ N N y ~AVi _N y b N _~ ~ q Y ~ U ~ N O a~ tUJ q A~~ C N d' G~ s C p a _C Yp. d A y W O y IL d G .- 7 D N N C a N~ O ~uu~~p,~,6LOGD:AC TN yQeM ~^3 C^N~q .~ ®O^^ S m .C L° 4. A Y. A q> G D N n. L A 'o y~~~' ~=1 7 ip q p q U !~ + Y C Olb ~ N~ ~C ~ O ~ Oar Old q NM OINM =nN N N d C ^ 01~ N •i q V ~gI N A C~b b,°_'a wMC ~d ~C~~LL ~ GC e~ N9^U ATV M S ,rd aO1w V yA dCp1aV G>O A^~.w. y bGOJ p~ LN,rb y~ p$.:.^.^Si~L~'LL~""° a4b~+A~y' as e~~G,GGG",~~ ~G+y.N ^dA'_~~ , Ta G VA ~O pYTN ^LLNO>nd. Ar N~~~Vw ~ Ls T q ~CLp` A OMW NYC^.OdC AMV~+~ ~OCi d> A~ y^ ~T No~ggn pp C O q t a~ V OiVY ~W d i74Ub GwwdUO NT A V NN+ aLp0 ~y r. ~ Y~ V0~4<r, y ~ !'! ~• N C C C y d ~' N d = g O d d a d q L 17c~~ Y ~ ~ s d it ai ~+ ";~ yGNa a ~ q T" r y a~-i °o a '^ • ~ c •w N L9^>YC pNW~_~w`~. ~ G NW bTn. N.~d M ~6111i~~ Y,= >1~~~ aC~ A H~,Oj ~~.VAO.O}NL i~ tCQ1~A >GL ^LM U ~yY ^ NN~y Qd A O 1"• O O JD M G Y 1~ w N ~~ ! O nT o~ b `~ N T A Z L O.Li 10 d O '.~ {V N ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ H '~ f ~q _ ~ $ a ~vo+eNOOL v ~ ~~~ ~ ^ 0 p +_ ^ ~ q y0. O A N C G ~ 9 N N OO > d H ~ N Y i! > O.~ N a M~ Y W @e d y~ A A d ~ O C d ~ L A M N V r .~'^' .'7 w("` • O N L `wV\ ~ O N U N U y A W$ ~ a ti C4pf M q LN GsaL'LwW Yr~^ GtL L M ..d i°NSOd~C.A- = O Y y 3 Y 'C A N n L O iC C ^YO Ger. C N b ` ''~ d7a G ~ N' +N^~b Or bt7 uY0 b ~ C4 ~C~Z~YM^Y6NI C d V O V ~~ q " y d 4 q~> Y~ O L J ~ o°ja°q G o i7 Ngoa^ s d A W Z ~ , ~ q A V ~ T N W O~ V ~ U M~ O O b ~ Y c,~ ~' ~ ~ v 8 d A N O d A L M d A d~~ ~ VO M~ ~OrjO~O G.i + _ N N N ^ = y V T_ V` bbw'7 C W q l~ 1 y„ ~ d ..N. ~ t y L Y ~y _Y A O A L O S 10 OGG V O LO G N Y _Y } y ^p p, O y p ~ , O ==x 7 C ~ ~ ~ f L e~Y L C ~I _GN ~ ~ Ly r" ~ K e y C O ~ 6~ ~ w. J d i Y yxj N _}~ d ~ C Lr. L dG o~ W GAL G ~' _^ty~ w,w C M W Aa *A N } Y ~ ~ ~ G O O L O OtIYNO~ +-O ~~ ~ ° d ~ q ` J i~ C O - > 1p Ow ~ C YYY d W U C ~~t ~ ~ ~ o L .d+~1O yac c Y ~ r > O. ° N L _O M ~ d y ~ ~ g'- ~ ``~ Sd>> ~ N v 'O = ° ~ q ~ 1p 6 r ~ N A N A O N W ~ d .V~ ~ J -• N 6. ~ t U F~ I I ~ ( 1 ~ /I'~ .~ m O ``Z I'~ 63 W >~ O Y OI «" aL+.c. e d o ea~~ ~c d d au„~ A « d ~d ac'u q N 8£ q ~ O M N Y d ~• a~ ^ s C O A A L N O O d C~ C 6 ~ ~ q M D o~c,. C N ^ N q N Y4 9~ q 0 N L O 01 L dW' a poL • C d C O. C Sir ~ O O V W N'+~o >~'O C ie a L C ~~i 01 q ~ .'. C M O.r Li C•Y^^. C d A G t ~ .rs i ~' lef ~+ J C 9 >~ aw:~g o v.,.. ®HpQC A Ly A O n~ N L N ~ M q^.. q N~ y =o~° $u e "' e a ~=o ~ ~~^~ C r « V °u N 'o' ~~L11 G « y L N p ~ ~ M .L. ` d L 7?. C ^ C q ~.+,^€a C ' ^ D q y 7 C q N 'O aCr O 'O C M N d q a a^ t N q A u d^ c 4 N +. O ~_ C q.^~. q C w0-L! C'O M O W d yq ~9 L d « _ V L +~ r~ d a0 ~C o:N ud,. b .r 1 es~oMMO~+c d Y {{e1I.r c~~ N d d O` {~Y1 p gLLi~yQ¢~! GN'y O~ wp A v W V LL d p d« N V V O d« p c~,qo ~ o+, 6.r ~« 7L L r. 6 O q -0 A ~ d~ d C~ N Q 0 7 r.3 ~ "' w a d ~. ~ N oaov^ 07 M ~ 1( V ~ T C N N ,;. a V M~ V V ^. « O L1~yC .L d L d i Cr a ~~ ~~''OaCWa ~ 7 _ LOM >~N Yd UN qT > M C Np., C~O O~ N NN MdyCM C`CO M C« L ~q ~ Ow 7 ~q Y O N d LL. N d .~ •,q M^~~N~~N7 1~~ ~§ var' {~~11 8 d Y y~ liM^MM L C rp•LLO C N Mt~..V. ~ ~QOQ HM NNL i~M 4L.1 ., I ccee oa gwOd 1 Lr' a+±a~ ~'~ ~° u e 7 V C aC ~O M > C ^ ~e Y p, d y C ~ 4« L OC~ Lw LEA Y r. «L p7~ ~ rw q _ N ~ d~C~ q d OdL~ w ^ L y « ~ Y p !`J Y Y ~ V OIL Ns q > y C a1n a « d Ov~+ ^ a 3u «Oi ,06NC dA CL7 A N « « N Y D d c'~~o di ~Oo'F q' C M A y~ N a~~ aM _~ ~ d ~o e u G 7~9 ~ N C L d O q ~C`. N C N ^wj L N N J q C N L ,r~• A M da'0p «s r.sw N 0.9 ~ 9 N N Cyr = ' ~ ~ ~ q 1 U ~+ O L V s ...t .~ C ~' d d "' V O N •-wriq:+ uc> ~~ve « > _Y V l ~ A ~ D a~~~11 O1 a C•~^ N t C~N• ~F nC D. ~..~N d I-.=NC to n as I ! i a ~~ ^r+w ~ q A q 20PP ~ N d >~ a 4 L L ° C N O q N + O e L q Y ~ a~ N C V wy ~~ ~ ~ °~ Nr O ~~o C V C {I q Rc d L « ~3 L o ,~, you q ] L !~ 61 O +. > d OI I~ V , ~ ~ = d a vari3. u y S Lp1 C 3 ~ Q7 ~ y t` ~ ~ O ~ q ~ ~d c e ~•+ d q d ^uL 2~ NQ O\ ~~ e~ w C ri w~ L M O V Ld M ~ D ^ 0 e o• s a a 7'^0~ q i Oa b ~~y 7 « N ~ ~v~ > « ` Qd'w e d '~ V ° d ~ 0 q N N = M a d C N C u Q d L ~ ~ .~ N A 0 ^ I ~4~ L~dir s q ^aq p L N N ~C N q d uL~,~ a p d ~ N C ~+ d r. A ~~~ L r,vs ~ d •^• yA~ C Oj Old q ^ .r v~°Na+ L ~fl q~„~+ dq C ~ ~CO d ` OIO d d N ~ yy N ~ y~ ar B r C CY^^ i d Y g q q G ~ LO •dC G ~ ~ C O~ ~vw~auya€ N C C ~ q q! ~4 d L~ V Cw^. N N^ q ~ ^ ^ p « ^ L c~ N N d O p al aw~ c_r d ~'' dAa~ d ~ M ! 9 7 .C+ ^ O v ~ d C N L~ ~pCp~~ ~~Twp C « 4 C 8'" 09S }~ p d q ' 6 a.G ~ O W N N d M~ Q O C a '•"' m Li d Y .o°ev A o=uo d Oy C 7«a V ya'= ~ NO~3 y ~ 6 N d~ y N L q q 1~ LM r~ q T ^~ ® q vNN ., d~~s a L C « q =~ O C L 'L°,e° L rgyn V N~ ~ L N A L OI ~~ C Yd d W. +~ N C K p= ~ w O ~ '~caLi r° vt.l+ n q N « M C ~ s d p d N y ~ y • M ~ p,Y d d u ~ ~ N^ ~ N+ ~ O.N Y Y L d.~.C Cy Q1 d ~= N O.N y d C 9 q~b q q~ C N ^ !!w q~ L p dw o0 o'w n C I] '~ ^ N ` r~ Y. C R v' LY ~.d. ~ C NO' CC a O c O y O^ 7« L g 9 q g uL«q a' ~°7's~a bt~aYi L ~ u u d ~ da C C~ b ~1 O .~ q p L ~ Y! ^s I~e ~~ A«~ N ~i rI t vt •>~vwy .~+ _v ~~cO ^u n L/ q C d ~D NrO~ ~OMC qM Y ~~N~sY ~yN w s Y p ^ C fir Y L E O f L d a !~ O V M V r ~~' NLCNUy~ r+u ^,~ MM qw A~ N Z e ~v a sN~ ==TM N ~ ~P 1 ~ N dr. V ` _ ~ =«^s. 7 4 C~ ,p O ~ C N 'O.rs u ut L ~w ~ ~ O L 7a N~CVN~q A> ~ C d dw ~ N p^~ CA v~ W A e e° o Lt a C u L O. q q wN. ~ N q r A~ C y w iJ ~ a~ O.~ N d g C L d q C~ O d C 4.~ «w C C~> C 9 Y C • A C d A ~ A 4 C N^ dp C M >+r L O^4~ C N Y ~' y w My a~ ~Ld~'vL~+NC •~ 0• C C d C V ~y {1 0 « ~-~'~~ N v C, f J q d^ a~ W ~ q O Q^+^ Q C p L Y A L ~e a` a^u.+>-L~~> ».~ N plVw ~ O ,,,,~ a~wN dL ~.~ L ~t.1 d • r ~+~vr5°~°~ ~u .-~ N ~I Y d C 4 N di~^M L ' L yl? d a r « M Lp y0, ~L O O N C C « ~ Z ~ y^ N {!1 L C L ~ O N q .. ~~ A L N L ~ ~ M .~ V tj C C N L ~~~O1z+ c N M • p w OYa';d0 Y L ~ ~ d L~ V O t pN~ M dC$~0 u c ~ ~ « a u v > ono.°+ C ~ q q C r d~ N C q N ~ pl G ~ d ~ d ~ c > Y+^ q A CCy 9~ C C Y a ~Yq c ^ ~ ~ q L L` O q N 11~ N N Y. Y OI N O N ~~~ C C C n0.0. ~' ~ d N Y V d 0/~.r q V+[ C > N^ dd anlavv°I ~L d 7 d N r Y N C q ..~ d Ol ~~ as p -0 o>o L o. n A a3 q w o~ N v L ~ w ~ L 6 a M d u ~w W •- o a a N + e.: /0 ~ Gm L ~ s q o ~ V ~ O w V ~ a'p q~il ~ C w q q EY N6 6 O C M p S M t~ n d O • N _V « L '+ a+ ;a ~vv CW '^J C d ~ ~ L A 7 4 V _ N N ~ V O L O N ~ N ~ L q .•... d > s d .V.p°~+Z c~ N ~ ~ C 4 C ~ U L 3 ti N d C N LI C O Y V ^ Ldd N C ~ ~ u d oc~W `°+o+ voav A ~ q ~ C ~ L^ ~. Ol _ pp> C= C d 7 L o ~°a a Y d C ^ d t q ^ ~ Cy,~ q p G e at ,.. O N d~ u'~ d v q °rsc~',~h N N C ~ U~. ~ N C .p t+ O ~ O C U ~ S g v y C > C p ~ o ° 0 0 0 d V n.+. V L C G•+ L d }-^q~nr. Q _~ N 55 /~ ~` d~~+L L .TWV cog0 ~o a ^e e ~ oYO O~+T K10N! Lp« +ue~ C L9 .~ C d d 7 K w U 0~ q ~ q d w ~ L d gn.CK ~ q OId q C~O OLdCH>DO ~d INN~ C > g>O.ppL. Nagel O~ N ~~ 9C yV... ^0~0 CLtL .C.'„•ddy L CNdO' \/ yy ~ u q^ L L 016....7 q O. ~1 _ v y d 0 d N 0! C~ O^ 01~ Mf ^ 10 ~~ td. C w L t C` d C Y e C 7 L Q.Na ~ I "p7 O~ ~ O G d 7 a+ U A r~ G a~ V O G qo° d« L~^ 0 N L q .O 7 G b.. q 0 ~ 7 V q y 4 0 ^d N ~ p pN Cy, gad+C OA OIT O.N N^ ~d OCL AOI r,{G tel. N C C d d 0 A y U 01 O ~ a d N N O G d N O ~. V« ~ y d L M Y ~ 7 ~ (, O C q N ~ L y ~ d L L .. L L O q 1r y d 7- d W Z p d 7 9 W d~ q N Lnn C C q C qr ~.• N q q N^ O~ ~~ C d `~ N u NM q y B r ~ d s d N d 7 + 0 N 01d OCC y _ q U N d q + C~ Q 0 y NYY. N N ~1 C >~~ q q d qo` ~.. VOL v0U701 ! y >T A^p K _7 NA Dd 3~N C r~LNd 9 QLI C ~+ y ylNdd U.C~ w_N Y~q Q ^ 'q q V N d~~ 901 r O 7 ~^ d d w ~ W C O N U~ 1-d- d y Ld ~ L L .C ... L O L U O. I adi p p N 01 Q ~ 6N O OT.- d~ a s+ O N d~ N~ d.. ~ D Lf 0 q G^ . '~' ~~ ... y q • N N {{~ L D q .. d w C 9 L q G^ r Ly ~/ 7 N L Ol V O L N d N f q L G L V N d 1.1 y C L N p17 N q d U ~+ q~ C N ... q~u Glv ~ 0'O aa6O Y.. G CC WY.art a L~ •ti1p9 6w C q q 0«y Y q T L N K M C O d A q g U y w d N Y • ~^ 01~ ydy0 ^Nb Y1d _>wL Qy~jd Ld NOd Cy'^Cq ~ d^~ ~ i C L$ e ` a 01 C y L ~ d y M p 01 C y r , 9 7 w M N L 01~+ 0 `O0 d..A ~V N.C.6 LV ~~dGg LLyy ,.,,L yCUC dq ~NL C ~! CCd} J[A q C O•.q ~.r .yNO C~G« 01V 0qC GY ~dN~ ~CN~ VCC Y dq0 ~ O NqL ZZCr dyV ~ L 9N C ~1/~ CCL C N V d _9 r y„ N L 4 N Y. W N L yL A g 0 N L C C N r C A M d q 9 ~ O ..0. d L ~> q 0 1 ~~q d 0 K M ~dyV'yq q N 7>^Td Nd dq' 6 !~L d Q a M • Y y d o L LC O d Cy cw ~9 ! 01d 01~ a+M> ~ yyN N~q Cyy p ddb _N C qLO Q N _C L.. q V L d Sy L ^> ~ q~ 7 w N C ~' eg6 q O N •O d O 01M N~^, V~ aY L }~ •L1~Y. d1 ~ dq 6qN NLO 41 ~•'~qLr•^y C w' C qtr N„N„wU O L q o1y 0 W^M d ~L~ G 4 YdN ~L ty 01q x_01 y~Y ~ SI MC pcdl a L d O ~•, p' ~ ~. q d q y w N 0/ L L L q 4' L N d d q C N d IY «~ L OI ~_ ~ N L ~ ^ y1~ a d G O1 d d d^ N y~ 6 Or. ~>, 4Y' ^ O C1~1~g L{,1I N q I` ppC q d L T~> C YY p[p y •+.-y dV •6.N '~W O.`G MOB O~q V1Nyr OagCV O. A~~~01 DC ~q~OOJ f •t dgdgd _CNd C~ •C.yd ~O L^ LL9q ~0•dC ^^QCG GO qOf p.Oy LML L Qd01 U d~ QUO. NO~OldC~ONdyqC4 q~.+ qN ~~ f.1 M C y C ~+ _N t ^ d ~ N d~ N r ..~ Y 01 01 7 M .~ D. B~ N L+ C Y ~I q L d q O. _ C L L O L^C O LC N .. 9 V+ ^ O d N w M A N ~. N r ! N = N O •• N L i N V ~ ~ L d g G r• d {~ G y ^_ C O d 7 ~. L 01s 01q N O.O i qT 00. C V 4. O q aN ~ Q 1N b • I ~ ~ , ~ ~ 7 I ~ ~~ ~ y 1 dr d4v da o°~ °~'° °^ ar y ~ del 01 o+e1 '3 d q N G O. o 0.~~ C C 01C ~ q~ >. D u 1: ~ q O w N ~ Ol q~ d d N +G• C q _q w. G 7, ^ ~« d O. N q N A C C 1 s + _ ~ N C q O .Cyl^ L d L~ ~ O.q t+. C CC 010 Old 4 3 9q^ ~M ! a+ a GGO.LL ~^ l L C ^ D d a _ _i N N N 0 it ~.1 del S,y^0 d 1Yi ~ fib. d + ~~ ~+ d Y q ~.. L N d~ ~ C y N~ L O~ Y M N _N ~ 0 D.T ~ ~= q q L qL N W ~ Gi ~dy O C N7 ~S+ ` 6 wGO.L ~y i•" B±iO~ q^ ^ C~ L L' > a C N q L i q ! q y C y a~ 0 q 7 C~ q 61 M N g t d d~ Q14 ~ d 0~ 01 > N~ 9 C 9~ C d q O M O ~- i >7 L ip C N C d L d L~ C d d OB.+ O q l '~ O q'~ q Y N A O .~ ~ a 01 6~ 7~ a ~ y d~ A y O u 0 U> ~, d ^ ! 7 C K O q q C N q~ U >1 0^ N C ~+ .C 01 Z C ~CC L C d •U.a N h A d 'C ~ti..w. 9 d diC A LU O ="q VU C y1~~ NCLC q0 •q~> 0•N?pNd C ~, N C N O q ^ L + O L d T 'L• C >L L K N nL ^' C r"q'^ _~ C N~ y~ i «6 gO{~`L{19 iddr.p d qd~ CV Nd Nq O N J.C U+Oq D•O.G3 L1L~fpp O.~ N >r O. tC d~1~ ~~1 qr U C LI A y L Nrr d~ ~~ C q 01Y d 0^ L d c ,,,, NL D d« 4 0~ Ny q ~ q y~ M N ~.1 L _yr '~-7.C. O ~ AZ yy q q y wNNN ~ TO ~~ C l~,o Cr Ly ~' Qq^Q yGNwCNN yd L d C N ~YN/ ~ u => d 7 Y C y O 0 N ay L Z$ sY ~~ O. ~ ~ p d 6yv •C qT M C^ yQd N +` qO~N d` ~M ~ ~^rL U~yL W~ dr N y + V q y 7 ^ >r" N C~ d d~ U Lw7 0 q @y Ol T O U L+ d N N N . L .- y1 O m C N O N ,~ W ~ L O q y C L 0 D L C ~+~ 9 ^ ~+ ~ Ly ~~ y C d d q 6~+ O1~ W~ n M y ++ d ~ w C~ q r,1 CO q d q Y U L G N ~. d 1.0. C O d 7 ~ C C q C w w~• Oq ~ Lw OC qU ~+pM M C~ G~O+ = O. 3N ^Aw+d17L v~ o L Y N q d O y O.y N y U d N q A N N i[ L C q {{II G >• 0'w N ~ 1D C C `.• d iJ , .' N V N q N O N 41 N L1 L C •~ q y ~ 9 q D. q^ ~+~ tdJ V d p N 4 N q y • q q 7 q W 1 Cam} d N CT y N y L d> y O1 O^ d L ` N~ L^ N C B U ~ q d N 7w O^ 9 C i T C N M T = ~ ^~ cc~ d y yyg GN7 ~ W'y b ~ L! S~O ~'q0 ~ C ~+ `+ C 7~i d U q 01= C d L d v. O v~~ 'o L' ..G. N C q iL C y C g O U L q ~ N w y C O w N y d 6 C y ~. L u q C ^ q d L ~+ >s d el L 7 C • ~ d~ C C q y _ 7 O. M V L a N q N G q f L p U O M ~. ~ ^ p1w C ~~~ T C^ Ow d G 7~ O V (~w dw y q q r d g q L y t q1 v> u V d L N N N E r >• y N '~ d i t N Ir ~`~; t ^ H q ~ O q .- V .- w L 7 M q ^ d^ L O Y~ ~ .. d d L O i q W m ad. i 7 N ~' L d~ O C L tt~ > G1 C a m Ly u C C M h- O.N tt.,) i7 ~ O Nw q <O O. i M O.q X d lC q L C W O. 6 ~+ of «~ ~ ^ C r hl ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ I 0 vi M t ~6 d ^ .C L A M ~i M ~ C d N \ v d v Eao d d ° M L 7 ee~ y p Y. p ~ ~-;~ V ~ .r. L W ~~w O _~ b N N d N O Oq a° ~ N «~ L ~ ~ s 0 w L O'C yoo LI « N y A d e ~+ v 0 v^ 'o ^ c o. A ~ oa N 0.16 ~ Cya~Na+ A d r ~ y C ^ m a~ w A O~ 7 L d S d G>d N qCA A~ ~ LL ° L M N y O ~ c a ~uy c y@c O d S j r O d ggyg dy ~ o L C > a a =moo vas C > 0 O v a a C 6 ~ ~ A uq d O ~ «~~ ~ A S' ~ y d s~E ^° W~ L r ~~~ '^+y- ~ u L M . C ~cayls N ~Pd ~ s o.5 YY r ~ ~ v aq~r O d e+t+~ 7 O C Oy' yYO.Di u d~~a Y 7 Vy,r rL..V. O s N y esp v ~ ~ V L q N L ~ '"' a o „ ,~ L O ~. YI OI = ~ C •rr. N y A v .~'~ _ ~' e ^ @~w. d~q o °c.~¢c¢QIlya ^ Q/G ~ .e Q N ~ C ~ ~ G~a;Jl~ L 9 Y C so'6o N r ~ ~ Y q C ~ q C N C e A L ~i d L^~mL N PL ~C~pp~ = L lL VI 6 ~O I o m.o.° c ~ ° au L 7 ~ v r OI N q 61 V O d dC q 9 N pl r i d N A C a 4 d OIA u N ~ L c A o d o ~ ~" Y ^.~ p° L O V D.y >I A YNL .;q~ w r va A~ C ~ ^ N d C> Lug s e ,o ~ m o •K. N = M ~ N '^ C D1 N > O C =°L'os v $ a Qod L~ p1 01 7 .~. O C r yy C ~ Z A 4 ~ L C O. A \j ~ N L A N N q " L d rr a b N ~0 Y L ~' C d Ma C iA C^ A B C d A U CI ~ ^ d L^ C^ N C L y q r y Sq ~+7 N N r L V L d ,Cd 3° L C L OI N G d f+ q O ~ C 01 C N p c A° e ~ c u O' O ~^ W D O. N r L C> C q S A L N ~1 ~° ~e c a o. 8 D d L O y ~ q V N^ ~ C y ^ C q d A V N a M v ^'N~cc r d ~ c .o ~"d'IN ~' ~ ~ ~Oq V A 7= C b N ~ A 7 W C L OI d} N C d y N M r= L t a O L d ^ ~ A y L F~ N° y .+ N N = fi r N r'1 I+I •_ ^~ ^1 C C C ~0 C ~G A 'vo~O _ '.~ a^ '~ d C O m i y ~^ ~NU O C~ od`a A L ~ ~ .~ OL d a " 01 . A C N^ y C IC0 J ~~C 6 O+C W O~O~ V O N V ~ W Rl y taw ~ ~+ au M ~ ^ d O C a E A 7 s F- ~+ ~ ~p V Lt = .~ N Y L O V a1 C1 O.~ N L.. i' ~+ A O dor 9 t` J M a LL~ Q) S O N ~ ~ V M r N « ~ u ~ O d C Vy _ A O~ O npm^~ ~C+~ Y 4. O y;er O L ~ V C A y .~ ~ _°v~ a ie ~ ~ ~ ~ w ~,., >~ $ r. N d N d ~~ 6i y ~ d C y L q ,•. u m A W O OI CG T 6J CNC qrA .~ G=VO L O N C A •N~ N d L r o. : v v ~di oa ~ew ~ o ~w°-:1w N .y d > > f\ I ..1 d O n .-~ y Y.1 p N m S G~ d OI C O C 7 W A q A 10 y } r C L N q Mye r u a~ b ''CC K,^OLL ~ 6r~ T'^~°' oca.p y O. ~ ~ N y ~aAadi'~u yvLa>1 Ldp q d 7gYm M t OI^ L U~c=~i ~ C ° .~.h d C A i~Yr a N W q N a 1/f CN Cd Lit '°eMO „°,dd LOAM C C ~ N O Only K r Ayrd _rrt.ry ~po ~ gg yy q ^^ N N y G Gr d r y G K~qg p~~~ {Id°d 'r ^6yi 6C«m g~''r t a'~ d s, ai e'v e a u ^ M d V LL O y ^ ~C1+ Y ~dOd o c > e 9 y w r Ip Y e O C R y3 q Oq Nq^6• ~M Or gO ;^~p N~C^ ~ °J j^° u N ~ ~r lei ~q N C d + O O C 01 ~ pp _ ..~ ~ P d NtaL M O C K ..>dy~j La'~al L .N.. C ILe ~+ u Is O L Nw. C O`y s,r di o'b' 661 4 6o~~tX ~~.ds~o N pj I A v Y.. O a c q m V °~' q d q s a a A ° N N d N N q q A d i N Q d OI C L ~ N N M K L d d 4~ ` O ~ N L N ~ G d p M D M ~ N o+ ~ c ~ 9 d ~~ Y.. 00 q A L C 0 V. p ~ q d L y M yl 0 t •+ a s~ L A ~V N O q ~ > 1O ~ d L N L ~~ o. u ~I 1 W d' = N K N YMY ~ o C~~ Olw L ~ Y ~ ~0 = d O L C A • Y d d~ ~ L ~~ d «+ vN v^^^ ~e u e s o. ^yA ~ 9D LL rw ~~0~ L d >I d >^ ~,, C ~~ L N N O Ip° y L L O dw 3 ~q+` y M^ V M QC L _N ~` p O R ^ a N S reLv > A r ^ > ° q ~ d N ~7 r y C A O ^~ 9 C C °d~ ~ Q°~~Na ~ pspae q M L o ~ L O C r N> L V A C A ~ u ~ v M d 9 q s~ C r p G p ` V M C d A C p O d L~ Ld ~ 'eq VO. ~~ °rrj nlp ~.r u.+ s a~ a ov L dv ~~q« v q~Td ~A ~.°o °m C L M y^N~ ~ N y L L L d~ a s ^~ f~ y~ >O r` O q M N A ip M ! v s, L 7 U G ; q OI ° N` d O N L N a L C a N N E ~ N A G r N ~~o~ a~N°y L~ s6sr na L > N ^ q~~ C ~ C C Y SOI ~~ N N q A p aaa N a o.N ?o oc~ :+ N r Q~ u tto ^ q CI~ A !1 Oo7~ y ~ _O C L Gpp «L O. y N Z q A L C e O r~ 9 L ~ C y V f V CY. ~^ Y 9 y~~ O O. b o n a a ~~~ q e P s~ g c p~ d a N L On A ^ ~ r C O N^ O.r. sq tT ~p.^ n~ ~+0 1i l a N 4 O~ d r C'~wy s ~ O/~1 L C a ~1 u^ AA A.. O C G Y U 1 ~p d > ~T•~ r.^~ N^ A C^ L _ + a~G C A~ r L N i V r C C U a 4^ N L ~1 q C ^_ a O. D. N 7 'O ~s L C O. N Q1 p J L H^ K /~ 4 •r ~o r rC L s O y N ~. U W6 4. C a ~.• ~ IJ •~ ••• N 1~ 4 .-1 1 I ~ ,I I I O W Ij O u C LA C qq ra C d L V « d qa CNd N ~ A .- V D o a d O y A L M ~ L > W V y W N d L N ^~ C N e o y ~; ~ « o B c a L O M M yy e @ L N ~ W v N q'e aN+°jOe a~ T r °~~ ~ C M L ~~.L. r ~o a^~ ~dL a a r ^ ~' O .O qT y~ L ^ dM ~g^1r ip ~ wN. W N Gq N~ a O O L r a V ° N = yl d L {~ O N d^ C L d d~u. w^aL u _ a ^ ~+ q N ^ ' L ~ O w N c U 0$ 0 g d s o~?L ovogo.a acr .L-- Si~ W~= L d V V N f7 ~I 57 L .~ • ~ v c c vlo N 1 L r.1d, e o A a.r.~ y w w ~°vd .'~ c c e N o~ c a°i {Yy~ ^ 7 N V C ,G d q a+ C N r N L .^~ d~ _~ d ~ j V N^^ L {~ q C Ofd d "J 9 d W G OOOIII .~, O V y .N.~ L .C L O d~ ff. d q qy ~ d 7 vv C 9 N a L aC M n 0 L v O = A q d L D <v d V d,C O D y y~ 1 Y y .J •C O D V ~~' >TyLGT NBC D q ~ ~ NCq .- ~. d O q d~ e 0 L L C 1 O L y g N d y OL d q N L ~ O Oa q a C >Gd'.^.n Lari t.. d w NLdq G v 0 ~ > ~. q• d q ~'. `U 1 V f..f ~ C G S N N V v C ~ ~ q A N L T O ~ ~L T ~ V = ~ ~ ~ $ >f~ ~ ~p6~p ~7. L>~ d C~ N OW ~~ O C~ ~ O~ n d L u ff y ~ H _ L = ~ O _ ~. q t C L L a du q_N ~d L NOf G N_OI r,U L O YgNr i+W L L t N d ,G d L O1 n N L p r ~ L ~ y C If. ~ L ^ d 610w. '~'~ s yyr3 y L gy q^ L d O ~ ~ C O V n 1 ._,+ ~ a 0 O r C H N^ L 1 N Y ~ M d 6d L N ~'~ `o=~v`~cqq CGS wr3N9~,lA w~ ~ v '~a~o. ~9 ~~ NNN~'~G ~~b OG TN ~ ~.^Y~d L. 4°.0~ ~~'°^@p,'°a as'd« " wM ~ a gCSCd> °o N>fp 61 Y1 C O~q .~.L~dw ~ V O O O G u > , ^ ~ N~ L~> NC _q d w. ..G L g N V d ~ q~ C ' O ~ ' C w 6 T T M L 11pp N ~ N y y y y ~ ~ L L~ C C O nN L N N q Qla L1 N~ CN7 a~ >I N a~ Yd. 1V W Yd. ~^ d N C ~ ~a f ~ ~ M ~ O1 N p d~^ d~ V n,,, G+ d O q ^ ~ \[ C7 v^ C n d q C 17 L 7 q V ~~,yQ d GL~ ,pOlOiOC~C ~ G.. ^Y •qf M ~p1 Y dL u yfA=di G i g ep~ d Y L p N q d~ L t^ q t d M y s L 4.~ « q N L O d.. ~cC~ OOyr• yd a Nq~~ NM Od L L U^Ni=JG qD yl "'.d O AG ~ O NaV N C ~ q qdq CL C 99 O N V G G G ~ d~ Y O Y qrr. Y'f ywrg L O C OIq 001 ~ O 7 ~ L V d 7q„'O G 7~ D r+1> ~CIV C1~ d M q C L 4+..G. tNp~ Y nN ,~V •• V dqQ~ 9^ 1+.m Y IKOV VO0IO O 9 VAIN U^ yr~ d..C. >y ~^C~d7y w+.C _R ^ ~ ` ^ q N i 4 d W C S d 0 L L O L l y V q` O a > ~ d D Or W C V 0 0 ~~ r+ N c.~TJ Z N zM q6~ da 4t a ~ :+ u ri N, e~i v ui ~ ~ -'Y~_lll i ~ ~ I I W ~ q~ \.G. G td C Y >1t yGy y r d L C P .. 0/ L 'O Y y CC v a~9 G' a LNeM OA a.~ GYO. 10~ fO~Y Or t10 OIL C= q p 7 M~~ N O u np, d~ TO ~ « O1 ~ d L M Ol O~ L •r N ^m ~ ~ 1COr y Vv Lp C C 1. a ~C01L0 ••~ CLJ '^~y C L dN~ fm C ^_ G O dr ~+ nw + Vr'r C A ` .^.. q N^~ ~7 G~ M9 q d n ua_ dL a 7Y~~, q~ G^ ~ e ~ ~ ~ A d N N:,~ v~ > r °iym d Y d L° °f a'" ~ L7 ~= t ~4y C ddNN d0 i N ~Gd a0+r•' 9E+^A+a~^ ^Lj .O >C N V A 01 L~ W~ d Y yNT~ T~~~ N W V C C Upy C 61Y 'r q C Od q^ LTG 7 m ~ 'O c ,~ G N Y .- e.r a ie o d "'~ ~ L~^ ~ o n of a M~ L q a 7 b O 0~^ O V ~ ~ Kw 0~ 9 q m4 ~ d O g q ai v c ,n N d N d e^ o~ c L d .- G ,~ a e ~O d~ q~ Y~' T dLA N~ qT ~ ~ CAN' ONd~ A~MS1~ a i~ y d r Of O• a C Y 10 L. Y d y M ~ ~ G r L ~~ q L N L T ~ N i u 7 q~ •~ r V~ C (~• ~ L O ^e ~ a A d Of d d M O 0 4 0 v U q~ a0+ O y l'Q d VI •~ q N G pG ~ ^p C L 01r C nG Y wN ~' O9 N a s L a 0. A V ~T L L_C L O O ~ IO C 10 ~.6 C G C~ G d O y d y y N.~ O N N01t 7 wL,,yr q V N M d 0 Vy> 7 d6 yy C N OI ~N w. LO O.~ q y^>~ .~ O~ d C C a ^ V ~ d G L d ~ d v N L L a y vm T d >,eie+- rev d o qv u..qu q « ~ L~ ..eav c~ ~uN~ p«+ a "' .~eyy~ q~°e eaf~~"' ~~ .rW q d dV7 nL LT D ppL ~ ... d C d {f~ N q Np ~~ yL aLd qG Ta O ~~ nd «V~CCO CT q T q,ry ~ OLyY >Cr+tpJ .. ^y ~d r C nVC 0 60 OEOO~ ^« NM G YC NT O- ~ ON~ L9~ LL Z L A~ ^= y `~ d y r` Y 0 q 4 N ~ N O Qf L T N L d N ~} n 0 n N O N N V 01d ,p IO ~~M NC C~ N O 41 O'p y OLT w. 6 V 7~ +d~C .. G C ~ N y C V y q O. > G^ A F L C O ~ B7 ~~ y y q N N ~- r_ Y L 7 f~ ' u ,~ L p 0~ y y O. ~ C d q n OI ~ C O e ~ 7 C T C~ d~ N~ O+~d N^ C'ppMO a~ G~ N ~^O~ d L GY7UT r aQ C d LLd C d p> « q VI C G S L N 9 .^.. y ^ O q N d d T O q T a d ... ~ q i O y JvT L L V ~ 7 p q q L dyC la ~' ~ L r_ ~ d y ~ n O Y. O q U P v L~ O t G C T O M m U L 00 b QI O a L 7 pf N V d. W. n n 0 .. p ~p C OI ^i^ N+ C Yy ~O v O T '^ O v G` d O ~~ O m N q L d ~~ 0 0 L U A O O ~ Y d >. C L G d 0 d ~+ V Of ad+ C N Ty ~M `d,,GYG y d C~+~ 01N A ~-+ y^yu1~ pVL'~ ~CUTA~+G.N O~•r D Ol C LAM ~ H 9 t'C q L O T Y O L nqT N L N Ni+ 7 Y a y G .~ r d I N q L U eL ~~ n ~il C> 1 Q' }^ ~ n 01 O +~ V1 9 q .. O a' Y. U 7 N `4 G +- O N ~7pf q d d C 0'. q L N L C C r. >1 pl^ y q VI Y C V1 ~ IC q O O 6.N• 8 T c~ n v o e ~! L K O ~i K q O C~ L C L d 9 7 L 6V O d d W N 9 W V L7 O n V• O n s < T O O d O..-. d L L N N a s GO q V K Of Y F~ w. ~( q ~' u N 1'1 .p y ,,. N ~"1 . ~~ r z H V W 0 O. over ++ u w+y O ~..+D N d L L a+ N P w " o d « C L ~+r L N ecv•+ d L •B Y q C ~o,~n c >< Ol ~ a, c y d > 9 eo ~~, ~~ ~_ d `,r C L w 4 d O S L) y V d N C a C y y N N v~*T d A L d NL 6l~. d oa d L el ~\ O a W 4 q ter fed 7`C' oyi~ o.~y L d d L O ~ r W L o ~ d M C i c ~+ W N ~ d •r wu > d ~~ D d p~ a~ ; ° o. L ~ t° C ° q G y a N ' y~T _ 7 V d L L L o.~ N ° O L O. y yac ~ et 'r N d s N ° • did > r- L v° c L~ L O Ip ~ v 0O d ~'° e. ~+ N^ L y a q N O L `^ C O. w d ~ O r..t n y C C O ~ « ° u~ ~ w O N C L tCOJ T d a y q w e~ ~ O Y. d q O tl N ~• q L O 0.d 7 d d c p CaC 4 ^ W w G ~ N ~ L V dt ~ 1..~~ d O G O •+ u w W N T Y w d O y ° ^ w C d p A t yHN d 6 L `~ d d yd ~ L ~ M C N W ~ y~ Kv d a R t N OI C L C d ~ C N ~ W c~ y ~ L 1` y N y C V q d U r w "- w0 N M c of c ~~ 4 Old a L ~' y d N ~ O C ~ ~w ! N O ~ L 4 d d d ~ aors d O w g 0 dTL L O M N N O u C L ~ L y u u N 4 ~ v ^ aC C N t~' ~>ttd N ~ 1J a+i ~N~°s L C M D O~~ Y d d C y N° L~ d~~~ e Q ae+dou C 4 a y d L~ y,N~ ~,~~°uw 0 ~ yrdc N T 'jy O N pl ~ +` ps+GaLr~ t s " d °u w A ~ ~ ~ d uyoaQ+o~ ~e r cuu°°de 1~ Y. d w~. C W T 11. d 7 ~ q L ~~- y K L y d T W•+N L ~V N C C G .e M ~e N u G C W d C C L d a .O N ..- w .~ e N C, N r L = M ~~-- 'C >f d s r N L d C e N it N N N `° v~ C N ^ M cu N M o ~ ~~ d lp OI q N C C v~ ~ ~ L N r+ C M dC V 7 ~ m OI ~ H ^ i o =' ~' ~ ° . . v d O d ~+ u ~ u o y C ~ ,~ M W a v Y M q O °~ ?I ~ •• ° ~ L ~ w d d b L R y s d M ~ a s M N r 1 U ~ U • r N y C O O w L ° y d ° 0 0 ~ C a i °'° a i ° e u ~ :. n «+ d~ .+ M O e v O a L O. p N ~ '~ c q ~ q eil d e C 7 d ~ q 0 N C y s N L D O ~ O. C` ~^ Nd ~°~ 1~ o N a c •a L = y ° as ~~~ er°. « C O d C q a a+ p,~ o _vT L sr q v s G G ao N~ °~ Q ' ^ d L L s O ~y ^ C t 1N~ ~+ 0.C D N C ^ ~ d N 6 } r ~ s O Y OI 'O .- V y> w d i O O N y q d ° d C O L y w^ ^ q N N d L N N V t N L r- O t ~ ^ {~ IL N d G° Y w w ~ r ~^ L O b y 41 C yl B N C N M y d Y ~ ~. 