Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2015/08/18 - Agenda Packet THE CITY OF RANCHO CUCAMONGA hDESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE L% J AGENDA RANCHO 18,u CUCAMONGA A g 2015 - 7:00 P.M. Rancho Cucamonga Civic Center Rains Room 10500 Civic Center Drive Rancho Cucamonga, California I. CALL To ORDER Roll Call Regular Members: Richard Fletcher_ Francisco Oaxaca Candyce Burnett _ Donald Granger Alternates: Ray Wimberly_ Lou Munoz Rich Macias II. PROJECT REVIEW ITEMS The following items will be presented by the applicant and/or their representatives. Each presentation and resulting period of Committee comment is limited to 20 minutes. Following each presentation,the Committee will address major issues and make recommendations with respect to the project proposal. The Design Review Committee acts as an advisory Committee to the Planning Commission. Their recommendations will be forwarded to the Planning Commission as applicable. The following items do not legally require any public testimony,although the Committee may open the meeting for public input. A. SITE DEVELOPMENT REVIEW DRC2015-00595 — KARLA BROCK — A request to change the paint color of multiple buildings within the Foothill Crossings commercial center located on the south side of Foothill Boulevard at Day Creek Boulevard in the Regionally Related Office/Commercial (RRO/C)within the Victoria Community Plan —APNs: 0229-021-68, 69, 71, 73, 75, 77, 78 and 79. 1 of 2 k J DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE Ls AGENDA RANCHO CUCAMONGA August 18, 2015 - 7:00 P.M. III. PUBLIC COMMENTS This is the time and place for the general public to address the Committee. State law prohibits the Committee from addressing any issue not previously included on the Agenda. The Committee may receive testimony and set the matter for a subsequent meeting. Comments are limited to five minutes per individual. IV. ADJOURNMENT The Design Review Committee has adopted Administrative Regulations that set an 11:00 p.m. adjournment time. If items go beyond that time, they shall be heard only with the consent of the Committee. I, Jennifer Palacios, Office Specialist ll for the City of Rancho Cucamonga,hereby certify that a true, accurate copy of the foregoing agenda was posted on August 5, 2015 , at least 72 hours prior to the meeting per Government Code Section 54954.2 at 10500 Civic Center Drive, Rancho Cucamonga. 2 of 2 DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS 7:00 p.m. Dominick Perez August 18, 2015 Project Description: SITE DEVELOPMENT REVIEW DRC2015-00595 — KARLA BROCK — A request to change the paint color of multiple buildings within the Foothill Crossings commercial center located on the south side of Foothill Boulevard at Day Creek Boulevard in the Regionally Related Office/Commercial (RRO/C) within the Victoria Community Plan — APNs: 0229-021-68, 69, 71, 73, 75, 77, 78 and 79. Site Characteristics: The project site is an existing commercial complex that consists of twelve parcels with a combined area of approximately 31.5 acres. The site is situated on the south side of Foothill