Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2021-01-19 SupplementalsDesign Review Committee January 19, 2021 DRC2020-00 138 Project Overview Project: - A request to construct a new commercial building and service station located on a 2.33-acre parcel addressed 8768 Archibald Avenue. Entitlement: Tentative Parcel Map (TPM20164); Minor Design Review (DRC2020- 00138); Conditional Use Permit (DRC2020-00087); Public Convenience and Necessity (DRC2020-00459). Zoning Designation: General Industrial (GI) General Plan Designation: General Industrial (GI) t 1 14 TI k u �a �r _ J S I Facing south across 911 St. ,, .,., iy�"�'"�r4 `:�� �- .:. .- ;,�- e r 91h St. At cu CD .00 14 .1 I � [ r f a Google Eart% SCOMMERCIAL TORAGE ( PROPOSED 9 T H STREET RIGHT 40 MPH wo II LOT i - PRO II -wc y (E) SIALIZ u T axe INTER cTIO I - -nmwr. •�micPOFEO EL 0.0 r .I I � gGNUMFNI SW _ t ( F PATIO SoaSo I • Il I I+TI•I I MRPQFiOi a Qi �A. , I rt I OF4w AIE➢ 1'. � ,�� ,II�riSiµMgNi Ii PaFMryYG / RMIS 4� qv w i T ' ]6fiW -F vi d Y STONE J to ® ( .pp ST Q O m �i FIlL I- U yF1.9 Elf Q � RES>pUWFNtO 1i. t IR NS: �. /.PoG`IL .11 Mi S Hl5 n /R lY oAGry$p iRMn. 1 TIME fA51G�[RCtli1iF,_ cOUNL'NIENt{ STQiF '� SeALLS \lYA'.! I5 N DiuNMj Y —rt ]u h ORAINAM R 01LUM1 FA%W.Ni XIII FARPIN! .. , .s mN I � -`a r PR PO A �► R ULL W ME GR I1PrvEnnr ro .. \ W aERonC I L T" i'IILE F'y� 4 + z.2 EXTERIOR ELEVATION -EAST EXTERIOR ELEVATION - I EXTERIOR ELEVATION - NORTH (FACING 9TH STREET) 6 21 ­C EXTERIOR ELEVATION - SOUTH MATERIAL SAMPLES VRITAGEWOOD DEW EMPIRESLOCK GRAY NICHIHA NICHIHA FIBER CEMENT SIDING FIBER CEMENT PANELS IM DARK BRONZE SILVERPOINTE-BW 7853 CENTRIA-ECONOLAP IQ" SHEMIN WILLIAMS CORRUGATED METAL SIDING TRICORN BLACK. SW 6258 REFLECTIVE WHITE -SW 7757 SHEMIN WILUAMS SHOWN WILLWAS MATERIAL SAMPLES AESTHETIC WH TE SW7035 SHEMIN WILLIAMS COLONNADE GHAv SW7[ I SHFRWN WILUAMS PANTOW P044BCC SOLLARDCOVER. TYP .o.�=4 9TH .4=- ELEVATION tV� 5W LKO R.G TREES ASCERCGOCCOENTµ6m CERCIS CAMA EN VERTI ACCENT TREES SUCH AS 4CET CULES UJ D RT ACCENT TREES SUCH µCE HE MET MI ftO RMG TREE55ULT1 CERC*CCCWENTAIS OR iCIS CANACE N55 '- 5IK $TABNIZ£D :WNSED GRANrtE ARCHIBALD AVE iTREET TREE V.YERED ONWEMTµ E.VA. AT ANOIBLL➢ MlYOW 1EA00N OiN55 pgASyES, EIprERNO WALKWAY CON515IM(: OF NTE6 TWESUCN AS CAI6J[ SMU65ADCULENTS CCIUTED CONCRETE WRN TOOCAST 5 V46A N CONCEPTUAL LANDSCAPE PLAN SrL ® 7-ELEVEN CORNER OF 9TH STREET ARCHIBALD AVENUE o To n � $l E T•. nu n s �& RANCHO CUCANCA M1F 1II6A'm0 L-2 Development Standard Re"ked Proposed Compiles? a x Maximum 35 feet (at front 20 feet Building Height setback) and (building). 17 YES 75 feet (I-footincrement from the feet (fueling setback line) cane 18.2% (inclusive of Floor Area Ratio (FAR) 50-60% covered patio YES and fueling cane 33.3 feet Front Building Setback Mint. 25 feet YES (9 Street) patio), 86,4 atio) feet oposed building); 69.6 feet (fueling canopy) Min. 45 Feet (Major 70 feet Street Side Setback ArteriallSpecial Blvd — Archibald (proposed YES Ave.)buildin 31.9 feet (Wh Average Depth of 25 feet (9^ Street); 45 feet Street); 70 feet YES Landscape (Archibald Ave.) (Archibald Ave, 35.5 feet (9'h Parking Setback Min. 15 feet (W St ); 25 feet St.); 90 feet YES (Archibald Ave.) (Archibald Ave. 115 feet interior Side Yard Min 5 feet pose (probuilding), YES Setback bu8.5 feet can 120 feet Rear Yard Setback Min 0 feet (Proposed building); 90 YES feet(canopy) Open Space/Landscaps 10% 31.8% YES Standards Parking Ratio Required Parking