1 M j~ q •+ T C N .~ C u •'' d O Y L ~ E O u 7 d L y q@~ L yg L e y ~+ ~ N I G L 1+ ~ 67 6! N ~ Q 000111 N ~ ` L ` O C C O ~ , W ~ x~ N J P'f ~ ~ .~r I to M g C t O w N c w L q L L ~.. L a o ~+ ~~ ! ~ y ~ .. e v~ 1A w I • d N 1 e O a ~, ~ ywy O p O b C y u u 7 ~ L ~ N ~ ~ C °u a Cd L .9~. ~ O T y ~ ~ w m d d ~~ o ra' 6 L ~' ~ a a ^ N N r .d. T T w r yr p c '^ U '~ O y a w a °c v °c ~v w d le ~+ N r L 4 i 9 q r w N q ~ U = 7 tdd 0 ~ M O ~ ~ ~ o. a ,e d v ad C ~ w O. = a q N ° v N G N d w w L u~t ~Ad ~° a _C y~ 1V T 1~ Q y ~ y ~ ~`v d° N ` O$~ j,1 O N Lys"' a a ~ pole ~. r. .+~a~ u y dL C µ~L L ~ adi ,Ca c h- N Y W M I 0. 0 N ' s J W ~ O H J 1 7 .~ W F~ C7 1' C L q 0 N Ld W M M N l~LL. d y N 0 a .. w ~li~ v a, i 87 r d C~ s ~ p ~ L L ~ y ~ L ~r N O ~ + ~ = F V ~ d ~ L M dl q f . y L'{. O ~1 ^ ,, CC ~O1 01 a j N p NL d d T V QIC a+ ~°e d L p p«~~ Y1 d Tp 0. o. o'- ~ A W ~ L t d~j ^ L d^d N ~ a• OL y~dLM 7 q 0. y ~~ c s ILOVd ~ N0 ~~y4 c ~ .rs~ c q ~aL+u' ° ^ L aa C C d O w Lr NT dTG Cr ~~ v ~ vyc CW o.w ~yco ~ ^ I. ^ dGy a o,- f ° LV 7~gbl~ ~ ~ .~ ~ . ~ L c G.1~ W O~ Q.~ y T N q L OI C "' O/0 N d d ~ C L L OI y i p C d ~ u c w~ r y C C J[ ° C f w a[ y ~r ~ C O y d L q j( C O: g d wL 'eN ~` y c^ ~ ~ w A ~ a~ ~ ~ ~ A w 0. C ~'p N w O L r d u~ O die T° L o c °,o a "p c C ,C W 3 C L r d d u^ y L d d w C C ~+ V ~ G.1 O - ~ • M l T ~! O.T 4 L d OI y y L C N ^ w C d NL) C N SW w^ Q O T~~ wuu~ v + c ~ ui 1 t/1 G + J~ W q -p~ ^ d Y+ d W O q y N ° L L O d N •+ d d ` a ~, .-. N i ''' Y. r~ ~ je O s~ C o ~, v d u d d t y N L ~ d' ° •• O L O d w 4 L ~ op O C N q 4 « C u c q M u 1° Olr q b ~+ v L 'O y O t 6M I q T aw C d O ~' y Of O l r ~ q } C le 6 d w O.p qy u N « v~ C ~ ~ y D N c q ° Y 9 C ~' q O G d a L r O q C M q }~ N sv ~vq q c Gy L d N w M L N L q ~' d 0.V y d N L O1 L 0.W ~e 59 ~~ (~~ W ~„~ W "'~ O •Y. y d > C O d O u A O L '^ C i • u~ N y G i 9 N d J O r N ay uw ~ Te C L N L d O. O. ~r {(U~~ ~ O L d Ol a •~ •+ O w L d 'O ^ p i V ^ r a J ^z °' = N ~ ~ 7 q O G V N S U ~~^ > ~ L O C.1 N v N ~ d d t C QI A ~ C N L ° o C «a o iR r. ~ '' A " ^ o A.= "- v W L ~ d C L o ++ a a ~~ W. V~ N y M W C j0 ~ O L N L ~- ~ O y O N q d > L ugo. ~ L ^ C d t yV/ ` q O M N V 2 O ~O f o e w o 4 .i3ea ~ ~ ~« c ,. y L' L V ^.~ pp S ~ p f1 V Y ° Y O. u~y6 wdt ~ ~ qa a N N N Y W K V _N C L u O.Y d O i~~. aON y O1C e ~ M C d ., a = q d ~ L _ e ~ o A ~^ ~ ~^ ^ ~ 7 ~ 4 C O A L.~. W d > L ~ 6 N Y d L Y C G O C V Y G V y H~ CN 'O ~'~ ^ T~y y O A y c'r L O au~,w qo~ ~ N ~.°'.M ~ f0.1 7 _ ~ q yZaA N ! ~ ~. .~' pu. C V D o+ v au L L v vv a d _ ~ ~ u~~ L r- ~ c N d N y A ^ ~' . + M C ,,,, d m ~ d~ V~d E4.l 0• L Or« C L ~~ N~ N~ M ~ V O N (1 Y _ y d a ~ « _ d a 'may Vl~ A GI- LV O 'O > d d V _ q t r ~ ~ ` d N N p L V L i0 N~ W 1p d N O~ 4 L L ^~ L~ .~ O NN wV NOJ~ y~ r UCT N 6L/ y g d A i,~ U,O ;~ ^~ a i a C C d 01 H N L v y> l L V~ ~ y A T N _ .-. A d c e r+ pc Noa ia aro O a e N T N N L L N V y ~ _QQ ! Q11 Q C O. ^ ~~ q L C V C p V L ~ C N n 61 7+ L M C L L ~. G a V O L V\ ~. q L L~ ~ L L y O i G N L O d N O ~^> C L O. 7 ~ it N d N a L 6 O y d N U N L A 04.9 • L . d V N^ M .. N ~' d d 01C a y N i W 7 •O O'er ~ ~I N •• +T+ ~ C G R A J L ^ d r C C7 V ` d ^ d ~A wO~~N LL O.J y OS^ ^ N A d+- l(1 10 n, W •+ ..w N I I ~ 1 ~ ~v~ ut x o ... A w `~ do T ~ -, v t N i d N c a L cw do-+ e vc > d Wit' ~+ L ^ L 7 ~ _ D L o O a C yl~ V _ q , 3 ip W o N ~ N L p L N y~ V ~ s 40 q ~e u V r d d . r f 7 a " { N L ~ y ,b~ N O O pp L t ~ 'O y L G ^ r _ ~ C L d y M L w N W O d M L 6 L O N ~p V •~ 9 ^ C = V c v '~ u .~ N i '° ~'. u ~ L L O L . - ~ ~ Q y ~ ~ 6 S . O ~ a ~ yw ~0. r 4 y U 0 C 'D N b LM ~.Cr u O L am. o c N y v c Y y N O N O Y~ ,. c Y N` ~° a c ya 0 v N yy V y Q A O + '~ s v ~ V i °'L a~ u.c. 1 V .cLO. ovo + nc- y c do ~ d ..pp O o V ~ y~ i ad T~ C u .. L C a d q a C'J C ~ b u V 7 ' , ~" ' a u L a+ c a N ~ ^ N d G Gy ~g Q L CG 4 VV dGd~ ,~ L ~ C^ ~,~ a ~ d N ~ L O C ~~ y 'O ^ C O U~ Ga C L ~ u +- L O.> O O V C a r ~+^ N^ L ~ d O. JCJa 20LL H i if d K 6 N ".~ ! K1 d C I I I bo ,~: ! f. K Dtn7ttttlen Ina rMt:.ltr atcett r• 1 Daelcll~ent tn111 pt Mat by Itmt Yv 01 eel tatt•to• {t•ett rlgntl• of •rty /ne alf Mce{sty anenr+ti at morn on cne cMUt,R •Ip, Int'ualnq Cewtt,n+tG tfutetrbn irltl rlgnts•of-py Ina teal ewae• -/ Z EDUtttrun !reel enewentt, lM tt = . Otuuon tnt ee Yet or ant tof le.+ne rtgntt•et..ty an the fe110rlnq tLrNlS (nlNlYfw erD ilrKt CMLI•Itnt) a , l _~ total feet en 7'T 0.a1P..tti ~D teat tees en V 1 ST7l ~ 10111 Ifll On tet11 fNt On _- 3. Irrtrvuele otter of aw+catlon ter _~ reef rest •oaerty a+tnent - / tnlu pe uoe ror In p•t.ate ttrwtt or ort.n. V /, Corner 9rDetrt7 hn! raQlu{ r+ll p! rwulrw pH C1t7 Stlnvlrot Me a•1.tngt. ~, teen. tln lCY Ur lCCtSt th111 bt el01c1ted t0 Ar Ctty tar SM IOi ler mq ttrteti, ~~~ OX/~ ~.+~ ~~ ~ ~ i t-pyt IJeI/S • Rer+oroul aeent ealeatMts Md YrntMMCe Ig•et+e•u entvrtng aceelt to 111 parcek tM yo+et ta+nteMnce of 1It cetaten rpaet, stern or pert roq loot {hall oe protases ey CCOR•S x by least Me tnlll -e t•Ke•atd CMtYrrawt rltk tY aY M prior t0 1ttYatKe 01 bllatttq Nt++t, rMrl n0 Yf If +nepl red 7, -r/ra It erllMet eatleMtt fDr CrOta•let arplMft {Mlf N reOY+rM Ma 1x/11 N aal+ntalM R Mttt16 M tat! fIn11 Yp. ~ 011 talitin i lt l Wthl f , ng g Nflaw y f n rturf HgM.or.ttt7 try t0 be lY1tc 11 itN ar tp M MllnNtae a tM ee0 per Ctty EnglnYr't tefYiretentt, 9. Ettwntt for {teeralb Ibr wo11c oats fh111 bt eaelcatae to LM Clt y there t+ee.IlYt render tnreugh frl Yftt proparty, L. Street Itprmtrrn tt _1, Conttroct fen ttraet tYrottwtenh Intludlnq, but net Ihftw ta, taro and gutter, l.C Ntrwtet, alaMalY, ar+ve aw•e¢nn, plrt.a7 Brett ono itrfft Ilgntt en ell lntfrl0r public tlHltt ~ , . A noises e/ ti-test pIM Nvwtnt .lento a lo•reot r+el laetutae ~ Mght •el rag fY11 K tAnftrtCtfd ter ell h11f •teet ten ttrlttt. . Ca»ttlytt tM f011arltq 1Arawrllp tat hd Uq, bt rot S41tle t0: STREEt tiMt CUTTER -gRT, YRIi AMR. LiCNTS OrERLA ISLAND OT1ER 1/r's c x X X X d hOttS' lal tl C onset faders lt, tt snail N curve Nmer per STD 2tK, let Itwlen 1sllnd tnc loon llnesup+ng Ind lrr lgat ion a YNn let C.A (teen agraa+ntl er Fee ttttn•Itau ItN tn111 be Oror+aw /vr the +tea a0 YrteO, O~ ~ r rOtrVt YYt alwt.l t,/t rr+o• to tnr wrt ttlnq per/orsd to tM t+YSl tc •+qnt w!•rtr, Ian fMll of alto ant M theroael~mS Nr~lt shall N wt11nN tree en! Lttr EngtYer't Olt act, In tN it IP1 to Iny et Mr pat~ttf rputrfo StrKt +aprare+elnt 91Mt InC lYOtM Otrtra7 treat Md 4trKt Ilgnti o•eotree ey 1 Mgttterte CIr11 [ngtnter an0 appro•e0 er the LtV Engtnet• tn111 a rwu+ree for 111 public ltreetl pr+or eo tttutnce or M tncrpKntrttt Dr•rti~ Itnt1 01tn4 My erDflltt tnell tow Ins loett ton vt eel en tttnq utlitef flcl litter taco to cne rtgnt •el-.a7, _•l 1 {fplrat! Olrtgr Yid/or Ye1M +{lana lens{tape Me 11n a1[ten phn off tl{r tleMlrel {nett bt prprl eat tub)t Ci t0 aeDrprll 01 •n! Lll7 Cngsneer Ior 1• SYMtr 1M 11 M NSLItI ed to tR~~ttot airy lac to tat Ht1411C 61on pr twt Ctt7 EMlwwr aM W Cltr attot•ne7, gwrantNtnq eenolatts, er tM pYO1lC sere/r prlraU Itrart +w•p•~rtl1, or for to apD•Drtl or tM anal tap Or tat Htu-nte Or Du 110tnq De•rttt, rntrM.er occur{ flrtt _/ Street +tDrorwwt Oltni per Cttr fCMeare fur ena t•l alt t••en1 D• ertKt tMll be rlpu tre6 for •taet ena rep tool or the .ttr Enq tntt•. 9 -rtpr tv am re•t bttwq ctrl o•er0 eve cne D•taLf ttrttit o• a•+rtt, f lei /nell D! Dt la top 1 Canlt ruCttM D!•rtt Sn111 :t :p:a ant: ' tot hie [ngtMer'1 Dftlcl, In .aatt mn to tnr etne• Dr-.,tat •tau~nc^ ~C all west +w•orrteetf malt De inittt le0 to ins u[ttra;t +en o/ tnr ht7 Enq toot, ~: It •erent ttrtDtnq, tart inq, t•Nfte cne tt•ett nine t•q•tnq +ntll at Iniu llN oe• the rasa trew,entt of ant tier Irlfttc Engtree• ~:L Crttt+nq reef •oadl rrout•tnq re[onttruct•r sn11t •rrltn oor 'or +•e•''c et 111 •t~t ritn aotouatr at lDV •t •.~ ,;•{•'ut•~a• A tt •ffl Clplurt or'r•• Yr e! •tau'•eC a Cetn ^l;:i 1^t•• 7e rev.'•re t. .a•e• ••e ca: a' q'er nq the p+• - ant ;e •r'.roM r coop ir•ton a' the co^t••~c•mn •• •-r u••t'1c •o• v' •,e 7 .~ .... t t v ~~ p p • 'tO~OCt KO. 00'3,Y' r...r 12. Yl lkra7i M111 pf prprldw NINM p~el•• t'0eet tl M: T•t •. paMtlrlM arfal Lent[n VI!ld Ory+Mfe flprl shell not :•^tl ftaRl4t :ne!• tytrl e eytnt mall De tnittllw to :+tf t•e+;rat 1t a p!"all r111 b! •wYl•ra '•pa ttltr ant 'a• Inr rp•t .••~ fel for tnq r+gnt •Or +a7 M, Ore+M r Ina rleea Cont•et -1 tot a0pllemt •+il et rltDOnt rol. •v• c:^u•.r••en e' a', ,• 1 •. arNMgt fltll It tee rpu+rev Oy :n! W+lo tnq .'the y' _2, Intertectlon ert1M rtll pr rwu+•w K tot toller+nq louttrt 2 Tnr Dt'eyKt for oert tent tnRtofl tt ivr ltM rttntn 1 rlwa v:r7 Lone, tnertlere tlooa Drolecuon n+u.•n Ivn ^• a•oad•• t+ ce•t Ulea b7 a 4eq+strrw Ctrll Enq tnee• ena apo rot.: or :nt ;'•r Cnglneer, _~l, t er1/MDI tnlnnel the/or flees erotect te• art al •. •rnv^tr •. D•etrct the uructurn e7 a+•runq tneec •unal' tp tt•ertt .: i ttgrt Ornn, 1~ A/ftuaL! Orowtlent tM 11 b! Yd! ror a[cleUntf ena alttoSal o/ alert aef aratnagt meat lnq the erapert7 hat layuant arse. /. Tha fst)trthq atl•aetlfl fhail M ltftpata n alt,la ^ate• car•ytnq atrwt{t1 rtau+r ltq t ter lnatlw K tease Hl euA ne+gntt, cnnuercnl t7M Mlq aspnawt, ratios ttraet een+aetlent, flees D•ottctlon Nile, aM/ar falMatYM aartA Nr~t ena rollb Irltart7s at praptrtr l tat: 7, t Ifnal lraltaga ft1AT that! k Welttlad t0 Ina Iaererty vy thI Sttr [ttplnfar peer U approval 0/ tM /loll Map n +Nuance or pu1101•q Nr+ttt, •MMettn' occur! hrt6 lit arl+ntge IaGl lit ut SMtI pe tnfallw n raoultla bf tM C1ty EngMKr, _ 1. 4 ter~it /rat tM COYnt7 FtpDa Control Dl ltrtct tt rwulrtd far .orY ^ltaln 1st rllht•ef+a7• N Illtltt ~•_ 1. -rorlee teplnte vtltit7 terrltes to each Ducat atiuatnp tantt.rr tatwggf ta'ttalat, ^KK, pt, alettryc pprtr, tolaeronl, ono cab l! Tr (NI rarfrgtertlel In accerlancaettn tla Qtlnq Stanatrat. GtlYnti mall M prorlNd ft ratulrw. Y t. The tewtertr than N retDrltlele for tM nleutfsn rf ttHttnq rttllttlt n tiaeasaar7. 0. Ipnpnt lavr/raaantt w Awrotatt _l, a -t•ttl YD mall b! reexeed otter LO Title Dhat! tubet+ l pt•tt•tnt crnt+a+ of urtrKOgn ued parc[It 2. Tae fellortnq Nrtrttr garotcaved Nrara74 nt rtoutre0 tv or fnneeea tree cne taneseaN YtntaMnee etttrtct 2, Mlor to rKOreat ten, a heats et Intent ton to fa•+ tna/vr tom lMOtcapt and tlgnt+ng Dtttr lC tl ant 11 Dt f11w •ttn the Cttr Counttl Tot angtnNrlnq cot is +nrp tree m 0l ttr let fonatt ton mall N porno b7 cot Ntaloper, a aloe lct Of Intw+tlan CO yelp tM YIIM 1{IMO IanattaN V1ntMMG! lltlrt Ct {h111 N /lied rata [he Ctty Lpln[Il e•ler to a0orvui et tn! r tool step Gtr IaWllca of b1101ag partial, ratcMttar eccYrt Ibtt. I, 1110 taparaN altthg NreN{ cattalYd e1Mlt tltf pro2Kt ttorYfrllt atoll M Igetl7 car trite lhta wq aarCfl Ir ter N fete /ftYMttt of bell trig parrs ts, _-i. M Nswtrtt ror a yelnt vte erla.tr tnln pe Drorlaea D•tor to lperoral 01 ant FInII typ or ItwtnGl 01 Oullattp Nrrttt, rn1Mlrer atturf flrtC, for. Metltt d lntant+vt LO lprr Md/pr )oln T4 llgnttnq Ina tMQS[1e'•q Oltenet fnall N Alta stn tot CI[/ CDUnctl Dr+Or to •tcp•tlt a• tX tls tap er torsos of put let nq ptn+tt, rnl [ne.r occurs t••t• [Lt'Lklf (~{ECC LISP _ 1.OR DICIIILF3INC DIVISION USE 01tLY. Prior co schedule for PC• :-.e.Clal Candtt:ont _l, Drntnege/Flood Report. 1 OHI;_com, c _2. Offsets eemt str drntn •~2, Retm str ~l _3. Offsets dretn ncpt letter, 3 Alte Loma Basin Etc _4 Approvel_Caltrnns_SSCFCD G, Apportion A-. _5, Revise Plans. ~5 Shored Acceea Esat _6 lfsatsrr PLn. 7 /, : ~ ~ ~ • CITY OF RANCHO CUCAMON6A Project No. CUP ~,$-.3~ EN6INEERIN6 DIYISION Type ~c~G( 4~,,,~{~ jam, ~ PROJECT REPORT AND RECOFMENDED CONDITIONS Location ,,,~"~'" ~~' APIv` Preliminary : TRC,_,° (~ gy~ ~ o ~~ ~~ Q ..~/ 9 ~o Ckd cj Final: PC Meetin g ~~ g y Ckd I. Yes No, Acceptable for Planning Commission - If No, see COPS}ENTS below, II. STANDARD CONDITIONS -See Page Z III. COMMENTS /SPECIAL CONDITIONS: A. ~~ ~. _ . '_ _ _•L n . Q 2. ~. ww i •~ c- ~+ n /~ ~~ .~ , .z ~ . -1,• ~` CITY OF RANC~UCA!lON6A Pr~ct Iv`o. CUP - gB 38 EN6INEERIN6 DIVISION Type~~Q /~~~ 11~ PROJECT REPORT AND RECOMIENDED CONDITIONS Locetion~ t,, w/ n c ~' o APN ~/ - /p/ _ LS" Preliminary: TRC By _Ckd Final : PC Meeting 9 $ y $, ~~y~P,e~ of / g kd ~~ •~ rG 8~ I. ~es No, Acceptable for Planning Commission - If No, see COMMENTS below, II. STANDARD CONDITIONS -See Page III.+~~~ SPECIAL CONDITIONS: ~ ev~aP ~noC .~i ~-/ ~ _~ .~.Q C~-OTY'~ C.Tf' a~ 7'~ ~I ~ir~ La/~ ~ /GIGQ.~Q l_G.~.ua or /1' ~ ~s.O .~ / S• Su.,-e~ s~a 1~ G,e was ~eo~ c~.l c,,,t Q~.rPe~.,.~`- .¢-~~ ru~of ~ Form Rey . S~ ?ti~35 1 of Z , ~* • .: , ~/~ K, Deo lcat ten and ttnlcular Acclts r 1, Oed leltlont shall be auae ey f•MI Sao of ail rntener street rtghts• of •r1- In¢ all netettary latetrntt al {her,t On LM llntaL ire rap, lne luamq Cowra.m ty EaueseHan TMtI rignttwhray and lout teener Etuttertln Tra/l la/auentt. • P~oJoct No.UJP Og'3gj ~. Oadfutson ins11 K ayde of the fDilorlnq rtghtt •ef-ray m tM follo.tnq SLrntS IM1lwred frm ttrttt centtrline) ~~ total fret on tout leer M l~ Q. ~ M total tell on tool fret On _ ~. Irrtwubk efftr of eedtcat len for foot .Ids roteray taseaent ~ ~ WI1 be Yd! for all Drrvate terttts or orlret, V t Corner oroptrty tine radius x111 be reou lred ptr taty Stanoarat and // drarsngt, Y 5. Men-.Mfwl~~jj actor tMlt be dedlutW to tot Ity fw tM fotlo.lnq streets: r'1'Q+~1~~lt. P~I[_LO,)wf ~ ~ G~t70.1'etlPd diw^1 Vf we,.trS ~„ 6 Ikctorocal access ufeaMif and watntMance agree+e•ts Mwrttrq aeons to 111 ptrcelt and Jefnt a/ntenanct of all caatnn roads, tlrfres er parttnq trees tMll De prortetM ey CCCNt or by fkedt and snail be racordad eertcrrtyrtt rlth tM aaD er prier to 1tfrMCt O/ bulldltq pert) t, rlwre n0 ayp is lnvplre¢. J, frlvate eralMR laawnttf for creq•let drainage tY 11 k rswtsra¢ one tea 11 Oe aeltMatN R net lct6 on tM final yp, ~8. A11 alatMp ntaatanu IF'itq rltetn future rfgnt-ef..¢y ova tp bt Mlultlpdd K to M dellttata0 an set Map per lily Erp lnwr't rdpetlra~rttt. q, Etaaralu for rldwalts for prblfc ores Ma11 be dedlute0 u the nay rkera tltferalks Man¢ar through private property. L. Strtet lurrrtttttts 1. Cmrtrrct fpii street taprortssantt /nclu¢1nq, Dot not lfaltad ta, wrb aid quttrr, A.C. paltsattt, tl¢watt, ¢MR approaeMt, portray trot sag ttrM[ 15gnn eM1 aJl Inttrlor public ttrtett. Y 2, A atn{~ sf to-feet r1M MrrtMt rltMtn t t0.faat Hdt dtotcttad r/gnt•af.ray fMall k cwtatruc4d for ill ha ll.aectten ttrteK. ~7. ttattrvtt nw follorlnq Itornw.tants Itlcludtnq, wt net Hatta¢ to: 5T1tEET UIE CUTTER MiNT, blAt.Lr AMR. LI6+tT5 Ot1ERLA ISLAJID CTNER L >?l .~ X E d MATES (al tf C radK tlee.a lt, tt the 11 be curralMur Per STO 704, (b) hedfan Ittand sac lusts ~an¢scaosnq and InlgatlM on aster (cl LA (iron aprtatentl or Ftt (fn.lqu ftt1 snail be provided for cne Stews to atrktd, (d) G1rp~d5acE.eT.i ~ y d, p.for to am tort betnq oerfented to tM tweite rtght•of.rar, toot 4Mt 17 tX pa to Ind M MtrolctraaRC Ofrt.lt tMl1 at Oetalnl0 frrtt tM Csty Ewgtnttr •s Off lea, 1n addltton tD .+r etr,tr perwltt repo trod. ~, Sirtrt Irgrortwwnt pltnf Including Asst^ty trot and ttrttt I/ghtt prrelrad sr a Atq/fitted Crr11 EngIMH art0 aoorored by the City ErArettr tMlt De rtpu trio for all puD11[ Strtt tf DnOr to ruuence of an tneroaeutent omit Ffntl D1ans Md oroftles snail Ina the Ixstton of ail taltnng utl ltty faclllt itS rrthln tM rtgnt •of-ray, 6, a separate olraray and/or need tan fsi Md landicaoe and Irv lgat lpn plan -- an Cllr Stanaard{ tM 11 M ororseed tuolttt to a0ororal of the Clty Etgsaet+ for ~_). Suety tuw11 ne tattoo ono In tq.~went taKUttd to ens tat raflct ion M ire Clty Cngtnttr sod the Ctty Attorney. {uarantetrnq etrro btten of tlt erDtk ono/x prlgtt ttrtet Inprortstntt, Dr1or to awro tat of tot FtMt t1C R the IftY ante 61 by 1101 nq 9trs1CL, rnltnerrr OCCYrt first. ~_ 6. Strta1 tKro.raent DLnt per city SUntlard IDr the psi ra;t t:reKS a 6rrq tYll Ge rtau lre0 fps tourer an0 approval Dy tn! aty Enq rn.rr -_9. trta tZ any .orl betnq Derto.+,t0 on the Dr4 rate tt roots o• ertret, to a411 be ea10 Ind 1 Conttrutt ton Arnett Sna II De net at ne0 fro. tlf .Sty [aq rnetr'f Dff fee, m taditmn to any aloes De^ti tf rteu trod 10, aJT rraet faro va..mu sna 11 be rmulled to the satts'aa ion of tot [tq Etgmer, Jl -..went tcrtofnq, .art inq, Lrdrlc Ind freest n/n,e s~en,nq sn/tf pt ~~ Mtai'Ite per one reautre,aents o/ the CItY Trlfflc Enq sneer IE Ears2 tag cltY rmdt reovtnnq rotor structron snail remnn nm for trs•fk at ell •L,tt .stn admutte aetours dv-tnq corstrutt rot J rc•rR cloture terwrt ary x reeu ,era t usn oeaosrt foist De rtaurrrd to :over the cast of area ,nD IrW Dannq, .~rc~ tv17 ae rttrnCe< on co,o ltt ton of the cons t•u<t for •, •ee sat •!'att ton of •nr [17y tn5 r.rtr r 1. /rortda iWante ut111ty atrrics to taeh parcel 1nclutllnq ssnltary Itatlr~ tytttn, rtter, qts, e1KV1c to.er, talaptrha, Ina cable it rttdergrerndl In teeeratrlea rtth the Uttllty Statdardt. Easttswtu ~~ aM11 bt prorlaad at rtwlrtd. _t, TM dttralaar that) ha «tpantible fx CMt rglxttton of settling utlittln H ntcttaary. 0. 4atwnl Aeaulrtaaatts and Farrpralt __ 1. t ptrui ran fMEI br recorded prier to rfrit pMft tuD¢1rttlen to prrrent cratton er uns,ecpgnf ltd parcels ,_ E. TM follorlnq per footer landst:aoed parkrayS err rapusrad tp W antrttao 1nt< the lanOtcapt sttMtenanct alftrlct: 11, to lkrl-t snail bt provtea¢ Ittwen wD11c Sldlral4S ant en.tt;r IaetttrlM IrHt, Y ,t. CencMVtted era lnaga flats shalt net cross Nderllks. tatde• ndewle Ora lot SM 11 De fossil led LD Clty Standarei. _` 15 t oerrtt x111 br rodutrtd trot CatTnns for am sari rttnlr ire lellormq rlgnt•ol.ray DrnM a ono Fleed Control 1 Th! apDllclnt r111 be retoohtible for construction of all Dn-site OralMge ftclltttn rcdv Mad bl the W110 mq Of/lefai. 2. Intersection drafnt WI1 b< requrrtp d tM lotlwtnq buttons 1. The preJ4tt (or port lent tMreef) It IeUted rltMn a Flood naurd EOM. tMrefort, flood Drottttlen telWrtt 1M 11 be prat toed n ctrl if ltd a- a Req lsterK Lsrfl Enq lnaa an0 aporored by the Ctty Engtttetr 1, A dra lnagt channel an0/er ftaed protKtlen wll .111 De rMurrtd to protect the sVUCLtret Oy dtrtrtlnq shtdt runoft to ttrttri, or to s tton dram, _ 5. Adeauau proriflont short be jade for acceotanlte an0 dltpoui et wMan ¢raleape reterlnq tJtt property tree a¢Jacmt arau, ,~ i, llw /sljw/tq ttrNt(t) aMall tw dotgtwd n ttyor rater urryenqq Itralt(t) MdWrlnq • eetllMatten O< tpt¢t11 Curb Iwlgntt, eantwrClal trw trio arproaetwt, rolled ttraet carlwctlont. flfto¢ orotectten mitt, andhr lanlaeaetd urte Mtrt aid rolled Orlrtrart at property l loot 7. A final drainagt array aMtil M nrbtitta¢ to and atervrdd 61 tMe C1ty EtegltrtK prier to appraral of tat F1u1 crap or tatuantt at w4101nq panalta, rhleMrar eeturt first. All erabage iactlttldt sMlt bt intutit¢ u rrqulrad Oy tM trey Ettgtnatr. _ t. A petals ftroel tM Cawltr flood Control Otstnet 1s ro0ulre¢ fbr task rfthln 1st ripht•of~ray. N, Vt111tlef __ 1, /tier to reeordat lets, a bttet of Intention to rorw and/or Join tandaupe and Clgnt tnq Otttrtctt Lhali bt flied rilh tM Crty Counetl Yoe engsmtnnq tests total red in Dlstr let Faratron mall be Dome 6y the Otvl taper. a, Matt<t of Intent fro to Jeln tht arLtaa ttltnd Itntlacaoe wntManer 1/ftri t! tM 11 b< It ltd rlth tM Cltl Cornell prier to approval of the f tool Mop or Isfuanet of ettldlnq aet,.ltL, rhlt7wrar attars first, _ f, iNt saeantt e4fat{rq urcels etrttalatd rnnln tM eroJKt botrsaar4s sMll be legally eoabined into one wrcet prior fa the Ittuance of wits lwq persist. E, M eutsent for a Joint use drtrwray tne11 b< prortdatl prior to aDDrova1 of tot flMt MoD or itwance ai bullalnq oenatts, .nlcMVer accost flrat, fort V T totter of ;ntant/on to forty molar Jotn rte ttgntlnq and LMOt uet Dq Dlttn tt ina11 Dt flltd rt to the Citl soonest prior to rltoraat ton of tort tea ar Itsuanu e/ wlldtnq oenrtts, .mtcna.er erurS first REYIEY CHECY LIST -FOR EMCIIIEEPI1iG DIVISION USE ONLY. Prior t~ schedule for PC• Seecia] .on +tione• _l. Drntnege/Flood Report. 