Boulevard, on the east and west side of Day Creek Boulevard and is located within the Regional Related Office/Commercial (RRO/C) District of the Victoria Community Plan. The site contains a total building area of 312,030 square feet. Design Parameters: The proposal applies to eight of the twelve buildings within the complex (Vitamin Shoppe, Friar Tux, Office Depot, Pieology/Sake 2 Me Sushi, Century 21, Ortho Mattress, Total Wine and Vision Center). The applicant is requesting to change the building colors of these subject buildings within this center in an effort to beautify the center, clearly define the buildings and to allow the center to standout when compared to surrounding shopping centers. The proposal does not include any changes to the architecture, materials, decorative features, and/or floor area of any of the buildings. Each of the eight buildings in question will be painted a combination of three colors: one color for the building projections, one color for the recessed wall plane and one color for the decorative wood elements. The recessed wall planes and decorative wood elements, such as the corbels used on the raised towers and trellises attached to the trash enclosures found on each building, will be painted to match each other. This will allow the center to maintain uniformity and compatibility. However, the projected elements on each building, such as entrance towers, will be painted a color that is primarily unique to each building. Three of the subject buildings are proposed to use bolder colors, including the Total Wine, Vision Center and Vitamin Shoppe. Although these colors, as shown in the table below, are not consistent with the existing color theme, the new colors are complimentary and work well with the other proposed colors. Buildings Projected wall color Recessed wall color Decorative wood color Vitamin Shoppe Hamilton Blue Inside Passage Chocolate Chunk Friar Tux Center Ridge Inside Passage Chocolate Chunk Office Depot Center Ridge Inside Passage Chocolate Chunk Pieology/ River Rocks Inside Passage Chocolate Chunk Sake 2 Me Sushi Century 21 Wheat Bread Inside Passage Chocolate Chunk Ortho Mattress S'mores Inside Passage Chocolate Chunk Total Wine Burnt Crimson Inside Passage Chocolate Chunk Vision Center Hamilton Blue Inside Passage Chocolate Chunk Buffalo Wild Wings Sears Grand Not a Part Red Robin Joe's Crab Shack The remaining four buildings within the complex (Sear's Grand, Red Robin, Joe's Crab Shack and Buffalo Wild Wings) are not included with this project. The Sears Grand and Buffalo Wild Wings buildings were not included in this request and will remain as is, but will generally be compatible with the proposed color scheme for the subject eight buildings since the buildings DRC ACTION AGENDA DRC2015-00595 — KARLA BROCK August 18, 2015 Page 2 currently utilize similar colors. The Joe's Crab Shack and Red Robin buildings each currently have unique architectural styles that set these buildings apart from the rest of the center and are therefore not included within this request. Staff Comments: The following comments are intended to provide an outline