Provided Parking Convenience Store 3 per 1.000 square feet 14 stalls 14 stalls (plus 14 at fuel pumps) Restaurant 10 per 1.000 square feet 20 stalls 22 stalls TOTAL 34 stalls 50 stalls Minor Issue and Staff Recommendation • The proposed building includes a tri-colored metal band. Consider if this should be illuminated or not; • Staff recommends that the Design Review Committee forward the item to the Planning Commission for their consideration. Design Review Committee January 19, 2021 DRC2020-00016 Project Overview Project: - A request to construct a 3,300 square foot single-family residence with two separate attached 2-car garages totaling 1,063 square feet on a vacant property of 15,601 square feet (0.36-acre) Entitlement: Design Review DRC2020-00016 Zoning Designation: Low (L) Residential District General Plan Designation: Low Residential � f' y c? d8 A T eM3 e jM1 s Y r � L esta mm SN3 J a, CITY OF RANCHO CUCAMONGA Street View ,-_--- u: _ Site Plan Development Standards 25 Feet-3 Inches 30 Feet YES 13 Feet 30 Feet YES 54 Feet 37 feet (+/- 5 feet) YES 10/15 Feet 5/10 Feet YES 97 feet 20 Feet YES 20 feet N/A YES Less than 5 feet 5 Feet YES 3 Feet 4 Feet YES Two -Car Garage N/A YES 16.8 Percent 40 Percent YES 3,300 Square Feet Lot Coverage YES 1,062 Square Feet Lot Coverage YES 483 Square Feet Lot Coverage YES Grading • The proposed grading design limits earthwork import to 6.8 cubic yards of fill, with the majority of the cut/fill necessary to construct the driveway and the lower side entrance garage, • The foundation of the residence is stepped with the existing grade, with the upper pad at an elevation of 1,303 feet and the lower pad at an elevation of 1,294, in conformance with Hillside Design Section 17.122.020.D.1.a to terrace the building to follow the slope; • Retaining walls are below the 4-foot height limit for hillside lots and are necessary to construct the driveway, the foundation of the house, and along the side property lines. Design Overview • The proposed residence has a Mediterranean design theme, which includes the use of a clay tile roof, smooth troweled stucco finish, cast stone window and door surrounds, wrought iron accents, and decorative garage doors; • The residence was designed in compliance with the Hillside Design Guidelines (Section 17.122.020.D.2), including stepping the building pads to follow the existing slope/terrain of the subject property and the use of hip roofs oriented in the same direction as the natural slope; • The building mass is broken up through the use of multiple wall plane changes and the incorporation of decks on the side and rear elevations; • The two -car garage on the upper -level faces Camino Predera, with a second side entry two -car garage located on the lower level. �r CITY OF RANCHO CUCAMONGA r� First Submittal • 31956 SF House • 715 SF Three -Car Garage • 540 Unfinished Basement • 7 and 13 Foot Side Setbacks Final Submittal • 31300 SF House • Two -Car Garage • Side Entrance Garage • 10 and 15 Foot Side Setbacks r CITY OF RANCHO CUCAMONGA ■rr� Staff Comments • Staff supports the proposed building design and site plan layout with that changes that the applicant has made through the design review process; • Through multiple rounds of review, the applicant has modified the plans to address staff comments related to architecture, site planning, and technical issues; • The original generic architecture has been enhanced to incorporate a Mediterranean design theme, all elevations