1, ONl1 tom, cond _2. Offsite eamt._str_drein, 2 Retm, sir SD OHU _9. Offsite drain ceps. letter. _3 Alta Loma Basin ftc. _~ Approvel_Celtrenn_SBCFCD L, Apportion AD. 5, Revise Pland. _,5, Shared Acceae East _4, ltMSter Plat, Z ~t z cr,rm Qot, 7 • • CITY OF RANCHO CUCAMONGA STAFF REPORT DATE: November 28, 1990 T0: Chairman and Members of, the Planning Commission FROM: Brad Buller, City Planner BY: Beverly Nissen, Associate Planner SUBJECT: CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT 88-10 - HILLSIDE COMMUNITY CHURCH - reques or a erne ex ension an mo 7 ica ion to conditions of approva 1 to the master plan for a church consisting of a sanctuary, administration building, education/nursery building, and family center totaling 11,520 square feet on 8.5 acres of land in the Very Low Residential District located on the west side of Haven Avenue north of Hillside Road - APN: 1074-271-01. CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT 88-38 - HILLSIDE COMMUNITY CHURCH - A request to modi ~fy a con i ti on o approva or an existing modular building (60' x 144`) for a church classroom facility on 8.5 acres of 1 and i n the Very Low Residential District l ocated on the west side of Haven Avenue north of Hillside Road - APN: 1074-271-01. I. BACKGROUND: The Hillside Community Church was originally approved y e anning Commission on February 9, 1983, (Conditional Use Permit 82-2S) and expired 18 months later since building permits for Phase I were not issued during ,this time period. Three temporary modular buildings were also approved under the original Conditional Use Permit, along with the construction of Parking Lot A. A fourth modular building was approved under CUP 88-38 in 1988. In addition, a Variance was approved with the project which allowed fora 50-foot height limit on the sanctuary building. The project was resubmitted in 1988 and given a new project number (Conditional Use Permit 88-10), The project as submitted in 1988 was identical to the originally approved project, however, it was modified through the design review process. Modifications made during the design review process included the following: - the height of ,the sanctuary was lowered from 50 to 35 feet and was significantly redesigned. (This height reduction eliminated the need for a variance.) - the roof material was changed from copper-colored seamed metal to tile. 65 a PLANNING COMh1ISSI0N•AFF REPORT • ,, C UP 88-10 - HILLSIDE COMMUNITY CHURCH ~ N OYEMBER 28, 1990 Page 2 • The revised CUP 88-10 was approved on September 28, 1988. II. ANALYSIS: A. Time Extension: Staff has analyzed the proposed time ex ens~on an as compared the proposal with the current development criteria outl inad in the Development Code. Based upon this review, staff has determined that the project meets the development criteria of the Very Low Residential District (2-4 dwelling units per acre). In addition, there have been no significant changes in the character of the area that would cause the project to be inconsistent with its surroundings. Hov{ever, since the project was originally approved, Tract 10414 to the west has been constructed. Neither the church nor the tract were originally approved with a perimeter wall along their common boundary and staff has been contacted by an adjacent resident wh o feels that a wall is necessary between the 'parking got and their side yard. A chain link fence has been constructed by residents to the west, The Planning Commission may want to consider requiring a block wal 1 along the western boundary as an additional condition of approval. As the more intense land use, the church could be required to install the wall consistent with Commission policy. Conditional Use Permit 88-10 was approved on September 28, 1988 with a two-year time limit. The applicant is requesting that the Conditional Use Permit be extended for an additional three years, rather than for one year as would generally be the case with time extensions for Conditional Use Permits. The applicant feels as though a three-year time period would be sufficient for them to complete Phase I of their master plan. The appl i cant feel s as though they have completed a significant amount of street improvements including reconstruction of the Community Trail along Haven Avenue, removal of the northern most driveway on Haven Avenue and landscaping along Haven Avenue and Vista Grove Street which, they believe, warrants a longer time extension. However, the Development Code provides for grand ng extensions only in 12-month increments. Phase I includes the modular buildings which are currently existing, the game fields i n the southwestern portion of the site, Parking Lot "A", and the Family Center building. The game field area will also serve as an additional 125 unpaved parking spaces when completed. Phase II will consist of the nursery, and one of the Christian Education buildings. Phase III will consist of the remaining Christian Education 66 PLANNING COMMISSI~ AFF REPORT • G C UP 88-10 - HILLSIDE COMMUNITY CHURC H NOVEMBER 28, 1990 Page 3 buildings and the Administration building. Phase IV will consist of the sanctuary a n d Parking Lot B (125 spaces). The sanctuary building will have a seating capacity of 1,500 and upon completion 375 parkin g spaces will be available, B. Modification to Conditions of Approval: The applicant is also requesting a on ~ ions o, an of Resolution 88-198 be modified to allow the three existing modular buildings to remain for an additional three years. Condition No. 3 states: "The three existing modulars shall be removed within two years or upon completion of Phase I whichever occurs first." The applicant has requested 'that this be modified to allow the modulars to remain an additional three years. Staff Comment: Staff supports the proposed modification to allow construction of th a Family Center building prior to removal of the modulars. These modulars function as the church's temporary sanctuary for worship services and gatherings. The Family Center is a large multi-purpose building that would a ccommodate congregation seating. Therefore, the need for these modulars will cease once the Family Center is constructed, as was intended by the original condition. The following language is suggested: "The three original modulars shall be removed by September 28, 1993 or upon completion of the Family Center, whichever occurs first." Condition No. 4 states: "The proposed modular shall be removed within two years o r upon issuance of building permits for the Administration building, whichever Occurs first." This proposed modular wa s approved with Conditional Use Permit 88-38 and is currently existing on the site. The applicant has requested that this be modified t~o allow the modular to remain an additional three years. Staff Comment: Staff supports the proposed modification to allow the modular to remain until the permanent Administration building can be constructed as part of Phase III. This modular is located upon the spot tha t the permanent Administration building will be constructed; hence, as a practical matter, it must be removed or relocated at that time. The following language is suggested: "The 60' x 144' classroom modular shall be removed~by September 28, 1993 or upon issuance of building permits for the Administration building, whichever occurs first." This language should be used for both CUP 88- 10 and CUP 88-38. III. FACTS FOR FINDINGS: The Commission must make all of the following in ings in or er to approve this application: 67 C• PLANNING COMMISSIOA~'AFF REPORT CUP 88-10 - HILLSIDE COMMUNITY CHURCH N OYEMBER 28, 1990 . Page 4 A. There have been no significant changes in the Land Use Element, Development Code, or character of the area within which the project is 1 ocated that woul d cause the approved project to become inconsistent or non-conforming. B. The granting of an extension should not be detrimental to the public health, safety, or welfare or materially injurious to properties or improvements in the vicinity. IV. RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Planning Commission gran a one-year time extension subject to modifying the language regarding removal of the modulars and adding a condition for a block wall along the west property line. Appropriate Resolutions are attached for your considera tion. ctful l ~ subm Brad Buller City P1 anner BB:BN:mlg Attachments: Exhibit "A" - Letter from Applicant Exhibit "B" - Site Plan Exhibit "C" - Building Elevations Exhibit "D" - Conceptual Grading Plan Exhibit "E" - Conceptu al Landscape Plan Exhibit "F" - Modular Site Plan Exhibit "G" - Modular Elevations Resolution of Approval 88-196 Resolution of Approval 88-199 Modified Resolution of Approval 88-198A (CUP 88-10) Resolution Approving Time Extension (CUP 88-10) Modified Resolution of Approval 68-199A (CUP 88-38) b8 RESOLUTION N 0, gg-lggq A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF RANCHO CUCAMONGA, CALIFORNIA, APPROVING MODIFICATION TO CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT N0, 88-10 FOR A MASTER PLAN FOR A CHURCH CONSISTING OF SANCTUARY, ADMINISTRATION BUILDING, EDUCATION/NURSERY BUILDING, AND FAMILY CENTER TOTALING 11,520 SQUARE FEET ON 8.5 ACRES OF LAND IN THE VERY LOW RESIDENTIAL DISTRICT LOCATED ON THE WEST SIDE OF HAVEN AVENUE NORTH OF HILLSIDE ROAD, AND MAKING FINDINGS IN SUPPORT THEREOF - APN: 1074-27 1-01. A. Recitals. (i) Hillside Community Church has filed an application for the modification of Conditional Use Permit N o. 88-10 as described in the title of this Resolution. Hereinafter in this Resolution, the subject Conditional Use Permit request is referred to as "the application." (ii) On the 28th of November, 1990, the Planning Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga conducted a duly noticed public hearing on the application and concluded said hearing on that date, (iii) All legal prerequisites prior to the adoption of this Resolution have occurred. B, Resolution. NOW, THEREFORE, it is hereby found, determined, and resolved by the Planning Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga as follows: 1. This Commission hereby specifically finds that all of the facts set forth in the Recitals, Part A, of this Resolution are true and correct, 2. Based upon substantial evidence presented to this Commission during the above-referenced public hearing on November 28, 1990, including written and oral staff reports, together with public testimony, this Commission hereby specifically finds as follows: (a ) The application applies to property 1 ocated at 5354 Haven Avenue with a street frontage of 660 feet and 1 of depth of 675 feet and is presently improved with four temporary buildings, a parking lot, and community and local equestrian trails; and (b) The property to the north of the subject site is vacant, the property to the south of that site consists of single family residential dwellings, the property to the east is Haven Avenue and single family residential beyond, and the property to the west consists of single family residential dwellings. 13--~-s 6q PLANNING COMMISSION RESOLUTION N0. 88-198A CUP BS-10 - HILLSIDE COMMUNITY CHURCH NOVEMBER 28, 1990 Page 2 3. Based upon the substantial evidence presented to this Commission during the above-referenced public hearing and upon the specific findings of facts set forth in paragraphs 1 and 2 a bove, this Commission hereby finds and concludes as follows: (a ) That the proposed modifications to conditions of approval are in accord with the General Plan, the objectives of the Development Code, and the purposes of the district in which the site is located; and (b) That the proposed modifications will not be detrimental to the public health, safety, or welfare or materially injurious to properties or improvements in the vicinity; and (c) That the proposed m odifications comply with each of the applicable provisions of the Development Code. 4. Based upon the findings and conclusions set forth in paragraphs 1, 2, and 3 above, this Commission hereby modifies certain conditions as contained in Resolution 88-198 to read a s follows: Planning Division: 3) The three original modulars shall be removed by September 28, 1993 or upon completion of the Family Center, whichever occurs firs t. 4) The 60 foot x 144 foot classroom modular shall be removed by September 28, 1993, or upon issuance of building permits for the Administration building, whichever occurs first. 5) A 6-foot high decorative masonry wall shall be constructed along the westerly property line with Phase I. The final design of said wall shall be approved by the City Planner or his designee prior to issuance of building permits for the wall. 5. The Secretary to this Commission shall certify to the adoption of this Resolution. APPROVED AND ADOPTED THIS 28TH DAY OF NOVEMBER 1990. PLANNING COM~SION OF THE CITY OF RANCHO CUCAMONGA B Y : / ~ ~~tc.c ry /. i e ,Chairman ATTEST: tto~Kroutil ,` Deputy Secr /~-ab - _.. _. 7~ PLANNING COMMISSION RESOLUTION N0. 88-198A CUP 88-10 - HILLSIDE COMMUNITY CHURCH NOVEMBER 28, 1990 Page 3 I, Otto Kroutil, Deputy Secretary of the Planning Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga, do hereby certify that the foregoing Resolution was duly and regul arl y i ntroduced, passed, and adopted by the P]anni ng Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga, at a regular meeting of the Planning Commission held on the 28th day of November 1990 by the following vote-to-wit: AYES: COMMISSIONERS: NOES: COMMISSIONERS: ABSENT: COMMISSIONERS: CHITIEA, MCNIEI , MELC~EP,, TOLSTOY VALLETTE NONE ~-a ~ ~~ • • RESOLUTION N0. 88-199A A RESOLUTION OF THE RANCHO C UCAMONGA PLANNING COMMISSION APPROVING THE MODIFICATION T 0 CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT N0. 88-38 FOR AN EXISTING MODULAR BUILDING (60 FEET x 144 FEET) FOR A CHURCH CLASSRO 0 M FACILITY ON 8.5 ACRES OF LAND IN THE VERY LOW RESIDENTIAL DISTRICT LOCATED ON THE WEST SIDE OF HAVEN AVENUE NORTH OF HILLSIDE ROAD, ANO MAKING FINDINGS IN SUPPORT THEREOF - APN: 1014-271-01. A. Recitals. (i) Hillside Community Church has filed an application for the modification of the Conditional Use Permit No. 88-38 as described in the title of thi s Resolution. Herei Wafter i n thi s Resolution, the subject Conditional Use Permit request is referred to as "the application." (ii) On the 28th of November 1990, the Planning Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga conducted a duly noticed public hearing on the application and concluded said hearing on that date. (iii) All legal prerequisites prior to the adoption of this Resolution have occurred. B. Resolution. NOW, THEREFORE , i t i s hereby found, determined, and resolved by the Planning Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga as follows: 1. This Commission hereby specifically finds that all of the facts set forth in the Recitals, Part,A, of this Resolution are true and correct. 2. Based upon substantial evidence presented to this Commission during the above-referenced public hearing on November 28, 1990, including written and oral staff reports, together with public testimony, this Commission hereby specifically finds as follows: (a) The application applies to property located at 5354 Haven Avenue with a street frontage of 660 feet and lot depth of 675 feet and is presently improved with four temporary buildings, a parking lot and community and local equestrian trails;~and (b) The property to the north of the subject site is vacant, the property to the south of that site consists of single family residential dwellings, the property to the east is Haven Avenue and single family residential beyond and the property to the west consists of single family residential dwellings. 3. Based upon the substantial evidence presented to this Commission during the above-referenced public hearing and upon the specific findings of 7a PLANNING COMMISSION I.ILUTION N0, 88-199A CUP 88-38 - HILLSIDE „IMMUNITY CHURCH November 28, 1990 ' Page 2 facts set forth in paragraphs 1 and 2 above, this Commission hereby finds and concludes a's follows: (a) That the proposed modifications to conditions of approval are in accord with the General Plan, the objectives of the Development Code, and the purposes of the district in which the site is located; and (b) That the proposed modifications will not be detrimental to _ the public health, safety, or welfare o r materially injurious to properties or im provements in the vicinity; and (c) That the proposed modifications comply with each of the applicable provisions of the Development Code. 4. Based upon the findings and conclusions set forth in paragraphs 1, 2, and 3 above, this Commission hereby modifies certain conditions as contained in Resolution 88-199 to read as follows: Planning Division: 5) The 60 foot x 144 foot classroom modular shall be removed by September 28, 199 3 or upon issuance of building permits for the Administration balding, whichever occurs first, S . The Secretary ~to thi s Commission shal l certify to the adoption of this Resolution. APPROVED AND ADOPTED THIS 28TH DAY OF NOVEMBER 1990. PLANNING COM SSION OF THE CITY OF RANCHO CUCAMONGA r BY: 5 ry T,; i el , Thai rman ATTEST: to~Kroutil/, Deputy Secretary I , Otto K'routil , Deputy Secretary of the Planning Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga, do hereby certify that the foregoing Resolution was duly and regularly introduced, passed, and adopted by the Planning Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga, at a regular meeting of the Planning Commission held on the 28th day of November 1990 by the following vote-to-wit: AYES: COMMISSIONERS: CNITIEA, MCNIEL, MELC~iER, TOLSTOY NOES: COMMISSIONERS: VALLETTE ABSENT: COMMISSIONERS: NONE '13 u CITY OF RANCH O CUCAMONGA STAFF REPORT DATE: November 13, 1991 T0: Chairman and Members of the P Tanning Commission FROM: Otto ICroutil, Deputy City Planner BY: Beverly Nissen, Associate P1 anner SUBJECT: TIME EXTENSION FOR CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT 88-10 - HILLSIDE COMMUNITY CHURCH - A request for a time extension to the master plan for a church consisting of a sanctuary, administration building, education/nursery building, and family center totaling 11,520 square feet on 8.5 acres of land in the Very Low Residential District located on the west aide of Haven Avenue. north of Hillside Road - APN: 1074-271-01. BACKGROUND: The Hillside Community Church was originally approved by the Planning Commission on February 9, 1983, (Conditional Use Permit 82-29) and expired 18 months later since building permits for Phase I were not issued during this time period. Three temporary modular buildings were also approved under the original Conditional Use Permit, along with the construction of Parking Lot A. A fourth modular building was approved under Conditional Use Permit 88-38 in 1988. In addition, a Variance was approved with the project which allowed for a 50-foot height limit on the sanctuary building. The project was resubmitted in 198 8 and given a new project number (Conditional Use Permit 88-10y since the original approval had lapsed. The project, as submitted in 1988, was identical to the originally approved projectT however, it was modified through the design review process. Modifications made during the design review process included the following: 1. The height of the sanctuary was lowered from 50 to 35 feet and it was significantly redesigned. (This height reduction eliminated the need for a Variance.) 2. The roof material was changed from copper-colored seamed metal to tile. The revised Conditional Use Permit 68-10 was approved by the Planning Commission on September 28, 1988. ANALYSIS• A. Time Extension: Staff has analyzed the proposed time extension and has compared the proposal with the current development criteria outlined in the Development Code. Based upon this review, staff has determined that the project meets the development criteria of the Very .Low Residential District (2-4 dwelling units per acre). In addition, there have been no significant changes in the character of the area that would cause the project to be inconsistent with its surroundings. ~y PLANNING COMMISSION ~F REPORT • CUP 68-10 - HILLSIDE MMUNITY CHURCH Navember 13, 1991 Page 2 Conditional Use Permit 88-10 was originally approved on September 28, 1988, with a two-year time limit. A one-year time extension was granted on November 28, 1990, which extended the expiration date to September 28, 1991. The applicant is, at this time requesting an additional one-year time extension to September 28, 199 2. The applicant still intends to construct the project in the phases which were originally approved. The Family Center building and ball fields are the only portions remaining to be built for Phase I, which also includes the existing Parking Lot A and the four modular buildings. The three original modular buildings are to be removed by September 28, 1993, or upon completion of the Family Center building, whichever occurs first. The classroom modular building (Conditional Use Permit 68-38) shall also be removed by September 28, 1993, or upon issuance of building permits for the Administration building (Ph ass III), whichever occurs first. FACTS FOR FINDINGS: The Commission must make all of the following findings in order to approve this application: A. There have been no significant changes in the Land Uae Element, Development Code, or character of the area within which the project is located that would cause the approved project to become inconsistent or non-conforming. B. The granting of an extension should not be detrimental to the public health, safety, r welfare or materially injurious to properties or .improvements i~t,~ie vicinity. RECOMMEFDATI N: t recommends that the Planning Commission grant a one- year ime xte i An appropriate Resolution is attached for your cons deratio . pact fu l ly/,~l`i~fttitted, Otto Krout 1 Deputy Ci y P1 OK:SN:~lg Attadhments: Exhibit "A" - Letter from Applicant Exhibit "B" - Site Plan Exhibit "C" - Building Elevations Exhibit "D" - Conceptual Grading Plan Exhibit "E" - Conceptual Landscape Plan Exhibit "F" - Modular Site Plan (informational only} Exhibit "C" - Modular Elevations {informational only) Resolution of Appraval 68 -198 (CUP 88-10) Modified Resolution of Approval 88-198A (CUP 88-10} Resolution Approving Time Extension for CUP 88-10 '15 ~ t RESOLUTION N0. 