for Committee discussion. Major Issues: The following broad design issues will be the focus of Committee discussion regarding this project: 1. No major issues. Secondary Issues: Once all of the major issues have been addressed, and time permitting, the Committee will discuss the following secondary design issues: 1. All wood features throughout the site are currently painted green (see attached existing photos) including the Buffalo Wild Wings building, which is not included in this paint change request. In order to maintain good design and consistency throughout the center, a condition of approval will be added that will require the wood elements on the eight buildings in question as well as the Buffalo Wild Wings building to be painted the proposed "Chocolate Chunk". 2. Upon visiting the site, staff verified that a number of buildings contain one or more wall planes with areas in disrepair due to the past removal of wall signs. Therefore, staff is including a condition that requires all buildings to be repaired and patched concurrently with the installation of the new paint. • 3. Although the color renderings that were provided by the applicant only shows each building's main entrance elevation, the applicant has indicated that the color placement for the remaining sides of each building will be consistent with these renderings. Therefore, staff is requiring that all sides of the eight subject buildings match the same color theme as the front elevation shown in the attached renderings. Staff Recommendation: Staff recommends that the project be approved, subject to the . recommended conditions, and forwarded to the Planning Director for review and action. Attachments: Exhibit A - Foothill Crossings Map Exhibit B - Site Plan Exhibit C - Existing Colors Exhibit D - Proposed Colors SITE DEVELOPMENT REVIEW DRC2015-00595 }k..�. FOOTHILL CROSSINGS MAP /� _ � > i .y. 'w 1 . «if •k ,s. 6 L- — tip' , —'* '� ' ' _ F - 1-.....- ..! ?,•jI --- • • °; "" hi .. - 0ti �,,,,,... .. Ti '�•.i �., r., 4• +• :.r��—"'oh '.1164.11.1 „iii g,„„ 1 r •'''.. . 1 11. - r" ' 'it 'Iii .,,,., 1 • 11 . , ' NAP 4 i .I -.4 * .:' 4—' 7 __. I • s f .< ,.., 1 NAP i 5 4 414 94 r b ;,l l': *t i t 1'+ .!7 4.4 * �"". ` y �. / . / R f v 1 _ ` ' ,4 , f /."/"4" NAP ' ., 4. ,g - is y , f f;' ,r • :41.444\01#/F1V/1 ! -' . ),' Ai .• a 1 • NAP S&' ' '. ;.;, ''41 •_ i r. •, 7i a. •' f,/ / .. . .; I 1 J ,rJ� r I r , f .. At t. r 4 ' .i' y rwhii.IL / „ -1. , .riter j. .,w 4 I - i r / . . ....- II . ' ...,.. �1 4� i : : ' Legend: 1. Vitamin Shoppe 2. Friar Tux 3. Office Depot 4. Pieology 5. Century 21 6. Ortho Mattress 7.Total Wine 8.Vision Center EXHIBIT A tes P.:2 i tf { J a 1: . J \ V t� 4i 3 ` (Minn ti' IS 6uissoJD II ! 410Oi Winn t• tifiliiiil hl Hi;ii ii r, 3 Iii •' -, N ,141;11 .. , t 3 I) ,1 1 �'V .p A :1 1) )' f y t I ! 5 1 ^f 11 1 1 1 a itt„ Liitilrititi tin L.., - �)i 1 i ' � I : I . , .345 I. uuuu , :„Ye 1 t �l I ' �' 1 e 1 1 ill 5 ,J IJ' ix 1-- - ; r -\ "J Eye\ \ :�' c. k,.., ,, „ f \ ' / { I , . ' \ \ cn/ � J \- \ \ \\ \i j _ y v ( d ` :, I lid '`l •� -ti `. --- ^ r,,, 1 \\\ 4 , � P ;/` L_�r I x” Ld: —L'i� _—.:_ 'l___..