have been modified to provide additional articulation and reduce massing and the three -car street facing garage has been reduced to a two -car garage; • The size of the residence has been reduced by 656 square feet and the side yard setback have been increased to 10 and 15 feet; Staff Recommendation • Staff recommends that the Design Review Committee recommend that the Planning Director approve Hillside Design Review DRC2020-00016. Design Review Committee January 19, 2021 D RC2016-01017 Project Overview Project: A request for site plan and architectural review of a 2,456 square foot restaurant with an 858 square foot second -story office Entitlement: Design Review DRC2016-01017 Zoning Designation: Mixed Use (MU) District General Plan Designation: Mixed Use ` � y and+no Rd San BernarGia Rd 7` WAN2. �b;b^ n Sr San Bernadno Rd San Bernardino Rd - SopO�c - CITY OF RANCHO CUCAMONGA _(AtT 4( r rr r CITY OF RANCHO CUCAMONGA Site Plan smtan ru ' � f VFR L2}N 2] RENT Z0r1� •® I° O zt LOT LOT 23 .. e'- �t.,�:.'.;.;.. O ..:`• $' �N a NO I � RESTr= W...._S e�±:. f _ INY. 0` r � • AY TYPE 110111 _ a .. sma, uw�ron � u � LA u:..o �� • ROADffl me curb and gotta snap b< 22' from the _<.�en�°e m I.n �p +.tn nistmg .mp�o..e.reNS _BERNARDINO EXIST. i f (Foothill Blvd.) (San Bernardino Road) Coverage Districts permit an up to 75 percent Restaurant (2,456 SF*) Office (858 SF) Total Parking Spaces Ar r requirements Pa CITY OF RANCHO CUCAMONGA Design Overview • The proposed building evokes a Spanish architectural design theme that includes a smooth stucco finish, cast stone window surrounds, tile, and a tile roof; • The tower element over the main entrance includes a tile -covered dome with decorative wood trellises located along the north elevation; • All equipment for the restaurant/office (A/C units, refrigeration units, and venting) will be located on the roof of the building and will be screened from view by the roof parapets. rr CITY OF RANCHO CUCAMONGA r �� F R.l. 29' 9' ELEVATION ON COKNEK CITY OF RANCHO CUCAMONGA ijJL-� Ili A • • 1 U 11 , SAN BERN Neighborhood Meeting December 17, 2020 • One resident attended meeting • Resident interested to see design of building, but had no issues or questions Staff Comments • Staff supports the proposed building design and site plan layout; • The applicant was able to deliver a well -designed project and overcome the limitations of the project site (triangular shape, small overall size (0.56 acre), and being located along two street frontages); • The project was also able to incorporate a second land use (office) on the second story to comply with the Mixed Use (MU) District requirement to provide two land uses; • The project will be required to install all street improvements along both Foothill Boulevard and San Bernardino Road, as well as decorative post and cable, landscaping, and accent paving required by the Foothill Boulevard Visual Improvement Plan. Staff Recommendation • Staff recommends that the project be forwarded to the Planning Commission as presented for final review. '"Make each customer's day better, make lives easier, simplier and more convenient" Pagel 1. Im R 7 R 7 I a I 4aaA ■ Wig LE 61 0 Page 4 H Page 6 n ` I Jm LAREDO TACO Fresh, locally sourced ingredients Options organic ,treet taco Style" Has eggs Ong and patio dining and dinner window ited restaurant ©Copyright 7-Eleven, Inc. —Confidential and Proprietary ="IPA ....sue Page 8 Itt A A m M. k mj i; )NACKS car r .J Page 9 �m v T