91-183 A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING CONA2ISSION OF THE CITY OF RANCHO CUCAMONGA, CALIFORNIA, APPROVING THE TIME EXTENSION FOR CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT 88-10 LOCATED AT 5354 HAVEN AVENUE, AND MAKING FINDINGS IN SUPPORT THEREOF - APN: 1674-271-01. WHEREAS, a request has been filed for a time extension for the above-described project, pursuant to Development Code Section 17.02.100. WHEREAS, the Planning Commission conditionally approved the above-described project on September 2B, 1988. WHEREAS, the Planning Cammissi on granted a one-year time extension in 1990 causing the project to expire on September 28, 1991. SECTION 1: The Rancho Cucamozzga planning Commission has made the following findings: A. That prevailing economic conditions have caused a distressed market climate f or development of the project. B• That current economic, marketing, and inventory conditions make it unr easonable to develop the project at this time. C• That strict enforcement of the conditions of approval regarding expirations would not be consistent with the intent of the Development Code. D• That the granting of said time extension will not be detrimental to the public health, safety, or welfare or materially injurious to properties or improvements in the vicinity. SECTION 2: The Rancho Cucamon ga Planning Commission hereby grants a time extension for: Project Applicant Expiration CUP 88-10 Hillside Community September 28, 1992 Church APPROVED AND ADOPTED THIS 13TH DAY OF NOVEMBER 1991. PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF RANCHO CUCAMONGA 76 PLANNING COMMISSION ~OLUTION N0. 91-18 3 ~.... CLIP 88-10 - HILLSIDE CON4~lUNITY CHURCH November 1B, 1991 Page 2 BY: AT'I I, Brad Buller, Secretary of the Planning Gommission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga, do hereby certify that the: fore going Resolution was duly and regularly introduced, passed, and adopted by the Planning Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga, at a regular meeting of the Planning Commission held on the 13th day of November 1991, by the following vote-to-wit: AYES: CONIlriISSIONERS: CHIT= EA, MCNIEL, MELCHER, TOLSTCY, VALLETTE NOES: COt~SISSIONERS: NONE ABSENT: COMMISSIONERS: NONE hq •-- ` .~ CITY OF KANCHO CUCAMONGA STAFF REPORT DATE: November 10, 1992 T0: Chairman and Members of the Planning Commission FROM: Dan Coleman, Principal Planner BY: Beverly Nissen, Associate Planner SUBJECT: TIME EXTENSION FOR CONDIT ZONAL USE PERMIT 88-10 - HILLSIDE COMMUNITY CHURCH - A request for a time extension to the master plan for a church consisting of a sanctuary, administration building, education/nursery building, and family center totaling 11,520 square feet an 8.5 acres of land in the Very Low Residential District located on the west side of Haven Avenue north of Hillside Road - APN: 1074- 271-01. BACKGROUND: The campus Master Plan for Hillside Community Church was originally approved in February 1983 (Conditional Use Permit 82-29). In September 1988, the Planning Commission reapproved the same original Master Plan with some modifications to the building design. At the request of the Design Review Committee, the architecture of the sanctuary was significantly redesigned, the height of the sanctuary was lowered from 50 to 35 feet, and the roof material was changed from copper colored seamed metal to tile. ANALYSIS: A. Time Extension: Staff has analyzed the proposed time extension and, has compared the proposal with the current development criteria outlined in the Development Code. Based upon this review, staff has determined that the project meets the development criteria of the Very Low Residential District (2-4 dwelling units per acre). In addition, there have been no significant changes in the character of the area that would cause the' project to be inconsistent with its surroundings. Conditional Use Permit 88-10 was originally approved on September 28, 1986, with a two-year time limit. A one-year time extension was granted on November 26, 1990, which extended the expiration date to September 26, 1991. An additional one-year time extension was granted on November 13, 1991 which extended the expiration date to September 28, 1992. The app licant is at this time requesting an additional one year time extension to September 28, 1993. 78 PLANNING COMMISSIO~TAFF REPORT ~• TIME EXT CUP 88-10/HILLSIDE COMMUNITY CHiJRCH November 10, 1992 Page 2 The church is currently preparing plans and intends to begin construction of the family center in early 1993. This will be the church's first permanent building. The church is currently operating in four separate mo dular buildings. Each modular building has been conditioned to be removed within a specific phase of the project or by September 28, 1993, whichever comes first. Though not a part of this request, the applicant will need to address the removal, or another extension of time, for these modular units before September 19 93. FACTS FOR FINDINGS: The Commission must make all of the following findings in order to approve this app Lication: A. There have been no significant changes in the Land Use Element, Development Code, or character of the area within which the project is located that would cause the approved project to become inconsistent or non-conforming. B. The granting of an extension should not be detrimental to the public health, ,safety, or welfare or materially injurious to properties or improvements in the vicinity. RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Planning Commission grant a one-year time extension. An appropriate Resolution is attached for your consideration. Resp l1y submi d, C~%/" Da Coleman Principal Planner DC:BN:js Attachments: Exhibit "A" - Letter from Applicant Exhibit "B" - Site Plan Exhibit "C" - Building Elevations Exhibit "D" - Conceptual Grading Plan Exhibit "E" - Conceptual Landscape Plan Exhibit "F" - Modular Site Plan (informational only) Exhibit "G" - Modular Elevations (informational only) Resolution of Approval 88-198 (CUP 88-10) Modified Resolution of Approval 88-198A (CUP88-10} Resolution Approving Time Extension for CUP 88-10 j79 5'1'K_llUC: U MENT_VIEW Document Name :CUP 88-10 RMOLLR'I00k bn7, 8Zr136 A 7mQOLUT2001 OC THn PLA~7NS~7D 007QISJiIOQq D4 TR! CITY OP ~N~ fi.UCAlWpOdi~ CJILISPFN311, AP@AOVIHO Tii& TIEla lttraaiioo~ tort coaaotrzolau, usa raexlT ea-lo r,.ak:krea ar 5354 1ut~^N RViZHUSr k1aD AN4RLkfC Pi0~rk9oe IN iDPPCDtT THSnZG1F - APHk 1674-17303, ipyQlns7~, a request hu baan til,re for a tlkn^ extanalkm !ar Ghe ^ba.a-daaarSb~d pxOjsvC~ put^u-nt to 0^otSen 17.C1.300~ OP}!si{eAi, tike FLaYU~ing Commiuien eorkditiansUY ipprovatl tE/ anew-daeorib^d prat^ct on 9aptember 2i, 1i88. 9blS7tER5, ti-a pLaaainv Cvmm3ealen granted ^n additlvnal Dna y~eer tlme aaetsneian 1n S9Q6 vau^inq Irks pra~^ot to +kepira oa kt+pt.^brr 28, i99i. 9P8931DAi, t}k^ Planning Commleeioet granted an addiCionRl onr-Pear ttma kp~lap^ioa in 1191 aav^inq Llks pra~k-ot to orpir^ vn &+ptambrr 78, 149. B4CSZbN ik 'irfe llsae]kA Cucaavap/ YLrnnikrkg Cnmaaiaeian 7f/s karaa the foilowinq lindin,~^k 7~. That preN^ilitsp ^canom,Le vvotpition^ have eavaiei a di^er^^^^d eark~t allirttr tar d~w]opm^nt o! Ch^ peaiWO4 J. Thee cuxr^nt +eonomla, marketing, ^nd 5nv^rnvey ovndi4lbn^ Eo^kf LL kulY^a^onFbl^ to d^u^lop tK^ projaet at thin risk., C. That ^tri~ eatxcemaes ai tn• eorxlitSan. oe igtlt'vv,41 rrgardlnq kueplsaCiov^ w0ula paC be oen^lst^rst with the lntvnt o! th^ Gwaloym^nt Cnda. a. That tda granting GP ~i1d tf.ef euter.^ion vill not b^ d^tsi..sisal t6 th^ p~Dlia lualth, ~at^ty, or w^1lak:^ ' or mat^riaily in~vrivukk• tv prnprttto/ nr inprovemrknte is t1u vleinlty~ 8~'7,7Iau 7k Tl1kh Ranoha cuk:emonga tl^nninp Cauni^*lon h.rehy grans. a ti~w extonsivn losk Pra1^SS ApolSCant zkevs.~it` ova ee-Sks xLlleik9• CooMmnsty bnura}, a^pt^mbar~~i, Y9 p9 Page 1 of 1 http //srv-laserfiche/webllnk/DocView.asp~DocumentID=142698&FolderID=13024&SearchH 8/9/2004 STR_DOCUMENT VIEW Document Name :CUP 88-10 riaenv=~ao ~raara~ aLUT:o~ Ha. 92-136 CGP 88-10'- EiSLLSror~=~ p~~RCy Rowabar I0, 199Q papa ~ ~rPAOVBC ~uio itoorraa rata SM~! war oa ~ti's~+asa 199x. 4LAN7QIOf0 4pbpa SO1P OS TNT r ar RlJ~FiO CtJC~N.OHpq l 3Yf L ry iy~ oha i rman 6tEe xrnut ~ napu~y 8aeraeary , s, oteo xrautii Orputy eaeratary a! th^ FLdri~inq ranmiuion o! c.he City of Rancho Cueamonpa, do harrby cartily that the Eoragnieq as^olution waa duly and rrquL^r1y Lntsaduead, paced, end ^dcptad by the llcnr~lnp ¢amalaaiva os the City a! Anbohv L1tiDamonpa, at a raqular p~tirig o! tha Planning Cemmicci0a ha13 an tha iCth day o! 1oov~ar 1992, bV tha lclLdwin~ von.-ta•Wiki ~LYZC7 C5M64=ASS409~R9t GTIITIE4r [A:HLBL~ TCI,SRDY xoese ,mustassooeaae~ loons ~aooaor~ coaa-ucrtoa®nci ~scH~~ vg Page 1 of 1 ~' http://srv-laserfiche/webhnk/DocView.asp~DocumentID=142698&FolderID=13024&SearchH 8/9/2004 CITY OF RANCHO CUCAMONGA - J STAFF REPORT DATE: April 24, 1996 T0: Chairman and Members of the Planning Commission FROM: Dan Coleman, Principal Planner SUBJECT: CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT 96-0~ HI 4inF ~~MMUNITY CHURCH - A request for a new approval for the existing modular buildings on approximately 10 acres of land in the Very Low Residential District (up to 2 dwelling units per acre), located at X354 Haven Avenue - APN: 1074-271-01 BACKGROUND: On February 9, 1983, the original church proposal (Conditional Use Permit 82-29) was approved by the Planning Commission. The approval reflected a phased development pursuant to a Master Plan (Exhibit "B"}, which included permanent buildings and temporary modular buildings. The church proceeded with development of their first phase which included the temporary modulars, parking lots, and landscaping (Exhibit "C"). A subsequent application (Conditional Use Permit 88-10) was approved by the Commission on September 28, 1988, which was identical to the original with the exception of architectural changes to the permanent buildings. On that same date, the Planning Commission also granted approval of a fourth modular building under a separate Conditional Use Permit 88-38. The church installed the fourth modular in accordance with this approval. A modification to both Conditional Use Permits was approved on November 28, 1990, which granted a three year extension of time for the modulars. The time extension expired on September 28, 1993; however, none of thc modulars were removed. In August 1994 the church completed the Family Center, its first permanent building. The church was sent a letter in August 1994 reminding them of their obligation to remove the modulars. ANALYSIS; Temporary modulars are allowed for churches where a Master Plan for development of permanent facilities is approved. This flexibility recognizes the fact that churches generally don't have sufficient funds to pursue an aggressive development schedule The Planning Commission sets the time limits for temporary trailers for religious uses fora "specified interim period" on a case-by-case basis pursuant to Development Code Section 17.08.030.D.2. Traditionally the interim period has been up to five years to coincide with the time limits established for development approvals. The intent is to provide encouragement for project applicants to make progress toward completion of their permanent facilities. Hillside Community Church has made substantial progress toward completing the permanent improvements to their site These include, in addrt~on to the Family Center, full street improvements, fully graded site, all parking facilities ', ;except for about 30 parking spaces underneath the modulars), landscaping, and ballfields The church is ~, •equesting a five year extension for the modulars (Exhibit "D"). 4a PLANNNG COMMISSION STAFF REPORT CUP 96-03 -HILLSIDE COMMUNITY CHURCH April 24, 1996 Page 2 FACTS FOR FINDING; Staff believes the following facts support the requisite findings: A. The proposed use is consistent v~nth General Plan policies to create opportunities wherein a population diverse in terms of income, age, occupation, race, lifestyle, values, interests, and religion may interact, exchange ideas, .and realize common goals. B. The proposed use is consistent with the Development Code provisions which allow churches within residential districts. C The modular buildings have been located on the site since 1983/84 without complaint and no evidence has been submitted to show that they are a detriment to the public health, safely or welfare or~matetially injurious to properties or improvements in the vicinity. D. The rnodulaz buildings were installed on the site in full conformance with the Development Code requirements. CORRESPONDENCE: The Planning Division was contacted by several residents expressing concern that the modulazs were not removed in 1993. Staff arranged a meeting between residents and church representatives on the church property to discuss this and other issues concerning the ballfields on January 11, 1996. Subsequently we received a letter from an attorney representing four residents on Vivienda, immediately south of the church site demanding removal of the modulars The City Attorney's office responded in writing to this letter. Copies of the two attorney's letters were previously transmitted under separate cover In an Aprii 17 letter (Exhibit "E"), the residents' attorney cites the "unsightly scene of the modulars which directly abut their homes" as the basis for their opposition to this Conditional Use Permit request and their reason for wanting the modulars removed. RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends approval of the request through adoption of the attached ,Resolution. DC:mlg Attachments: Exhibit "A" Exhibit "B" Exhibit "C" ~, Exhibit "D" Exhibit "E" Resolution ~ - Vicinity Map - Master Site Plan - Modular Site Plan -Letters from Applicant - April 17 Letter from Tred~iay Lumsdatne & Doyle ~f Approval ~ ,~ C 43 Principal Planner • • RESOLUTION NO. 96-27 A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF RANCHO CUCAMONGA, CALIFORNIA, APPROVING CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 96-03 FOR EXISTING TEMPORARY MODULAR BUILDINGS LOCATED IN THE VERY LOW RESIDENTIAL DISTRICT ON THE SOUTHWEST CORNER OF HAVEN AVENUE AND VISTA GROVE STREET, AND MAKING FINDINGS IN SUPPORT THEREOF - APN: 1074-271-01. A. R cita s, 1. Hillside Community Church has filed an application for the issuance of Conditional Use Permit No. 96-03, as described in the title of this Resolution. Hereinafter in this Resolution, the subject Conditional Use Permit request is referred to as "the application." 2. On the 24th day of April 1996, the Planning Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga conducted a duly noticed public hearing on the application and concluded said hearing on that date. 3. All legal prerequisites prior to the adoption of this Resolution have occurred. B. Res_ olution, NOW, THEREFORE, it is hereby found, determined, and resolved by the Planning Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga as follows: 1. This Commission hereby specifically finds That all of the facts set forth in the Recitals, Part A, of this Resolution are true-and correct. 2. Based upon substantial evidence presented to this Commission during the above- referenced public hearing on April 24, 1996, including written and oral staff reports, together with public testimony, this Commission hereby specifically finds as follows: a. The application applies to property located at 5354 Haven Avenue which is presently improved with a church, including the subject modular buildings, family center multi- purpose building, parking lots, and landscaping; and b. The properties to the north, south, east, and west of the subject site are single family residential; and c The temporary modular buildings were installed on the property pursuant to an approved Master Plan for phased development of the church campus under Conditional Use Permits 82-29, 88-10, and 88-38; and d. The church has, since 1983, been steadily making progress toward completion of their permanent facilities, including the family center, permanent parking lots, full grading of the site, landscaping, and ballfiefds consistent with the approved Master Plan; and e. The application contemplates maintaining the modular buildings for an additional five years until completion of the next phase of development; and ~~'Hi~tT tt~~~ Sy PLANNING COMMlSSIO~ESOLUTION N0, 96-21 • CUP 96-03 -HILLSIDE COMMUNITY CHURCH April 24, 1996 Page 2 f. -The Development Code Section 'f 7.08.030. D.2 gives the Planning Commission the authority to establish appropriate time limits for temporary trailers for religious uses on a case-by- case basis; and g. The temporary modular buildings have been located on the property since 1983/84 without any record of complaints from surrounding residents. 3. Based upon the substantial evidence presented to this Commission during the above- referenced public hearing and upon the specific findings of facts set forth in paragraphs 1 and 2 above, this Commission hereby finds and concludes as follows: a. The proposed use is in accord with the General Plan, the objectives of the Development Code, and the purposes of the district in which the site is located. b. The proposed use, together with the conditions applicable thereto, will not be detrimental to the public health, safe#y, or welfare or materially injurious to properties or improvements in the vicinity. c. The proposed use complies with each of the applicable provisions of the Development Code. 4. The Planning Commission hereby finds and determines that the project identified in this Resolution is categorically exempt from the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act of 1970, as amended, and the Guidelines promulgated thereunder, pursuant to Section 15301 of the State CEQA Guidelines. 5. Based upon the findings and conclusions set forth in paragraphs 1, 2, 3, and 4 above, this Commission hereby approves the application subject to each and every condition set forth below: Planning Division 1) All modular buildings shall be removed by April 24, 2001, or upon completion of the next permanent building, whichever occurs first. 6. The Secretary to this Commission shall certify to the adoption of this Resolution. ADO jTED T~iIS 24TH DAY OF APRIL 1996. ING C\O~JIMI SIONi-'~E CITY OF RANCHO CUCAMONGA BY: ATTEST• David 13ark~r, Chairman ra d B $5 PLANNING COMMISSIO~ESOLUTION NO. 96-27 CUP 96-03 -HILLSIDE COMMUNITY CHURCH April 24, 1996 Page 3 1, Brad Buller, Secretary of the Planning Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga, do hereby certify that the foregoing Resolution was duly and,ragulariy introduced, passed, and adopted by the Planning Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga, at a regular meeting of the Planning Commission held on the 24th day of April 1996, by the following vote-to-wit: AYES: COMMISSIONERS: BARKER, LLiMPP, MCNIEL, MELCHER, TOLSTOY NOES: COMMISSIONERS: NONE ASSENT: COMMISSIONERS: NONE 86 DATE: June 6, 1996 CITY OF RANCHO CUC • ONGA STAFF REP®RT TO. Mayor and Members of the City Council Jack Lam, AICP, City Manager FROM: Dan Coleman, Principal Planner SUBJECT: CONSIDERATION OF CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT 96 03 HILLSIDE COMMUNITY CHURCH -Appeal of the Plannng Commission's approval of the continued use of modular buildings on 10 acres of land in the Very Low Residential District (up to 2 dwelling units per acre), located at 5354 Haven Avenue - APN: 1074-271-01. RECOMMENDATION: The Planning Commission recommends that the City Council approve the modulars through adoption of the attached Resolution. BACKGROUND On April 24, 1996, the Planning Commission unanimously approved Conditional Use Permit 96-03 for the church to continue using their existing modular buildings. The modulars, which house classrooms and offices, are required to be removed within five years or upon completion of the next permanent building, whichever occurs first. This decision was appealed by an attorney, who represents the four adjoining property owners of ~vienda Street, on the grounds that the Planning Commission allegedly failed to follow Development Code Section 17.02.100 pertaining to lapse of development approvals. The City Attorney's office had previously responded to the appellant that they were incorrectly applying a section of the Code which is no longer applicable in this case (Exhibits "E" & "F"). The City Attorney reiterated during the public hearing that Development Code Section 17.02.100 provides that approvals will expire after 24 months if the developer has not diligently pursued building permits and obtained a certificate of occupancy. By its temps, the time limit becomes inapplicable once the project is completed. The permit for Hillside Community Church for the modular buildings was fully exercised when the modulars were installed and a Certificate of Occupancy issued; therefore, Section 17.02.100 has no bearing on this matter. The Development Code recognizes that temporary structures may be allowed for churches for a time deemed appropriate by the Planning Commission. Accordingly, the City Attorney has stated that the Planning Commission was acting within its authority to approve this CUP for the modulars. ANALYSIS During the public hearing, property owners to the south objected to the continued use of the modulars, citing the length of time these temporary buildings have existed, noise, and aesthetics as their primary concerns. The modulars were originally installed in 1985 The residents felt that 8~ CITY COUNCIL STAFF RE~RT • CUP 96-03 -HILLSIDE COMMUNITY CHURCH June 5, 1996 Page 2 the modulars have already been allowed to stay far too long. In their findings, the Planning Commission noted that the church has been