+�\ —_ _r ti- I_ �l mi_ l_ 8 11 I I ; : .,, :;:_ .... , d5 ui i . ., . • li, . .. ::, , , , _ _ . . . . I \ . . . . .. . , • EXHIBIT B Existing Colors Foothill Crossings • EXHIBIT C . -- il' ... : ...E .. . _ m ., 1...k. . ..., - . - . ; - . . _ . . . .-_ . i . - - ... ..i:.-, :,... , i - i (111:' 2 N., \ • \ - \ k \ , - z ... \\,,,,,,... ,., :I r ' vow = ...... ‘113 I ji . : 1 , : 7., 1-; ...., 44 _ .... :f. - . ....1 . t..--••••..--.-- `4.:.,e," :-t ..- ..„ - L., tt :411110 4. -4...1 a •..-.;. - -,..-. 9r, re. I i.„t. .,. ' TANI.'..•...."...nr■'.''. ..: ck- C.."' .0' t.Z) ..'" qt...1 1%, .... ,.-,..7--""-..■1611116...'• Y 'n ...' r) 7'. .... tf:: •••• . . ) ... C.......) . • = .... tt•••••4 `.......4 •1e...1 / / •'5.4 ., . •.-- •• 1 Iii .,_ C.) 41OPPI:___ ".. 1 r 0 I III 4▪. •-r. r_ 7. A. i_ t -- I 1 ,. -. 11 -.......z ,...-1‘ ......" '7-- ...-. -'; ''5. -... 4 1' ...•••• _4 ✓ r .."... ..' ,—.1 a........ II _... ...,•••• x— ....... r,.. 1 ' ,--4 ".,— X.• ...,*, I 1 if/ ....• •:-. —7' --... C.5. 7..• — ••., ...Z —.,. 1.•:: If a E C E O Z CZ c cc ;..) C W vi E A 1 75 IV _.—, > !_ U cup//�� ,_ ,- tMJ .L O _: = E LL tiO o (..f) z 0 (n = v L 0, C/) U U ° ._ a L o 24 w O T-1 2 ., O O z Oz Al : e U o r 1 ` 1 , ' � MI CL) , a) ca o_ IL 1 ill' � i y tQ era t ..ti _ . .Ili i I O J - +-+a 3 Z /Z 2 i3 C W J P (i) +J g, C a = 0 a) U Q = E • aw U_ >- a 4- O v 0 4— L O a_0 O 01 •Itl�'t:- J.i. Y I ' 'a.. y�� ',•.t.+i I 0 up J t1J c cc cf) y O v cn U L U ° C/) Q L 0 = i O w Q c? Q Z ° U o � Q Cl..)1g ,, . , . illt 41 (v ,: U ) LL T ■ CO Q s • l ?)V Z • 3 Q Cc a I 0 a O Z CU Cc W 0 1_ i rL,I E no co cs "� Q) CC (j_ = i o n ', 0 0 J i O T o v U U � } i f < CD a L la ...= Lii ' IL *le ..C.- .' .... . CD 0 _ s 6 i i . . a.) \ •_. . i 4 •J 4....•-•--,, -5", --- '1'-'... I a) / . U CU IP Q ' a in• v .� Z _ Q to /4:, c C E O 0 J - - - ¢ ♦� r z M L _ C Co j4,....._ .• r--�_ ��j . , 0 0 .0 Q N o (..f) o > ) co '' a) ^^ Cr) • I- W{ -ate' LL 0 ci Q 3 = @„ - a J J L CD Q Q z U_ .i12 ,: \ - • • • • +-+ %Iillmemesimprigila v..,...r,. I..L / . s r I U a i :ikiii- \,___T____ ,:: iz-. oul r-_ 4i f r • • ' % s - •,. • .. la?.. );-,.L.'--l'irlil7---■,dr;-,,,ibo;.st--.0.11 ! ..# . t ? • '? ° fir-doW c.:'- -rip 0 i 0 ..-. _---. ..-- z (73 7.3 o CD CD t- -0 #19 — ..... -0 I, 0_ 13 S (I)) . .. C 0 (n !-,5 0 .p ( -... : _ c ..= __ , D E .., Lri ' .,..A. 0 -= (13 . i CO -zr .• ›- a. 4--.1 o a) .— (.o > - 0 = I S LL. T-, (r) - cf) ca, CD 4 (J) -,-i , a.) C)0 7.1, ..0 . ..,_ ; . -...(......--...------•-•"""""" 0 l° C..) Hj / .... ... - 4,140...... . - 4116111%101116. CC = ...1 . ._ CI -:,,, • 4 r 3 - ^1,1111111 1-- 0 0 Li _ I- = d *tr.- IFIr , z, 1 0z 0 0 - 0 5- // -1 D Li_ L, I _. ■ •Tc • / . . (I- 4.Q A ) la:.... - - ,-- — 4-1 CD (1.) - , a".3 0- 4P‘mcs-alito=4\ 4—I .it ri C.) 16........ . Ir. : s . 4-- L- (1) . \ , , - .- CD_ \ , : I ,,, ...I ...AM if AM r* *Ig .. t..-.` I/ ( 'J'' z ;t1. Cr .-... ) rt a , ... , _-1..--.•=3(:::, - "2":41° fra . _ - • _ ___. t; ,, E • c 0 - CO -2 c (1) -0 .. m , ; „ ,•, ' j i va ) . 0 o . • VI _...= 1 co c.1 >-.. c_ Lo 0 co l 1— 1" .• 0 99 7 • LI— b-cf, N._ ..f = ; ....