diligently pursuing development of their property since 1983. Permanent improvements completed to date include: full street improvements, grading and landscaping of the entire site, construction of the family center multi-purpose building, parking, and balifields. The Commission also noted that the modulars had existed on the church site since 1965 without complaint from surrounding residents. One resident complained that a compressor comes on at 5:00 a.m. and disturbed their sleep. The church testified that the air conditioners and heat pumps in the modulars are on a double fail-safe system to minimize energy costs. The air conditioners are preset to come on during the times they use the buildings which is normally after 8:00 a.m. The air conditioners must also be activated by manually turning a timer switch inside the buildings. There are heat pumps on one of the modulars which work on the same type of timers. Three bad timers were replaced recently because of the expense to run the units when they are not needed. The third concern was a general dissatisfaction with the appearance of temporary buildings versus permanent buildings. The residents felt that temporary buildings were less attractive than permanent buildings and should not be allowed to remain. In addition, the residents complained about the level of exterior maintenance on the buildings, citing cracked and peeling paint. The church indicated that these buildings are on a regular cycle of maintenance as evidenced by their repainting earlier this year. The modulars were repainted approximately 2 years ago and 2'/z years prior to that. The Commission also noted that modulars adjoin two of the four residents on Vivienda Street and that only portions of the modulars were visible because of extensive landscaping between the houses and the modulars. The fourth concern was whether the modulars meet building codes for seismic safety. The Building 8~ Safety Division has indicated that the modulars met all seismic codes in effect at the time building permits were issued in the early 1980's. Although seismic codes have been amended since then, existing structures are exempt and are not required to be brought up to current code standards. CORRESPONDENCE This item was advertised as a public hearing by mailing notices to property owners within 300 feet, posting notices on the project site, and publishing a notice in the Inland Valley Daily Bulletin. Resp ctfully ubmitted, Dan Coleman Principal Planner Attachments: Exhibit "A" -Appeal Letter from Mr. Lumsdaine (dated April 29, 1996) Exhibit "B" -April 24, 1996, Planning Commission Staff Report Exhibit "C" -April 24, 1996, Minutes of Planning Commission meeting Exhibit "D" -Planning Commission Resolution of Approval No 96-27 Exhibit "E" -March 6, 1996, letter from Ralph Hanson Exhibit "F" -April 18, 1996, Letter from Ralph Hanson Resolution approving Conditional Use Permit 96-03 Sg T~ ~ , ~ ~ '• RESOLUTION NO. 96-093 A ,RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ' RANCHO CUCAMONGA, CALIFORNIA, APPROVING CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 96-03, FOR EXISTING TEMPORARY MODULAR BUILDINGS LOCATED AT HILLSIDE COMMUNITY CHURCH IN THE VERY LOW RESIDENTIAL DISTRICT ON THE SOUTHWEST CORNER OF HAVEN AVENUE AND VISTA GROVE STREET, AND MAKING FINDINGS IN SUPPORT THEREOF - APN: 1074-271-01. A. Recitals 1. Hillside Community Church• has filed an application for the issuance of Conditional Use Permit No. 96-03, as described in the title of this Resolution. Hereinafter in this Resolution, the subject Conditional Use Permit request is referred to as "the application." 2. On the 24th day of April 1996, the Planning Commission of the City of Rancho Cucamonga conducted a duly noticed public hearing on the application and following the conclusion of said public hearing, adopted Planning Commission Resolution No. 96-27, thereby approving the application. 3. The decision represented by said Planning Commission Resolution was~timely appealed to this City Council. 4. On June 5, 1996, the City Council of the City of Rancho Cucamonga conducted a duly noticed public hearing on the application and concluded said hearing on that date. 5. All legal prerequisites prior to the adoption of this Resolution have occurred. B. Resolution. NOW, THEREFORE, it is hereby found, determined, and resolved by the City Council of the City of Rancho Cucamonga as follows: 1. This Council hereby spec~cally finds that all of the facts set forth in the Recitals, Part A, of this Resolution are true and correct. 2. The City Council hereby finds and determines that the project identified in this Resolution is categorically •exempt from the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act of 1970, as amended, and the Guidelines promulgated thereunder, pursuant to Section 15301 of the State CEQA Guidelines. 89 ~~ Resolution No. 96-093 Page 2 • 3. Based upon substantial evidence presented to this Council during the above- referenced public hearing on June 5, 1996, including written and oral staff reports, the minutes of the above-referenced Planning Commission meeting, and the contents of Planning Commission' Resolution No. 96-27, together with public testimony, this Council hereby specifically finds as follows: 'a. The application applies to property located at 5354 Haven Avenue which is presently improved with a church, including the subject modular buildings, family ,center multi-purpose building, parking lots, and landscaping; and b. The properties to the north, south, east, and west of the subject site are single family residential; and c. The temporary modular buildings were installed on the property pursuant to an approved Master Plan for phased development of the church campus under Conditional Use Permits 82-29, 88-10, and 88-38; and d. The church has, since 1983, been steadily making progress toward completion of their permanent facilities, including the family center, permanent parking lots, full grading of the site, landscaping, and - ballfields consistent with the approved Master Plan; and e. The application contemplates maintaining the modular buildings for an additional five years until completion of the next phase of development; and f. The Development Code Section 17.08.030.D.2 gives the Planning Commission the authority to establish appropriate time limits for temporary trailers for religious uses on a case-by-case basis; and g. The temporary modular buildings have been located on the property since 1985 without any record of complaints from sun'ounding residents. 4. Based upon the substantial evidence presented to this Council during the above- referenced public heanng and upon the specific findings of facts set forth in paragraphs 1, 2, and 3 above, this Council hereby finds and concludes as follows: a. The proposed use is in accord with the General Plan, the objectives of the Development Code, and the purposes of the district in which the site is located. b. The proposed use, together with the conditions applicable thereto, will not be detrimental to the public health, safety, or welfare or materially injurious to properties or improvements in the vicinity. c. The proposed use complies with each of the applicable provisions of the Development Code.. qo ~~ " t 1y • Resolution No. 96-093 • ~ Page 3 5. The City Council of the City of Rancho Cucamonga, hereby approves the application subject to the conditions of approval contained in Planning Commission Resolution No. 96-27. 6. This Council hereby provides notice to Tredway, Lumsdaine & Doyle that the ~' time within which judicial review of the decision represented by this Resolution must be sought is governed by the provisions of Califomia Code of Civil Procedure Section 1094.6. 7, The City Clerk of the City of Rancho Cucamonga is hereby directed to: (a) certify to the adoption of•this Resolution, and (b) forthwith transmit a certified copy of this Resolution, by certified mail, return-receipt requested, to Tredway, Lumsdaine & Doyle at the address identified in City records. PASSED, APPROVED, AND ADOPTED this 5th day of June, 1996. AYES: Alexander, Biane, Curatalo, Gutierrez, Williams NOES: None ABSENT: None I, DEBRA J. ADAMS, CITY CLERK of the City of Rancho Cucamonga, Califomia, do hereby certify that the foregoing Resolution was duly passed, approved, and adopted by the City Council of the City of Rancho Cucamonga, Califomia, at a regular meeting of said City Council held on the 5th day of June, 1996. Executed this 6th day of June, 1996, at Rancho Cucamonga, Califomia. Debra J. Adams, CMC, City Clerk 41 Hello Commissioners I have put together a packet of information for yoga to review. Ihave hi-lighted & post noted what I thought was important information to save you tithe. Enclosed are: #1 Sound report done by the Smit's Family showing noise levels well about city code #2 Copy of the city's development code 17.02.1?A about noise abatement # California Civil code 3479- 3480 and 38771 about public nuisance #4 California Noise Control Act #5 Hillside Community Church schedule for games a practices March -June ' ~TiG~ ~ ` ®/ LrY]' #5 Aerial Photos showing how close the bail fields are to our homes #7 Aerial Photo of a park showing how far the ball fields are from homes #8 Copy of an email I sent to Hillside Community Church asking for a meeting so we the neighbors could resolve the noise problems with the games at the church #9 Copy of an article from the Inland Valley Daily Bulletin about rejecting a church's expansion because of neighbors complaints If you have any questions or would like to reach me please feel free to do so at 909-851-1321 or email at calpa12002@yahoo.com Thank you Terri Smith Spokesperson for the neighbors near and around Hillside Community Church FSrs.,. ~ ~_ w ~ ~1;' r L `_ l+~ s„~ ~ 4 I .-, 5i~ ~. h ~~ } _~ Yi ~ ZL K ~ T ~ f r ~~ ~ t ~ C ~ '~ Y F-' ~ ~ .~ ~~•, 4 ~ •.~ ~ ~3 ' t ~~ s F k ~~ •~ ~f~~ ui~,-~ ~, r ~~ ~~ r ,jy d t' ~, Y i 3 ~~ [" f r} 3 C~ l`~ . \J ~ ~' ~~~~~~ ~ ~ I ! VL I GV IVVIJC dV41C111Clil 7/ 1 /VO J I d YM Title 1 ZDEYEL4PMENT C4L~E Cha$ter 17 Q2 AQ11tI1N15TRAT14N 17 02 120 Norse abat®ment A Purpose In order to control unnecessary, excessive, and annoying noise and vibration rn the city, it rs declared to be the policy of the city to prohibit such noise generated from or by all sources as specified rn this section B Decibel Measurement Criteria Any decibel measurement made pursuant to the provisions of this section shall be based on a reference sound pressure of twenty micro-pascals as measured with a sound level meter using the "A" weighted network (scale) at stow response C Designated Noise Zones The properties hereafter described are hereby assigned the following noise zones Noise Zone 1 Ali single and multiple family residential properties Noise Zone II Ali commercial properties D Exterior Noise Standards 1 It is unlawful for any person at any location within the city to create any noise or allow the creation of any Horse on the property owned, leased, occupied, or otherwise controlled by such person, which causes the Horse level when measured on the property Ilne of any other property to exceed the basic Horse level as adjusted below a Basrc Horse level for a cumulatrve period of not more than fifteen minutes in any one hour, or b Basic noise level plus five dBA for a cumulative period of not more than ten mrnutes in any one hour, or c Basrc Horse level plus fourteen dBA for a cumulatrve period of not more than five minutes in any one hour, or d Basic Horse level plus fifteen dBA at any time 2 If the measurement location is a boundary between two different Horse zones, the lower Horse level standard shalt apply 3 If the intruding Horse source is continuous and cannot reasonably be discontinued or stopped for a time period whereby the ambient noise level can be determined, the measured Horse level obtained white the noise rs in operation shall be compared directly to the allowable noise level standards as specified respective to the measurement's location, designated land use, and for the time of day the noise level is measured The reasonableness of temporarily discontinuing the noise generation by an intruding noise source shall be determined by the city planner for the purpose of establishing the existing ambient noise level at the measurement location E Special Provisions The following activities shalt be exempted from the provisions of this section 1 Crty- or school-approved adrvrties conducted on public parks, public playgrounds, and public or private school grounds including, but not limited to, athletic and school entertainment events betty®en the hours of s®ven a m and ten p m , 2 Occasional outdoor gatherings, dances, shows, and sporting and entertainment events, provided said even#s are conducted pursuant to the approval of a temporary use permit issued by the city, 3 Any mechanical device, apparatus or equipment used, related to or connected with emergency machinery, vehrGe, work or http //munlclpalcodes lexlsnexls coin/codes/ranchocu/_DATA/TITLEI7/Chapter_17_02~4DMINISTRATION/17_02_120_Nase_abatement_ html Page 1 of 2 17 02 ~ 70 Nose abatement 9/1 /06 3 1 6 PM- warning alarm or bell, provided the sounding of any bell or alarm on any budding or motor vehicle shall ierm+nate its operation within thirty minutes in any hour of its being activated, 4 Noise sources assocated month, or vibration created by, construction, repa+r, remodeling or grading of any real property or during authorized seismic surveys, provided said activities do not take place between the hours of eight p m and six-thirty a m on weekdays, includ+ng Saturday, or at any time on Sunday or a national holiday, and provided noise levels created do not exceed the noise standard of sixty-five dBA plus the limits specified in Section 17 02 120(D)(1), 5 Ali devices, apparatus or equipment associated with agricultural operations prov+ded a Operations do not take place between eight p m and seven a m on weekdays, including Saturday, or at any time on Sunday or a national hol+day, or b Such operations and equipment are ut+lized for protection or salvage of agricultural crops during periods of potential or actual frost damage or other adverse weather conditions, or c Such operations and equipment are associated with agricultural pest control through pestic+de application, provided the application +s made in accordance with permits issued by, or regulations enforced by, the California Department of Agriculture, 6 Noise sources associated with the maintenance of real property, provided said activities take place between the hours of eight a m and eight p m on any day except Sunday or between the hours of nine a m and eight p m on Sunday, 7 Any activity to the extent regulation thereof has been preempted by state or federal law F Schools, Churches, Libraries, Health Care Institutions-Special Provisions It +s unlawful for any person to create any noise which causes the noise level at any school, hospital or similar health care institution, church, or library while the same is in use, to exceed the noise standards specified in this section and prescribed for the assigned noise zone in which the school, hospital, church or library is located G Administration Any act creating or permitting the creation of a noise disturbance as defined by this code, not otherwise excluded by the preceding section of this code, shall constitute a violation of this code and shall be abated as such H Prima Facie Volation Any nose exceeding the noise level standards for a designated noise zone as specified in th+s section shall be deemed to be puma facie evidence of a violation of the provisions of this section (Ord 211 § 6 (part}, 1983) « pt~vlQSis (f1eXL» ittp //murticipalcodes lexisnexis coin/codes/ranchocu/_DATA/TITLEI7/Chaoter_17_02 ADMINISTRATION/17 42 1?n NnISP ahatPmPnr hrml pang ~ of ~ PRIVATE NUISANCE CAI,IFORNLA CIVIL CODE 3479 Anything whicl- is iginnous to health, including, but not limited to, illegal sale of controlled substances, or is indecent or offensive to the senses, .~;rH t~.• ...,,.f«~able~njo.~ment of Ii~Qr _DrQ or unlawfully obstructs the free passage or use, in the customary manner, of any navigable lake, or ever, bay,stream, canal, or basin, or any public park, square, street, or highway is a nuisance. PUBLIC NUISANCE CALIFORNIA CIVIL CODE 3480 CALIFORNIA GOVERNMENT CODE SECTION 38771 The statute says that by ordinan ~~ ~ h is n urious,~ob decent, or off s ~e to the sensesaor an obstruction Naissncc is defined as anything J P P rty to the free use of property, so to f nterfere with the comfortable enjoyment of life or ro e a California Noise Control Act California Noise Control Act Catiforma Health and Safety Code Sections 46000 - 46080 (Current as of Sept 20, 2001) 46000. The Legislature hereby finds and declares that (a) Excessive noise is a serious hazard to the public health and welfare. (b) Exposure to certain levels of noise can result in physiological, psychological, and economic damage (c) There is a continuous and increasing bombardment of noise in the urban, suburban, and rural areas. (d) Government has not taken the steps necessary to provide for the control, abatement, and prevention of unwanted and hazardous noise. (e) The State of California has a responsibility to protect the health and welfare of its ca.tizens by the control, prevention, and abatement of noise (f) All Californians are entitled to a peaceful and quiet environment without the intrusion of noise which may be hazardous to their health or welfare (g) It is the policy of the state to provide an environment for all Californians free from noise that jeopardizes their health or welfare. To that end it is the purpose of this division to establish a means for effective coordination of state activities in noise control and to take such action as will be necessary to achieve the purposes of this section. 46001. No provision of this division or ruling of the Office of Noise Control is a limitation or expansion. (a) On the power of a caty, county, or city and county to adopt and enforce additional regulations, not in conflict therewith, imposing further conditions, restrictions, or limitations (b) On the power of any city, county, or city and county to declare, prohibit, and abate nuisances (c) On the power of the Attorney General, at the request of the office, the state department, or upon his own motion to bring an action in the name of the people of the State of California to enjoin any pollution or nuisance or to protect the natural resources of the state. (d) On the power of a state agency in the enforcement or administration of any provision of law which it is specifically permitted or required to enforce or administer (e) On the right of any person to maintain at any time any appropriate action for relief against any private nuisance as defined in the Civil Code or for relief against any noise pollution 46002. Nothing in this division shall be construed as giving the Office of Noise Control authority or responsibility for adopting or enforcing noise-emission standards for any product for which a regulation has been, or could be, prescribed or promulgated by the Environmental Protection Agency under the Noise Control Act of 1972 46010. This division shall be known and may be cited as the California Noise Control Act of 1973 46020. Unless the context otherwise requires, the definitions set forth in this chapter govern the construction of the words used in this division 04/24/2007 OS 09 PM http //home netvista net/hpb/calnca html Page 1 of 4 California Noise Control Act 46021. "Local agency" means and includes every local agency, including a county, city, whether general law or chartered, city and county, school district, municipal corporation, district, political subdivision, or any board, commission or agency thereof, or other local public agency 46022. "Noise" means and includes excessive undesirable sound, including that produced by persons, pets and livestock, industrial equipment, construction, motor vehicles, boats, aircraft, home appliances, electric motors, combustion engines, and any other noise-producing objects 46023. "Office" means the Office of Noise Control 46024. "Public agency" means and includes every state agency and every local agency 46025. "State agency" means and includes every state office, officer, department, division, bureau, board, council, commission, or other state agency. 46040. There is within the state department an Office of Noise Control 46050. The office shall, in order to protect health and well-being establish and maintain a program on noise control, including but not limited to (a) Determining the psychological and physical health effects of noise. (b) Determining the physiological effects of noise upon plant and animal life (c) Monitoring noise. (d) Collecting and disseminating authoritative information on adverse effects of noise and of means for its control. (e) Developing, in cooperation with local governments, model ordinances for urban, suburban, and rural environments. (f) Providing assistance to local governmental entities engaged in developing and implementing noise abatement procedures. (g) Developing criteria and guidelines for use in setting standards for human exposure to noise (h) Developing standards for the use of noise-producing objects in California. (i) Developing criteria for submission to the Legislature so that state agencies may require noise control in equipment purchased for state use. 46050.1. Notwithstanding Section 65040 2 of the Government Code, the office shall adopt, in coordination with the Office of Planning and Research and each state department and agency as it deems appropriate, guidelines for the preparation and content of noise elements as required by Section 65302 of the Government Code In adding Section 39850.1 to the Health and Safety Code, which was the predecessor to this section, and amending Section 65302 of the Government Code by Chapter 1124 of the Statutes of 1975, it was the intent of the Legislature to ensure, insofar as possible, that new and periodically revised noise elements in local governments' general plans be more standardized, comprehensive, and utilitarian than they had been previously. However, the Legislature also recognized that some cities and counties had already adopted noise elements pursuant to the existing Section 65302 of the Government Code and that others had received extensions on the due date of their noise element until September 20, 1975. Those cities and counties were not required to resubmit new noise elements consistent with Section 65302 of the Government Code, or to recognize guidelines adopted pursuant to this section, but are 04/24/2007 05 09 PM http //home netvista net/hpb/calnca html Page 2 of 4 California Noise Control Act required, upon initial and periodic revision of the noise element, to comply with Section 65302 of the Government Code and to recognize those guidelines The requirement that the office adopt guidelines for the preparation and content of noise elements shall be inoperative during the 1993-94 fiscal year 46060. It is the purpose of this chapter to encourage the enactment and enforcement of local ordinances in those areas which are most properly the responsibility of local government It is further the purpose to insure that the state is of maximum assistance to local agencies in the discharge of those responsibilities, furnishing technical and legal expertise to assist local agencies in the enactment and enforcement of meaningful and technically sufficient noise abatement measures 46061. The office shall provide technical assistance to local agencies in combating noise pollution. Such assistance shall include but not be limited to: (a) Advice concerning methods of noise abatement and control (b) Advice on training of noise control personnel (c) Advice on selection and operation of noise abatement equipment 46062. The office shall provide assistance to local agencies in the preparation of model ordinances to control and abate noise Such ordinances shall be developed in consultation with the Attorney General and with representatives of local agencies, including the County Supervisors Association of California and the League of California Cities. Any local agency which adopts any noise control ordinance shall promptly furnish a copy to the office 46070. The director shall promote coordination of the programs of all state agencies relating to noise research, abatement, prevention, and control Each state agency shall, upon request, furnish to the director such information as he may reasonably require to determine the nature, scope, and results of the noise research and noise control programs of the agency. 46071. On the basis of regular consultation with appropriate state agencies, the director shall compile and publish, from time to time, a report on the status and progress of state activities relating to noise research and noise control This report shall describe the noise programs of each state agency and assess the contributions of those programs to the state's overall efforts to control noise 46072. In any case where any state agency is carrying out or sponsoring any activity resulting in noise which the director determines amounts to a public nuisance or is otherwise objectionable, such agency shall consult with the director to determine possible means of abating such noise. This section does not apply to any action of a private person for which a license, permit, or other entitlement for use is required to be issued by a state agency 46073. The Legislature authorizes and directs that all state agencies shall, to the fullest extent consistent with existing authority, administer the programs within their control in such a manner as to further the policy declared in Section 46000 This section shall not be construed to limit or expand the authority of any state agency to issue or deny a license, permit, or other entitlement for use. 46074. Each state agency authorized to adopt regulations in the area of noise control shall in the manner specified in subdivision 04/24/Z007 OS 09 PM http //home netvista net/hpb/calnca html Page 3 of 4 California Noise Control Act (c) of Section 11423 of the Government Code give notice to and invite the comments of the office concerning any proposed adoption, amendment, or repeal of a regulation in the area of noise control 46075 In accordance with the provisions of Section 11426 of the Government Code or other applicable law, the office may petition any public agency for the adoption of regulations or other measures otherwise within the authority of that public agency in the area of noise control 46076. The Office of Noise Control shall maintain a program to insure that all state agencies are advised of available federal assistance and funds for noise control programs. The office may, at the request of individual agencies, act for them for the following purposes• (a) Applying for federal funds which may be made available to the states for noise control programs or related research as a result of the Noise Control Act of 1972 (P.L. 92-574) or any other federal program or law. (b) Receiving technical assistance from the Environmental Protecta.on Agency to facilitate the development and enforcement of state noise standards and model noa.se legislation 46077. The office shall maintain a program to ensure coordinated state and federal noise control programs including, but not limited to, the following: (a) The study of federal noise regulations proposed for adoption pursuant to the Noise Control Act of 1972 (b) The preparation of comments, evaluations, objections or the use of any other means to ensure that the federal government considers existing California noise control statutes and regulations prior to the adoption of regulations in order to prevent the adoption of federal noise regulation weaker than existing state standards (c) The preparation of reports to the Legislature containing recommendations for legislation necessitated by the adoption of federal noise regulations pursuant to the Noise Control Act of 1972. 46080. In furtherance of his responsibilities under this division and to complement, as necessary, the noise research programs of federal agencies and of other state agencies, the director is authorized to: (a) Conduct research, and finance research by contract with other public and private bodies, on the effects, measurement, and control of noise, including but not limited to (1) Investigation of the psychological and physiological effects of noise on humans and the effects of noise on domestic animals, wildlife, and property, and determination of acceptable levels of noise on the basis of such effects (2) Development of improved methods and standards for measurement and monitoring of noise. (3) Determination of the most effective and practicable means of controlling noise generation, transmission, and reception (b) Coordinate with and become knowledgeable concerning the noise research programs of other governmental entities including the federal government (c) Disseminate to the public information on the effects of noise, acceptable noise levels, and techniques for noise measurement and control. 04/24/2007 OS 09 PM http //home netvista net/hpb/calnca html Page 4 of 4 ~~ Hlllslde ~emmunlty Church Event Calendar s ', 3 elr ,,~y ~~~li{`~41~,tr' ~i~(niCl~~tl{~~r ~ 111~it ft 6~' v+ z .= i / i + Cr + ~1 +~I YI ~ t Ir I +ir ~ _I~il © ~ 03/09/2007 10 50 AM >~ e 1 1+ 1 4 IS 08 30 am 5 30 pm to 09 45 am to 8 30 pm I RoWired club volleyball practices 11 30 am 5 00 pm to 1 00 Dm to 8 15 pm Child) en s Just 4 Kids Basketball W orsh I p Tea m prattice _ _ 6 00 pm to B 00 pm 12 30 pm Heart 2 Heart Worship '. to 3 30 pm Team Reheaiaal ~~ Hdlsitle Jr s i Basketball Game DAy 6 30 pm to 8 30 pm Wide Open 6 _ _y7 _. _ 5 00 pm 5 30 pm to 7 15 pm to 8 30 pm ]us[ 4 Klds Basketball ~ Club volleyball practice 6 00 pm 6 00 Dm I to800 pm to800 pm club volleyball prachce Infuse 7 00 pm to 9 00 pm Ignite I1 {12 08 00 am 5 30 pm to 4 00 pm to 8 30 pm Baeebail/Softball club volleyball practices prachce and games _ _ _ _ 6 00 pm to 8 00 pm 08 30 am Basketball Ciosrng to 09 45 am Ceremonies (Just 4 Kids) Rewired 12 30 pm to 3 30 pm Mdlvde Jr s Basketball Game DAy fi 30 pm to 8 30 pm Wide Open 13 06 00 am to800 pm Basketball Closing Ceremonies (Hlllslde Jr s) 6 00 pm to800 pm club volleyball prachce 7 00 pm to 9 00 pm Ignite 14 08 30 am to 9 30 pm HCC Staff Meeting 5 30 pm to 8 30 pm Club volleyball practice 600 pm to800 pm Infuse 1 09 00 am to 11 IS am Heart 2 Haart 6 00 pm to 8 00 pm club volleyball practice 6 30 Dm to 9 00 pm Heart 2 Hcart 8 09 00 am to 11 15 am Heart 2 Heart 6 00 pm to800 pm club volleyball practice 6 30 pm to900 pm Heart 2 Heart {15 09 00 am to 31 IS am Hear[ 2 Heart 6 00 pm to 8 00 pm club volleyball practice _I 630 pm v_ to 9 00 pm Heort 2 Heart rr rl r tut'i 2 {3 l6 Men s Conference !0 00 am to 5 00 pm Carpet Cleaning (PC/LfC/ill) 10 30 am to 12 30 pm Women s Ministry Team Meeting Tha Core Conference 08 00 am to 12 00 pm SMART OS 00 am to 2 00 pm Just 4 Kids Basketball Games 5 30 pm to 6 45 pm ReWVed 10 OS 00 am [o400 pm Baseball/Softball practice and gantea 08 00 am to 2 00 pm Just 4 Kids Basketball Games 5 30 pm I to 6 45 pm RoWved `I17 I Mon s Cmt/erence 08 00 am to400Dm Baseball/softball practice end games 5 30 pm I to 6 45 pm Re W I rerl http //www hlllsldeminlstry org/calendar/month php Page 1 of 2 Hillside Community Church Event Calendar 03/09/2007 10 50 AM 18 19 I20 ~21 I22 I23 I24 Men s ~ Conference 5 30 pm 5 00 pm 5 30 pm 09 00 am 5 00 pm O8 00 am to 8 30 pm to 7 45 pm to 8 30 pm to I1 15 am to 7 45 pm t0 400 Ptn club volleyball pracbces Softball/Bawbalt/ROOkIe/T- Club volleyball Uracuce Heart 2 Heart Softball/Raaabali/Rookie/T easabab/Softball OB 00 am _ _ _ _ ___ bail praedu and and games ball pwctiee and and games practice and to 400 lain games oaaabaN/SoRball 5 00 pm 5 00 pm 3 30 pm practise and to 7 45 pm 6 00 pm to 7 4' pqt to 6 00 pm ', games SoftbaltJbnabell/Rookw/T to 8 00 pm Softball/iaaaCaUJRpokre/T Serving at the G A P 09 00 am bait prattic! and and games club volleyball practice ball practice and and games _ '~.. to 11 OO am - - Fiag Football ' OB 30 am 500 Pfn Evaluations to 09 45 am 6 00 pm 7 00 pm 6 00 pm to 7 45 pm ReWlrad to 7 00 pm to 9 00 pm to 8 00 pm SoRbaq/8aaabail/ROOk~e/T- _ _ _____ __ Board Meeting Lgnrte Infuse ball practice and and games 5 30 pm - Co645 pm 2 00 pm ReW~red to400 pm 700 pm 600 pm T-ball and to 9 00 pm to 8 00 pm __ Rookie Fhck Ch~ckc club voile ball Y practice 7 00 pm coach/parents to 9 00 pm meeting )r High 6 30 pm Volunteer Staff to 9 00 pm Meeting 6 30 pm Heart 2 Heart to830 pm Willa Open 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 09 00 am 5 30 pm 5 00 ptn 12 00 pm 09 00 am 5 00 Ptn 08 00 am to 4 00 pm to 8 30 pm to 7 45 pm to 2 00 pm to 11 IS am to 7 45 pm to 400 pm tAa1Mi11/Softball club volleyball pracbces SoftbaliJleaeball/Rookie/T Senior Luncheon Heart 2 Heart Softball/Raaabafl/Rookre/T Baseball/Softball pracbce and ball pr~ettw and and games _ bait practlea attd and games praetioe and games -- - - _ - _ _ _ Dames _ ___ _ __ _ 5 00 pm 5 30 pm 5 00 pm _ __ _ _ to 7 45 pm 6 00 pm to 8 30 pm to 7 45 Pm 08 30 am SaJf6aRJYaaabaR/Raekia/T [0 8 00 pm Club volleyball pre trace Sof tbMflJBaaaCaR/Reakse/T 5 30 pm to 09 45 am 6a11 praetloa and and games club voile bait V pracbce ball praeHea and and games [0 6 45 m P ReW~red -._ - - _ _ -_ _ ___ _ ReWsred __,__-_ _ S 00 pm fi 00 pm 7 00 pm to 7 45 pm 6 00 pm 12 00 pm to 8 00 pm to 9 00 pm Softball/lasebaltJROOkia/T to 8 00 pm to 2 00 pm Heart 2 Heart Worship Ignite beH pridlp and and games club volleyball pracbce Garden Lunch Team Rehearsal Bunch - - 6 30 pm to 9 00 pm 6 30 pm Heart 2 Heart to830pm Wide Open Sales a Category AO Calendars Lo View Punter Friendly ~? tai o~ ~t S~r r Select a Calendar Search for _-__ All Adults All (alentl lrs Go Search Advanced Search ~~ w i -1 r' y~'r ,, T ~ ~ .~iNngyT K ~' ~(4 tip //www hillsldeministry org/calendar/month php Page 2 of 2 Comm+3r -~ Ctwrch Event Calendar ry^ ,! xa t 1-;t~,t''~r_ tCl'lt'i1t,Ef,JC'~ L_'i~ `~~~ d /1 ~~ Y~ , 03/09/2007 10 52 AM ~6 t rl ~ c r n ~ ~ r c~ _lr) ~ © Mi ~r ~ ~ 20r __- - tie ,~ S I .r y 1 r -r J 2 I 3 1 4 I 5 I 6 - - I 7 -- -- ^ 08 00 am 5 30 pm 560 pm 45 5 30 pm to 8 30 pm 09 00 am to 11 15 am S 00 pm to 7 45 pm OB 00 am to 4t60 pm tb 400 pm ll f b S to 8 30 pm ball practices lub volle pm to 7 Softball/NaabaH/Rookie/T- Club volleyball practrre Heart 2 Heart 'MM!%i3 > ,~ 9 b: U~~ all p f~ a o t BasaWg/ y c baH pstiaatA aaa! and games u ~ G t f « praotlea and - _ gamaa gamaa 5 00 Pm - 500 Pm StOA 4m - 30 to 7 45 pm 5o{Hall/YaWall/pookre/T 6 00 pm [0 8 00 pm to 7 45 pm Sonbail[RBaabaY/Rookie/T- 1a ~ 45 pm SaRbatl/taaaball/ROakie/T- 5 30 pm 6 45 am OB to 09 45 am baH pniaUea and and games dub volleyball practice baR praatln arli aa/d flames WU praetlte and and games pm to ReWrred ReWrretl - - - - - 630 pm 700 pm 600 pm 600 pm 12 00 pm to 8 00 pm to 9 00 pm to 8 00 pm Infuse to B 00 pm club volleyball practice to 1 00 pm Toolahed Practice Ignite Rainbow Acres - Mrssron TriV Mtg 630 pm - - ' - - ' -' to 9 00 pm Heart 2 Heart 200 pm to 4 00 pm Easter Egg Hunt 630 pm to 8 30 pm Wide Open 8 g 10 11 12 13 _ 14 OB 00 am 5 30 pm 30 S 00 pm [o745Dm 08 30 am to930pm 09 00 am to 1115 am 30 30 am to 1230 pm 08 00 am ~400pm to400pm BataYall/Softball pm [o8 club volleyball precbces 9oftbalUBaaaball/Rookie/T- HCC Staff Meeting Heart 2 Heart Women s Mrnlatry Team BiCWaR/8aftball praetiu end baH praatlaa arN and gamas Meeting praWoa and gamea 9amaa 5 00 pm 5 30 pm 5 DO pm 8 30 to7,ur~ SoftbaUJRaaNalllRookre/T- 600 pm to 8 00 pm to830pm Club volleybag practice Yo745pm Softball/Bnaball/WOOkIe/T 500 pm to 7t45 pm 08 00 am am 0 to 09 45 am ball ptveHp and aad games club volleyball pracbce - bell praetiaa and end games Sehball/haa-all/RwMN/T- ball pratt7u and and games to 12 00 pm Handyman c Frx- ReWrred It Oay 5 00 pm 5 30 pm 7 00 pm t0 7 45 pm 6 00 pm - - - -- 6 30 pm to 7 30 pm to 9 00 pm SofWaR/RaaWaU/Rookie/T to 8 00 pm OB 00 am to 8 30 pm Flag Football prachce Zgnrte ball pnetlw and and games club volleyball pracbce to 2 00 pm Wrde Open Flag Football 6 00 pm 6 30 pm games to800 pm to900 pm Infuse Heart 2 Hearr 5 30 pm to 6 45 pm ReWved 15 lfi 17 18 19 20 21 OB 00 am 5 30 pm 5 00 pm 5 30 pm to 8 30 pm 09 00 am to ,1 15 am 10 00 am to OS 00 am OB 00 sin to $ 00 pal to 400 pm Baseball/softball to 8 30 pm club volleyball practices to 7 45 Dm 8oftbaliJMN-aN/ROOkia/T Club volleyball prachce Heart 1 Heart Carpet Cleaning (FC/LFC) praMiMukeSottball praedu and baH pracbp and and games games games 5100 ~ 500 pm S 00 pm 5 00 pm - - -- - _ B 30 to 7 45 Dm Sohbail/Baseball/ROOtua/T- 6 00 pm to 8 00 pm to 7 45 Dm SdfbWl6faaMii(Reaatb/T to 7t4S pm SottbW//BIabIF~Raokla/T- to 7 45 pm SoRballJ~aa6fU/RoHia/T 08 00 am am O to 09 45 am belt practice and and games club volleyball pr acute ball pnetiea arW end games bail praeNee and And games baH praldYae am! and games to 2 00 pm ReWtred _ - Flag Football games -~- - 5 30 pm 7 00 pm 6 00 pm 6 00 pm IS 30 am to 7 30 Dm to 9 00 pm to 8 00 pm Infuse to 6 00 pm club vo{Icyball practice I 5 30 pm CO 1 60 pm Fleg Football prachce Ignite to6 d5 pm Children s http //www hlllsldeminlstry org/calendar/month php7cld=0&catld=0&d=9&w=0&rn=4&y=2007&s= Page 1 of 2 HIIlslde Cc.mmunlty Church Event Calendar 03/09/2007 10 52 AM Worship Team Practlca J __ 5 00 Dm to 6 30 pm Khaos `___ __- 630 pm to 8 30 pm Wide Open I 6 00 pm to 7 00 pm Board Meeting __ _ - -~- 7 00 pm to 9 00 pm Flick Chicks 6 30 pm to 9 00 Dm Heart Z Heart ReWrred 22 23 24 26 26 27 28 Rainbow Acres Mrssron Tnp Rainbow Acres Mrssron Tnp Rainbow Acres OB 00 am S 30 pm 5 00 pm 5 30 pm Mrssrors Trip to400pm to830pm to745pm to830pm _ _ _ Baaeball/Softball club volleyball practices Sokball/Baseball/Rookre/T Club volleyball practice - "" -" practice and ball praetlce and and games - 09 00 am 500 pm 08 00 am pamcc to 11 15 am to 7 45 pm - - 500 pm 5 00 pm Heart 2 Heart Sokbaltl8aaeball/Rookre/T Baseball/Sokball to 7 45 pm 6 00 pm to 7 45 pm ball practice and and games ratXFrx and p 08 30 am Sokball/Baseball/Rookre/T to 8 00 pm Sokball/Baseball/Rookie/T games to 09 45 am ball pracUCe and and games club volloyball practice ball precttce and and games 5 00 pm ReWrred to 7 45 pm - ~ Sokbal!/Baseball! ROakiel T- baH pracrrce end and flames 08 00 am 5 30 pm 7 00 pm 6 00 pm to 2 00 m D 12 00 pm to 7 30 pm to 9 00 pm to 8 00 pm Flag Football to 2 00 pm Flag Football practice Ignite Infuse games Garden Lunch 6 00 pm bunch to 8 00 pm ---- club volleyball practice 5 30 pm to 6 45 pm 12 00 pm ReWrred to 1 00 pm 6 30 pm Rarnbow Acres to 9 00 pm Mrssron Tnp Mtg Hurt 2 Heat 5 00 pm to630 pm Khaos 6 30 pm to 8 30 pm Wide Open 29 30 Rarnbow Acres Mrssron Tnp 5 30 pm to 8 30 pm - -- - - club voileybntl practices 08 00 am to400pm Baeeball/Softball 500 pm praetlee and ~ ~ gamea ReeabNl/Rookre/T ball praatFc~ entl and pamea 08 30 am ' to 09 45 am 5 30 pm ReWrred to 7 30 pm Flag Football practice 5 00 pm to630 pm 630 pm , Khaos to 8 00 pm Toolshetl Practlca 6 30 pm , to 0 30 pm Wrde Open Select a Category Select a Calendar Search for - All Calendars All Adults All Calendars Ca^ Ga Search View Pnnter Fnendly Advanced Search ,' r ,~~ ~~ , . ,. ~ , _ t ~~~ r_ ~, a,~,,,,r~,a~ ~r http //www hlllsldeminlstry org/calendar/month php7cld=0&catld=0&d=9&w=0&m=4&y=2007&s= Page 2 of 2 Fi'illside Comu'lunrty Church Event Calendar . ~` x :- ~~I~I,RC~r:. t r,r~~rt~~rt-ty Cfs~it'_~-I ~~ ,. ~t li r •,~ , '~1 Yl fj~ ~§t ; N f~ ' ~V 03/09/2007 11 21 AM x~ Y~ Y~ N . ~ . ~. 1 1 . 1 ~ 1 . a ~ "L' l a alontn of May i.U•") 'ui.d .v ~ .r< ii - ~. i i . t ii fri'~l Situi ley 1 ~ Z - ~ 3 l 4 - -- -~ 1 5 - 5 QO pm 5 30 Dm 5 00 pm 500 pm OB 00 am to745 pm to830 pm to743 pm 10745 pm b400 pm Softball/Baseball/ROOkIe/T Club volleyball practice Softball/Baseball/Rookie/T SoftbelllBatabalt/Rookie/T BasebrR/!'softball bell praeuot and and games - ball praefiq and and gamec bell praottca and and games praeba and - ~-- - - - - - - games - 5 Og pm 6 00 pm to J 45 pm 6 00 pm to 8 00 pm SoRbaR/6aarMR/Rookie/T to 8 00 pm 08 00 am club volleyball practice WR praCHce and end games club volleyball practice to 10 00 am Computer Boot I _ _ _ _ _ __.._. _ _ _ _ - __ _ _ Camp 700 pm 600 Dm 600 pm - -- -- ~ ta900 pm to800 pm to800 pm Ignite Infuse H2H Leader s Celobratwn 08 00 am to200 pm Flag Football games 5 30 pm to 6 45 pm Re W fired ^ y 6 _ J ~_ _-__~. _ 7 8 _ ___ _ _ _ 9 _ 10 _ ]1 _ _ 12 08 00 am 5 30 pm 5 Oo pm OB 30 am 500 pm 10 30 am 08 QO am to 4 00 pm to 8 30 pm to 7 {g pm to 9 30 Dm to 7 45 pm to 12 30 pm to 400 pm Baaebail/SOfthell club volleyball practices SoftMR/BtlWNI/Rookie/T HCC Staff Meeting Softball/Bwlall/Rookie/T Women s Ministry Team BaiebNf/loftball pracNee and bah praesf0e and and grmac hall praeHp tl1d and games Meeting practice and gamas games -_ --- - -- - 500 pm S 30 pm -- - - to 7 4S Dm 6 00 pm to 8 30 pm 6 00 pm 5 QO pm 08 30 am SofWN-/ItfsrbaNlRookie/T to 8 00 pm Club volleyball practice to 8 00 pm to 7 45 pm 08 00 am to 09 45 am hall proetlla and amt games club volleyball practice club volleyball practice Saftbrli/Baaebait/Rookie/T to 30 00 am belt practice end and games Computer Boot ReW fired Camp 5 ~ ~ 5 30 pm 7 00 pm to 7 4S pm - 11 30 am to 7 30 pm to 9 00 pm SoRball/BpWelt/fieekie/T to 1 00 pm Flag football practice Ignite bah preeder artd and Armes O8 00 am Children s to 2 00 pm Flag Football Worship Team Practice 6 00 pm games _ to800 pm Infuse 530 pm 500 pm to645 pm to630 pm Re Wired Khans 6 30 Dm to 8 30 pm Wide Open 13 - - - - 14 -- - - - 15 - - - - 16 - - - 17 - - - 16 - ---'- -- - 19 -- --- - 08100 am 5 30 pm 0 500 pm [0 7 45 pm 5 30 pm to 8 30 pm 500 pm to 7 45 Dm 30 00 am to 5 00 pm D® 00 am to 4 00 pm to 400 Dm BUNrNI/Softball to 8 3 Om club volleyball prarnces SoftbrR/Baubrll/ROOkfa/T Club volleyball practice SolabaB/WM1rR/Reokio/T- Carpet Cleaning 0asaball/Softball priCtlCe and ball p/'rCYlea and and gamec bait prrctxe and and games (FC/lFC/#1/#2/#3/Office) VraCt-ee and games _ -- _ - _ - --- - - - - gamas __ 5 00 Drn 5 ~ inn to 7 45 pm 6 00 pm to 7 45 pm 6 00 pm S 00 pm OB 30 am 09 45 SnRball/Baseball/Rookie/T raatiq and and games ball to 8 00 pm club volleyball prarnce SoRbaN/Baaebail/Rookie/7 ball pteeHCe and antl games to 8 00 pm club volleyball prirnce tq 7 45 pm 53116M1/1iQW11/RoeMe/T 08 00 am to 10 00 am am to p haR pnaklar arM and games Computer Boot Rewired _ - - -- _ _ _ - - - _ - Camp - 530 pm ) 700 pm I 600 pm - --- 6 30 pm to 7 30 pm to 9 00 pm to 8 00 pm I OB 00 am to 8 30 pm Flag Football Vractice Zgnite Infuse http //www hlllsideministry org/calendar/month php7cld=0&catld=0&d=9&w=0&m=5&y=2007&s= Page 1 of 2 Hillside Community Church Event Calendar 03/09/2007 11 21 AM Wide Open to 2 00 pm Flag Football I - games J 10 00 am to 2 00 pm Spring Garden Tour 530 pm to 6 45 Dm Re Wired 20 - 21 22 23 24 25 - _ - _ 26 08 00 am to 4 00 Vnl 5 30 pm to 8 30 pm 5 00 pm to 7 45 pm 5 30 pm to 6 30 pm 5 00 pm 7 5 00 pm 08 00 eat BaeebaN/Sokball practloe and club volleyball iractices SoftbaN/easebag/Rookie/T- l Ciub volleyball practice to 45 pm Sokball/BasabeU/Roohia/T- to T 45 /Im Sokball/Eaaabetl/Rookie/7 to 4100 pRl BYaYaR/softball grmes ba l practice end and games bait prachca and and games ball pracgee and and games praCYrp and - 500 pm - - - - - - 500 pm games to 7 45 pm 6 00 Dm to 7 45 pm 6 00 pm 08 30 am Sokball/8aaabatl/Rookie/T to 8 00 pm Sokball/8aaaba4/Rookae/T to 8 00 pm to 09 45 am ball praetlse and atd games club volleyball practice baH pnaalea and rnd games club volle b ll ti 08 00 am ReW~red y a pi ac ce to 10 00 am "-"-'-- -_----- -- - - --- -- -- - - - Computer Boot 530 pm 700 pm 600 pm Camp 5 00 pm to 7 30 pm to 9 00 pm to 8 00 pm - ` [0 7 30 pm Flag Football practice ignite !n/use SNOTH 08 00 am __ _ - - "-- -- --' - [0 2 00 pm - 6 30 pm Fiag Football 500 pm to800 pm games to 6 30 pm Toolshed Practice - -- Khans - ~~--- - 5 30 pm 600 pm to645 pm 630 pm to700 pm Re Wired to 8 30 pm Board Meeting Wide Open 7 00 pm to 9 OD pm Flick Chicks 27 - 28 `- 29 30 31 08td0 am 5 30 pm 5 00 pm 5 30 m 0 ~" to • QO pm to 8 30 pm to 7 d5 pm to 8 30 pm to 7 4S pm Baaa1MN/Softball club volleyball practices SottbaR/aaaabNl/Rookie/T Club volleyball pratt¢e Softltlsll/lR4+e41a/T prraYaa and - bail prattles and and games bolt Ila'actfea aM and pwtas games 5 00 pm Soo pm to745pm 600 pm to745pm 600 m D 08 30 am SWiYall/baaaball/ROOkse/T- to 8 00 pm SoftbaN/taiabap/Rookie/T- to 8 00 pm to 09 45 am beN pF14Yea eat/ and games club volleyball practice bah p~aatlea snd and games club volleyball practice ReWlred 530 pm 700 Dm 600 pm 1200 pm to730 pm to900 pm to800 pm to 2 00 pm Flag Football practice Ignite infuse Garden lunch Bunch 6 30 pm to 8 30 pm Wide Open Select a Category Select aCalendar -"""-'-' '----~--- Search for - All Calendars All Adults , Ali lalendars , Go (gyp Search yew Punter Friendly Advanced Search a 1 7 ?3 ,~, r ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ' +~ ,.s ..rrvt,n'~n'rGA ~ ~ ~`~ ~ ~ '' f~ ~ i f~°' ! % ~~ ^ i ~ r w ~ r ~p `R}p~, ~ :,~d lttp //www hlllsideministry org/calendar/month php7cld=0&catld=0&d=9&w=0&m=5&y=2007&s= Page 2 of 2 riilislde Community Church Event Calendar e,~ -^. .