= . E (1) 4,u)C) C Ci) ‘• CD IC7 . iiii (..) c . . ; .1, . . CC g.. . I - m U 0 L _. zt. 1 .., _ ,-- ----- :..1 . ■ Fa to I--t.--'I- ,..i. r• P a) L -1-1 .1...a CO k 0_ 1 I J:- 4—+ 0 a) I 4-- ,, 4- .,---- . ...... )_ ,_ ,-.. ,---.,.. •-....,...of ... , -7 -. . .• 'y)., .i -, .%,...._. , .. 11 ,..,.,.. .. • ..... 4 li '.,' . •‘ ' `• wit' Atelt.i■'1's: U O a D I. ¢ -.-J VC CC3 y V t O 0 U X 0 L N ca ° ttlh:fil I >-- 0_ 4 I -0 CUO a a v J /D CC o r c 0 4 Q) U a U ° o U) Q I. Q o -- O Z 0 ° U o LL., a r CD 1 _ , _ 4_, 4_, W f a-.5 ♦J 0 / i , (1) 9- Q.) _ Q 1- ,ra Ut • Proposed Colors Foothill Crossings • EXHIBIT D i - -r---. . , L _ > y _ O k° 1 - m ..... '4 . , ..., I ..,... ..:. . _.:,---,5 :! . ). ii j - II . y l..^J T e Tzt -5 0 , . .401110 ig ,.JJ v1 3 I r O A 1, r o s. JD. a G. zx r...; -. c0 •-W t� Grri � 00 !Ir. la a i a v j J '4., V. \ ......"--.....,,...4". , r---- •t---....., .1.- kj i ----c _ 0 0 Q Q) a • 7t- C1.) L o .. .. r - O F) MI 7 I'Iii te. / a, N f A O a Ur . t. 3 n J + .. O -- b_ L o Q O 161111111 - V D ,}J i U �I u �— is U a) o. y A - Ea 1 o Q. J mg L C '0 U V U yr O a 0 VD N � w c L 4 - � Q) E- CC _ ^L O E a. Y �_ G $2 m � CZ cm ca m c — U till I~ 7 I r a q ,I U z u U° IA el 79..) .MI _ - C 5 >-� 1 U } /� O o .CD N _.- �, GE o co co • i cncup I (.1) „.,„ till'IIII' : . I kf U 8 ._ R Li. Q ,I \ " ® _ _ It o a- 1 � C W ' 4.__., @ cc C ._J 0 U LO u E Q� To O .a cn lO .a E c•= p O 5 % U U o4" U u ki U \ � o > ° a) 4 4 ' o S cu n p O -0 c 0_ - L) Q g � '• — r. )n © © © �1 aE r, Z _ t N = II i.i� (/) v •E ,----- 2 o U r N a I 0 cn m C Lri O N up g O 1 O., Go ) u^ N c V, V/ :4 m m O W U ° o a i ° a °tc O — 0 IO, t .tn LL Q c v Z a 00 c C g 4V r.I (13 rd Q - ;� o ,, i t\ U cc U 0 >' 0 W C L'Q) 1.z m E - C Q h Q ^ Y MI 0 al LI c r,- z) a cu cm ..2, ; EL - -. '' c a ,:. Cr) 0.z° r -'t '4 ar. f ^1• 0 ^. J -- _ ,ii. - "J r V. Q 0 a 4 c N Tii Cnn :g Q cn Pa O ...............1.,4- / _... —r- G U W . � �`' c -4—.1 0 • t O c Q F, a t LL .I! 2 , CO o = a• v no — - a •,�, N C.) � �1 cri v 61 T m -.7..5 mQ ..r. \.. . N O c w 0 i _ c x V^� C Lo W °c W 1'� W u 4— �' -O lL C g°-g`o L ; O E �° Q) -. _ m Q D x P Q z" s' - Y 0 Qa �t v a O c� D 0 ., � .�w (1)IT mil yl ..S1 �t V m o CL • P o ,; - 4Yl CO a> • ._ • / i m t C7 4 , j 1 Q I „ N 61 ID L \v.) J © c me cn . J 1 j U . if O j:., a�! -'L - — -•.- !, , — G 0 O O '#, -• i r '_ w oaf i Z .IJ A , , _ ;$4. , , j co cu L Y el 4...) i a m y 4 • _ - p o ° 0 U u L1 m,, `o ', 4_ 4 0 L.,... W o 0 a� s; i m N 1I 7 C r E a Co Fs 0 r o L1. E r Uu c T _ IA s ,aia4 .-w CO 1 ,.a E o D O9 1 CO 1 g = y ,.. .. �r ) iiii C O • N cr) .— T U 0 t _ .Q ` L +J La m" i 5 . Y O C O _ 1_ ti : LL —zt- ` c N O !J :J CJ O Q (n m _. 2 r-' V m CO . -1, _ .ztzsit-6.i..- ___.- ril ° ^L 1 - p 0 0 2 O m, U _ L `o % U 5 () w O m d n C c � as -- o 3 c 0 • H■ IIRYIIIIgi ti Vi MI © © m v • Cm C _ N 3 (�` Z m m N 3Q E a ` ra a) a , U `c a iU e I ' V o vi P co il o -411111117- v a ro U R co X O Q L7 CZ g S V i •— y VI y J © c a u, O N N U a r 0 a`. a TO O - ° `s e cu c C II N - 2 CL 4.�J e 4: U N CJ ^s a a Es __ 3 m c }J U :L.9 w a a.) CZ :U 0 -W f ° m = 9 n a) fff - O a cm so U I !:m 8 9 a z