~ ~ }lif <<CjE' ~ rmll"~i4f'11~y C``it.r f~l ~~ ~` wp tr ~w >, ~~ ~, ~ r ,., , ,~ .,r, ,,, ,~., t,, t p ~~ rl , , ] MO © "uMh M Ixaro t Zara! r~ 03/09/2007 11 23 AM u c(ar i 1 a ~ J 1 t I fri /rr >>turr i. 1 - I2_ ___ __ f I 5 ~ Pnt OB 00 am ~ to 7 45 pm to 4 00 pm Soribail/SsnbaH/Raolw/T Basebaq/twftball ball praerip end and yames practice and t yames I 08 00 am ~ ~ [0 12 00 pm Handyman cFix- I It Dey i 08 00 am to200 pm ~ Flag Football i ~ games _~ _ _ _ _ ~ ~ 5 30 pm to 6 45 pm ReWn ad ff + ___ _ _ __ 11 3 4 I S 6 17 _ ______ J _ _ __ _ __ _I __ _ _ _ ___ _ _ - - 8 9 OB 00 am ~ ~ 5 30 pm to 8 30 Dm 5 00 pm to 7 45 Dm S 30 pm to 8 30 m 5 00 pm 7 4 10 30 am OB 00 am B tl 1 /Sottbali d dub volleyball practices $oftbell/baseball/Rookie/T p Ctub volleyball practice to 4 pm $olgfal~/i~YMj~OWe/T- to 12 30 pm Women a Mrnlstry Team to 4 00 pm BaseDali/SO(tbell pncttu an ball pt'iWd and and games ball praetiea end and yames Meeting Yl d games prat p an ___ ^ 5 00 pm S 00 pm games 08 30 am to 7 45 Pm SoRbatl/iaNbaq/Rook,e/T 6 00 pm to 8 00 Dm to 7 45 pm Sokbell/BaeNaN(Reok,e/T 6 00 pm to 8 00 Pm 600 pm [0 7 <S DBi - -- - -- -- 08 00 to 09 45 am R wi d ball pratMp sad acrd games club volleyball practice ball preettce and and games club volleyball practice SottA1~+{aeabail/Jiapk,e/T am to 2 00 pm e re bag p/aeKCa ant and yames Flag Football _ _ - s 30 pm _ _ ____ __ __ _ games 5 00 pm to 7 30 pm to 7 46 pm Flag Football practice 7 00 pm Adult Ministry to 10 00 m P Valentine s Palley Bunco N ht end Dessert 9 to 6 45 m P Rewired 6 30 Dm to 8 30 pm Wide Open 10 11 _ 12 13 14 IS 16 OB QO am to 400 pm 5 30 Dm to 8 30 pm 6 00 pm to 8 00 Dm 08 30 am to 9 30 Dm 10 00 am t 5 00 6 00 Dm 08 00 am BaaabaUf$Oftbail club volleyball practices club volleyball practice HCC Stall Meeting o pm Carpet Cleanin (FC/LFC) to 9 00 pm F h to 2 00 pm praepea end g at er/Daughter Dance Flag Football games - - -- - -- _ games -_ _ ,__ 5 30 Pm 5 30 Dm 6 00 pm T - ~--- -"- OS 30 am to 7 30 m Fiag Football practice to 8 30 pm Club volleyball practice to 8 00 pm club volle ball ti s 30 pm to 094s am y prac ce to 6 45 pm Re Wired Re Wired 6 30 pm to 8 30 pm Widc ODen 17 38 19 20 21 22 2 3 08 30 am I s 30 pm I 6 00 pm I 08 00 am I 6 00 pm I 6 30 pm 5 30 pm I Ittp //www hfllsldeminlstry org/calendar/month php7cld=0&catld=0&d=9&w=0&m=6&y=2007&s= Page 1 of 2 Hillside Community Church Event Calendar 03/09/2007 11 23 AM to 09 45 am ReW tl to 8 30 pm I [0 8 00 pm 1 to 12 00 pm to 8 00 pm to 8 00 pm to 6 45 pm rre I club volleyball pracGCes 1 club volleyball practice Surt Oays at MunGn9ton I club volleyball practice Under the Sea Party Re Wired - - _ 1 beach 6300m 600 Dm to 8 30 pm to 7 00 Dm S 30 pm Wrde Open Board Mee[rng to 8 30 pm ____,_ __ ~_ _ _ Club volleyball practice 700 pm to 9 00 pm Flick Ghrcks 24 2s 26 27 28 29 30 08 30 am to 09 45 am S 30 Dm to 8 30 Drn s 30 pm to 8 30 pm 7 00 pm 08 00 am ReWsreO club volleyball practices Club volleyball practrce to 12 00 am Midnight Madness to 12 00 pm 5 M A R T 12 00 pm to200 pm 530 pm Garden Lunch to 6 45 Dm Bunch ReWrred 6 30 pm to 8 30 pm Wrde Open Select a Category -All Calendars Co V7ew Pnntar Frrendiv 1y sr~ l ~ ry~av ~ ~ Select a Calendar Search for -~ All Adulb Ali Calendars (.o Search Advanced Search ~~ r + e ~ ~~ ~ ~r [ 4, 1 tttp //www hfllsldeminlstry org/calendar/month php7cld=0&catld=0&d=9&w=0&m=6&y=2007&s= Page 2 of 2 Hlll~ide Ci._~~riunity Churc~!h~Evvent Calendar ~s p ~~ 'eh5} ~ i -`~ -" ~~ alr^ - ~ s ~ ........ ~~I~.~rr XL n '1d~ F'"Z",i'in. 'h t 04/25/2007 04 53 PM r ",~$'"'"M 4 W ~'- p'~~ F { i p~ x. s ~^~d~,t ' ~" _l~S. ~ tl ~.-,t S=r~l~t ~ ~ ..C J. 1 alt r Home Page C~ lenuar Llst \~IEWS Log In t~Forr~i~i of august (2C ;~ vidFy Szturday Il ,~ o~ `~1 ~ `P~V"'''~2 ~ (~, / c~°~i~ 4 I 09 00 am to 11 00 am Soccer Evaluations 5 30 pm to 6 45 pm Re W fired 7 15 pm to900pm Parent/Kid Game Night 700 pm to900pm Night Swimi 5 6 Summer Camp Summer Camp (Grades 3-6) (Grades 3-6) 6 30 pm to830pm Wide Open 7 Summer Camp (Grades 3-6) 8 9 Leadership Leadership Summit 2007 Summit 2007 _-- - Summer Camp Summer Camp (Grades 3-6) (Grades 3-6) 08 30 am to930pm HCC Staff Meeting 6 00 pm to 7 30 pm Soccer Evaluations ttp //www hilisideminlstry org/calendar/month php~cld=0&catid=0&d=25&w=0&m=8&y=2007&s= 10 Leadership Summit 2007 Summer Camp (Grades 3-6) ' ~ ~.~ '.3 '~ ~(d~ 1 i R 4- X .~ (e Y +;~ F 'J ~ .d Y Taaay ~,pril 2S, 2007 li Leadership Summit 2007 Summer Camp (Grades 3-6) 5 30 pm to 6 45 pm Rewired 600 pm to 10 00 pm BBQ and Game Night Page 1 of 2 Hdl~Ide Cc, i~tiunlty Church Event Calendar S E t r a rr r ~r ,r ~~ ~~. r k s r http //www hillsidemmistry org/calendar/month php~ad=0&catid=0&d=25&w=0&m=8&y=2007&s= Page 1 of 2 04/25/2007 04 53 PM Hon~E: f `ln L-lo ~id~i I n n 't ~ c ry -_ ..! C. Hillside C... ~mumty Church Event Calendar 04/25/2007 04 53 PM 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 Summer Camp -' '- -' -'- - (Grades 3-6) 09 00 am 10 00 am 10 00 am ~_ ____ to 9 00 pm to 5 00 pm to 2 00 pm Beach Day Carpet Cleaning Soccer parent's 6 30 pm (FC/lFC/#2/#3) rtreetmg to830pm Wide Open - ---- -- 5 30 pm to645pm Rewired 19 -- - - 20 -- _ - - 21- - - 22 23 24 25 3 30 pm to 6 15 pm 5 00 pm to 8 00 pm 5 00 pm to 8 00 pm S 00 pm to 8 00 pm 5 00 pm to 8 00 pm 5 00 pm t 8 00 08 00 am lumping lacks Soccer practice Soccer practice Soccer prad~ce Soccer practice o pm Soccer practice to 12 00 pm Handyman's Fix- - - - - - - - --- It Day 6 30 pm 6 00 pm - '- -- --- to 8 30 pm to 7 00 pm Wide Open Board Meeting 5 30 pm to 6 45 pm --- - - - Rewired 700 pm to900pm Flick Chicks 26 27 28 29 30 31 11 30 am 08.00 am 500 pm 5 00 pm 5 00 pm 5 00 pm to 2 00 pm ' to 3 00 pm to 800 pm to 8 00 pm to 8 00 pm to 8 00 pm H2H Leader s Soccer practice Soccer practice Soccer practice Soccer practice Soccer practice Meeting 5 00 pm 7 00 pm 6 30 pm t0 8 00 pm to 9 00 pm to 8 30 pm Soodar practice H2H New Leader Wide Open _ _ _ Tra~nmg 6 30 pm to800pm Tooished Practice Select a Category• -All Calendars Go View Printer Friendiv X24 -*~ -* "" • . e _,z~.~.~ _._.. Select a Calendar - All Adults Go .. ~' ~Cm~ri a* au'~x-,NS,e.~.;M z^cx.+rd*, y,H =-fan*.y ~yar tyr Search for All Calendars Search Advanced Search ~ ~~. r ' _r ,`~ ~ http //www hillsidemmistry org/calendar/month php~cid=0&catid=0&d=25&w=0&m=8&y=2007&s= Page 2 of 2 Hit s!de Community Church Event Calendar c ~l S 1 `4 ~K S ~~ ~M1 04/25/2007 04 47 PM i G` ~~'Ifl~l~~E~' ~ (al~ltl{i,1f`ll~l~` '~. ~ it1';-~~ _ t'rl { ~'i~ !~ }~ Nome Page Calenc3~r t itii V~~ tnn Tr ~~ ~,~y k~nl ?~,, 2GC7 © t'iot~ttt of Sepf~rrstzer (ICIG: ' Sunday h4cntl ~c~~ y w~r+rr~ r ~ ,, SaWida~ } ~, ~4 rt r ~ C 4 , 530 pm ~ to 6 45 pm i Re W i red -- ( , 1 ~ i ~ I _ 2 - 3 - 4------ 5 -- - 6 7 8 Campout 2007 Campout 2007 5 00 pm 5 00 pm 5 00 pm 5 00 pm 08 00 am 8 00 - ----- to pm to 8 00 pm to 8 00 pm to 8 00 pm to 4 00 pm Soecer practice Soccer practice Soccer practice Soccer practice Soccer games 6 30 pm 5 00 prn ------ to830pm to800pm Wide Open Soccer practice 7 00 pm 5 30 pm to 10 00 pm to 6 45 pm Musical Miss Rewired Match and Dessert 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 6 30 pm 5 00 pm 5 00 pm 08 30 am 09 00 am 5 00 pm 08 00 am to830pm to800pm to 800 pm to930pm to 1115 am to800pm to400pm Wide Open Soccer practtce Soccer practice HCC Staff Heart 2 Heart Soccer practice Soccer Qames Meeting 7 00 pm 7 00 pm _.__.-- - S OO pm 5 30 pm to900pm to900pm 500 pm to800pm to645pm Women's Ignite to 8 OO pm Soccer practice Rewired M~mstry Team Soccer practice Meeting _ _ _ _ r _ _ 630 pm to900pm Heart 2 Heart 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 --__ --_ ^ ` ^ - __ ^- `-- I SOOpm 0o OOaSam to830pm I t 08UOpm I to 8 00 pm I t 800 pm I to500mm I t0o400pm I http //www hilisideministry org/calendar/month php~cid=0&catid=0&d=25&w=0&m=9&y=2007&s= Page 1 of 2 Hil~side Community Churc h Event Calendar 04/25/2007 04 47 PM Wide Open Soccer practice I Soccer practice I Soccer practice Heart 2 Heart I Carpet Cleaning Soccer games ` _ (FC/LFC/#1) 5 30 pm 7 00 pm 5 00 pm _ 5 30 pm to 8 00 pm to 9 00 pm to 8 00 pm 5 00 pm to 6 45 pm Fali Volleyball Ignite Soccer practice to 8 00 pm ReW~red League Soccer practice 6 30 pm 600 pm to900pm to 7 00 pm Heart 2 Heart Board Meeting 700 pm to900pm Flick Chicks 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 12 00 pm 5 00 pm 5 00 pm 5 00 pm 09 00 am Dana Point Weekend Dana Pomt Weekend to 200 pm to800pm to800pm to800pm to 1115 am Garden Lunch Soccer practice Soccer practice Soccer practice Heart 2 Heart - -' -- - ~- --- _ -- --- Bunch -- -- - -- -~ - - - - - - - - - - - 5 00 pm 08 00 am --- - -- 5 30 pm 7 00 pm 5 00 pm to 6 00 pm Soccer practice to 4 00 pm Soccer games 630 pm to800pm to900pm to800pm to 8 30 pm Fall Volleyball Ignite Soccer practice --- ' -'- ~'-- W~de Open league 5 30 pm to 645 pm 6 30 pm Rewired to900pm Heart 2 Heart 30 ; ~ ~ Dana Pomt ' ~ Weekend i I 12 00 pm ~ ~ I to200pm ~ i First Step Class ---- ~ I ~ I I 1 00 pm { to 3 00 pm O i Fall Volleyball League ~ i ____ ~ I 6 30 pm , ~ to830pm Wide Open i Select a Category: -All Calendars Go View Punter Fnendiy Select a Calendar - All Adults Go Search for Ali Calendars Search Advanced Search ~, k http //www hillsideministry org/calendar/month php~ad=0&catid=0&d=25&w=0&m=9&y=2007&s= Page 2 of 2 Hil'=ode Community Church Event Calendar t= ~" ~x ~~, ~~' .~ 3 $, ,t €., ~' k -,I~~SIC'~ ~~~fll~~~~...~Cil~~~ ~ ~`i~_~E ~ '` ~ ~i ~ ~ I ~ Nome Page Caicnct3r I i~' \n ~d• tn~; Irr r , i t i r 1~ .~U' © Month of Octe~ber ~ "w`:.' Smda~ t+cn~ay 'ire<d ~ WPa e.-'<y t', ~ri~oy `'aturda} ~~ ------ ~~---~ 3 --- ~4- --- -- ~~ ------ ---- ~~- ~ 5 00 pm 5 00 pm 5 00 pm 09 00 am 5 00 pm 08 00 am to800pm to800pm to800pm to 1115 am to800pm to400pm Soccer practice Soceer practice Soccer practice Heart 2 Heart Soccer practice Soccer games 530 pm 700 pm SOOpm 530 pm to800pm to900pm to800pm to 645 pm Fall Volleyball Ignite Soccer practice Rewired league _ i~ - 6 30 pm I 6 30 pm to 9 00 pm t to 8 00 pm Heart 2 Heart Tootshed Practice 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 12 00 pm 5 00 pm S 00 pm 08 30 am 09 00 am 5 00 pm 08 00 am to 2 00 pm to 8 00 pm to $ 00 pm to 9 30 pm to 11 15 am to 8 00 pm to 12 00 pm First Step Class Soccer practice Soccer practice HCC Staff Heart 2 Heart Soccer practice S M A R T Meeting 1 00 pm 5 30 pm 7 00 pm 5 00 pm 6 30 pm 08 00 am to300pm to800pm to900pm 500 pm to800pm to830pm to400pm Fall Volleyball Fall Volleyball Ignite to 8 00 pm Soccer practice Garden Fall Kick Soccer games League League Soccer practice Off 6 30 pm 5 30 pm 630 pm 700 pm to900pm to645pm to 8 30 pm to 9 00 pm Heart 2 Heart Rewired Wide Open Women s Ministry Team Meeting 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 08 00 am 5 00 pm 5 00 pm 5 00 pm 09 00 am 10 00 am 08 00 am to 12 00 pm to 8 00 pm to 8 04 pm to 8.00 pm to 11 15 am to 5 00 pm to 4.00 pm Handyman's Soccer practice Soccer practice Soccer practice Heart 2 Heart Carpet Cleaning Soccer games 04/25/2007 04 45 PM ~i r http //www hillsideministry org/calendar/month php7cid=0&catid=0&d=25&w=0&m=10&y=2007&s= Page 1 of 2 klil'~ide Community Church Event Calendar 04/25/2007 04 45 PM F+x-It DaY - - 1200 pm to 2 00 pm F+rst Step Class 1 00 pm to 3 00 pm Fall Volleyball League - 630 pm to 8 30 pm W+de Open 1 - - --- - J 530 pm to800pm Fall Volleyball League 6 00 pm to 7 00 pm Board Meet+ng 7 00 pm to900pm Fhck Ch+cks I - - - - 700 pm to900pm Ign+te ~ - - - - - - -- - SOOpm to800pm Soccer pract+ce 6 30 pm to 9 00 pm Heart 2 Heart ~ (FC/LFC) - - 500 pm to 8 00 pm Soccer pract+ce I - -- - -- - 530 pm to645pm ReW+red 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 12 00 pm 5 00 pm 5 00 pm 5 00 pm 09 00 am 5 00 pm OS 00 am to 2 00 pm to 8 00 pm to 8 00 pm to 8 00 pm to li 15 am to 9 00 pm to 4 00 pm F+rst Step Class Soccer pract+ce Soccer pract+ce Soccer pract+ce Heart 2 Heart Adona+ Soccer games Halloween Party 1 00 pm 5 30 pm 7 00 pm 5 00 pm - 5 30 pm to300pm to800pm to900pm to 800 pm 500 pm to645pm Fail Volleyball Fali Volleyball Ign+te Soccer pract+ce to 8 00 pm ReW+red League League Soccer pract+ce 6 30 pm 630 pm to900pm to 8 30 pm Heart 2 Heart W+de Open 28 29 30 31 ~ ! 12 00 pm 5 30 pm 7 00 pm to 200 pm to800pm to900pm ~ Garden Lunch Fail Volleyball Ignite ~ Bunch League ~ 1 00 pm 6 30 pm i to300pm to800pm Fall Volleyball Toolshed League Pract+ce 6 30 pm to830pm ~ i W+de Open ~ i Select a Category -All Calendars Go V+ew Punter Fnendly Select a Calendar• Search for All Calendars Search ~~" ~y~ - All Adults Go Advanced Search ~'~ l .a http //www hillsidemmistry org/calendar/month php~ad=0&catid=0&d=25&w=0&m=10&y=2007&s= Page 2 of 2 H~.aIdF Community Church Event Calendar c, i x , ~: `<1-. .~ x" a a 04/25/2007 04 42 PNi Home F~g~ ~alcn i~~ t<< ~ o,~ ~ ~ ~ ~ _t ~~ © P~tCJ,I~fE ill I~~U _ ,t)t 'l'`x 5~ noa~ t o~~a ~ T~ i ~. 1h~coi ~ ~~' ~ ~ ~ „t ~~aay __ '1 -- - ~~ - ---- - --- )3--- ~ 09 00 am 6 30 pm 08 00 am j to li 15 am to 8 30 pm to 4 00 pm ~ ~ Heart 2 )umpm' Jammie Night Soccer games ~ ( Heart - - I _ S 30 pm 6 30 pm to 6 45 pm II to 9 00 pm ReW~red Heart 2 ------ --- I Heart 4----- 5 ---- - ~6-- -- 7 8 - - - 9- - -- -- --- - -- 10-- -- - 12 00 pm 5 30 pm 7 00 pm 09 00 am 5 00 pm 08 00 am to 2 30 pm to 8 00 pm to 9 00 pm to 11 15 am to 10 00 pm to 4 00 pm Adona~ Fall Volleyball Ignite Heart 2 50's Night Soccer games i Volunteer League Heart 'I Luncheon _ _ _ _ -- ---- 5 30 pm 6 30 pm to 6 45 pm 1 00 pm to 9 00 pm Re Wired to 3 00 pm Heart 2 Fall Volleyball Heart League 6 30 pm to 8 30 pm Wide Open 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 OS 00 am 5 30 pm 7 00 pm 08 30 am 09 00 am 10 00 am 5 30 pm to 12 00 pm to 8 30 pm to 9 00 pm to 9 30 pm to 11 15 am to 5 00 pm to 6 45 pm Handyman's N~Iiside ]rs Ignite HCC Staff Heart 2 Carpet Ciean~ng ReW~red Hx-It Day '- -_ Basketball - - Meeting _ - -_ Heart (FC/LFC/#i/#2/#3/Office) _ -- 1 00 pm I ~ 90 p m I 5 30 pm I I 9 5 30 pm to300pm O pm to830pm 00 pm to to830pm http //www hilisideministry org/calendar/month php~ad=0&catid=0&d=25&w=0&m=11&y=2007&s= Page 1 of 2 IJ+~s+de Corc~mun+ty Church Event Calendar 04/25/2007 04 42 PM Fall Volleyball League 6 30 pm to 8 30 pm W+de Open ( Women's M+n+stry Team Meeting Hdis+de Jrs Basketball Heart 2 Heart H+Ils+de )rs Basketball 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 6 30 pm 5 30 pm 7 00 pm 5 30 pm 09 00 am 5 30 pm 5 30 pm to830pm to830pm to900pm to830pm to 1115 am to830pm to645pm W+de Open H+Ils+de )rs Ign+te H+Iis+de Jrs Heart 2 H+iis+de )rs Basketball ReW+red Basketball Basketball Heart 6 00 pm 6 30 pm to700pm to900pm Board Meeting Heart 2 Heart 7 00 pm to900pm Flick Ch+cks 25 26 27 28 29 30 12 00 pm 5 30 pm 7 00 pm 5 30 pm 09 00 am 5 30 pm to 200 pm to830pm to900pm to830pm toi115am to830pm Garden Lunch H+Ils+de )rs Ign+te H+Ils+de ]rs Heart 2 H+Ils+de )rs Basketball Bunch Basketball Basketball Heart 6 30 pm 6 30 pm 6 30 pm to830pm to800pm to900pm W+de Open Toolshed Heart 2 Pract+ce Heart Select a Category• - Ail Calendars Go V+ew Printer Friendly s ~a -.-~-~_~ Select a Calendar• - All Adults Search for . All Calendars Go Search Advanced Search http //www hills+dem+n+stry org/calendar/month php~cid=0&catid=0&d=25&w=0&m=11&y=2007&s= Page 2 of 2 Zillow - 10343 Ridgeview Ct, Rancho Cucamonga, CA 91737 http //www zillow com/HomeDetails htm~city=RANCHO+CUC ~~i,~ ~.1gi~ m k~ a E~-ia'c 10343 Ridgeview Ct, Rancho Cucamonga, CA 91737 3 beds, 3.o baths, 2,930 sq ft Value Range ~~127,i1~3 - ~ji,1 J4,<~5.~ 30-day change: ~4~,~c,9 Last updated: 03/14/2007 Home Fact` ~y ,~ ~~" 1 of 3 3/21/07 446 PM Bird's Eye View .2r~r ~ lin. Go~pnur~:~icw ~~ ~~ ~~~ ~'~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ a ..~` ,~,~"~' r ~ ~~ '~' /r ~} v ~~ y, .~ ~ ~~ ~~~ I~ ,- ~ Cr '~ ~ ~~ ~ # ~~ ~~~~~ F.ai IIH~~. ' 1~'." - + r ilk ~ i ~ r ''S. r ; t~ 14 ' as - ~,y~~~ ~ f~, +' ~ ~' j ~ ~~ • ~~ ~ ~ Fes'+fi ~ ~~ ~ ~~ r~+S r~~ k ~{ ~ ~ T~ `"~ "~~`yt,` "ti @~~4 + . '" Ra ~ -vr ~' `-= t+~ ~,•'~'~ ~ ~, . ~ tr ~i ~A ~~ ,r..,. ~ .._ ~~ ~'~~' '~ i ~ ~ = 3 i ~- * . S~' ins. `+ y.,.w:."cte~n«~,~5.~..i..a. a-x-•--G -_,?ca~~1.r,•,.. v~~. k~ ~arx~ , ~~ ~~~A.. -~-„ ~• ~ ~~ si Yahoor Mall - caipa12002@yahoo com T dilOJ` Irv a~ o,> ~^au Make Y! vour home oaae .~ ~ ~ ~ t Welcome, calpat20O2 ,t L [ i n Out, My Acrount] Calendar Notepad 03101/2007 10 36 AM _- - ---- - Web Search Mail Home Mad Tutorials He!o Th~E NEW ..'.~ .. Hoetc a~scs Y~HCC~O.COM t,"K`r7Y~ 1"- r Addresses Check Mail i Compose Earn a degree uT less than 1 yr Folders [Add Edit] Inbox (4) Draft Sent Bulk [EnTntvJ Trash [Empty) Search Shortcuts My Photos My Attachments See your credi, score free Earn a degree (n t yr ~ / '~ Bad Credit ~ p ~ Nd~`RN Refinance Rates No times Degrees 0 fast as 1 yr 4earch Marl For Mobtle -Marl Upgrades - r n ~- Y' Search Marl Search the Web j r vi u I Nr.xt ! hack to Messaoes Delete Reply Forward Move Thls message Is not flagged [Flag Message - Ma. k as unread J Date Tue 16 slay 2006 16 57 48 0700 (PDT) From Cal Pal - calpa12002 wyahoo com> ' ~ ~ Add to Address Bauk I Add Mobile Alert Subject Pastor David Burns PRIMATE & PERSONA[ To inforShillsidemmistry org Hillside Community Church I have called several times and left several messages asking for a return call. I was told that I needed to speak with Alan Aylor. Of course I have never received a return call from Alan nor anyone else from the church. I would like to discuss the problem we are having with the noise coming from the baseball games and practices. You (the church ) are making it impossible for my fama.ly and I to enjoy the use of our own home & backyard because of all of the noise that is coming from the baseball fields. I might add 6 days a week and then lets not forget Saturday services and Sunday services. So that is a grand total of 7 days of not being able to use my home and backyard with any peace and quite. Do you think that is fair?? Your non response to my requests to discuss this matter it is very upsetting and in my opinion not very Christian like. The name of your church is "COMMUNITY CHURCH" your lack of respect for the community that surrounds the church is astounding. I was reading your website....maybe you all should set down and re-read what you publish to be HCC goals and missions & core values. Because from my side of the fence it dosn't look like you are practicing what you are preaching. I would like you David ONLY to call me and set up a metting with me and a few of my neighbors to discuss Printable Vrew http //us f317 marl yahoo com/ym/Showl_etter~Msgid=3868_0_86232_ ta=yes&inc=25&order=down&sort=date&pos=7&view=aBehead=b&box=Sent Page 1 of 2 Yahoor Mafl - calpa12002@yahoo com Check Marl Compose this problem. Thank you Terri Smith 909-851-1321 P.S. My husband said go ahead send the email they won't respond to it either 03/01/2007 10 36 AM Do You Yahoo!? Tired of Spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around http://mail.yahoo.com Delete Reply Forward Move Previous I jdExf I back to Messaoes Save Messane Text I Full Header<_ _ ~ ~ T Search Mari Search the Web Copyright ~ 1994 2007 Yahoos Inc All ru,7hts reserved Terms of Service Copyrigh~rlo Polrcy Gwdelines Ad Feedback NOTICE We collect personal rnformation on this srte To team more about how we use your information see our Privacy Policy rttp //us f317 mall yahoo com/ym/ShowLetter~Msgld=3868_0_86232_ ta=yes&rnc=25&order=down&sort=date&pos=7&view=a&head=b&box=Sent Page 2 of 2 F*tp //www dailybulletin com/portlet/article/html/fragments/print_article~sp~articleld=5631743&siteld=203 04/23/2007 OS 23 ~'M Church's expansion rejected By Andrea Bennett, Staff Writer Inland Valley Daily Bulletin Article Launched 04/09/2007 11 43 56 PM PDT NORCO - To some folks, a church on their block would be a welcome neighbor that deters crime and builds a sense of community But several residents on Corona Avenue argued a proposal by their neighbor -Norco First Assembly of God Church - to expand nearly fourfold would not bring peace and peacefulness "City living in a rural atmosphere," resident Don Kindred said, in reference to the city's motto, as he addressed the Planning Commission recently "That's why my family came here in 1975 I hear a lot about wanting to keep it rural You want to tell me how that's going to happen" A handful of homeowners spoke in obJection to the church expansion, citing loud music, clogged streets and rock-throwing youths who were already degrading their cherished country lifestyle They also complained about a large, fluorescent-lit cross that won't stop glowing Kindred said he's had chickens stolen, sheep inJured and vehicles damaged by rock-wielding kids Dozens of the church's predominantly Latino congregation attended the meeting as well to support the vision of their pastor, Alfred Somoza Increased membership at the church has been a point of pride, but also one of inconvenience, as its 160 parishioners cannot be seated in the current sanctuary A new, 480-seat sanctuary has been proposed In addition, atwo-story, 11,300-square- foot building would replace modular trailers on the property used as classrooms and offices The big changes are intended to meet future growth needs Mike Jackson, who lives behind the church on Sagebush Lane, said the proposed protect is too massive for the area "That's four times the traffic, noise and trash," Jackson said "I don't want to live in a prison That's why I left Orange County I like the openness, the free-flowing air " But the music is the biggest annoyance to him "I have no idea what they're doing It's in Spanish," Jackson said "I'm all for having a good time, but my backyard isn't a frat house I don't want to listen to someone else's party every weekend " Planning Commission Chairman Greg Newton said he grew up in a big Catholic pansh in the middle of a residential neighborhood, which is where churches should be Newton said churches have changed since those days -often operating daily now -and he doesn't know if they are still the ideal neighbors they once were "If you look at older residential areas in Upland and Ontano, the neighborhoods developed around the church," Newton said "Very rarely do you see a church put into a neighborhood " Norco First Assembly of God Church is close to two other churches and Sierra Vista Elementary School, none of which have caused noise or other problems, neighbors said "The only thing I hear from any of them is children playing," Jackson said "I don't like to hear kids scream, but I don't want to be a bad neighbor and kids got to go to school " Somoza's wife and secretary, Elisa, said last week that many of the comments made at the April 5 meeting were false, but the church declined to comment until the city made a final decision on the planned expansion After listening to residents' concerns, the commission denied the proposal as it stood http //www dailybulletin com/portlet/article/html/fragments/pnnt_article~sp~articield=5631743&siteld=203 Page 1 of 2 fr~tp //www dailybulleun com/portlet/article/html/fragments/print_article ~sp~articleld=5631743&siteld=203 04/23/2007 OS 23 PM Commissioners urged the project architect to return with ascaled-down version of the church, a study of traffic impact to the area and a less obtrusive design than the Mission-style architecture proposed in order to blend in better with the homes around it Staff water Andrea Bennett can be reached by e-marl at andrea bennettC~darlybulletrn com or by phone at (909) 483-9347 Close Window Send To Printer http //www dailybulletin com/portlet/article/html/fragments/print_article ~sp~articleld=5631743&siteld=203 Page 2 of 2 CONTENTS Pon~vard Summary Effects Qf Exccssrve NO1SC Appendix Z George Leightozt, Consulting Services 2 Noise Survey Data Sheets 3 Excexpts. }?h s~lo~ical PSychc~loR~cal and Sacral Effects ~f Nrnse - Karl D Kryter Page s 1 ~`~ 3 4 F(~RWARTI The following are excerpts from the Ctry of Rancho Cucamonga Municipal Cade - Section 17.02 120 Noise Abatement Extermr Naise Standards s 1 It shall be unlaw;Pul for any person at airy locattan wtth~n the city to create any no~sc or allow the creation of any noise on the property owned, le sa ed, occupied, ox otherwise controlled by such person, which causes the noise Icvcl when measured on the property I1ne of any other praperty to exceed the bask na~se level as adjusted below {a) Baste Noise Level for a cumulative pcrlod of not more than 1~ rumutcs in any one hour, or (b} Basic Noise Level plus S d$A for a cumulative period of not more than 10 minutes m any one hour, or (c) Basic Norse Level plus 13 dBA for a cumulative period of not more than 5 minutes in any one hour, or (d) $a5ic NOiSC Level plus 15 dBA at any time TABLE 17 08-080-D RESIDENTIAL NOISE. STILNDARDS LOCATION Ol~ MAXIMUM ALLOWABLE IvIEAS[T,LtEI'vIENT 10 p m. to l a m l a m to 10 p m 1. F~tcrior 55 dBA 60 dBA Note Each of ttae noise llmrts above shall be reduced ~ dBA for noise conststln4 of unpulse or simple tone noise. As will be shown, the noise created by playground :1ct1vxtl~S aP the Hi3lti~de Community Church at the rear re:~idential property line of mines S Grace and Tarn Sm1CS on 1018 and` 10438 Vivtenda Street vialatcs every provision of the above Municipal Cade 1 ~ ... il~~ll yllylt-~il~ On &-8-96, a Haase survey was conducted fmm 10 00 a rn_ to 12 30 p m an the rear property line of Tom Smtts aid tames Cxrace to measure baseball game noise from the ad~accnt playbround of the Hillside Communuy Church 'I'he noise was primarily impulse or pure tone noise (yelling, screaming, chanting) reducing the allowable daytune Horse limit from ~0 d$A, to 55 dBA (Table 17.0$ 080-U, Note c). ^~„ The following noise levels in dBA were measured CUMULATIVE NOISE LEVEL -dBA MAX TIME FERIUD 11~E.A.SURED ALLOWABLE (MINUTES) 15 72 55 ~a 71 60 5 73 69 ANXTIME 102 74 As can be seen, ttus is a clcaz violation of all of the provisions of the City of Rancho Cucamonga Municipal Code It should be zaoted that the peak naise levels of 102 dB.A is tlxe level created by a laud rack band in an extremely noisy discotheque. Cozilpa>;ed to the measured 40 dBA ambient noise level Chas rcpreserats over one nullaan tunes the acoustic energy that sounds over 6Q tunes as loud. .. a shattez~><zg intrusion into this hush-Quiet ne~ghborlxood Effects of F.xccssi~ve Noise Aside from the total laclt of visual pnvaty oeeaSxoned by baseball fans aztd participants peering directly into second-story windows and down mto first floor windows and yards, the following aze other negative consequences of the blatant vtolanon of the no~sc ordinance "Phvstolo~ical, psychologtcal and Social F,ffects_of_N_ o_tsc" s Appendix 3 contains bath a definttion of impulsive noise as well as an excerpt deser~ing "nonauditory-system response to noise and effects on health" Coupled with "the startle- alerttng-arousal response" cited are the anger, and outrage of havuzg the peace and txanquiliiy of ones home destroyed and the fnistration at nc~ inaction of the city ~n preventing rt 2 Loss of Enjc~tment of ]?ronerty The normal pleasures of ones home are dez~aed Backyard cookouts and parties wztli faintly and friends are trnpoSSble because of the screaming hollering and chanting of the crowd and the lack of visual privacy. Use of a bacltyard swizannrng pool is out of the question In addition, doors and windows must be closed to minimize the interior noise intrusion, denying homeowners the freedom and enlayment of the outdoors 3 Loss of Property Value Califortua's recent passage of the 'bisclvstue Law requ~res that a seller inform a prospective buyer of any defects or negative envaronxx~ental aspects of a home Any buyer who was shown the home during a game would likely be shocked and appalled at what he Saw and heard, effectively enduig any prospect of a sale I~owever, as a fudge rerx~arkcd during trial of a sunilar case, "Don't say it can't be Sold Anything can be sold tf the price is right " 3 JUrI LU uu uu...r.v Apl~'F,NnTX Z . George E Leighton, Cansulting Services 2 Noise Survey Data Shccts 3 Excerpts• Phy~~oloateal Psvcholo~?eal and Sacral 1/ffects of Noise - Karl D kryter s ~~ =F ~.... _ w~. .M--.i.~u.. rt . - ~EDIt~E E. LEIC~TaN ,_ - "' cotvstrI.Ta,Nx', rrars>; cor~T~oL _, ~„ CONSULTING SER~CES Mr. Leighton is an acoustical consultant with an irripressive list of clients. Some of the znpre` well lmown are listed below .~ Chevron Texas Instruments Digital Equipment Textron General Electric 3Iv1 Gulf Qil CJ S I~1avy International I3arvesier United Technologies He has over 35 years of professional engizicenng experience with over 25 years exclusively in the field of industrial, cartimcreial, and residential rtoisc control Il~IDYISTR.IA'L His industrial experience covers the entire range of noise abatement. ]'-Te has wozkcd with OEM's (Original Equipment Manufacturers) to design quiet equipment and provide field retrofit lilts. He has dcsagned, built and Installed noise-control systems zzivolving single items of equipment through enure plants for the rnetalworiing, automotive, construction, pritiung, chemical and petrochemical indiistrzes Techniques ranged from initial noise surveys ti~rough computer prediction and computer modeling to unsure compliance with in-plant and community noise standards .. OSHA compliance experience ranges from noise surveys, corrective action to meet OSHA standards, consulting with clients and attorneys under OSHA citations, and negotiating with OSHA to develop abatemen plants for cited clients Cl~MI1~RGT~A~L His commercial experience covers netiv construction and corrective action for churches, recreatsoa halls, existing schools, restaurants, factory and offce buildings, hospitals, hotels and motels. Code-compliance reports prepared fox Interior aiid exterior (community) 'noise requirements Mechatucal systems analysts provided for new construction and corrective action for existing systems. .~ ~SYDE~TTIAL His residential experience covers new and existing apamnents, condominizams, and private homes Acoustical Analysis Reports prepared for Title 24, bntldirig and grading permits He specializes in analysts and correction of prabierzas In existuig buildings Expert-witness testimony provided In court actions. ' Typical clients are Industrial firms, architects. developers, contractors, homeowners, attorneys, consulting engineers, schools, city and national governments. 1307-A SOUTH EUCLID STREET + ANAHEIM, CA 9280? • (714) 535-8648 F.~ (714) 535-3649 (SUO} 57d•3666 Jun zU Ue ua:~ra !t av GEORGE E. Z,.EIGH'Y'ON PRQFESSIONAL QT~'AY,YF'ICATIONS s ,~ - $OARD-CE~,tTTFIED ACOZ3STICAL CONSULTAI~TT 12EGYSTEREF~ PRgE'ESSIONAL ENGINEER. (MA} r GRADUATE ENGINEER, MASTER'S DEGREE - 35 YEARS PROFESSTO~tAI, ENGINEERING EXPERIENCE i 25 YEARS EXCLUSI~IELY IN NOISE CONTROL ~- r ,~ - - MEV1$ER• Acoustical Society of America Institute of Noise Control En~meers iational Council of Acoustical Consultants National Society of Professional Engineers Society of Testifying Experts w aG 7~ y s U H lil X N Q Z y Q (~ U W ~ ~ a w z rWr~~ z [V J Ca ~ w z ~ o ~~' c r 0. 2 ~~ ~ ~. ~. Q ~ N of h\V~ Q \ ~ ~+~ r. I~ I ~ G ~I ~ n ~ ~e N 1 C ~n v `~ N C ~ ~ L o~ E ~ ~ r .. ... C m ~ ~ ~ y_ ~.+ ~ _ ~ U O `~ti `~ r z Q ~ w L ~ ~ ti -- _ t`J ~ ~` ,~~ ~ - ~ I ! i ~~ ~ ; i i` { I t ~ ~ I~ I ~ I ~ i ` ` O ~ I ~ ~ ` ~ ~ 1 I ~ 1 ~ ~ ~ ~ l ~ ~ ~l~ ~ I Z ~` ~ ` ~ ~ ~ I I ~ I vt ~ o. 1~ r ~ ~ I_ I ~ I , , } \i ~ '~ ~ I U ~`~~~~ I; I I l I ~e~j ~ I~ I I!~ i I! 1 1 1 o daa ( ~ y ~~ I I I l l it ~at~ ~ ~ llk) III ~_°~ i~ l i i I'= 1 1 ~u,oa `III ;II ii4~I + { 1 1 ~ ~ ' ' I ~ ~ 1 ~ ~( i { 1~ j ~ ~~ i I i c i I I ! I I I I I I I 1 ~. ~ i , m C ~ `tea ' V1 ~ w I S y 4 <, ,~'~~` I~ ~h ,~ ~ j ~, ~~ N - ~~ ~` ~~~ ~~ ~- z~ o° ~- 0 ~~ w~ ~ o ~~ >._ !w z v J a~ E a ,a LL a x cc ~ ~ a~ x ~ H Q ~ 0. Y .-. m O c h a o . ~ --~ A n U N N L ~ - a ° ~ ' E E ~ Q '!' ~ ~ . _ ~ ~ ..~ n ~~~I I ~ ~ ~-.~ ~~~' r ~' c ~ ~~ ~ ~ t 1.~ N ~ N iet~ I I I I o dS0 I i ~ I } na~~ i { ~ l 1Si a { ! j i iuiad ~~I~y~~~~l _" 11 ~ '~~ ti k ` ~ ~I 1 ~ ~ I 1 a ~ {° l~ ~' r ~. I :ti' -I , -~ ~ ' I iiii JUt'1 ~U Ub uti: aria ~^ W OC }~ ~ d U W Y h J Z ° c~ U , w ~ w ~ J ., a z ~, ~ ~ R q d a T G c 'a E e .~_ w C ~ s a x a N m a a °o ti LL, v '° Y, o `" C ai ~ m E 'cs ~ L C m a` •- ~ ., n v ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i g iii i i~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~. `~ try ~'h ~ I p~ `" ~ R _ ~ ~' ~ ~ ~; ~ ~`~ ~~ ~ ~~ ~ ,,~~ ~ h- ~ ~ ~~ ~ .~..~ ~ ~ ~ ~, .~ II iefd I I I I I I I I ~ o~aa II ~ lilll,l!I ~~13 i i I I I I I =Q~ II Ilil l i II ~~,od ICI l! I i l I I _ I ~ z ~ I t ~ I ~~ I I I £, ffects of Noue Low- and tnfrasonic-frcquettcy sounds 456 Ultrasontc•frequcncy sound 459 = ` 1VI0$H srtudtes 468 ' I~calth-Related Effects m Workers 468 ~`~ Introduction 468 Effects ftozn long-term exposures 469 Hearing [oss and hypertension 473 Short-term experiments 476 Health•Related lrffects to Residential Communities 482 Mental health 483 Annoyance and mental health 488 Strtss- versus noa•stress-related health disorders 490 Longitudinal study 497 Street traffic noise 499 Health in children 50Q Health m fetuses 501 >rPA summary and rcacarch plan for effects of noise on health 504 Summary SAS }7eflcxive responses 505 Indirect effects 506 Health effects 506 Effects on artnnals 507 , References 507 IntrQdnction It is generally believed that continued exposure to Horse in real life can be a source of phystologtcal stress possibly capable of causing health disordCrs btyond that of direct damage to the audttary receptor system (refs. ]and ?) SomG~ theorists hold that some of these effects occur because of innate, reflexive re- sponses to none that cannot be prevented or, when suppressed, that rcqutre some effort that may itself become somewhat debilttaung in tune An alternative theory" ~s that the truly nonizab~tuatirig reflexive responses to na~sc are not suffie~ent in character to caubc any ilI health, and that those responses to nCiS[ that are or could be stgniftcactt in this regard are not directly the result of e~cposure to noise but are respr~nses to the emotional mesnuigs cottveycd by the sounds. Qbnoasly, the degree to which noise can Iead to harm to nonaud~tory physi- obgieal systems of tote body arc questions of utmost importance far the assess. rtient of the need for noise control. However, research on these questions is cam- plicatcd and somewhat cuntroversial, as seen in the discussions to follow 390 Nonaud:tory•Sysiem Response to Norse and Effects un Health Functions of Nonanditory Systems )'inure ~0 1 (ref. Y) tllustrats.s some dsrect and mdtrecL cgnncct~ons between the human auditory rystem and the neural-muscular-gi.tndular systems m the body Special attenuon is envited to the autonomic (svmpatheuc nervous and glandul.>.r) system,. The primary function of the .eutonomsc system is to control and coordinate the l-fe-support tunctians :end organs of the body-the dtgest>on t PERCEPTION ~ ~' OF t0UM0 *,AREFUlME55~ = t"r NvrarNVSEA~ ~ srsrcrr .. w. ~ ^*i 1 ., r. r' ~~7e3 eyond Some ,ve re- same theory ant ~n arc or Horse ohvn- -ssess- com• ~ ~Y.... ` ~~~~ SYn Y SETfC YOTOR srsrErr i,, AOREYOGORTI[j1 ~ MORMONE GASTROINTESTIN~I MOYElAEN7S 1 REACTION ON { SICELETAt, uu,ClES F'TGURE 10 1 Ms~or resounse mrc,hanams and subsystems of tht aumncxnl~ ,vstcm tFia.~ ~n rw 1 ) X91 r - ...,.-. ~`' ~, r Effects of Norse of food, the cardiovascular blood supply rystem, the resptratioa of air, the control of body tt:mperatun, ere. These functions are carried out atrtomattcal(y and un- consciotaiy. An extensrn, rccertt renew of the effects of sound on the non- audttory systems in man and anunats iz given by Borg (ref 3). The sudrtory system has some drrcrt acural connect~oas wcth the sympa- thetic nervous system at levels below the brain proper It is bei~eved that vca these connections sounds can cause autonomic-system responses that occur wtthout any conscious "thought" processes as !o the meaning or effects of the sounds or new, and thereby servo as a wsrnutg system about the presence of things >si the en'nvameat+ In this reed it can be noted that sounds, unlike light, bend around and, to some extent, go through objects, are omn~drrect~onal, and arc generated and transmitted as will at night as in the daytime In brief, sound (or noise) !s generally a more effective warning signal about things, espeaally moving things, in the environment than is light It is considered to be advanta~eus to have the autonomic system acttvate the body in ways that best enable it to fight or flee rather than to merely continue to vegetate. However, the pnmary components of poss~'ble direct autonomic- system response to sound (sometimes called the startle response) appear to cease to function, or atr suppressed, with repetitions of the sound or noise when ~t rs no longer an unexpected stimulus. As an aid to the intcrprctat7on of some e~cpen- mcntal data presented, a beef outline of the general physiological responses to wand and major theones that have evolved around these responses are bnefly discussed below. Y Tn this list ca mottlity (refs from giandul 'nc~sc v; rate, blood c sl~letal-must have been co '$"ira~7ablc cla However, the any of these c mean char ar the nonaudit~ hau5ted, over can sometime cult. (See Sup Figures h.~bicuatlon o 124 52 1. . ~ .~. s i .~ l ~,, ~~ Tha stank-alerting-sroQaal >~sponse Suite the earip 1940's, numerous laboratory measurements have been made of nntiaadrtory-system responses to sadden, mtcnse sounds or noises, both unex- Pectad and repeated or expteted. Davis er al. (ref 4) called the resulting complex of responses to these sounds the N-response, herein called the "startle-sIerting- arousal" response (alerting resp~ for short). The magnitude of this response generally depends ~omtly on the suddenness of the onset. the intensity of the Horse, and the state of gntesecnee of the organism. The following physiolog~c.r[ re• spouses appeared to be mvolved• 1 A circulatory response dominated by vasoconstriction of the peripheral blood vessels antic other adjustments of blood pressure throughout the body 2. A r,cdaced rate of brrathing 3 Gglvanic skas r~esponae (GSR), n ehango,n tl,e eleetncal resistance of the skin 4. A bnef change Iii skeletal-muscle tension 392 120 >>s as ~,0 77 ° ,06 ~s 8 i o, s. 96,92 02 a+ 67 59 1 i e, ea FIGUR1r 102. .Jun cu uo uo•.ioo _ ...~~~a~~uri. J.. -- - - NonarJdrtory-SysrPm RespansP ro Norse and ~ffecrs ar Health 'r of z- 1- a- se ~t ~r ,•e rd re or ng lIG ue rc- rse no -ri- LO fly de ~x. ex ~- ISe he ~- Cad •hc To thrs lut can be added, among others, the changes that occur m ga_strorntestlnal motility {refs. S and 6) and chetrucal chatrgcs or excretions In the blood and unne from glandular strmulatton (refs, 7 to 10) These vanous responses arc interrelated. As a rrsult, slomc rncasure of heart rata. blood clrculatian (usually blood vahrme or pulse to the skrn of a finger), skelctat-muscle response (such as from the rnuscle4 of the forearm), and GS12 have been commonly used because they c-:~n be rcadi.ly sensed and recorded by available electronlc transducers without grestly incanventencing the sublecL. Y-fawcwcr, ttrc Presence of one of these responses does not ncecssanty mean that ~rry of these otherresponses have occurred Further, the lack of response may not mean that an alerting reaction should not have occurred, the reason being that the nonaudltory system at the t1.rnc of the noiu sttmutatton maybe some~~ hat ex- hausted, overactive, or under the domrnauon of other sttmulatsons These [actors can sometimes make the eallectron and Interpretation of data to this area drffi- it. (Sec Surw~Ao and Arenberg {ref. li).) Figures 10 2 to 10,5 (from refs. 4, 12, 13, 14, and 15} show the rather raprd habituation of responslvcness to meaningless sounds or Horses that are presented -~ 110 IC ___ 9o.e .ore 7 Y~ 67 1 ?0 00 115.78 ~Uy~ 11D 77 3 70676 S 101 ~ 96 92 9Z.~ 1 E7 69 "t n= p`i'wS M Aa'°5 a`6 ^!i°g A9A1DA1t'~'1Y SECONDS (a) Mean response BO ~ 80 i 70 EA 5D ~ 40 ~D sD io ~ AES~DNSE TO A ~~~ . pES~OMSE 70 0 ~ C -- D ~lSPOMSE 70 ~ -- D RESroNsE To e a c FIGURE !0 2. Mean muscle action-notCntlal response and adaplauon o! response iD 10U0 Pic toile, Horizontal lure 1ndlcatcs almuins duration a lndicate~ bneC tatenc~ b md~ caret tong Ia~eDCy (From ref 4 1 393 1 Z ] 4 QuAHTERS OF SCTTiNG (b) Adaptatlvn of re~t>unse IS mui srttmt,